Commissioner Of Central Excise And Service Tax v. Gaurav Pharma Ltd.
!!
" "#$%
"& '% ((##
)*"&+"!, !
- ( !"# $ %"& !"# "! ' " " +" + .&. "+((##
$ %"&(
'+-& *
((#/
+""(
01+2 !0"3 + +* .$%
"& '%((##'"
#.
"
(#3 +.4#+ " +".5+'"
#5."
/* ((# 678 9 6
3 678:
3. "
/
##4
*0 #;*
#4 < =++" ((## 0 "$''/
+ ""(
01+!!
"* * "
+* . : "("&
"# +/ " >
=++"+" " $''5 ,"/"3 + 7 !0"
#/##1 !
0# + 0
/"* *!!"
?>
=++"+@ @ +,"/"3 +
$'' :
0
/ 0 *( + ""#/#(
";* 1
"
" > & =++"+,"/"3 + 7!0"
!1# @
4"+" " ! +
+
((# /
" "" (
01 !!
" * "("&
#"#
? / *! . . ! * "
+ * . : # 0 " + $''* "
: +* .
: >A '+((# 4"(" ""0 "+'"
#/
+ ""(
01+!!
" * "#$%
.-+@.
"
/("&
#"# /
%"
(4"
* "
* . : " +".5+* 5 '4!0"
3 + + '"
# 4+ #
/"
/ 4 + "# " "" (
8 : $ , ' '"
*!0 .4+"
4 (
++((#/
+ ""(
* "
+* .
!
0#.
""+!"+"
+'"
"
* ,"/"3 + +
* B
+4+!"4 #
0 " 0 +
/
&!!0"
#*
/+"
+'"
# ,"
*
# "+((## */+"/*+4 !0"3 +*# +&(
0#1" ""+!"+2 !0"3 + *#+0 0" "","/"3 + +" !!0"
B "# " .4+ +4 *0.+!"4
"01 + "!!0"
" (
014!!0"
C *"+"
*0!
+ 1""(
* "
+*
&"".+ . ((#4 !
0#/
+ ! 0 "+'"
#* "
: +* "+"
/#"
*
# "+((## .4
1!"
+ *0!
! '4!0"3 + +'"
+&
/*0 +(
%("
01 "# "
,"/"
3 +
*(".& ""
7 7 7 " "" + !" + "
+ '"
# "
8
"
* ,"/"3 + "
+
* -#& ("+"
%"0#4 <'+"/
"1
"(#+"" 0 " +C 50#"
"
"
*+ ,"/"3 + +
'"
# 0&!
* A ("* # + " (" +4!0"3 + '"
+4 +
"
"
01 #"
*
# " + ((##
##1!
& +!"4 " ""0+" 010 +
/
&!!0"
01+4!!0"
4 !"#1 ""+"
+'"
"
* #"/"3 + '+" ". 4
& 01+"
+'"
"
/+ "*!
+ +4!*+!!0"
+*#
*+#"/"3 +
*"/"
/D*"
+"
+'"
#
*#"/"3 + "+"
/ 4
"01C 50#+ *("!*"
! :: *("!*" 78. 4 (
++ "
+'"
#+ +(4"
*,"/"3 +. (4"
+"
:7 +* -#& ("
+ " D*/! ""("*+"* " < '++"
+ !(#(4"" " #"/"3 +
*0
& 4 *0
7
:.4+ +4+& *0& '+ ("&
#"#1 1 +
+& +!!0"
3 +
(
1(
. +!!0"
" ;*##1 . + +## 0 " "" + "
"+"
/ 1 *+(
01 "!" "
!!0"
+'"
#. *+ (
+##0
"
/+(
+!D"
1 !!0"
B
"* + *0 7 "
" (
"
/! / !!0"
3 +
(" *#" . (
##14+"+!!0"
3 +*0+""
"# "
C4&".
:
(4" " " *(
+"
'+(4" +*#0
"*04 */+ 0#+"
!@" " 4+" !!0"
3 +
+!
#& * 0# "
/=++1(" &0+""#4 0* !( ! "
"! "#
4 +4+ ++1
+ #1/" B *+ .
