Gurmeet Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS
!
"
#$% $&
$!'$$ $
$& $!
& ( &))* +,, -
! "
# #
$
%
" &
! &!
& #
&
"!"
$
!
$
!$*
.%/
!, # 0
$! $ '()(*+, '$ -./'/0123-4/+( 5-'+6(.(+0+0-*(')0*
1
1 #
1 &
1 !
/*2
'/778123-4/+( 5-'+6(.(+0+0-*(')0*! "
1 &!
/*2 #
'$6/9/*123-4/+( 5-'+6(.(+0+0-*(')0* "!"
'--*123-4/+(5-' ' /++6123-4/+( 5-'+6(.(+0+0-*(')0* &
)*86/+'/+61'23-4/+(90+6 ):;0</ (20118*=/; ' 0</)0*76123-4/+( 5-''().-*2(*+- 0* ! "
/*2 #
/*2 5-''().-*2(*+)- /*2#0* &
1 &
1 &!
/*2 !
>>>>> $! $1 #, * +60) ;8*46 -5 .(+0+0-*)1 +6( (')+960?( (:.?-@(()
.(+0+0-*(')-5+6(/+0/?/--.('/+03(87/'0??)%0:0+(26/3( )-876+ A8/)60*7 -5 -?8*+/'@ (+0'(:(*+ 46(:(
5-' )6-'+1 96('(;@1 +6(@ 9('( ./02 4-:.(*)/+0-* 960?( 20).(*)0*7 90+6 +6(0' )('304()58'+6('20'(4+0-*6/)/?)-;((*)-876+20'(4+0*7+6('().-*2(*+) +- +/<( +6( .(+0+0-*(') ;/4< 0* )('304( -' /2=8)+ +6(: 0* /*@ -+6(' 4--.('/+03(-'/*@-3('*:(*+2(./'+:(*+*4/)(+6(.(+0+0-*(')2-*-+ )844((20*/5-'()/02.'/@('1/*/?+('*/+('(?0(56/);((*)-876++-+6((55(4+ +6/+ B 2(/'*()) /??-9/*4( ;( /22(2 0* +6( ?/)+ 2'/9* ./@1 960?( 4-:.8+0*7+6(4-:.(*)/+0-*./@/;?(+-+6(:1/).('2(50*0+0-*-5C)/?/'@C 2(50*(20*+6( 0+)(?5
/30*76(/'2+6('03/?4-*+(*+0-*)-5+6('().(4+03(?(/'*(2 4-8*)(?)/*2-*.('8)/?-5+6(.?(/20*7)/?-*790+6+6('(?(3/*+'(4-'250?(2 +6('(90+61/:-5+6(30(9+6/+/)5/'/)+6(.'/@(')((<0*7A8/)60*7-5
0)4-*4('*(21+6()/:(4/**-+;(/44(.+(25-'+6('(/)-*))+/+(20*+6( )844((20*7./'/7'/.6) '0:/'@/'78:(*++-/))/0?+6( 0)+6/++6-)(96-202*-+ -.+5-'+6( 9('(0*+6((*2;(++('-5/)+6(@9('(?/+('-*/2=8)+(2 (0+6('0* )-:(-+6(' 4--.('/+03(-'0* +6(-3('*:(*+2(./'+:(*+1/) /7/0*)++6(4?/0:-5+6(.(+0+0-*(')196-9('(0*284(20*+-/44(.+0*7+6(
-*+6(.'(:0)(+6/+0*4/)(+6(@2-*-+-.+5-'+6()/:(1+6(@9-8?2 6/3(+-5/4(+6(.'-).(4+)-5'(+'(*46:(*+10*/44-'2/*4(90+6?/92-*-+ 50*2/*@5-'4(0*+6()/02/'78:(*+/)1-+6('+6/*+6( ;/?2/))('+0-* +6/+ +6-)(96-202*-+-.+5-'+6( 6/3(;((*703(*;(++('+'(/+:(*+1+6('(0) *-+60*7-*'(4-'2+-()+/;?0)6+6()/:( # *+6(.'(:0)(1+6('(6/);((**-6-)+0?(20)4'0:0*/+0-*-' /';0+'/'0*())-'-+6('90)(/*@30-?/+0-*-5'+04?(#-5-*)+0+8+0-*-5
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
4/* ;(0))8(220'(4+0*7+6('().-*2(*+)+-+/<(+6(.(+0+0-*(');/4<0*)('304(-' /2=8)++6(:0*/*@-+6('2(./'+:(*+E4--.('/+03( !
