Makhan Singh v. State Of Punjab
2 IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH ( )* *+ / 01. "2" 3
"""
- ,-..
.
""".4 0
!
"
#$%&!
& % - .$/! , $ ! - , 0 0" ,,1 & & %'
#"
2! 2! 0 *34
44
03
50
7
00 6% <6%
7!$ ! ! !!" # #
! !
" 2"
" 0%!# 0! !! ! %!89 9:!#" #!! ;2% .! ##%70 , " !# # !! "$#"! % %&!
,!"
! ! "'#!" ( )#$ ! #$ $ #!!$! # ! !
* *+ ,- ! " $
" ! ! %! 8 9 :! !
!2 %# !! ?
)! !
$ #!! 2
+3 - # #! ! !
!"!! $ "! ! ! !
!!! & % 0! " !!! ' #!! ! !##! =!!!! ! ! ! % ! 2 ! ! " 2 % !"
, ! $ #
' "" > >" ! 2 ! $" #
.! # ;
, " 2 $ " # ! 2 ! #! "" " ) !
"$ ! !"! "
$
.! ! 2 ! ! ! 2 ! ! ! ! 2 "
! .!! ! #! ! & " .! " # ! 2 # ! " ! 2! "$ ! ! %!## .!
2 !"! #!!!>
2 !" $! " !!
.%2%" .!
! "
(
3 ! ! " ! " #
$ 2 !" 2
7 8! 2 2 )(0 " .!
! ! $ # !
$
0 "! 2#! !
!$!"2 ! 2! 2 ! !"
) # $$ > " #!
! 7 8 ""#! ! !# !$"
) ! 2!!"
" 2 2#! 7 8 !$"#! # " .! ! "" ! " % !## ) $22! .! .!
! " ! ! ! " ! # # ) ) !! "
+ !$! ! ! !$ !!!"
?
.! #!! 7 8 !$ % ! # # "2 % %! 8 9 :! ! !
!
?
.!"$ ! """ !# !!#>" #! 7 8 !$"!! ""#!7 8 ! 2#! % !$"2 !#! # .! !
3 ) """
" !## " ) ) " .! .! ! > 2 0! ! " "
" "
" ! " ! #
.!$2! " !
@ 2!
0! " ! % 2#! 7 8
!
+
2!) (0 " 2 ! .! % $#!$2 !$"" 2! ! !
!"
!' "#!!!$ "2 !
" ! ! $# ! !
$$ ! ) ! "
) ! & ! #!
2"
" 2 " !! $" !$ 2 ! ! ! " ! > !
!"! ;
A 2 ! !#! 0 0 6% # # " 2" (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE "2"3
Whet Whet ther speaking/reasoned ther reportable Yes/No Yes/No