Priyanka & ORS v. Union Public Service Commission & ORS


 

       


        



     

      

  



  
 

 !


"   

 !
#!$   !"#$"#%$"#&'()#*#+$,"-'.(/#%#0-%$#(1+$"#(1)#,$2



  







  





 



  

 3



" % 
&

& '



00.145$1-+  1,  5..-6#(  5+(  $"#  -771415.  %#,0-+(#+$,  5%# 0#%*1$$#($-0.54#-+%#4-%($"#544-*05+81+)5771(591$

&

& 3 

5,#(  -+  $"# 1+(#+$  *5(# /8 $"# -771415.  %#,0-+(#+$, $"#

+1-+'/.14#%914# -**1,,1-+:7-%,"-%$;

 ;<1+91$#(500.145$1-+, 91(#5(9#%$1,#*#+$ - => 0'/.1,"#(1+ $"#*0.-8*#+$#6, -+ ?

?

7-%500-1+$*#+$$-$"#0-,$-7%')+,0#4$-%1+$"# %'),  $5+(5%(,  -+$%-.  %)5+1@5$1-+  1+1,$%8  -7  #5.$"   5*1.8 !#.75%##05%$*#+$-7#5.$"5+(5*1.8!#.75%#

,$"#500.145$1-+, ,'/*1$$#( /8$"#6%1$ 0#$1$1-+#%,,$--( %#&#4$#(/8$"#  -+$"#)%-'+($"5$$"#8"5(+-$7'.71..#($"##.1)1/1.1$8 4%1$#%151+$#%*,-7%#A'1,1$#('%5$1-+-7#B0#%1#+4#$"#6%1$0#$1$1-+#%,


500%-54"#($"#.#5%+#( #+$%5.(*1+1,$%5$19#%1/'+5. "5+(1)5%"#+4"

:7-%,"-%$;%1/'+5.;<  "#4.51*-7$"#6%1$0#$1$1-+#%,,$--(%#&#4$#(/8 .#5%+#(  %1/'+5.

 "#%#7-%#  $"#8  "59#  71.#(  $"#  0%#,#+$  6%1$  0#$1$1-+ 4"5..#+)1+)$"#1*0')+#(-%(#% 

#5%($"#,'/*1,,1-+,*5(#-+#1$"#%,1(#



+545%#7'.0#%',5.-7++#B'%#
(5$#(D  6"14"

1,5-$17145$1-+1,,'#(/8$"##05%$*#+$-7#5.$"5+(5*1.8!#.75%#1$ 1,7-'+($"5$1+#B#%41,#-70-6#%,4-+7#%%#(/8$"#0%-91,-$-%$14.#3D -7$"# -+,$1$'$1-+-7+(155+(1+,'0#%,#,,1-+-7 #+$%5.%'),$5+(5%(

-+$%-. %)5+1@5$1-+:%'),+,0#4$-%< #4%'1$*#+$ '.#,DD %'),  $5+(5%(  -+$%-.  %)5+1@5$1-+  :%'),  +,0#4$-%,<  #4%'1$*#+$

'.#,6#%#7%5*#(  +(#%$"#5/-9# '.#,$"#7-..-61+)#('45$1-+5.

5+(-$"#%A'5.17145$1-+,%#A'1%#(7-%(1%#4$%#4%'1$,"59#/##+0%#,4%1/#(
E




                              !"#"$



 
%&       % %$
%&               % %       

"   $

  '  %  &                 % %

3
 " (  F =

++#B'%#
1,$"#5(9#%$1,#*#+$- =>1,,'#(/8$"#

 1+91$1+)500.145$1-+,7-%$"#0-,$-7%'),+,0#4$-%1+$"# %'),$5+(5%( -+$%-. %)5+1@5$1-+5,6#..

"#5/-9#5(9#%$1,#*#+$"5, /##+1,,'#(/8  0%#,4%1/1+)$"#,5*#A'5.17145$1-+5,*5+(5$#('+(#% $"#5/-9# '.#,

(*1$$#(.8$"#6%1$0#$1$1-+#%,(-+-$0-,,#,,,'4"#B0#%1#+4# %#A'1%#(+-$-+.8'+(#%$"#5/-9# '.#,/'$5.,-'+(#%$"#5(9#%$1,#*#+$ 45..1+)7-%500.145$1-+,$-71..'0$"#5/-9#0-,$

?

+-'%4-+,1(#%#(91#6$"#%#65,+-$"1+)6%-+)1+%#&#4$1+) $"#500.145$1-+,,'/*1$$#(/8$"#6%1$0#$1$1-+#%,-+$"#)%-'+($"5$$"#8 6#%#1+#.1)1/.#5,$"#8(1(+-$0-,,#,,$"#%#A'1%#(#B0#%1#+4#5,0#%$"# 5/-9# '.#,5+($"#5(9#%$1,#*#+$)19#+,$%14$.81+544-%(5+4#$"#%#61$"

"#%#7-%#6#71+($"5$$"#%#1,+-*#%1$1+$"#6%1$0#$1$1-+5+( $"#,5*#,$5+(,(1,*1,,#(

 

"  

#$

  #0$#*/#% #!$ '.5$1 

#$