"1 "++#+1
/ '"
# + + "
+*# +& + ";*
*+"
1" "+ #"/"3 + '+
(4"
4+ +
!(#
+ %("
/" *+"
/ + "
*0 + +'"
"
%( *
+"/
A '+'"
*01+ "#)&"
! * "
: +* *0
7
:
+* ." * "
: 7B +!!0"
3 +
"
(
1 (
. + (
+## 0 "
/ + (
+!D"
1.
+"
!D"
1.0*
!!0"
";*##1 .+1 +## +(
"
(
4+ ++1
" + +##0" "" 01+"
"+"
/ *+(
"(
01 "!" ++"!!0"
+((##'"
#.
*+(
"(
+##0 "
/+ (
+!D"
1 +!!0"
+((## '"
#4++&+"+
#*
/+ 4+
"
+" "& +4+"+!!0"
( #3 +
7 ";*##1 .+(
"(
4+ ++1
+##0 01+"
*0D+("&
+
.+((## '"
+##+&(4""/*# 4 ("*" +("*" +3 + +"
##!"
"
/* +%"
(4"
"+
+"/
.
#*
/+(# 4+ ++3 +
+##+#+ "
/ E =+ # *""
/4 ++& 4%("
.4
!"
+ " "
01#"
*
# "+((## "/"
/
* +2 &!0"3 + "+"
/ +((# '+
* */+ 0 "
"/"
/ !
0 # 1 ((#/
+""(
01+!!
" "
("&
#"# /
%"
(4"
* "
+* -#& ("&
+"%"0#4 ! #!()*+, <- #!",.)/<D*
/*+"
1A!
1*+"
1 !( (
1"""
* "+
.0*
#*+3" .!!
"((# "
((##'"
#F - #!"))0 1" " 23& (&# !
&!%"3 "4 &5 &"3&$ &"#!"6 1/ .
*! " +
/ ? * "
. !1.
(
/+"" +D*
/*+"
1.0"# +4 " @
/0 "!+ !
+("(" "!
+ *+ *"
1
+ D*
/ *+"
1!1";* - #!"),*55 !!% 55 !
" G 1("
//"
&01 1 + ##4
/""
!1 ((#+((##'"
#/
*+""
"""(
01+"
(# !!
" * " !!
"
* D*
/*+"
1F 0 "" (
01 + !!
((# * "
F ""(
01+3""+((## !!
" * * "
.
!! #10 "+((
1F ""(
01+3""+"
(# !!
" * " !!
"
* . +"0 "" "+((
1.
" 8. !! #10 " +1 A :
'+ */+0"
01+((##
*((" +"/*! + ((#
!
0#/
""(
01+ !!
" "("&
#"# /
+ *+ ""
##1
&
B
D* "1.& +*/+ !1+&0 (
01 D* "1*+"
1
( + ("&
+ * +D*"
%"
01+D* "1*+"
1+
0 *!!*(01+'"
(" 9 +"".4+ +" %"0#4 <
+!(4"
+
+("("
"+ "
0# &+ 1/ "# 0#
* "+
.+!1 ? *+/ F*(
?*" + / "
"#6 * 1 + * ("! 4 + ( ?/
*
+ + ("
"! 4+! *+ / 4" ?
("& "("&
#"# ? / (
/+"" +D*
/*+"
1 *+ "# 0"" #101D*
/*+"
14 +
*+
+!1";* " ,".
0 # 1
?*"
;* "+4 "4 ##0 "*!(#
/ .01+D*
/
9 *+"
1 "" " ("&
# "# " " + ? / + 4 " '+
!( " *+ "
01+D*
/*+"
1 *+
4 ##"
#1+&#/#
;* +4 / +# /+ (4"
%"
01+D* "1*+"
1.
4+;* "
4++"
"!
("&
: * ((#
!
0#0 "+'"
#.
*"(
.
+
4"4*#0
(
&
: +* ("& + 1("
//"
&01 1 + ##4
/""
!1 ((#+'"
#/
*+""
.
*+ ""+ 0 ! 01+"
(#!!
" * "!!
" *
D* "1*+"
1 '+ +"" ("&
#"# /
(
01 D* "1*+"
1
(* '+ #1
*/+0!
+ +
&+"" ;*
# #("1
01
#((#0 "+'"
# =
1"""
+0 "&
!01+'"
+""
!(*/ + + !
