Garima Bhardwaj And Another v. State Of Haryana And Another
!"!!
# !$% #&' !"!(
)0 12) + 3 4
!
"
!
"
# !
"
$ %&
$ '&
( !
"
)* !
"
$ !
"
4 +
"
+,'
- ( ./$ '012'3'3 ''
$ !4 '3'3( " 4 "
,3 #! #" 5 "
6 " '3%1 5 7'3%1 "76
"
" 18 ( ' 4 !
$ '&
!
4 9*
"
: 9./" 4(
4 # " (%
( "
%185:6 9"
./ & ;9"
"
4 %9 "
! ( &4 ("< (
9"
4 ( "
4 ""
""
! ((
!
"
" "
( ""
" (* * !
"
* (
"
9""
4" ("
"
! " "
!
" 4 ! 4" ' 9 $ =
4
5 ! ( (6
"
"! "
94
"
( >
* "
" &?
@ !
> " 7"
" 4
"
* $@ "
4
4 "
*
A
" 4" " !"
"!
> " 7"
B
B&% :9 " B" ( "
" 4 "
"
" "
"
"
! " (( "
( C &
(9+ 9 "
"
( " &
(
(
4 *=*"
"
44
(
B&// 1 9 "
" "
"
"( "
"
( 9"
* "
" "
4 ! 8 9
3'3A2'3'3 "
( " "
(! 4 "
3:3A'3%0 5
3:3A'3'36 ( & "
1 # '3%0 "
"(
" "( D 44 !
B
B& ///A9 "
*44 ( "
"
" 9 ((
* "
! / "
( "
!
" "
4(
"
,9
(
4"
"
B "
"
(
* ( ( " 9 "
(
("
!
( 4 " 09
>"4 '3%0 "
! "
&""
"
15!6
(
"'3'3 "
"
"
( (
"
* (
!
(%39 "
D*=*(!
"
"
( 4 ! 44(
5
" ! * ! ! !
(
"
" %%9"
4 ( "
(
"
@ 3:3A'3'3 "
"
"
" &18 ( "
& > (
3,3A'3'3 ( 4
(" 9 "
"
( & >
"
B
B&/%'9 ""
( " 4" ("
" "
"
"
4 " "
"
! "
(
"
( !
(
4 ( " "
%: 9 "
4 ! ""
"
"
! " " 4 " ( " "
"
(
" "
%+9"
! ! @ " &18 (
"
"
" - (
"
* *"
< "
* "
( ""
(
./4
"!(
!
""
"
* "
""
./4 ( (
9
"
" 7 "
< *
E!
" " 4 (
"*& "
( "
(
4 *"
4"*
"
%19"
-
" " *"
(
, "
(442" 4"*
"
" " &18 7
F# "
*
!*"
F " %89 >
* !
"
"
" "
"
! " (!44 4 ( "
"
>
*
"
F * * 4F9"
4* -
4 "
4
"" %A/
"!
" ./ 4( ( ""
""
4
""
" %,9" (
"" ! "4"
"! "
! ! " "" %0/ ! 4 !
" "" " "
! 4 ( !(
4
"-
!
(
"
<4 ""
4B
" !(
./( ( 4 ! ""
4 ! "
'3 9"
""
4 "
* ( " "
@" &18 ( (
./ " "
"
%185:6
4 "'%9
" "
"
" &18(*
!
(
"
%1+
! ( 4
/ !
(
(
(
4D ( " " F
"
" "B" (./"! ("
"
<4
6
"F4 "
"
"
( ./( ""
! "
4*
''9
"*
( ""
( (" 4 ( "
" ( 4
B
) = ! C '3%:
5%+6#9:00
( (""
!
!( (
"
"
" ( "" ':9"
"" ! 4 4 "
'+9
" ! 4 "
4
""
4 !
""
" "
"
"
""
"
" (./( ""
'19"4 "
%32& 4 B
"
/ !
" " "" "
4 !
4("
(569 " @ " &18 ( (./ "
,3 #! #" " :++ +38 +'3 %'3& :+ /
( ""
5469 "
" - / ""
2 4 2 %%1 $
>2 .
"4 9
( >" E (4
#* 9 )
" &1283% ( 9 (
( !
" (G + 9
4
"
("
(!
4"
(
7
/4 (
( " ( 4"
4 ($ ?2%12'3'%4 .
( "
(" "
44
"4 "
9
- (! ( * ("
./ " (!
4
./
( 4 4 " / "
( ! " "
4
4
( 1
"
* ( ! " "
" 4
"
"
'3%1 " "
"
4 B
3&
&'&&&%+%+%&8&2&9&% ::-/
-+/($(
4"
B"
"
! "
+,' -./ /
$ "
4
& "
;
+",,, !": & <4&#+ < <&& % "
!$% #9' !"!" 8 "
"
4 "
"
9" 4
( "
"
4 "
,3
'3%1 " /4 "
! " >
* ! (
"" ./ "
("
<4 " (
4 A /! "
!(
( "
" , / "
-
"
7
0 "
'3%1 " & ;,+ 3& 8 & & !",&5%6 "
%1
"
*"
" "
:056
56 +1 +A*
4 (
:
" 4" ( " 5'6 9 C $
!
(
4 /
%%%'%00' - *
" "
( "" !
( (56 "
"
" 7 (
546 " (" 7 " ( 5"6* ( ""
" 7( 4 (" 7 (
" 7 (
"!
