High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13900/2024disposed of

Puran Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others

2025-11-28Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

B $ B $ B $ B $ (" $# (" $# (" $# (" $# 3C977 3C977 3C977 3C977$# $#7@ 7@ 7@ 7@/ E1 / E1 / E1 / E1 :''$! :''$! :''$! :''$! 33 337 7 7 7H "'"'$!

"'"'$!

&$!* !"

!" #$

(!%(+*<$:(" "% & "'"'$! "%(%) *++ ,!-(. DDDD +/ (01 +/ (01 +/ (01 +/ (01 234 5 6(5$#& !"6'"& "'"'$!+:% %(00 != %(. !0('*"$"% $ * *(" *78797 3&( *.5"% ,.'<''$!(0 0(='"(" :,) (!*:A,''"

$00 :"$+ (!*%(%&,;(!*'() $- :"+ +%(%&,;(!*'$6!%'&+6% .5 # !: & # * (" "% '!"(!: $# "

"% & "'"'$! >0(!*$6! %(< <'!= '!<$; * :"'$!

!$#"% (!*:A,''"'$! :"+39@/#$%$"F"% 39@ :"G1 6(*')' * 24 '

' #05 "("'!=+ '! "% & !" :( + $) 0(!* $6! * .5 $6! '",(" * 6'"%'! "% < < !, "(" $# <'00(= $" ';

;;( (-(+ %'0% %( (0(!+'"",*(&,+:() ) "$. (:A,' *<'* $"'#':("'

$! *(" * 3?7?399 9@ (!* 37399@ ', * ,!* * :"'$! @ E ? $# "% ( (!* :A,''"'$!:"

"+39@ & :"'< 05#$"% &,.0 ':&,&$ !() 05#$:$!",:"

$#%(%&,;(!* *'() $- :"% 6(*,!* * :"'$!33$#"% 39@:"6 &( *.5"% ( (!*:A,''"'$!$00 :"$/#$ %$"F G1$!7@3399?

2C4 '

'!=(==' < *"% $#+$) $# "% $"% 0(!*$6! & "('!'!= ="$ "%' < 5 (:A,' '"'$! $,=%" # !: ,!* :"'$! 3 $# "% 39@ :" 6% %':% :() "$. * :'* * *$!77H73(!*"% )(;

; "<(0, 6(( *K 3?7 77> & )(0((0$!= 6'"%(00"% "(","$5. ! #'",!

!* "% 39@:" 2@4 ( * $! "% (#$ ('* 6(*+ "% % & "'"'$! >0(!*$6! & # * # !: ,!* :"'$!$#"% 39@:".

. #$ "% $!377 % ('*(&&0':("'$!

6(; &"& !*'!=!"% ) (!

!6%'0 +"% $"% 0(!*$6! .

'!= (==' < * $# "% % 6(* *(" * 77H77+ (& &&$(:% * "%' $," %(<'!= #'

'0 *

=,0( '" && (0+6%':%6 *'&$ *$# # $!*'## !"*(" I$! ,:%

$3CC$#738 8"'"0 *F,=' <'(!*$"% < < ,!-(."(" (!*$"% G* :'* * * $!3?7C738< <'* 6%':%"% )(; "<(0, 6( ( !%(!: *"$ 38H@>& )( (0( #$"% (:A,' * 0(!*& "('!'!="$"% <'00(= $ $"';;((-( ,"% "% (&& (0 & # *(""% '!"(!: $#"% &$!* !"6 *')' *.5"% $!G.0 & & J $,"<'* -,*=) ) !"*(" *779738 2H4 ! "% .('$#"% (#$ ('*#'!(0 * " )'!("'$!$#"% )(; "<( (0, A,( "% & !"

" (:A,''"'$! &$: *'!=+ "% & "'"'$! >0(!*$6! )$< * (! (&&0':("'$! *("

* 3738 . #$ &$!* * !" $ #$ 6(* $# ') )'0( :$)& !("'$! .

