High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/396/2019dismissed

Ramesh Kumar v. Commissioner Of Income Tax

2020-02-19Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan6 pages

!" # " $$%% & '"" "( !$ ! " # ! "$" %&'&()

% (*++(, %-.)/+0%+1,23+)&'

%)-&+44&55+() )**+,+- , -&+''&''&&.'.(+44&+50(,&%"&3).(

)-&(36& +73)1 8 %'-%)1 )-&3) 9+*+.('))-&%,&%,+)&, :

4+''&, ;<)-&(36&+744&55+)&%.;0(+51&= &5-.8 %'-%)1 )-&%.;0(+5 9 35+.6.(* 55=.(*'0;')+().+5>0&').(' 5+= ? #-&)-&% )-& !, (36& +7 44&55+)& %.;0(+5 .' @0').

.&,.(3( .%6.(*)-&%,&%4+''&,;<0A'

)-&%&;<'&)).(*+'.,&)-&%,&%0A'B89=-.3-.'+*+.(') )-&=&55'&))5&,5+=+(,0) )-&40%2.&= "&3).(

C #-&)-&%)-&!,=+' @0').

.&, .(04-5,.(* )-& %,&%4+''&,;<)-&0A'

'4&3.

.3+55<=-&()-& %.*.(+5%,&%0A'B89=+'()+)+55&%%(&0'%,&% +(,%&+'(+;5&145+0'.;5&+(,3%%&3)2.&==+'&74%&''&, ;<4+''.(*+(%,&%+ )&%)+D.(*.()3('.,&%+).(%&45<1 &2.,&(3&'+(,)-&%%&5&2+(),306&()'CE

-&%&5&2+() +3)'+%&)-+)%&)0%( .5&, %)-&+''&''6&()<&+%

BF:,&35+%.(*.(36& 1 1B AF=+'4%3&''&,0(,&%"&3).( B89 )-& 3) "0;'&>0&()5<1 )-&%& ;&.(* +( .( %6+).( %6 )-& (2&').*+).(#.(*+;0)'0'4.3.0'5(*)&%63+4.)+5*+.(('-+%&'1)-& 3+'&=+''&5&3)&, %'3%0).(<).3&+5(*=.)->0&').((+.%&=+'.''0&,1 %6+).(A,306&()'+(,&2.,&(3&=&%&)+D&((%&3%,+(,%,&%,+)&,

=+'4+''&,)=05,;&%&5&2+())4%,03&)-&+''&''6&()%,&% .()) ?&)0%(,&35+%.(*))+5.(36&+60().(*)' 1 1B AF =+' &F .5&, ;< )-& +''&''&& (

B1 =-.3- =+'

4%3&''&,0A'B89 )-&(36&+73)1 ()-& %&)0%(&,.(36&-&+''&''&&.'+4+%)(&%.(+.%6,&+5.(*.( &)%5&06 %,03)' +(, ,&%.2&' .(36& %6 %&()1 '-+%& )%+,.(*+(,.()&%&'),0%.(*)-&<&+%0(,&%3('.,&%+).(!+)&% (1 )-& 3+'& )-& +''&''&& =+' '&5&3)&, % '3%0).(< +''&''6&()0A'B89 )-&(36&+73)1 )-%0*- ""'<')&6 %2&%.

.3+).( '0'4.3.0'5(*)&%6 3+4.)+5 *+.( ( '-+%&' 8.(40)' %6 .(2&').*+).( #.(*9 ")+)0)%<().3&0A'B8 9 )-&(36&+73)1 ,+)&, G

: =+' .''0&, +(, '&%2&, 04( )-& +''&''&& "0;'&>0&()().3&'0A'B8 9+(,B 89 )-&(36&+7 3)1 +5(*=.)->0&').((+.%&=&%&.''0&,+(,'&%2&, 04()-&+''&''&&"-'-D/06+%<+5H"-"+).'- /06+% <+51 -+%)&%&, 330()+()'1 30('&5' % )-& +''&'''&& 0%(.'-&,=&% ))%(&<,05<'.*(&,;<)-& +''&''&&+(,+33&4)&,;<)-&6+(,+))&(,&,)-&+''&''6&()