" 5:69#! #"5 "
" " '333 ! "
" 9 " " '338 '3%% (
* " &
> "
" ! " " ( " 4 "
-" - " 4
( " "
" ( "* "
( (
4 ""
4
-
"( " ""
"
"! ( ( ! B ( 5+6 . " ( " " "
4 " (( %8&%, " * ! "
#! #" 5 "
6 " '333
- "* " (( 9
" 4$
"
4 "4" (( %8&%,! " "
" "(
" 516$ " (- B (#! #"5 "
6 " '333
"
4 !
B (#! #"5 "
6 " '333 & " "
! (
! ( " " "
"
" " " " "
" "
" 4
" & (
" "
4
" " "
( " 9 (
" "
!
" & (
" " "" "4 (" &
"* ( ! 4 " 5869
B !
"
G 5 6 %3 "
%5+6 '3%1 " ! & ;5 6$ ( ("
4 ( "
"
"
" (" " "
"
" (H 6
"
4
" & (
"
" I
6 " "
( 4
& (
" " "
G %%
" "
4 "
'5%+6 '3%1 " ;!5 6;" " "
G " H 6 "
4 4 4 "I
6
* (
!
4 4 ( " 4(( ( ! (
I
6
5 ( "
6 "
H 56
B
4 ( " " !
4 (
" "
" I 56 *
B
4 "
4 *
4 (" I 56*
4 ( " B
" "
4 *
" -
4 (*
4 B
( " 4
I 6
"
"
( ( "4 !
* ! ( ( *" 4
I 56 ( " ( 4 "" 4
" "
&4 ( " I 5 6
!
( *" !4
I 5
6 ( " "
4 * (
4 - "
4"4 I 5
6 4 4 ( * 44 B
B 4
(
"I 6 !
4 * 4 " (4 "* (I
!
5 6 4 ( * 4 4
"
4 ( I 6 !" " 4 "
" "! " I
6 * (4 ( ( 4 (
* 4
4
"(IG %'
(
( "
" !
(
4 "! ! ( " "
"
94 "
"
4 ! (" "
"
" - (
" ""* 4 "
"* (
!( "
"
4 ///
"
18"
& ;,6+56
4 (( 4
"
"
(
4
( 56
" !4
! "! (
" 4
"
(
4 5 6$ ( "
"
" " %018 6
&"
4
"
(
4 56
* " (
* ( (" " "
(
!
4 4
"
,3G 5 6 %: 9 "
4
2 " 4 "
< ( "" "
185:6"
" !
! ("
"
" " %018 /J
"( " "
,3 '3%1 " & =$"+ /
(
(! "! 4
"
(
" ! " "
(
4 4
"
"B
* 4 ! " ""
4
5 "
( "
4 !
&"(
4
" & &
( " (
"( " "
+% "
"
81
4
G %+
(
"
"
18 "
,3*"
""4
7 7 74
7 7 7"
9 B
" ;!56;4
" G " 4 4
(" ! ( 4
"
4
4
-I !5 6 ;
G " H 56 4
(" ! ( ( I 56
( (
( * "4 * (" " I !5!6 ; " G " - 4 (
""
"
" " 4
"
"4
IG %1 /
* !
! " 4 < " " 47 7 74
7 7 " "4 "9"
"
,
(
!
./ " ! 4 4 ! E! "
./ "
"
"! " ( "
( * ( " 4
"
* $@/
* ( " 4 "
" 4"
"
"!@ " 7 * (
"
" "
"
5
6 ( "
" ( "
(!4 "
:
# '3%0
*" /
"
! (
" "
"4 (
"
4
" "
4 7 7"
! - 4 (
?
"
"
'A "
'5''6 " 9" 9 "
4
"
4( ! 4 /// '3%1 "
" 4 "
,3 " 4 4 %8 9 4 .
*
6 " " !
" "! /
4 "
" ( "
4 4 ! "
* (B "
%A
(
B" "
"
+,'
%+%&8&2&91
& B
& ;%3A/ 4"*
! !
J/ "
" 4
"
( B" B "
''8 "
+,'
" ! B" " 4 ! (!
("(
"4
" "
4 B" ! 4 "
" " (
4 4
" "
" "
B4 ( ( (! B! * " " 4B" %?
(
./
"
! * " ! ""
"
" * " ( "" '?
(
./
""
(./
"
"
<4 " ( !(
7 4
" " "
%185%6
B" ( ! "
%115'6
:?
!
(
./
"
! ""
"
"
"
"
* "( "" +?
(
./
"
<4 "4"
&"
<4
"
!(
4
" "
("
"
%115'6
1?
(
./ "
4 44
4
"
" !" "
" ( " (( "" 8? B ( 4 (
"
" "5
"" " ( 6
" " ( ""
"
" " ! ( "" (! " ((! A?" " ( " ( " ! * (! ( "
"" ! !
( (G %, 9! 4 B
$ " + +4+><8&'&&&%'.++3#%&3%&& .
+-!":/637(: 4 (
B" "
"
+,' - B ! "
( " "
( / ! *
"
"
( " " " " ( 4 - "
+,' 9 (
-"
" ( ( "!4 "
"
4"" " * ( "? ( -
" "
4 ( "
"
" " (
"
4 "
%0 @ "
"
"
" "
( ! 4
"
'3%1 "
./( " 4 "
,3
( (
4" /// '3%1 " "
4 . ( "
"
" %+%&8&2&91 &
:
56 ./(
4- '3 9
""
#&'!$ !"!( - 4/ ? Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No Whether reportable :
Yes/No