. '!= '* !"':(005 &0(: * 0(!* $6! $# "% () (:A,''"

&$: *'!=% % ('*&(5 :() "$. *')' *.5 &$!* !"$<'* $ * *(" *78797 36%'0 %$0*'!="%(""% (&&0':( ("'$!#'0 *.5"% & "'"'$! +,!

!* :"'$!$# # "% 39@:"6(.( *.50') )'"("'$! 2?4 )& &,=!'!= "% (#$ ('* $* + 0 (! * :$,! 0 #$ "% & "'"'$!

! ,.)'""%("$!:

: *,'!=& !* !:5$#"% (&&0':

:("'$!& # *,!* :"'$! $#"% 39@:

". #$ &$!* !"$+"% # #'!(0* " )'!("'$!A,("% )( ; " <(0, "$$*(*-, ,*':(" *,&$!.5"%'$,""$"

"% ",! $# 38H@>& )(0( I'!

<' 6$#* :''$!

!)(* .5"% $!G.0 & J $,"'!:( $#(!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% % % % % <(5(!("( <(5(!("( <(5(!("( <(5(!("( (" !*,"'(0(!*!#(",:", (" !*,"'(0(!*!#(",:", (" !*,"'(0(!*!#(",:", (" !*,"'(0(!*!#(",:", < 0$&) !"$&$("'$! ')'

< 0$&) !"$&$("'$! ')'

)'" * )'" * )'" * )'" * /1 (!* /1 (!* /1 (!* /1 (!* * (!$"% * (!$"% * (!$"% * (!$"% G &$" * ( L7 7 7 7 H/31 /'<'01 CM+ H/31 /'<'01 CM+ H/31 /'<'01 CM+ H/31 /'<'01 CM+ $6! %$,0*%(< . !(6(* * *"% () )(; "<(0, (!* *( ,:%"% ')&,=!

! *$* &( *.5 &$!* !" $6(0'(.0 "$. "('* 284 ! "% $"% %(!*+ 0 (! * "("

" :$,! 0 ,.)'" "%(" $!:

(&&0':("'$!*("

*377& # *,!* :"'$!$#"% 39@:"(" '!"(!: $# "% & "'"'$! >0(!*$6! 6( . 5$!* 97 *(5 $# "% 0 (!

! *

# !: $, " 6(* *(" * 77H77+ "% () 6( '=%"05 * :0'! * .

'!= .( *.50')'"( "'$!(!*(,:%"% ')&,=! *$ $* :(00#$!$'!" # !: 24 % %(< % (* 0 (! * :$,! 0 #$ "% &("' (!* & , * "% &( (& .$$; #'!* ,."(!: '! "% ,.)''

'$! )(* $! . %(0# $# $6! 294 !"

"% ='< !#(:"+"% (&&0':("'$!& & # *,!* :"'$!$# 39@ :" (" "% '!"(!: $# "% & "'"'$! >0(!

!*$6! 6( #'0 * $! 37 77 .( * $! $!

# !: $," 6(* *(" * 7 77H77 %$,=% "% () 6 . 5$!* 97 *(5 + %$6 < + '" 6( ; &" & !*'!

!= .5 &$!* !" $ (!* '! ) (!6%'0 "%' $," <'* '" * :''$! *(" * 3?7C738 &( * '! "% :( $# ,=' <'(!* ,=' <'(!* ,=' <'(!* ,=' <'(!* *$"% G *$"% G *$"% G *$"% G/,&(1( *"% )( (; "<(0, K 38H@>& )( (0( #$ "% 0(!* & "('!'!= "$ "% () < !, "(" (!* 0("'!= "$ "% ( () (:A,''"'$! &$:

: *'!= % #'!(0 * " )'!("'$ $! )(* .5 "%' $," =(< # % :(, "$"% & "'

'"'$! >0(!*$6! '!" )$#0 0(60('**$6!.5"% $!G.0 & & J $," '! :( $ $# (!6(' (!* $"% (!6(' (!* $"% (!6(' (!* $"% (!6(' (!* $"% GGGG /,&(1

0 <(!" &((=(&% $3H E 3? "% $#( J"( (:" *% ,!*

L3H H !"% & !":( +'"'!$"'!

