← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/67/2006allowed

Jaswinder Singh v. Vijay Kumar & ORS

2024-10-18Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages



     

     

"#$# %& "

'( )  $*#%+( ,#%-.

//////0011 %

2$/ 2#3 (

%+

.($ //////$0 %+%

$  & 89

,/ , ,  ,  

  

     

  

  

 !"



# $ !!!!

,  ,

/

9 % & 

 '  (

   %%)    

%**     

%+,,'$    



# &' 

- .

  / &' /0  



 (

  



1

,  

,  &'

  

  

 %  ' ,   ( 2  (

  (    3 ' ((  45!!#!6!77,+' (  '$6  (&$ ( (  (  8 '9 (  # - &   ' (      

  : $ ' 71, 

   # -  2 ;  -' ((  <=!

7!,)7.

  / 

 ( /0    

   

  (    -

    

 



 $ 

   (  2    3              

      

 



   >     (           &'     

 (  

    

 





  

    ! #$"

 %



& 





'     ! # $"

%

     !  "

(    ! #) !

 %



& 





*  (  ! ) !

 %

     !  "

+

!  

  

 



  

  ! 

,#'

-,  ) 

 - (

    (   



   &'       = %))1!

 ( 

 ?*@

<

 

1

   

  



  '$ &' 

:

, ,,,   ,9,   , * &     

!



  

  '$  &'     <  



  

0    ' $  A8!%  

 ' $   2      8

7@ 0 >   (

    

 (  

 8      >  

 (

 

  

  



(  &     $      

   '      

  ' 

   7

               

  !"



# $

$(        

    5&' ( $    , "                 +         &'  ( $       

  ' $     21 

   7@  .   A8!% 0 0 >   (

    

 (  

 8        

 (

 

  

  



(  0 >   

$  $     

         ' = %))1!   $ "   2' & $

  

8  A8!% A8!%

 $  2   '= %7*1!



( 8$' 

;

  =   %*%771!    

  

      2       ' = % ,, 1!&  

$

       = %+*1!.= % ,, B%0 % &   C  (

  # ,9

9<   , %% < D'#   

  ( ((

  

  ' $&8#     ( 2$/ 3 (

%+ % .(

   ,60(7  6(

$$ :;:              *. /0

$ 12234$ 45 "     !  "&!

"  

 6  

     

. &  ! 

 "  "         !           "  

  

      

  "

.        " & 

6  "

 

    " & !

   

  

   

  $       



& !

    

&. "       

     

  & "  "

!

!

  & 

& 

 

    "         3%78% "

.8   $ ,1-9%"7'-+,: ; 

 7 3

5< 11*35%77**

=  1-9$7(+-5 + .     

  !

    ! 

 

&  !

>      

=

5  ?6    

     "      @    "

      

 

"

 6



5< 

3



5!



& !

 "

  

&  "

> 3 5< 

 

  " A 35  <       

  

     "

  

5B"

6  # 

 " 3C   : " 5 5: " 





 "      

&  35< "

3

D "  5 3 5<6    3

 "   5



 

&  !

 ! 



 3 53

53 5

3 5   

  

&! 



"



  

 

   !

  



 3

5353

535

3 5 

  

  

     "

 

      "

6  "

3

D "  5

6        

   

 ! 5$

& 3"

   

"

& 5



 

 



5.  "

  !

  !   

 "     

 

.

     

 

   "   "

  36 

 ! !.      

      

 

  "   "

  5

5. ! 

& # !6 "

"  6  "

  

    

    

      6     "

  . 

 

 "

 !

    .  !

 



 5  .   "  "

 

    "    

            

  

 

   



   

  &  

  "#$ 

 %

%%  

& 

%  

% '

 ()(>.

&  !"

!   '9 

 

,'999D#"   "

$ : 4  

    "

 

         "   

      

&  !   +9E 

    "

   !    '9E.  

 

 !  .   *E   

  



"" 

 ! 7      !>  5$

 

"

>,'+999D# 5< 



" 3*E 

 

"5> ,*(99D#

5/   

!

  >-

5< 

>3*(996-5> ,1299D# '

 (*(>.

& !     '9  

,'999D#" ;



 " 

 "

      +9E;! "

 " &            ;

      

     "" !  

  &  !     ..       

 

 -*E7     !

  !> 5$

 

" 

>,'+999D# 5< 



" 3-*E 

 

"5 >,-999D#

5/   

!

