← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3571/2017dismissed

Ravinder Singh v. The Punjab Agro Food Grains Corp Ltd And ANR

2019-03-29Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill9 pages

 



          

   



    !"

 #$ %& '"$&()*!+ !,-

"

, 

 

 !"#$ %#& '  %% $  .

/ 0 *

1"  - 2 !"""30*

",

 *&,4 !"30*

, 5 

  " !"'" 0*60$&()

77777 %#& '  %%("



'",   !"3(& !4  

, )8 3  *

3    .& !0  -& "0  1")8  "  ,,3 "33!!(& !4 9 

, )83 .& 3!  30-& ""3 !"4!&38&  9 5!)3:&4*099 " ;<" )) 4 " &  9" *0")&,"3

*1080"",4+  3 &,,306 4$&()" ,, =>.6&& 64

 

?

8! 4@",&,,&!,

8)"3"=+

,: @ &4433!"4"&!""33 '" ,      !"  )!  8    /"&,   A&  )!

"4=>.6&& 64?

8! 4@1 )" ,  ,)3    8!  8 8  &!    "  "33

&!"8

 0"4,3" & 9 4 ,

8&4433!!1"" 4 1) 3 )8& =+ ,: @)"3 "4,3 B1 0"4,333! ""& 3 

3 " & "CC9 4,

8131"

"  &    "  4,3            "  ,

8  4

   3 " 2"!")



=>B 3 !"  @01"12 3",

84" ,4"& )&38 4,

8&3 )3  "1"231""& ",4 :"& 33! ""& " 44 )"&)84,,,!

"2,

8& "4 " ! 3 "&4 433 =+ ,: @



:""4,3""& 01"3213 !!" 4&0D0

>1 &), )8"& 0" &

"  "E&      "4  )!  "E&  )!  5

  



4&0CD0

>)&"4&,, 1 "& & )2"4,3  44

C 

1""42=&3 @ '""E&E&1   )8  "  4,3  "&!"  "  )2    

  '" 4,3  &  !     C

  33!  &,  "



& 42! ",840)&"4" !)4 0" 4,33 4,3&  9"*

'",1&44 &1 &, "4 '"4,3 )3""F4  "

5

"40!0$&()*!+ !,-

G     3  3 &48      '"  3  3  &0  &,  !"    !"&)4  )0"3 ",!&38" !44  ,&")3&  9"*  "4& ! 4,34,4 8 3,84&! 0

>

 (& !4 9 

, )83 .& 3! 30-& " '",,33 )8",)"& 1 4  (& !4  

01""") 3 )8183!", ,



'"3 &3","&)4 ""3 3 &33"3 !"""E&E&" )& 

"!3!338)33)38!",01" "4" )& 438&8"E& 1 & "E& '"3 &3"&"&)4 "08 0",34& )" ,&3 )

3 1" 33)38 "4,3" 3 8,," "*)2 8"4&E&" 33! "33,

80"0",, !&   9"*)3&4&,31

C

:"  " &)4 " 3,& "  "



*"&0 ) "","" ",""" )& 1"",

8 """"E&E&   )"!& '" 4,3"3 4,3  )3"""& " ) & "9 4,

8&4433!! 1"""1&,,  3  4=+

,: @)&"&   3 " E&8  :&")&"&)E&38"4,34,  ,

8 !"4,

81!"!CC9 4 3 4",4"& &"4 =>B 3 !"  @)&,

838"F 4 &3 )3 "1"21""&

'""E&E&" )& )8"&  "!, "3!33)380"3)!0D0

>)&"4" !)

