Ravinder Singh v. The Punjab Agro Food Grains Corp Ltd And ANR
!"# $% & ' (#%')*+" , " - . #
-
!"#$ %#& ' %% % / !
0 1! + 2# . 3 !"###41+ #-
+'-5!"#41+ - 6
# !"#(# 1+71%')*
88888 %#& ' %% ("
(#- !"#4)' "5
- *9 4 + 4 ! /' "1 .' #1 2# *9 # --4 #44"" )' "5
- *9 4 /' 4 " 41.' ##4 "#5"'49 ' !
:6"*4; '5+1 ::
# <= #** 5 # ' ! : #+1#*'-#4
+21 91 ##- 5, 4 !'--417 5%')*# -- >?/7' ' 7 5
@ 9"!5A #-' -- ' "- 9*#4#>, - ; A '5544"#5# '"##44 (# - !"# *" ! 9 0#'- B' *" # 5>?/7' ' 7 5@ 9"!5A2 *# - -*4 9" 9 9 '" # #44
' "#9
1#5-4# ' :
5 - 9 '5544""2## 5 2* 4 *9' >, - ; A*#4# 5-4 C2 1#5-444" ##' 4 4 # ' #DD :
:
5 - 9242# # ' # 5-4 # - 9 5 4 # 3#"#*
>?C 4!"# !A12#2 3 4#- 9 5# - 5#' *'49
5 - 9'4 *4 # 2# 342##' # - 5 ;#' 44" ##' # 55 * # '*95-- - " #3- 9 ' #5 # " 4 #'5 544 >, - ; A
;##5-4##' 12#4324 ""# 5'11
?2 '*- *9#' 1# ' # #E' #5 *" #E' * " 6
:
5'
?*'#5'-- 2 #' ' *3#5-4 55
2## 5 3>'' A (##E'E' 2 *9#5-4# '"##*3
(# 5-4 ' "
44" '- #
' 53" #-951*'#5# "*5 1# 5-44 5-4' ! :#+
(#- 2'55 '2 '- #5 (#5-4 *4##F5 !# 6
!# 51 " 1%')*+" , " - . G
4 4 '5 9 (# 4 4 ' 1 '- "# "#'*5 * 1#4 #- "'49 # "55 -'#*4' ! :#+ #5' " 5-45- 5 9 4-95'" 1
?
)' "5
- *94 /' 4" 41.' # (#--44 *9#- * #' !2 5 )' "5
12###* 4 *9294"#- -
(#4 '4 #- #'*5 ##4 4 ' 44 #4 "###E'E'# *' # "4"449 *44*49"#- 12# #5# *' 5 49' 9#E' 2 ' #E' (#4 '4#' # '*5 #19 1#- 45' *# - '4 * 4 2# 44*49 #5-4# 4 9-- # #+ * 3 9#5'E'# 44" # 44- 91# 1#- - "' !
:#+ *4'5'- 42
D
;# # '*5 # 4- ' # #
+#'1 * ##- # # #- ### * ' 2##- 9 ####E'E' * #"' (# 5-4#4 5-4 *4###' # * ' #:
5 - 9 '5544"" 2###2'-- 4 5 >, - ; A*'#' 4 # E'9 ;' # * '#'*E'49#5-45- - 9 "# 5- 92"#"DD :
:
5 4 5#- 5#' '#5 >?C 4!"# !A*'- 949#F
5 '4 *4 # 2# 32##'
:
(##E'E'# *' *9#' # "- #4"44*491#4*"11
?*'#5# "* #' 1#' # #544*4 # "55 -'#*4 ' ! : # + (# 4 ' # 5'4'495 #4 # * '"# # 5 "#5)'99 # " *9 # 4 ' '-#4 *9 # +--44 '
E'491# #- ' ! :
#+'-#4
+ " #E''55- 51#4 '4 # #549 "' ##5- 55- *9#
4' 5-45- 5 29 #5F5'5 #'4 *5- ##- " *'9 4 2# 4451##' 49#5 ;#' # *'*5 #191# 5- 5 5- # - 59 * ' ' 49 2# # 5- 5 5- 2 # 5-4'? :6"*4; '5+1 "'#5 1 2# 4 # - # * ' " 5-45- 5 29 ##
;# # '*5 " "- - 9
; '* ##5F5'55- 52## *5- -' ! :#+29 1 #*5- #- 1*'2444 ## #E''55- 5#*F *9#' 3-" 2#" 9# ;# 2 1# #'4 -- *55' 2##' 5 2####*55 ; 2####E' E' -#545'
?1# # 499 5 #2"949#5 C2 13-" 2# ##- *- ' 1#'* 5- 55- '-#- ' 5 5-45- 5 9 5-45- 5 9 5#
+ # - 9 # - " # 5- 5 '' 492#5- ## 2
5-46 :?
