High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17396/2012allowed

Sandeep Kumar And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2017-01-10Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh9 pages

Pooja Sharma 2017.01.13 15:08

"" # $% &!!

(") "" # $%

&!!

()") ""

# $%

&!!

+,-./+.001

!12 +34"5" ,673" 4"85,67

"! ,)" "5" ,673" , 6" 5,67

!! *"

!"!' '* & ,)) 345+,95 $% ::::

- "! $ ) " ! 44 "!! "6"4

""!% ")!

5' '* !7

!" 43 7! "646"44 7!! / !8 76"75 7! %")< 7

- !"" !% "4 , "74! = !"

" 0" "!!

7 3 ""

7 " ! ") 7")! +

4 "

" "

!> +> 4' 7!" "

" !! % +"6"!"4 .)" !5 3 %?5 7"

! 4? +"4 @4 ! 6 % 7!" !53 5,0.=+) ! 6%") ,

? !4!% "!!

7 "

7" !! 4 6"3+ " !!

%?7!" ") 7"

! !"

7 ;

44%?6"

$%0

")"+

9 >,> 6"7 4!5A "

!> & 4!5A>,

! 4! % !! %"

" !!=677"!" 7 !

2"6"3 434"3%?@>%4 ,<

" 7! !"

# !$ % &'('& !) * - !$ % &'

A " 4?5 7! 7!! " !"" "" ! )) "6%? 7" !!" 7!" ") " !! %+"6"!"4

"7 != +"6"!"4.)" !"

7 4!5A5!

. 4" 5 "" )6 %? & 4!83!

$% 6"7 .)" ! 4!!200 0

")" B 7 & 4!5 A

! > & 4!5 A> ,! !" & 4!5 " ! !3!%

)! 4?!5 3 3 !!!!") +) ! !7 "% " ,"<>,> !"& 4!") %?44 677"!3 %

)! ,0.!=) ! %!;

4?5 4!5A7 "<"!7! !"& 4!5AC!! +"6"!"4.)" % "44%?3? "

"2! 6"7 7"!5 3 "7 C 3! !7 "%

,0.>!=) !- "

4 " D & 4!5AE3! 677"!53 "7 <"!3 2!4"3%?@>%4 ,<

"& !) * 1- !";

C3!"7 !*C%?6"

" & 4!

%? $%0

")"+

9 >,> 6"70!, 4!5!"

" " 4 D & 4!5 AE5 44 677"!=!!53 "7 7 "<"!7 ? 2 3 % "44%? 6"") ;

! !7 "% 4!,!

7! !5"44? <"

4? !!3 44 ;

,0.=) !- "" ! )) "6%? 7" !!! !2+

%?7!" ") 7 !3 43 ? A5 $7 7"

! ! F !" !4 !7! ! $" !2+

! ( "

.)" !

")! 6"75 ?7;

") 4"

"7" ,0.G 4!5 A5 3! 6"!" "

)! "4 ! !"

56 "

A 3! 6" "4 ! "

3!4! "< ) !- & 4!5A7 "<"!753 "7 3

6""

"7" 53 ";

,0.=) 4 ! " 7 % +"6"!"4 .)" ! 3!

"7 !

C*CF !" !44!7! 7" !!"7!" ") 7!! !

" !! "!44?"44)45 %"

7 ? " $ ) @>%4 ,<

" & !

) * 15!" !4 ?%74 " 4!5A3 8

7 677"!77

2") %? & 4!5A3 !7"6"

77 ")4?44 677"!53 "7 7 "<"!7 ") " 7 & 4!5A % %? ;

!7 "%

!"& 4! 0"!4! )

4 !" !4 ! ! 4!5A5 "7 4 7) !%

"< "44") "4!!!

7 & 4!5A 6 %4"4? !!% 677"!!344, 5 4 !" !4!

"! !! % ! "

" =* C 677"! 6 ) 7 ,0.=) 4 ! 77 ")4? "" ! "4

=*C ;

!!3 7 4!5A F 7 !4 !2 !

"! ! 6 7 "!

3" 74 !! ? 6

7"7

% "!

- ;

,0. !

4 ?% %!"! 7

" + 4 ' "6"3 !!%? "!

"F,

* * ' "4! &2!$ &2!+%) - &(' !"

#- ! 6 "4 !"" ! ") 7")! + 4'%?7!" ") "

7! " !! %+"6"!"4

"7 !- 7! !7 4% 7!" " !" ")!! ,0.7) ?3!6"4%4

4!5A!!

7 !"""! ""%4 F 7 !4

"! !! % 7) "! " "4 !,0.=+) ! 64 ?% !

( " .)" !

,0.;

64 ?% ! +"6"!"4

"7 !6" "6"3 $ ) !!%?F,B7 " &2!$ &2!+%'.

1 F !" !4 !! * !4! ! !

"!!"! %?4 !" !4 ! @!

"! ! !2"!74

3 " 7

"7" "4"

'53 "5" !%

" 3!< ""3! 3

' !! %+"6"!"4

"7 ! 3 "7 AC!!3 %

)! ,0.=) !5 5

3 ,0. 4 ! ?3 77 ?")*!!4?- 7 7")!3 " ?

