Banarsi Dass v. Union Of India And ORS

 
  
  
  
 



 

 !"#"$% 

 !"#"$% 

 !"#"$% 

 !"#"$% $& '()  $& '()  $& '()  $& '()  '#" ##  "$'

*'#&# $"$ $ "

$  +'# #,$ $
-%
-%
-%
-% ./-00
0 ./-00
0 ./-00
0 ./-00
0 '#$ % '#$ % '#$ % '#$ % -'0 2) 3!

' "$' 44444 44444 44444 44444 0) 0) 0) 0)  "$'+ "2  +"#, "$!+ 22$5"$5 ' '

 6 78$$9&':;< / '$ !&$#2 ' "$'+ ##&=>"

+'#,$ $ #+ $ !''!

2( "9 "$'

, '1"

++"#?&$"'  "$'  2$5  1"

+   +'#  + "2 
  ; @+# " 1'"

, "$1 # "#,#  =(

+"#
&'

3" ' '

   7 +# " ' '

#&$ '%: A+  , "$'#)  1+  '    "$  $&>=') 3 "2  +"#, '"##& $!  "'!

"$#

+'#,$ $ # ,&, +"',

, 1"

+"'?&$"'#

+"'?&$"'#1'

,'>   B,"$5  "$  3"1  +  !"#"$    "21 ( ' 

  0+'

',2(+ #=$ "2 $=+ '#,$ $ #  $  '#,!

 #3$  , "$'#)  "

#=$#

+"', (+ #=$# ,, &, $ $ &'

+''2"

"# =5'

+> / '$ !&$#2 ' "$'#

$ &= #3$, "$'#+ #=$ ,,  &,  =&  1+"2  "$5  #)  "

 + #  =$ C&

  1"

+  ?&$"'#)  1+  + 3  =$  ,&$"#+>$  # ,, 5    $  "$!'>$  1"

,'> $$

!

$!)+#

"$'#"#2"

=2 =C&

 1"

+"'?&$"'#)1++ 3$ =$ #&!+,&$"#+>$  / '$ !&$#2 ' +'#,$ $ ##

 "

+#  #3$  , "$'#)  +  +'

+'  , "$'#  1+  + 3  $  # 

'  =$ 5'

+=$ # ,&,)#,

2(#&=>"

 ','#$

"$  1"

+ 

"2#   +"'  ?&$"'# 1"

+"$ +'>$ +# () +'#,$ $ 1&2 

B   !"#"$  +'$  1"

+"$  +'

>$ +# +'

' "#,#  "$ =3 '>#D +'

')  , "$'  #&=>"

  ','#$

"$ $$9&':6)1+'"$)"

1 #,'

( 

"$'  =  # ,,  &, 

 , '  1"

+  +"#  ?&$"'  $ >2( E&#+ 2
+ $ #$ '>
+ $ ) 
$#

=2)1+1

,,"$ #
$#

=2"$ +( '6 $ ,'>

+  ,#   
$#

=2  $     + ','#$

"2 =( "$'1 # "#,#  3"

">,&5$ ' '

 6 78$$9&':;<+# ' ''

#&$ '%: A "#"$ ">

 =( +"#2

'

3" 2

@ ++

"!)= '"$5:F FFF/8"9<

@  )  2

'  
:*:

@FF

    ,& (  "'!

'  
>>"##"$)   ( 
>>"##"$:*)   "21 (   #'!"3 "$ +"#

"!"$1+"!+"

1 #' '

# ,:&, 0$"'
$#

=2,'>

= '     1"

+  &$"' 
$#

=2 ,'>

'    '>  + 

?&$"'!$#

=21 #,'>  !!' "$5 +"#

')(&', (1 ## ,:&,1"

+E '$ "20"$5+#F 0+  -&$#+  0"$5+)   
$#

=2F  1  $ "

1 #"$ ">

(&3"  +"#

"!2

'

  @$ +"#'5 ' )
"3"2'"

 "$ ;F @ "2 =((&1 ,$ "$5"$ +$.=2"5+
&'

&$?

=  '( ) 
+ $ "5 '+ 1  +$.=2 &$?

=

$  '( "5+
&'

)
+ $ "5 '+"$ +"#1'"

"$+ #"##& ' '

  7

(&!

$5 (&', "9 =(#&=>"

"$5 $1

,,2"!

"$    +  , >$  1"

+"$  +'

>$ +#  '>  + 

 ' '  >$ 1"22

B !

"$$(&' ,,2"!

"$"$

& &'  +'  >$ +#   $  ,&'#& $!    (&'

,,2"!

"$  #&=>"

  $   7 7)  >$ + ## ,&,(&', (1"

+0+E&#+
+ $ #$ '>
+ $ 1+#$ >+ #=$ 1'"

$=((&"$(&' ,,2"!

+  +  =$  ,'>   +  ,#  

$#

=21+"!+"## > "9  '2"'& ,'  +"#  +  =$  + #  =$  5'

  1  7 "$#

 +'

') =$ 2'

(  5'

  (& "#  ,','   + !+  , (  , '"

(  1"

+  0+  E&#+ 2 
+ $  #$ '>
+ $ "#$!2# +'1"

+D

+&#) ,'&# 2 =3' ''3 2#

"$'+ 2'

(=$5'

+=$ 1  7  2$51"

+">,&5$ ' ')!+ , '"

(   +  , "$'  1"

+  E&#+ 2 
+ $  1 #  2# $!2# ,'&# 2 +# >'3 2#

"$'1 "9 

+'

G@) 7F: #1 #="$5 5"3$ +"#?&$"'E&#+ 2
+ $ 1   7  +&#)

+  '2"

 !2 ">  =(  +  , "$'  + #  2'

(  =$ 5'

+"> 5'&$  '"$ '$!=( +"#
&'

"#>

&  "#>"## 13')"$!

#)"

$() ''

'#$

!!&$ "9

"$ , (, '"

"$'1"

++"# ?&$"'E&#+ 2
+ $ # "22'> "$ =, " ) "$'

1&2 =

2"='

> B','#$

"$"$ +"#'5 '  '#,$ $   80< 80< 80< 80<      $& '()  $& '()  $& '()  $& '() > 3"'