'!*'&," "%(""% '"&& (06% %':% 6( (00$6 *.5"% '=%$,"<'* -,*=) !"(!*$* *(" *!* (5 73 3?6('! & :"$#"% 0(!*6%':% %6(:$< *.5"% () !$"'#':("

("'$! ,!* * 6%':%!$"'#':("'$!"% (&& 00(!

!"G0(!*'(0$:$< *"'(0$ !$" '! * *'&," "%(" "% ()$,!" (6(* * * .5 "% '=% $," '! "% ('*

'" && & (0''! J: $#"% ()$,!"(6 6(* *.5"% $00 :"$,!* :"

:"'$! 33$ $#"% 39@:"'!"% :( $#"% 0 0(!*$#"% (&& 00(!""'(0$!$ $"'! *'& &," "%(" "% (&& 00(!" %(* !$" ) )(* (! (&&0':("'$! "$ "% $00 :

:"$ ,!* * :"'$! 3 $# "% 39@ :"

" " ' (0$ !$" '! *'&," "%(" (&& &0':("'$!)(* .5"% (&& 00(!",!

,!* :"'$!$#"% 39@:

:""$ "% $00 :"$ 6( 6'"%'! ( & '$* $ $# "% )$!"% #$) "% *(" $# # "% -,*= *=) !"(!*$* $#"% '=%$,"

" 3?

$)"% & ,(0$#"% -,*=) !"$#"%'$,"'!"% :( $# (* * &

,) ,)(' /,&(1+ '" ' :0 ( "%(" "% 0 0')'"("'$! #$ )$<'!= "% (&&0':("

("'$! ,!* * :"'$!$#"% 39@:"6 6'00. ='!"$,!$!05#$)"% *("

" $# (6(* $! "% .(' $# 6%':% * * " )'!("'$! $# "% :$)& !("'$!

$! ' $,= ,=%"% (&& 00(!"( ;'!= * * " )'!("'$!$#"% :$)& !("'$!

!$! .('$#"% -,*=) !"(!*$* $ $#"% '=%$,"'! '"&& (0 $ @9 9$#7C*(" *!*(573?"' '!$"*'&," *"%(""% (&&0':("'$!$ (&& 00(!" ,!* :"'$! $ $# "% 39@ :" ' 6'"%'! ( & '$* * $# "% )$!"%#$)!*(573?M

, "% "% * :''$!)(* '!"% :

:( $#(!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% /,& &(1 %((0$. !#$ $00$6 *.5"% '<''$! !:% $#"%'$,"'!:( $#F !'$!

!'$!

!$# !$# !$# !$# !*'((!*(!$"% !*'((!*(!$"% !*'((!*(!$"% !*'((!*(!$"% % <% & :'(0 (!*:A,''

% <% & :'(0 (!*:A,''

'"'$!$00 :"$ '"'$!$00 :"$ '"'$!$00 :"$ '"'$!$00 :"$:,) :,) :,) :,),.

,.'<''$ '<''$ '<''$ '<''$ $!(0 $!(0 $!(0 $!(0 (='"(" + ("% (='"(" + ("% (='"(" + ("% (='"(" + ("% %(!;$"(!* %(!;$"(!* %(!;$"(!* %(!;$"(!*$"% +7H/C1 $"% +7H/C1 $"% +7H/C1 $"% +7H/C1

/'<'018?

/'<'018? 2374 ,:%+ $!: "% (&&0':("'$! & # * ,!* :"'$! $# 39@ :"+ #'0 * (" "% '!"(!: $# "% & "

"'"'$! >0(!*$6! 6( & !* *'!= (*-,*':("'$! 6'"

"% &$!* !" $ (!* *,'!= = ,:% & '$* "%' $," )(* ( ) !" $# )(; " <(0, K 38H@> & )(0( <'* '" * :''$! *( (" * 3?7C738&( *'!"% :( $#,=' <'( ,=' <'(!