8'+6(':-'(1+6('(0)/).(405044-*20+0-*0*+6( +6/+-*4( /*(:.?-@((-.+)5-'+6()/:(16()6/??*-+;((?070;?(5-''((:.?-@:(*+ /*2E-'/2=8)+:(*+0*/*@7-3('*:(*+=-;-'0*/*@4--.('/+03()87/':0??-' /*@)8;)020/'@6('(?(3/*+?/8)( 0D-5+6( 0)'(.'-284(26('( 0*;(?-9,
!
"
#
!
"$
& ('8)/?-5+6(/;-3(?(/3()*-:/**('-52-8;++6/+6/30*7 -*4(3-?8*+/'0?@-.+(2+6( 1+6(.(+0+0-*(')/'(;-8*2;@+6(4-*20+0-*) -5+6()/:(/*2+6(0'.'/@('5-'/2=8)+:(*+0*/*@-+6('4--.('/+03()87/' :0??)-'7-3('*:(*+2(./'+:(*+0)*-++(*/;?(0*?/9/'+048?/'?@10*30(9 -5+6(0'6/30*73-?8*+/'0?@-.+(25-' )'(7/'2)+6(/?+('*/+03('(?0(5)-876+;@+6(.(+0+0-*(')10+ 9-8?2;(/..-)0+(+-'(.'-284(+6('(?(3/*+?/8)( 3-5 /);(?-9, F %%%%% &'
$ ( )
*+,&+ ,
'
"$ 6( 0))8( 96(+6(' )/?/'@ 0*4?82() (:-?8:(*+) -' 2(/'*()) /??-9/*4(0)*-:-'('()0*+(7'/1/)+6()/:(6/);((*4-*4?8)03(?@)(++?(2 ;@4/+(*/-5=827:(*+) -''(/2@'(5('(*4(1+6('(?(3/*+(D+'/4+5'-:-*( -5 +6( '(4(*+ .(D -8'+ =827:(*+ 0(
! " # $'(.-'+(2/)%&'( % ) '*+0)'(.'-284(26('(0*;(?-9, F
!
F
!
"
#
!
#
!!
+ ! $
% &'! ( ) * + , -.//0123,,4.0
!5
67
F/ !!
5
6$
-!1 3 .- 18
-19
!
- 19 !
!
! !!
5
!
!
& !
!
-1,
! !
.
"## $ % # $#&$' (# ) * *
# +, -.- /0
F:
!;;
-'
9 <1 $
$
! .
! !
!
/ 9 ! !
&!
!
!
9
!
!! !
!
!
"
=
!
!
!
!
5
&
!
3
2> (
<
!
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
'(*2('(2;@+60) -8'+0*"
1+0+?(2/) ) ,- )./)
01 ) 23- 96('(0*60)%-'2)60.
8'@/$/*+1 /)6(+6(*9/)).(/<0*75-'+60)-8'+-.0*(2/);(?-9, F- ) ) .
! / ( !
"0 + 1 ) . "0
+1
4
"
"$ ..?@0*7+6('/+0--5=827:(*+0* /029/*C)4/)(1
/ 9'0+-5
0)0))8(220'(4+0*7+6('().-*2(*+)+-/22 B-5+6( 2(/'*())/??-9/*4(0*+6(?/)+2'/9*;/)04./@-5+6-)((:.?-@(()96- -.+(25-' /*27'/*++6(:+6(;(*(50+-5+6(2(50*0+0-*-5+(':)/?/'@/) 4-*+/0*(20*+6(2(50*0+0-*?/8)(-5+6( +0):/2(4?(/'+6/++6( 50*/*40/??0/;0?0+@/)/4-*)(A8(*4(+6('(-5)6/??;(=-0*+/*2)(3('/?A8//?? '().-*2(*+) # %(++6(4/?48?/+0-*;(4/''0(2-8+90+60*/.('0-2-5
:-*+6) /*2 +6( 50*/*40/? ;(*(50+) +6('(-5 )6/?? ;( 20);8')(2 +- +6( .(+0+0-*(') /?-*790+60*+('()+G"B.('/**8:90+6(55(4+5'-:+6(2/+(-5(*+0+?(:(*+ +0??+6(/4+8/?2/+(-520);8')(:(*+ 0).-)(2-50*/;-3(+(':) " 0)4(??/*(-8)/..?04/+0-*105/*@1/?)-)+/*2)20).-)(2-5 ! 6-+-4-.@-5+60)-'2(';(.?/4(2-*+6(50?(-5-+6('4-**(4+(2 4/)() +,, -
$! $ ):'0+0 # &
6(+6(').(/<0*7E'(/)-*(2 ,H()E- 6(+6('(.-'+/;?( ,H()E-