" %"
(4"
+&
/ 0
(
##1
+* +% 4+ + +""4 ## 0!
&";*
D* # "
+ * . + D* "1 *+"
1%"
4 " /
" "1(4"
=+ &" *+
(4"
%"
.+
"1
;* 4+ +
"!
"
/+ + (" . + ("
(# *"# D* (
. * #
(
##1%#*01+ * B
+ +-& *++
* 0"
(("*
1 +"
/ + ("1
B
# ("
(# #4+4+ &" #
;* ##4 "! ""
(
01 *+"
1.
*!++"" ;*
D* #""
- " + 0 !D*/! C 50#+*("!*"
"# $ !% 9
'+
* 4++" 1*+"
1
" ;*
#*+"
1 +
" "01 ;*
D* #
&
4+"+#
04 +4
/(" .0* +
4
"01C 50#+*("!*"
!& '
!! () 7 7 '+(
%("
4 +4+"&" *"1*+"
1
##1.
"! ;*
D* # +"
/+ 04 (" ""!
-#& (" +" "%"0#4 < 3*+"" 4+"+"
#
"4
/(" 0 " *"1*+"
11 *+
*"1*+"
1+ 0 +#0;*
D* #
" "01 ;*
D* #
4+
*+ *"1*+"
1
";* "D* ##1 B
H* & *0#
"(" 9 B,-89 . 4
+#+* EB +
+"!D* #
"
#1! I*/"#/#"
"+"!
!"
#4.
0* "(*"( +
;* .D* #
!
0 01!( *+"
1 *(
" "*!
!(
/# 0 # 1"
/+"
/+
+"001!(4"01#4 ;*
.!@ ! !( "
"
. 4*# !!++ *+ 01
&#&
*+
;* 4*# 0 # @
, I ++ 4 .
-%& $#"
1
: !!
:
J3 +4+ 01 ("
+&
/ #/# *+"
1 "!
;*
/+"
/+ *0D +&
/+ *1D* ##1. *+01 ("
;*
#01
/ 01+!
;*
D*
B +
.+"4 "#
04 + 4
/ (" 0 " + !!
" '+ !!
". " !@
/
;* "1 +"
/+0D
4 ";* "(
"" B * +##.4+4 +#
+ "
4 .4+" *"1*+"
1
!(4"@
4+ +
+"
/+ ("
*+
*+"
1 * " + "#& #4 ";* " !@
;* "1 +" + (" . *+ *+"
1
;*
#
" "01
;*
D* # "&
3!01& J* # &
"
*(". 4 +#+*
E +
*!(4"
*+"
1. 0
/*"
+"
"1
.
(* "
/* # !!01 ("1 " + * 4+ + # !
(( 01 +" ("1 "!
+ " ( "
/+ +
/(" 4+"(( ++".+"
#
("
!
+ 0 1+
/
+ * + ""1
+*1 +*+"
1 ##1 +
+*+"
1
;*
D* #F
+
*"1*+"
1+ (4" 1 4+ + 4 ## ("D* ##1
+
*0D.+ .#+*/++"" 4("
(" "! + *+"
1 +
04 +*+"
1("(
/+ + *0D((
.+
#"!
+ *+"
1 4 ## 1 0 ;*
D* #
("& +*+"
1
";* "01+ * D* ##1 +"4" .4+ #+(" 4("
0
+
/*+"
14 ##("
!
+0 1+" " !( *( +*+"
1+*1D* ##1.+ 0 4 *+("
&
@
/+ +*+"
1* +/"1 ;*
D* #
+ *+"
1
&"+#
";* " 01 + * ##1 E
'+#/#("
(# #1
/4 4+
*"1*+"
14*#0;*
D* #.4+ + !"/ "!+ "
"+ =+" *"1*+"
1!(4"* "
* 1 0 4+ + 4*# ("D* ##1
+ *0D#+*/++"
#
"4
/(" +
04 +*+"
1 + *0D + *"1*+"
1
";* "D* ##1 " + *. +
+ *+"
1
;*
D* ((#1
/+ " ("
(#.4" +& 4 ++(" #
" 04 +
/ (" 0 " *"1*+"
1.