5 3! 677?53 "7 3!%)"6,0. 4 !F !" !4

"! AA

3! "4%?,0. 4 !5 3 "5

"6"3! "4%? !2 < 7!7" !7"!" %8%? !2 "44") 44 <"!")677"! ) 4 %!"! 04'

!!3 )"6 "!5

,0.=) 3 8")" +

7 ?3 "<7!! "

F !" !44!!

"! "" ! 6 ") 74"

!! " & 4!5A!!7"

"7"

7"!3 "!!

%?@>%4 ,<

" & !) * 1 "44 67!!! & 4!5A @ )

! 67 %? 4 7 !4 "! 64!) ) 7

!6"4%4 "4 - ) "67 !" !"""! !! 7!" ") " ! +"6"!"4

"7 !=.)" !"

7 4!5A. 4" )6 %? & 4!5 A! !"

4!5 "! ! %

)! 4?! 3 3 !!!!") ,0. +) ") %? 677"! 3 % "44

)! ,0.!=) !- 4!5A7 "<"!7 ! !"& 4!5AC!! %

)! "2! 6"77"!5 3 "7 5 C3!

!7 "% ,0.>!=) 4 ! - & 4!5 A 3 % 4"7%4 !!53 "7 <"!3 2!4"3%?

@>%4 ,<

" & !) * -'/' 0& 1 - !" C3!"7 !*C%?6"

" 4! %? $% 0

")" +

9 >,> 6"7 0!

, & 4!5!"

" - !!=677"!5 3 "7 7 "<"!7 ? 23 % %?

6"") ;

! !7 "% !"& 4! - 74"

!3! $7%? !! ) !"7 A

) 4 ?"<7!! "

" C5 5 "

74"

4%7!" )"!!"!@36 %?7!" ") " 7"!" @>%4 ,<

" & !

) * -'/' 0& 1!344!& 4!5A53 "7 3!% 4"7%4 !7"64? !7"64? - !2 +

!747 4 ;

%!"! !!6"4%43 ? A %!"! 677"!3 "7 7 "<"!7 20 + 4'54? "4 3 7!" 7! !3! $7 ? 6 7 "!

%?3? "4") !"" - " " & 4!5A3! %?@>%4 ,<

" & !) * 1 3 "5"3!

!7"

"744? 4 677"!53 "7 <"!

? 2 3 % 6"!"! & 4!5A,! 6""

"7" 5 ;

,0.=) !" 7 !3!"7 !

C*C-

!2+

"4 ! ? 2- ) !53 3 "%?6"

& 4!5 A 4 ? "

!7 "% C*C@>%4 ,<

"& !) * -'

/' 0& 1 !4!)"6!7"

"7 "") & 4!5A3 8

7 677"!53 "7 ! ? 25 ") %?44 677"!3 "7 7 "<"!7 ")" 7 & 4!5A3 4 6% %? ;

!7 "% !"& 4!,77 ")4?5"6"3 " $ ) @>%4 ,<

"& !) * -'/' 0& 1 "" ! "4

' *C !!3 7 4!5A "!!

3! "!"F,* ' 53 "7 3!

"!!!

3 "!! %? "!

6" 3" "

7" 96 3"44 "44 !!! 4!5A - 6"3 4"7"3! "4"F,* ' " !! '3! "

" < "!5"

?5! 44% %$7 "47"!" 40"!!4 "7"4 43 4! %"7

"?3" 6"!"! 7 6"!"!

!" ! %85 !!7!7

4?") 3" " " 3" ") %$7

4!- 7 "?"!<77"77 73" 43 43 07! 43"! " $ !"

5 ! "!!

!"%4" ?! 43"!4"%4% ! G"! 4? "" & !) * -'/' 0&

4!677"! " ? 203! 4%?@>%4 ,<

96 87!7" !7"!"

8? "%7 ! 3& 4!- "7"4 D4677?

4& 4E3!4!"!7 !!%?@>%4 ,<

" 7!

3++ - !$ % &(' & $ '% !$ % &'

!! *- F,B7 %! 6 3 ""! "4%?"4 !!8")"

7"! 96 7"77 73" "

7"!)"6%?

" & !

) * 1 96 3 4 "44 !!! & 4!5A

06"3 7!! "%65 7 6 !?" 7! "!!;

4?76 %? 7"!" @>%4 ,<

" & !) * 1- + 4'3!

7!" " " ! %+"6"!"4.)" 4?

"4 !53 !5 "" ! ,0.=) ! 3 7!" - "" ! "4%7!" )"!

!"!!"6"3 "

! 6" 4!5A"7! ? 3"!4")"%4 ,77 ")4?5 ""! 443 !! "

7 7!" 7! !)"! "

6" & 4!5A)"! !!=677"!3 "7 6 77

3 2"6"3 434"3%?@>%4 ,<

"7! & !) * 1 - 7!! ?

< 7"!"!%3" " "

7" 7? 07! "" ! %"4 % "! ""77 73" & 4!5A5 ! %) 3" " " 3 ! @36 5" 7! "" ! !"44 )) "65 ? 4"% ? 6"4 " ? / 1 $ !8")= ! I!

%4 I!