High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11578/2014disposed of

Bhubneshwar Lal And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2015-04-23Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh3 pages

!"#"$%& '()$ #'* +, - $.' +# ""$ +# / +#(# +1 $ $.' +# #2$. $#

0% 3#3"$ 4#'" #* -5.6!

+' 2 ""$ +# 3#

-"4 3$7 5 2(1.6!

$ + -5 +1 $ !

" 1* 1"$# $2 ""$"- .($. ++"!- #89' $#"("$$."

5' 2 ""$ +#'

6 2+ 1 .+"##( $! *+""$ ' $ (+ ! +"+ +"+:( #'"$7' $""!

"$#.

. ;;

<$$ =(+ >?"##( .($. +0 !"$ ' , $.!:("#""$!5;

<"$#'+@' !A? $..

;;<$$ =(+ >?($. +0 !"$8 ' ! $.!$#". +' "+!

# "$6" *0 !"$ <?' "7'

"+ B2 $# "$ $. + $#2 + $!1 "$ , $. !:("#""$5

)"-"

"$ $. # - B $!5 &<' + "$ ++ ++ . @ &!A? ' 2 ""$ +#2(+!'

# .' - $.B #(+"$7

#:( + +.#"$' 1 +;8 $.!$#+(! .' "+'(# #6 +""$' 1 + ; 6 +$B $ +1 $ 6". $""!

"$ .

. ;;

<$$ =(+ >?"##( .($. +0 !"$ ' !--* .)1$""!

"$ .

;;<$$ =(+ >?($. +0 !"$8' !5 !:("+ .'

- $.' 2 ""$ +#' 2 ""$ +#"- .)C !"$#($. +0 !"$> ' !$&;;

<$$ =(+ >&? /". +. +.

<$$ =(+ > ?5' - $.B #(+"$7#:( + 1 +.#'

#) $- $.

+ B "$"$7- $. ;#:( + 1 +.#'

#) $ !:("+ .' 2 ""$ +# "- . ;& 2+ 1"$7+' + - # ' "+- $.*'"!'

* #."#B"## .)1'"#(+6". +. +.

.& &<$$ =(+ >8? * #)# +6 .' + "$ '

"*(-.) 2 $ ' 2 ""$ +#

22+ !'' + #2$. $#+7 "$7' !B2 $# "$+ - # . $."$ !

# $1 22-"!

"$ "# B6 .5 ' # B *(-. ) . !". . "$

!!+.

$! *"' - * $ 2(+#( $! ' + 5 ' 2 ""$ +# # $

+ 2+ # $ "$"$3 +!'5 &+' 7+ $!B2 $# "$)($ !' + +5' 2 ""$ +#"- . & & $.'"# (+6". +. +.

. &<$$ =(+ >?."#2# .' # *"' ."+ !"$ + #2$. $ & 4 . !"#"$ $ '

+ 2+ # $ "$ )1 2 ##"$7 #2 4"$7 +. + $. + +."$7 $ 22+($"1'

+"$7*"'"$ 2 +".*B$'#+B' .

+ ! "2 ! +"" .!21' +. + ' 2 ""$ +# + #"--"$ 2'1#"!

-2## ##"$' - $."$."#2( $.$!B2 $# "$'

) $ 2 ". ' B !!+."$7 ' 2 ""$ +#5 ' !:("#""$ 2+! ."$7#'

6 - 2# ."$6" *0 !"$ <? ' &! $! 5' 2+ # $*+"2 ""$ & , +$ . !($# - + ' 2 ""$ +# #()B" . ' '

2 ""$ +# + "$2'1#"!

-2## ##"$' - $."$."#2( $.'

!B2 $# "$'

#$) $2 ".' B* #!- "B .'

"$#(!'

!"+!(B# $! #5"$6" *0 !"$ <?' &!5' $""!

"$#

# ($. +0 !"$# $.8' !'

.- 2# .* #(+' +#()B" .

#"$! $. B $.$"! !- "B"$7' + -" #!- "B ."$+ #2 ! - 2# $""!

"$#'

#) $"- .*"'' + #2$. $#5 -") +1) 7+ $ . ' 2 ""$ +# "- .

"- . $. !B2+ ' $#"6 + 2+ # $ "$ ) + ' 22+2+"

('+"1 )1 "$!+2+ "$7 '

7+" 6 $! #+ "# ."$' 2+ # $*+"2 ""$5'* 6 +5."+ !"$) "##( . ' ('+"1 !$! +$ . . !". ' + 2+ # $ "$ =2 .""(#-1"$ "B )($.B $$ +"$ !!+.

$! *"'- *

+"$7- +$ .!($# -+' 2 +" #52 +(#"$7'

2+ # $2 ""$ $.*"'( =2+ ##"$7 $12"$"$$' B +"#'

# 5 * ."#2# ' 2+ # $ 2 ""$ )1 7+ $"$7 -") +1 '

2 ""$ +#"- .

"- . $.!B2+ ' $#"6 + 2+ # $ "$+ "#"$7 -- ' 2- # #+ "# ."$' 2+ # $*+"2 ""$) + ' 22+2+"

('+"1"#."+ ! .'

"$' 6 $ + 2+ # $ "$) "$7"- .)1 ' 2 ""$ +#*"'"$ 2 +".*B$'#+B.

15' # B #'

-- ) . !". ."$ !!+.

$! *"'- *)12 ##"$7 #2 4"$7+. + $.

+ +."$7 $22+($"1'

+"$7' B*"'"$ 2 +".(+ B$'#+B' .

+ ! "2+ 2+ # $ "$' 2 ""$ +##'

-- ) $"- .- $1 6". $! #()# $"

' "+!- "B) + '

!$! +$ . ('+"1"--' B +"#. !". .)1' # ". ('+"15 (#:(#'

--) B "$ "$ .)1' 2 +" # $ !

% &' ()*+ #" $!

% 7)# &'