"& 0"& "  "433)3" !44

  ,&")3  &     9    " * '"  3  &  " 4&3&384"3 "  )&!" " 4 !"4(&88" !   )8  "  3  &      &,"3  )8  "  *,,33  &

E&380" ",&  9 "*&,"3



*! "E&&44,40"3 &3 " "438!& ""4,44, )8"



3& 4,34,418"4F4&4 "&3 )4, "",! )&D8  3 1" 3340""&  38"4  :"&")&)4 "080" 4,4    4,    "  ,    48  )      & &38  1"  "      4,4  4,    1  " 4,3&>95!)3:&4*0!&"4 0  1"  3  "  ,  "  )      & ! 4,34,418""



:"  " &)4! !,,8



: &)""4F4&44,41"" )4, ,&  9"*180 ")4, ",0)&1333 ""

"E&&44,4")F

)8"&2,! 1"! 8" :"1 0" "&3 ,,)44&1""& 4 1"""")44

: 1""""E& E&,"434&0CD0

>0"" 388 4"1!838"4 B1 02,! 1" "", ), & 0"&) 4,44, &,", & 4 4,34,4 84,34,48 D 4"

D



*      "  ,8    "  ,     !  "     4,4&&381"4, ""1  4,35 9D>  C

 4,35 C

 

0"3 &3","&)4 " 33"""E&" )&  "!3)38!

& "40"""&3 )4 &&381" !",4,3" )3

'"3 &30 "44"" &)40 , (& !4B@)3" &,4&,  



  !"

#

$ % & "

'

( )"

 )



:"  " &)4 " 3!"&!""  (& !4 '" (& !41, 1"338!&,1 3(& !4 )8B@)3" &,4& $*( 

$ % ! )+, "

 -  .    ( )$ % ! )+*

- 

  B@)3" &,4 &01"3 &!"$*( 

/  &,"3 331 ; # #

# :1& 3 ""& 

4&3"&3310"F&",1  ""(&)38"1"401&3

, "&"44

 "  &4 :1"1 ,&3 ""3!3, &"F"

")",1"" ,&) !304   4,33"4!"" ) 3

######



C

'"4, 38!3"  )3"& "&)E& &&381"", &1"&& 

:  1  F,&    133 " "    & &!1&3 )34 "&)  3 #

#

#

#

< C

+&"01"3!( )/   &,1"3 331 ;#####'")" 1 " ,,33"!133") %

/3 &," &338 18!"(2 ,,""4 " ""&)E& 1&3 &&3801&3 338 ,

"&" " 33 & ?  )380",,331E&  "

&31 1"" "" 4,  "    )  , 0  "  &3     1&3 && 38 #### ##

< 

:",038) ,& "33"""E&0  "&1"""4,313 0" )&

 "!"3)38 0D0

>! & "4  '"3  3,!" "E&04,3  (& !4, )8"31& 331  



 

       

    





    

 

   !  "  #   



 



  

    

  

 

  

      

        

 

  

   

   

        

 



9

D

'""E&" !)&  "!3)38!&" 40",38)F ") &84,402,! 1" (& !4B@)3"*,F& !"

#

/   &,

*&"0 ""&) 4,40" ,0"33&&381""4, "" 14,3 4,35 9D>  C

,!

"&"E&)!5

  9



4&  0

>    4,3  5 C   

  ,!  

"&"E&)!5

 9  

4&  0

>  B1 0"4, &,", " 4 0

> 0

>02,! 1"4&"

"& "E&01""0CD0

> '" "33) , 4,"4,3  :133)&,3 4"!"

#

/   &,0D0

>"" 1" )4, 03"&!"""E&""1 4&0

> :"&40" 0

>0 ), 4,4,3&,301"" 4&"3"""E&4&0)!4, 01"33)! 4 " ""33"")! &

)! &&38



'"&01"3 &!"4,34,48

F  4"    1"3   !  "      4,4    & &38,33""4,30",)! 4, 4&! 0

>   ) '"



 "33), 4,"4,3 : ,840","33&"& !4,4C 4" :3 ",840" &3 4,4C4"3&"133&& 38, """ 9

'" , 4 F,"4    )

)*!+,!)+-* .%

/  %001 ,2(   "

  G"",2!>

H>5 G"",)3 H>5