4%3&&,.(*' %6).6&)).6&+(, 0%(.'-&,)-&%&>0.'.)& %6+).(A,306&()'A&2.,&(3& -& %&>0.'.)& ,&)+.5'A %6+).(A,306&()'A&2.,&(3& .5&, ;< )-& 30('&5 -+2& ;&&(45+3&,(%&3%,-&;D' +A3+5(*=.)-%.*.(+5 203-&%'+(,)-&%,306&()'=&%&4%,03&,;<)-&+''&''&&1 =-.3-=&%&&7+6.(&,

-&3+'&=+',.'30''&,=.)-)-&30('&5 %)-&+''&''&&1 +(,+ )&%,.'30''.()-& 55=.(*+,,.).('+%&6+,&.()-& )+7+;5&.(36& )-&+''&''&&(+*%&&,;+'.''0;@&3))( 4&(+5+3).( .9(+60() 'BB1BGAF(+A3 .()&%&')4+.,(3+% 5+(8;&.(*.(+,6.''.;5&&74&('&9.'+,,&,.()-& )+7+;5&.(36& )-&+''&''&& )+5,,.).(F'BB1BGAF -&)+7+;5&.(36& )-&+''&''&&.'%&3640)&,.'+'

0(,&% (36&%&)0%(&,;<)-&+''&''&& ' 1 1B AF

,,.).(+',.'30''&,.(4+%+ +;2&'BB1BGAF )+5(36&+''&''&, ' 1G 1B AF ''&''&,''0&%&>0.'.)&,306&()'E -&4%3&&,.(*'=&%&.(.).+)&,0(,&%"&3).(

)-&3) +(,().3&=+'.''0&,(

I-&%&=+'5(*)&%63+4.)+5*+.(

1 1: AF135+.6&,;<)-&+''&''&&+'&7&64)0(,&%"&3).( 8G9 )-& 3) -&+''&''&&)D+')+(,;& %&)-&%.(3.4+566.''.(&%

(36&+78 %'-%)1 9)-+))-&''&''.(*

.3&%-+,3(,03)&,)-& &(>0.%.&'+(,4+''&,)-&+''&''6&()%,&%1)-&%& %&.(2D.(* "&3).(

)-&3).';+,-&3()&().(=+'%&@&3)&,$.,&%,&%,+)&,

G1)-&%,&% +''&''6&()=+''&)+'.,&+(,)-&6+))&%%&6.))&, ;+3D))-&''&''.(*

.3&%)4+'' %&'-%,&%+ )&%4%2.,.(*44%)0(.)< -&+%.(*))-&+''&''&&**%.&2&,1)-&+44&+5=+' .5&,1)-&%.;0(+5 ,.'6.''&,)-&+44&+5( :

1-&(3&)-&4%&'&()+44&+5 !&+%(&,30('&5 %)-&+''&''&&+%*0&,)-+))-&4%&F%&>0.'.)& )=.(3(,.).(' "&3).(

)-&3)+%&() .55&,).'3()&(,&, )-+)%&2.'.(3+(();&,(&(6&%&3-+(*& 4.(.(1)-&&%%&,.( %&F4&(.(*)-&6+))&%+'+))-&6').)=+'+3+'& .(+,&>0+)&&(>0.%<+(, )-&'+6&3+(();&+%&+'( %%&2.'.( -&3()&().('%+.'&,5+3D6&%.)"&3).(

)-&3)*.2&'

+'04&%2.'%<4=&%)+(,)-&)=%&>0.%&6&()'+%&)-+))-&%,&% 4+''&,;<)-&''&''.(*

.3&%.' &%%(&0'+(, .' 4%&@0,.3.+5 ) )-& .()&%&') )-&%&2&(0&745+(+).( )"&3).(

)-&3)=+'+,,&, ;<.(+(3&3)1

:=&

:'4&%)-&+,,&,&745+(+).(1.(

55=.(* 0%'.)0+).('1)-&%,&% )-&''&''.(*

.3&%'-+55;&,&&6&, );&&%%(&0'

?8+9 )-& %,&% .' 4+''&, =.)-0) 6+D.(* .(>0.%.&' % 2&%.