5-46 D
1#4 '4 #- #'*5 # 44## #E'# *' # "4*49 " ' #5 1# ##'4 *5 '' 492# "#- 5-4# *4
(#4 '41 #55 ## '*51 - )' "5CA*4#!'- 5' -
!"
#
$ % & "
'
( )"
)
;# # '*5 # 4"# '"## )' "5 (# )' "52- 2#4 49"'-2 4 )' "5 *9CA*4#!'- 5' $*(
$ % ! )+, "
- . ( ) $ % ! )+*
-
CA*4#!'- 5 ' 12#4 '"#$*(
/ '- #4 442 < $ $
$ ;2' 4 ## ' 5'4 #' 4421#F '#-2 ##)'*49 # 2#512'4 - #' # 55 # '5 ;2#2 -'4 ##4"4- ' #F # #*#- 2# # - '* "4 15 5-4 4# 5"## * 4 $$$$$$
(#5- 49"4 # *4#' #'*E' '' 492##- '2#''
; 2 F-' 244 # # ' '"2'4 *45 #'* 4 $
$
$
$
=
,' # 12#4 "( ) / '- 2#4 442 <$$$$$(#*# 2 # --44# "244#* &
04 '- # '449 29 "#)3 -- ##5 # ##'*E' 2'4 '' 49 12'4 449 - #' # # 44 ' @ *491#--442 E' # '42 2## ## 5- # * - 1 # '4 2'4 '' 49 $$$$ $$
=
;#- 1 49* -' #44## #E'1 #' 2### 5-42 4 1# *' # "#4*49 11
? "'#5 (# 4 4- "# #E'15-4 )' "5- *9#42 ' 442
! " #
(##E'# "*' # "4*49 "'# 5 1#- 49*F #*
:
' 95- 513-" 2# )' "5CA*4#+-F' !" #
/ '-
+'#1 ##'* 5- 51# - 1#44 '' 492##5- ## 25-4 5-46 :?
- " #' #E'* "6
5' 1D1
? 5-4 6 D
- " #' #E'* "6
:
5' 1
? C2 1#5- '-#- # 5 1
? 1
?13-" 2#5'# #' #E'12##
? (# #44* - 5-#5-4 ;244*'-4 5#!"
#
/ '- 11
?## 2# *5- 14#'"###E'##2 5'1
? ;# '51# 1
?1 *- 5-5-4'- 412## 5'#4 ###E'5'1*"5- 12#44* " 5 ###44## *" ' *" '' 49
(#'12#4 '"#5-45- 5 9 F 5# 2#4 " # 5- 5 ' ' 49 -44## 5-41#- *" 5- 5'" 1
? * (# #44*- 5-#5-4 ; -951#- #44' # ' "5- 5 D
5# ;4 # -951# '4 5- 5D5#4'# 244 '' 49 - ###
:
(# - 5 F- #5 *
)*!+,!)+-* .%
/ %001 -3) "
G## -3"? H?6 G## - *4 H?6