,=' <'( ,=' <'(!

(!*$"% G (!*$"% G (!*$"% G (!*$"% G/,&(16%':% < !6

,&% 0*.5"% $!G.0 & J$,"6%'0 *') )''!="% (&& (0& # *.5 &$!* !">"("

" <'* '"$* *(" *7797 38+"% (&&0':("'$!& # *,!

!* :"'$! $ # "% 39@ :" (" "% '!"(!: $# "% & "'"'$! >0(!*$6! 6 A,' *"$. (* *-,*':(" *,&$!.( *$!"% #'!

!(0* " )'!("'$!A,("% ()$,!

"$# :$)& !("'$!+ ("% "%(! )(;'!= "% ) & # # % (&&0':("'$! .( * $! * " )'!("'$!) )(* .5"%'$,"#$6%':%"% 56 !"'"0 *'!<' 6$#* :' '$! !* *'!:( $#(!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% (!6('(!*$"% /,&(1 %,+"% & !*'!=(&&0':("'$!#'

'0 * ,!* :"'$! $#"% 39@:":$,0*!$" %(< . ! - :" *.5(!5) ( (!+ . '!=.( *.5 50')'"("'$!("% #'!(0* " )'

'!("'$!6()(* .5"%'$,"

38H@> & ) )(0( $! 3?7C738 (!* $! "

"% ('* *(" "% ('* (&&0':("

& # * (" "% '!"(!: $#"% & "'"'$! >0(!* *$6! 6(& !*'!= (*-,*':("

6'"% &$!* !"

" $ ! #(:"+ ; &'!= '! )'!

!* "% &'!:'&0 $# "% 0(!*$6!

! . '!= !"'"0 *#$ $-,"+#('(!* A,(0:$)& !("

"'$!(=('!":$)&,0$5(:A,''"

$#"% '0(!*+ &$!* !"$6( A,' *"$( (*$&"(&(=)("':(&&$(:%$( "$ #,"% "% $.- :"+ &,&$ (!* '!" !" $# "% "(","$5 &$<''$! !(:" * .5

='0(", '! "

"% #$) $# :"'$! $# "% % 39@ :"+ ("% "%(! "(;'!

= ( %5& " :%!':(0 (&&$(:%+"% .5:(,'!=& -, ,*': "$"% '=%"$#"% & "'"'$!

0(!*$6! 2334 !< <' 6$#(#$ ('**':,'$!+"% % & !"6'"& "'"'$!'(00$6 6 * (!*"% ')&,=!

**(" *787973&( *.5"

"% ,.'<''$!(0(='"(" :, ,)

(!* :A,''"'$ $! $00 :"$+ (!* %(%&, ;(!*' () $- :"+ %(%&,;( (!*' $6!%'& ' % .5 " ('* % & "'"'$! >0(!*$6! ( % 0* !"'"0 * #$ (6(*$#')'0( . ! #'"$#)(; "<(0, K 38H@>& )(0(. '* (6(* *$# (00 $"% "(","$ $5 . ! #'" (!* '!" " ( &$ $<'* * ,!* "% &$<''$! $# 39@ :" /() !* * ,&"$ *(" 1 % *, ( ()$,!" . 0 ( * '! #(<$,

$6! 6'"%'!"6$)$!"%#$) "$*(5$ 0 &$!* !"$% %(00 . 0'(.0 "$&(5 :$"$# 30(;%"$"% & "'"'$!

#$:(,'!=* 0(5% :$"% %(00 . .$! .5 & &$!* !"$#$)%'>% $6!& &$:; "(!*. !$"" (" *(.,* * ! ,&$!"% "(" J:% A, 234

!*'!=(&&0':("'$!/1+'#(!5%(00 (0$"(!**'&$ *$# /

1 /

1 $< ).

$< ).

$< ). + + + + "'; 7 7 7 7H B% B% % "% & (;'!=> ($! * % "% &$"(.0 >$ >$