.3+).(=-.3-'-05,-+2&;&&(6+,&J 8;9 )-&%,&%.'4+''&,+55=.(*+(<%&5.& =.)-0).(>0.%.(* .())-&35+.6J )-&%,&%-+'();&&(6+,&.(+33%,+(3&=.)-+(< %,&%1,.%&3).(%.(')%03).(.''0&,;<)-&+%,0(,&% '&3).( J% 8,9 )-&%,&%-+'();&&(4+''&,.(+33%,+(3&=.)-+(< ,&3.'.(=-.3-.'4%&@0,.3.+5))-&+''&''&&1%&(,&%&,

: ;<)-&@0%.',.3).(+5.*-0%)%"04%&6&0%).()-& 3+'& )-&+''&''&&%+(<)-&%4&%'(E ()-&4%&'&()3+'&1+30%'%<5D+))-&+''&''6&()%,&%.' *, &(0*- ) -5, )-& '+6&) ;&&%%(&0' -&%&=+' +'4&3. .3 %6+).(4%2.,&,))-&''&''.(*

.3&%+;0)'0'4.3.0'5(*)&%6 3+4.)+5*+.(#.)-0)*.(*;<)-&5&(*)- )-&%,&%1)-&%&.'()&2&(+ =-.'4&%)-+)+(&(>0.%<=+'-&5,=.)-%&*+%,))-&5(*)&%63+4.)+5*+.( =-+))'+<+;0)%&3%,.(* '+).'

+3).( -&3()&().( 5&+%(&,30('&5 %)-&+''&''&&)-+).)=+'+ 3+'& 3-+(*& 4.(.(%3+'& .(+,&>0+)&&(>0.%<.'()=&55

0(,&,-&%&.'(&(>0.%<+)+55;<)-&''&''.(*

.3&%1)-&%&.'( >0&').( 3-+(*& 4.(.( -&.( %6+).(=-.3-=+'=.)-)-& ''&''.(*

.3&% %6)-&(2&').*+).(#.(*=+'()&7+6.(&,+(,)-& )%+('+3).(=+'()2&%.

.&,-&%&=+'6+)&%.+5(%&3%,;& %&)-& )-+))-&)+75&2.+;5&=+'().64'&,+')-&''&''.(*

.3&%-+,() +445.&,-.'6.(,=-.5&+55=.(*&7&64).( 5(*)&%63+4.)+5*+.( "04%&6& 0%) .( ./ .% % ' 0 & '"" "1( #%

3''45 -&5,+'

0(,&% ?1()-&.(')+()3+'&1)-&66.''.(&%()&,)-+))-& (36&F)+7

.3&% 4+''&, )-& %,&% (.5 +''&''6&() =.)-0) +445.3+).( 6.(, (,&&,1 )-& .*- 0%) %&3%,&,)-& .(,.(*)-+))-&(36&F)+7

.3&% +.5&,) +445<-.'6.(,))-&3+'&.(+554&%'4&3).2&+(,)-&%,&% 4+''&,;<-.6=+'&%%(&0')+44&+%')-+))-&%&'50).( 4+''&, ;< )-& ;+%, )-& +44&55+()F364+(< =+' ()

45+3&,;& %&)-&''&''.(*

.3&%-0'1)-&%&=+'( 6+)&%.+5)'044%))-&35+.6 )-&+44&55+())-+))-&'+., +60()%&4%&'&()&,364&('+).( %5'' +*%.305)0%+5 .(36& & +33&4)&, )-& &()%< .( )-& ')+)&6&() )-& +330() .5&, ;< )-& +44&55+() .( )-& +;'&(3& +(< '044%).(*6+)&%.+5+(,=.)-0)6+D.(*+(<.(>0.%<( )-&'& +3)')-&3(350'.()-+))-&%,&% )-&(36&F)+7

.3&%=+'&%%(&0'.'.%%&'.').;5&#&+%&1)-&%& %&1

)-&4.(.()-+))-&.*-0%)-+'%.*-)5<-&5,)-+))-& &7&%3.'& )-& @0%.',.3).( ;< )-& 66.''.(&% 0(,&% "&3).(

89=+'@0').

.&,E )=05,;&=%)-6&().(.(*)-+))-&4%&'&()3+'&.''>0+%&5< 32&%&,=.)-.()-& 0%3%(&%' &745+(+).( )"&3).(

)-&3) &)-+)+'.)6+<1&2&()-&%=.'& % )-&%&+'('6&().(&,+;2&1)-& %,&% )-&''&''.(*

.3&%.'&%%(&0' -&+44&+5.',.'6.''&, 2)**+,+-32,6*7!3 ,8-*,8-* &;%0+%< 1

6D #-&)-&%'4&+D.(*A%&+'(&,

&'A #-&)-&%%&4%)+;5&

&'A