Director Transport, Chandigarh Transport Undertaking, Union Territory Chandigarh & ANR v. Manoj Kumar & ANR




   

 

 


 



!"

# $%&%!'( )*+*

,- .


 
 - / 



0* 
,&*   1



***- -

( 2. * -
   -.












 




  








  -./ 

.



 !



"
##$%##&


' 

(

)!
!


*

#

+ #+ ,
-.


/01
*2
3 
4


'!

*


 

*) # 
/*) 



' 

#++5 6
#0 +$ #++$

*


'  



7 2
 8
 !
"

*
2
*
*
!
2
6//'!
*

*
!
""2
8
 

"

#5 +$ #++$

#, +$ #++$


 


 2

#$ +$ #++$


/ *) 

*

""*


*






 
*) 

"

#9 +9 #++$
 

:"
!
' 4
'!


2



2

7
 




 


!
7 2
(
!
 "



"


! 

+& +;

#++$
)




 2 
! 

 

"






*) 




< 2
!

8
*
 
!/

(< 2
6

*""

!
6
*


(< 2
6
 

*) 
!

"2
(








!





!

# +;

#++$
*
*



' 
 2



+9 +;

#++;
*
  

 

2






 =
#++$

 !

=
#++;

"
* 
2 6



2
 


 




3 
' 
*


< 2


*""



2
7"2
 2

3 
 


"



*) 
*




"
 2

"



(< 2
6

!
6


*

""


*
*



*)

"
.


!

2
3 
' 

 

"*/



                     

   



 



 

    

 







  !""

   

 



  #

  % 

             



    %& 

     



       

 & 

        

   





  #    




   

       

 

     

  

 

 !'

(

 !"")     *     & 

   #

  

     

   

          

 !'

(

  !"")                          +

 

   

 

        



   

  

   *

!'

(

 !"")

  #

    

 

   ,
-        *

 

  

     

  



   



 !'

(

  !"") 

 

     

       .  



          !""'   !""/     

 

    %     

 

 *

   

  

   

   



 



       0        1"

 2    !"")    



     



  

       

         

  

  

 

   

   

    

  



   

        #      

           

 

           



  

 



 


       $

 

    

      3  

     

       



    %   

  

0

 4  5    

  

  0

   

     

        

    

 %  

 

     

      11 2   !"")

       

   6 * 7   !""   1 (    !"")  !!

 (

  !"")        

    

 11 2   !"")      1!

   

        , 37 8  

 6 * 79!""   1 (   !"") !!

(

 !"") 

   :

; 7  <= :

;>   <!1

!/  :

; ?   <'@  %

   

  %#

   





  1A1 

   

 ,9 3#

 

      

  7          

 





     

  



     B  

   



  -       *



  

       



  

 !'

(

 !"")  

 -

#    8#      

   @


           

     




     

                  

           

      

  

0

 

        $   

   

       

 #

            

 #       

      

      !1 2   !"")           

      

  $          !1    !"")   !

    !"")    

       C  

   !""A         

   0    $







  

  

    2 

     

       +



  

>

, 6
!

*
!

3 





.

"2


 
2

"




 "
 2
8
 "2
  

< 2
*
 



 
*

"



!

3 




*) 


< 
*

!
 2

 


8




*) 
* 
 

*)!
*
' 4



"2

.

""*
2
3 
' 


7
?


 
' 
"

!

' 
?





 








 !
"
" #

 #
 "#
$ 
 "

 %"
""


 
 

& 
'


()(*

+#

 
 




*
"
"

"*
!!
 

*



"
##$


' 

(

-1
8!
' 


.

*

""
 "

(


*

*!



*

 



 "
 



(
 "


*




* 



""2
 
 


  

*
*





 "


*




 




"*







@
-1


!



 



""!


*


 


""!"

"

8!
' 
*"
.!

.2


 

 




*

*

!
 "


*


(

"2



*
 
.!

"."
*


 


 "


A
< 2
 

8!
' 
* "

"!


 2





< "


 "

"


.


.2


2


* "


8!
' 

 "
 

"
*


 & 
*




 

!







2

 

 "
B



"



2

 

 "
* 




.





 "

"



.



*

 ""2

 
*

.







' 

 "

""!""2

 "2






< 
* 
!!

 2





2

2



*

 


"!
*

 



"

 "




*

 





 

*




 2






' 
.!



"




""
' 

" 
"2


!



2


' 

 "

 "









< 

*
!



"*
*











2

*
 





*
!

2



(
!


!



2

 "

*




 



*


!


!

 "

 "2
 

 
 "


"



 "2
 
 "

*

"



  !
!

""2


!








* "

!




"*
*



2

*


(
"!
*

!2


*
*


"*2





!



2

 "


""!

!


*




! 


"

"

 


 "
*
 

< 

 

  !
!


< 2

 2


"










*



!

*

."






 "






!


*
' 
(

*

" 







8!
' 


##$

 

*




"! "2
. 


"2
 "
*
  !


*) 

*)!
*
 ;

8!
 C

!


3 

' 



2

"



""!"2

 2
*!




+ 7 

!
"" 
"-1

2
""
"


 +;

+9 #+#5

3  -.4



 

D
)!%


E% 
D
"

E%