← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/28756/2020disposed of

Harchand Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Another

2020-12-18Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

   

     

  !"#$"%&'&#()**  +%, (-.&(/, (-#!,"+' 0"!&!&#("+' 1'* .! !"#$2(3 4 (- (#!,"+  0"'5#(-"(!'

#+ 6) #(748"+*2'!&%"*.*9 8& * +"'"(!) +*:#;"',<#,+ =-1#% !"$#+!,"5"!&!&#("+'* '*#(&;  8#! = =2(3 4* '*.2%,&.#-,&=-1#% !"$#++"'5#(-"(!'#*!#>* ??? *.*9 8& =* < *

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

FG * *=  ' 5"+ C,&%,= +"'5#(-"(! #* , ' '! !"- !, ! ," , ' (# #43"%!&#(&$!," $#+"6"(!&#("-&'A2 ',"-$#+C,&%,,"2(-"+!##;!# 6 ;" '! !"6"(!4"$#+"!," #2+!!#'255#+!!,"5"!&!&#("+'$#+A2 ',&(/#$ !," * :" +("- %#2('"8 $2+!,"+ %#(!"(-' !, ! !," %#65+#6&'" "$$"%!"- 6#(/'!!,"5 +!&"'&'C&!,#2! (@&(-2%"6"(!=!,+" !#+%#"+%&#( (-#2!#$ !," $+"" C&88 #$ !," +"'5#(-"(! %#658 &( (!* "8& (%" , ' 4""( 58 %"- 4@ 8" +("- %#2('"8 #( !," -"%&'&#( #$ #(748" !," .25+"6" #2+! &(  



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

', 884"C"88C&!,&( &!'32+&'-&%!&#(!#A2 ',!,"%+&6&( 85+#%""-&(/*L >* :" +("-%#2('"8, ' 8'#+"8&"-25#(!,"-"%&'&#(#$!,&' #2+! &(!

# 





# 

$       % &'  (

)    

 *

  +

 ,   #- " 

  # $    ./0=&('255#+!#$!,"

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

,"+"C '(#5+#%8 &6"-#$$"(-"+&(!,"% '"=(#("#$ !," %%2'"-C '&(1#81"-&( (@#!,"+% '"*:" +("-.! " #2('"8 'C"88 '8" +("-%#2('"8$#+!,"+"'5#(-"(!', 1" 8'#'255#+!"-!,"5+ @"+#$!," 5"!&!&#("+'$#+A2 ',&(/#$ !,"  (- 88%#('"A2"(!& 8 5+#%""-&(/' (- '! "!, !!,"@, 1"(##43"%!&#(!#!,"A2 ',&(/#$!,"' 6"#(!,"4 '&'#$ %#65+#6&'"(("D2+"E- !"

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

FG 5+#%""-&(/'= '(#2'"$2852+5#'"C#28-4"'"+1"-4@5+#8#(/&(/8&!&/ !&#(* * (!,"8&/,!#$!,"5#'&!&#( '(#!"- 4#1"=#*- !"- B**=+"/&'!"+"-2(-"+."%!&#('BB=B>=>= => (->#$  =  = ! #8&%" .! !&#( .#, ( = &'!+&%! ..  / + ' C"88 ' 88 %#('"A2"(!& 85+#%""-&(/' +&'&(/!,"+"!#= +"A2 ',"-* * "!&!&#('! (-'-&'5#'"-#$ %%#+-&(/8@*

*.*9 8&  2-/" **  M 3"',.7 9,"!,"+'5" ;&(/E+" '#("- )"'E# 9,"!,"++"5#+! 48" )"'E#