+0 +""
0* ;*
D* #*+"
1
+# + *+ *"1 *+"
1
;*
D* *+"
1 C4&".
+ 0 #
0 "
*"1*+"
1.+*+"
14*#0;*
D* *+"
1
";* "D* ##1
!
/+ "/*! #"
*
#
"+" ( .
"*+!"(" "
4"
0* ;*
D* #*+"
14*# !@
& ;*
D* # B ! .
!
&*+"
1!1"!
;*
0 """
/
4+ +!1
+"
/+
((## 0* *+
4*# 0 ;*
# B
" +
/+
! "(#1 !1!
"
/ (("*
1+# ! 4+ "
/+
/
/ 0
01 + + !
& *+"
1. ## *+ !
*+"
14*# 0;*
D* #*+"
1
=+
/*
+
& "!;*
#
.
+ ;*
D*
* "
+"#& #4+ *"1*+"
1
";* " ##1 B +" 4" . 4+" #4 ";* +
*+"
10 """
/
!* !@ ;* "1.
*+";* "! #4!@ +*+"
1;*
#*+"
1
,"
*
# "+" ( + +;*
D*
&
4+ ++#4";* 0%"
!" (
4" D* #
+ & 4 + !". +
+"/ 01 + $# !!
* "
: +
##1!
&
*" ,"
*
#
*((" +
"/*! "# *(
##4
/(
/ "!=2"
1+5 !
,4 E;*
D*
4+ ++#4";* 0%"
!" (
4"D* # 1( # %!(#
!
"
/4++""
"!!(*# "1(*"+ """##4 (#
/ ((# " (*0#
;* "1 '+
#
!
&. 01 (# 1 %( 1 3* + ("*"
*0D+("
(# *"#D* .4+ + ";* " + !
" "#1 4" + 0D
"%!(#@ + & 4 +*
#
+! ;*
#
+" "
4+ +
*0D !! *"
#("*" E =
1!"
+ *0!
+ * . !* 00"
!
+ +" 4+ +
/*
+
& "! ;*
D*
. + *+"
1 4+ ;*
D* ##1
";* ""
/+"*# .4+" +*+"
1 4+ +

01+(# 1 %( 1 B +(" .+$# !!
";* ""/
"(# #("1
" + 1(# 1"%( 10* "
#1
" ++ *"1("&
'+ ";*(
/
"!!
&,401=2"
1+
4+##1
((# 0#+(" -+". / /
+ "/*! #"
*
# "+" ( '+ " ;* (
/ +4 + 4+" *+"
1 4+
01(# 1 %( 1%"
!
#+*/+ !10%"
!" (
4"D* #.4+ +
+ +" A!(+
*((# B
0
(* + + (4"
& 4 + + D*
/ *+"
1 0 %"
"
"
/ + ("1" "
("&
#"# /
"*!
"
04 +4## #("
(#
#4/&"
/+ ! *+ ""
0 1(# 1."+"
#("
(# #4 '+ ""
0
*!+
##1."+"
! 1 "
"";* "0
" *+ + *" / .
*
.4++"+/ 0
!(""("+ .
1 *+""(
+ #
;* .+ .
0 (
++ !
(
01+D*
/*+"
1
%"
&(4"
"+" + "
/+#10 (
01+'"
8 ++%"
(4"
01+!!
"* "
;*
D*
*" +""(
'+# /*/
+*
;* 4
((# @4 +
*!0"## *+ ""
(
./
4+ +((#4*## +'"
# - "
&!
/
*// 01+-& *
0/ +("&
4"
#"& 4
%"
%""
"1D*"
* "" #8
+
* B
#/+"
"
0 !("4 + *"1"
/+ ((#4+"+ (
"
"
#"/" '+"!
*
: +* "5
"5""
5
/+"01
# !
1
#
!
#"& 4+ 0 %("
01#+ C /+*"
*$ (
=
7 9 :
7
(+
8 $ , ' 7.01-D +
/+*"
+ %
=
:
6
.
'
'B
2" + "
! 0&. 4
*0 # ;* #4 "
+ (" ((# '+ !
"
/#1
!
-D +3
# I*/
!
-4#
I*/ =++" (@
/6" K 6 =++"-("0# K 6