High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11674/2014allowed

Satpal Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-12-22Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari8 pages

!

"#$%

&'

"

())#$

*$ +,* ---,

!"

#

$ !!$ --, . "

%&'&%'(&)!

* +,-.

/ %+0 "$ ".

. '1'&%'(&)!

*+2- .

/ "$ ")!3

- 0$ )!3

- "" /

.

. 3 ('('%''()!

*+(- .

/ &

.

3 " / 3 (1'4%'',)!

*+%- .

/ %

.

3 " / 35 6''4%'', )!

*+6- (

3 " 3 " / 7

0$ "

/3 %,'6%'(&

! '1'1%'(6 3 ,83 3.

""/ 0$)!3

-.

"

""

. /

9 .9

"

/ /

" 3..

%'

" ".

. 9 " .

(11'

/ < "" / " 3 (''6(114 %('2(114 =%

&

.

3 " 3 9 < "

3 / "3%4'%%'','4'6%'', 4 %

. 3 3 (1'4%'',)!

*+%- / " . .

;

"" / "3%6'4%''2%1'1%''2 6= (

.

3 " .

3 3 6''4%'',)!

*+6- 9 "

/ " . / 6 .:" '1'1%'(6)!

* +&- ;

:

"

/ . / 0 "$ " /"

=

.

/ " 7

> /9 / %..

" 3 .

" 3 " . . ..

%

. .

/ ""/ 0$)!3

- .

>./3 "

/ 7/3 * %4'&%'(&)!

* +(-.

6''&%'(&;

" ./

%

/ ! (,%4 :/ " (16& .

6

. % . "3 . / /

" .

"

"3 "

.: 3 . '1'&%'(& / 0$ )!3

-..

: .

". "3

.

: /

. / " 0

? :

!"

#$ %!

3

(,%4 @(,%4. ."

+)(-;

> " $ 0> "$

"3" " .3/ /

" 3

" 3

3 37

""

/3/

);

$ 3 " " . .3/ > "$ " :// /

3- )%-> . 3

"

.

/

./

3 ;

" 3 " )6-> "

"

. /

" "

"

.

/

"A ./:"3" /

? / .

"

3 3 " / " 6

/ ! ! %('2(11, B / 0 "$ " ',(%(11,;

3" .

/ %((%%''&

6

.

3 "." (

3 " 4 /9 .

/ " / "$ 3."

&

! %('2(11,. " /9 6'('%'',./:" 3"

/ 0

? "3

"7

: "

3 4 /9

" / // . /

/"

"

"

"

"3 " : 0

? . / "/ " "

"3 " "

.

"

" 3 .

/ .

;

3

. > " "

"3 " " / " /9 %&'&%'(&

/

/.

.

" "

"

(')"-

"

. 3 1 7 0$ "3 "

" ..

" <

. /* 3 " "

"/"

.

;

" "

" / /

" / /

" "" /3 : !*

' ( ) *+ * )

"

&&.

.

"

/ "

.

"33 7 @

3/

" 3/

: 9 + : 3

: " + @(1 "

" " 3/ .*

3 ;

3/ 3 3 / 3 C "

" / 3 .

" * /

"3 * " "

"3 " " 3+.7 .

9 ;

/. : " 3

" .

.

3

.

"

" 9 " 3/" "*

B"

" 9 "B "3

" 3

/ "

/ 3 +"

3 > .

3/ "3

""

D

"

A "" / " )

"

%

!*

.

*"

. (,%4 ""0$ . . 3. /

/ / .

: " ;

!

""

. .

"

"

. 3

/ ..

: /"7/ .

. / 3

.

. " 3 3

" ."

/

;

@(= C . 7 37 "

"33 : " . ""0$

"

".

"" *

37

. 3

/ .

.

3 /" "

3.

""3 " . / . ""

/ ";

.

".

" .

.3. *"

"

7

" .;

"

/

" " "

. . / " ..

: .

/ .

"

3

. D "B"

..

: .

.*"

" 3> ".

/ 0$ . . /"7/

3" . 3

/ *"

"

/ 3

E

"

!

. : "

*"

* .>. "3 " 0$.3.*"

*"

. / F 3

"

3 " . / 3 ;

/

3

" / 3 " /

C3 :

"/.5(1%2!

%&

.

.

.

3 G!

3 " 3 *"

" / !

" 3.3 .

7 3 /" 3

+ 3

*"

" .

7/.

> . 3 /

"

. ".

" 3" / G " " "

/ /+

%&'&%'(&)!

* +,- .

./ .

.

"

/ /: 3 ""

9 > . 3 " .

/ . " " / " '1'&%'(&)!

*+2- %%(%%'(= /--,0