  >-

5< 

>3-9996-5>,(*1999D# '

 (+( >.

& ! * 

 

  ?



 $ 

! 

"

!"   

!  " 

 !    ."

 " !    -9E$

& ! 



     

             

 

!     -9E.    !

 !> 5/

""

 

"!     "   ?

 >,+9999D# 5< 



" 3-9E6 

 

"5 >,(999D#

5/   

3* 5  >2

5< 

>3(999625 >,-*+999D# F  >  .     

    3$5 

 3=5   

. 

   375!   

   "

$

8" /  3 5G % < D'    #          ,   '  +- .



/0 >    , ) ?       

%**%* ! %*,    

%+,, 

 ( 

.0 4

    (8       E .90 

   ( (   E .#0 (    '   $ ( E .40 =  ' (   

  $ 

       8     .A0 >    

    (           



( 

2'E  !$ 8 $ &

 2(

     .!

 " 6  "  "      

"              " 

   

)

6     ,*999 ,(9999

 ,*999  .





  

 

=   #



   "# 

     

      !  

  "  !          

 

 "    9E

     

    !





 

  H %  < D'#    1  .

 1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34    I-.   !

   6 "

 > 

 %  %(5( 

%(6(A . 

 "            '  

   & "

    7" <   %

 9-  $7)  -99  3%75      (+      

 & "    7   =    " "  "    "

 

 %  0" 3%"5

: . 7 

$ 991$7) 123%75  *#* "    424  !

 



6 

   . 

   

  

 

% 7 

! "    "   

    424

4-4 -

%  

%





  %78

        

          "

 !     



) 

/ J 92$7)93%75

%

 8 & $:

J$ 9-$7)1-13%756 !



) 

3 5

  2>

@

K2   

           



   

"

$

"! "

    "  

    

  

           !       . !      "    "      !

  >

  

 

  "  

  "  

A

<

"





"A

. 

       

"       "     !

  "

A 5 /

6 



 

""    

 

A

35 <6    K F"   G . 



   "  @

  & "  %

8 &  3 5

 "  " ! 



 !     

"     "

  



     !6 "



    

 !  D   @   2

   " L "$ 9)  9'. 

&     

> K, % >

"

  "

   "

"

    " 5  ' (J*"   

35  

  " 3   " 3

        

6      !

       

       



        

% 7    "!    

  =   "        "

 

&   ! 6 B   

  ' %

  8 &    3 5     !   

   "  "   "

 

   



        !  "

   

 



 !

        "    

    

"

   'E. 

 "    & "

    7<   3 5"



  +3

5



    ! *9E    

   $ 





 

  

    "8

  

   ! 

!



  

  

1E

!      &

    "  



 

  ) 

M 3 5

     

 !   

      

  "!  

1E



!

 

    7 +0,+-9'0, 2. 

 

 



       

  *  !  

  !> :

)  <     

  ! ,121-2D# 3,(+(266'D99



B     3*9   ,(19121D#

/

6 



,2(+2+(D#  

 

 "  <    "  "

,*99999D#   <    "     ,*9999D# "



"    



,99999D# .  ,(+12'D# .  !    ,(+12'D#  "   !

 "

   1E

""  

    "  9, %  '  

      %%)  

 ($   



    

'$< D'#  

' 

!



 

   



      '

,(/  / +$  70%$

# % * (++ %

 = %+1!  .   

 

= %+*1!0 5    

.)@0 = ))1!.)@ %+0 

"

 = %+*1!.%+G))8%0 5    (

.7@0 = % 7 1!.%+*H7@0 )

 .%*0 = %+71!.% 7 H%*0



*   

 (  = %1!

 

= )1!

,

 8 = 1!

+ &  ( = %1!

% 



#( = %1!

%% 5      = )1!

 70%$

# % $/=A;A;; B 7 6%

* (++ '4

.

(#'6% $/A==A B %.

%"+

7 6%

$/:A@A;; B %)         

      

       '$  < D' #   

; *.

  

.  @  :   <. 0

 .$ , $ 

+ 

  = ,60(7  6(

$$  A



      $ 

 ?+@

     (       ; %* =  

%  2

$  $

  $   ( 

  &'   



       $  2(

&&'  

  '     



  ' -



& 



   

          ' -  



       &'  %7 4  



 ($ %,   (   $    

,  ,  

 

"

'( )A  ;

  :  - (1  ! - ( - (   :  '  I