Simarjit Singh v. Pspcl And ANR





     
   

  !"#"

#$ % &  '( ( 

"& ("



 
! ") *   #+(, -.  & 

*   / #00+(, -.  "& ("

* * (&

+(( 0(, -0+ #$

!"# $  &"%& + ,-% "$

"($2 & " ( -",-% &  ((. 34
567 0046
568 " $9 -- #":#0.2 ",-. - &# &" 2$."

.-"" ( %& 

&  (#$0--2 ( 34
567  9& % 9 ""#- 003;

56;

3<
56;+% 9- ",-  .     &   %"  .#   =((  #& 
>
4
566

.+ "(& (%".# =((#& 48

.+  .    , #"  =" "+     ",-  .  

& %" #0?(""""',( (((

7   &   9&    % 9     #0  $""

.  (  #002+     &   (  .   ",-      ."#&#  7

&  "$ , $. .452" .

",-" .  ,$+
568 %("% " (  ",-  %   &   ((  "  . 
56700 ,$+
568 " $9 -- #.  - # &" 2$."

 #"0.  &  #"

"& #00- #(  . " #%&'()
*(+,-' .(.& /+0(1.*)/2*.*&&3)&.()4" 5
*(+,62()* (+,.*&)'"

# $ 

+ % 9- (",-"(( $2&0 2$.  #0" " $9 -- #.  - &# &" 2$."

&    -  .    +     "& ("  ,  .0(  

&02       &02+     & (  "&  $2     &     % 9 (  $""  "  $  ((  $2     "& ("

  02 $- 9" #

& ( 7
4338+

&" ".   . $. .% 9- (",- . - &# &" 2$."% ,*- +43
;+ " 

02$0((- $- "(( 0,&"

. &02"#() @
&"%& ("," $("""( 02      #(  .  (02  (  0- "  "  

& ( 7
43
8% "+& (   &"   .   ."         "%

"& ( 
7 43
; ( -0#( "% 9   & (  "  :#0.2  ",-  .   .=   . 

0$."-0#( &" ( #2

&784+9&)6.':

,"( "&(( $- -  = & "-? .(+$#"$" 0#02%  ((( 

-, 9 =#"(-  . " A$0 # $2.0 &"%& 

- " . "&(( $ - -        &    (  "  % 9B-

$""% "% "& ( 34
567 (",(003;

56; % 9- $"" #$,"  ..-+#$%00 "#- ," +  (

- " . "&0" (( $ - - & ",("% 9-

$"". 3<
56; 
>
4
566  ..- .

#$,"  ..-  #$," + (

>B; ,"( "&0" (( $  .- (

< - " .&(( $- -     47
568+     ",-  .     &   %"

#0?((&& ("

#0"""' ,( ..- (
<856((
7 " .

- " . "&(($  .- (

- " . "&(( $- -   = & %" (5C
< $ #(  &   0  "-0  "  &  "  0

&   %"  .#   &  (  "  0  %

.

7
4
55<(#002 ( 7

,"( "&%  ( ( . "%  ((($-#"-#0( .

"7
4338( 7
 , ( - #"0.  &"( , 

>  #

- ( . -"% $0"""-

.-# .( -",-(($2 &  .  - $+
56700 ,$+
568 "$(( -

"(  & (  "  $  ((+     "& ("  %  #( $0     0.  & $2 (  ",-  "  :#0.2  ",-  % 0  - &#

&" 2$." . &  .#00-  . " # 0(-( %&'()
*(+,;'3('&#'/7)($ "0(2 0(

% 9  - (  ",-  ((  $2    &0 2  $.  #0?  . ",-"+ " $(":#0.2 ",- . - &# &" 2$." . &0 2 0, &   . #( ""#() @
5  0

 . $ ,+0#"= ,0(2 .

#07
6EF . #$ ,0,-" #0"+! 0  #0"2" & ( .",-% 9B- "$0"

  "

00     $  9    -- #   -0-#0 :#0.2 ",- . ",-" . % 9B- (  &0 2  ,  $   #0"( 

$- "    &#$0-  ",   ",-  "  #(  

 ,("&($2 ""% %"&-"02 "( (#"0%(((#
+
564+$% % 9( . +  E C F+ "$0"

  - +  #$+  0+  %  %"

&#$0"

(  ,?((#02
>+
564

,   %"

    %"  "0(  $2     #$  , *   
>35;B E7FB64H;787  (( <

$#2+
567E=#6F% %""( 00 "% 9- (&0 2"% (&#2"

.",-  " 
; # #"+
564+ ",-"

% #0($((  ,$ #0"( -

;

",-"  .    % 9B- (  &0 2  ,  $ #0"(+     &&"    $  (02  2  0 -   (&,  . &" 2$."",0$0 &#$0-","#( #07
6 . #0"

:#0 & -  .0%"#" & -  .:#00%"

.   00  &" "  "002  "#(  -0 
>  "9"   $""  $-#"    & ,"   %  "  $2 , 0,"         :#02  ,     & 2   ..- ",-#(  , "

 $ -9 (. ( :#0.2 ",- 0 9"

  $  00 -0        & (  .  ",-  "&  $2   &0 2      % 9B- (  "$0"

  $.   #0"  " $9 - "( .  ( "  :#0.2  ",-   -0"".-  "" #

 $(   ,","

 0 $0  .   &"   (   "  %  "(  % 9 (  &0 2"  (     ",-"   #0"( "#$":#02+( ""$"( 200 $0 -(+$. +" "#"$00% .

",-"  .    % 9B- (  &0 2  ,  $ #0"(+ "&#$0-",09  ", (&,    .     &"   "     02  ##"  ( :#$0" $2 ,- .$""+(. "

" " & ," " ."#$B#0EF . #07
6 .

#0" , $"#-9( %$ , 0, .-0
> .  "#  D #"0.  "& (" " $$0 "

2  - 2+% % #0($0  (2 -0 

& ""( &"%& 

 02  #(9$2 "& ("" "

(02" (( "&- #"0.  "& ("+

& ( - $+4338% " ((%""(

< *- +43
;

. + "$0(" + "- $ (  '%" 9 %  "& (" % 9- ",-"  $ - #(" :#0.2 ",- .  - &#

&" 2 $."

  "& ("  "

#0(  ,  (     "( =-"  . ("

#0(  ,. -(

&     && - "  # # +     (0  .  -#0 &" "-# -#"(- $-(   #( .

(02 . + &0 . & . - #  (",-. 34
5670073
568"

#0($("

:#0.2 ",-. - &# &" 2$.""00 %(

'     -0-#0   .     &" 2  $."  .  

& $( $2 "& ("% & ( .%   "

.      (  .  -&  .    -.(  - &2  .   "  (  . - &# +% ,$." & "0(. +"

00$ =((  & -0#( "(&" (  $."

%& "00 %( $ ,"

()3*"  0. #!$  ! "&9 H" ()"H & $0 )"H