High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/26878/2025allowed

Maya v. State Of Haryana

2025-10-27Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

= = ! 54(%( #$ ! 54(%( #$ ! 54(%( #$ ! 54(%( #$ 4 2" 4 2" 4 2" 4 2" , -= , -= , -= , -= F7 ( #"

;"%+%

! "

F7%3 #5#

$ $ $ $ "%# $ "%# $ "%# $ "%# $ >& >& >& >& 7 7 7 7 & & & & "7 '(1 ' +5'"

, 5< 4

! "

( #"7 "7 +"6

(#)', "

#7 ?????

?????

& & & &, 7 /&@ , 7 /&@ , 7 /&@ , 7 /&@

"%# ( # '% 2# !(1 5 +#5"

. !

'" )"(* +"*%' #'( , -.

/! " %' "

>@ ! " )"# ")+1" 2(1

( #" (# 4% 2"(#) ) 7 5 5 -7-.7- =, ")(% "5 !

' !!#4% 3+#(%'21 +#5 ( #% .- #5 .

#5(# #1 5, - /! " %' "

>@ /

( # .- !

51 5 #5

( # .- 555 1 " #@, ")(%

"5 1(4

( # "*3+", (% "(4 6 6+##)"7 7 ' )"<6# !

' (# A A+% ( # (% # -7-.7- =,

("61 (#) ' /4 631(## @ 65 % 6# 2! "

' 3 1(4, 11)(#) )

' '% 8 %(21(#)%B # 2"

'" #5 # # %(% "7 (% ' 15% , 8'(1 9(#5" : ;

;(4* (% '(% +#)" 2"

'" # #5 "

( : &*'8(#5" G+" (% %

'("

+#) % %(% "7 % 2 + % %(C "% ) , ' % 16#(H5 1 < 6""() 8( ' 2 /"!""5 % D<(4

(6 E@, 5+)'

" ! 1( (#)',

#5 %(#4 '#, ', 1 #) 8( ' '(% 8(! #5 4'(15"#, '5 2# "%(5(#) %3" (# "# 5 ' +% 21 #)(#) ("

(#)' /+9(@7 ' 4 +31 '5 # % #, ;(*%, )5 2 + !(< "%7 2 + # #5 '1!

"% 3"( "

' (#4(5# ' 4 631(## '5 3+"4'%5 # #5() 4", 2"(#) ")(% ( # #+62" -..7 33" C(6 8* 2! "

' (#4(5# '(% 2"

'" 9(#5" : ;(4* #5 %(% " "

( : &*'8(#5" G+" <(%( '(% "%(5#4 #5 % "

5 56#5(#) '(" %'" (# ' %(5 4"7 '(% 15 # ")+6# 8# '6I ' 8<", ' 4 631(## 34(!(5 ' 6

" #5 %#

'6 24*7 # -=7-.7- =, 2 + .$-- 3767, 8'(1 ' 4 631(## 8% 8 !" 6 ' 6, 9(#5" : ;(4* 11)51 46

' ' +% #5 ! "4(21

* ' * ' %(5 4" !" 6 ' 4 631(## >% 8(!7 3 # +"#(#) ' 6, ' 4 631(## 8% (#! "65 2 '(% 8(! 2 +

(#4(5# 7 13' #(411 4 # 4 5 '(% 2"

'" #5 56#55 ' "

+"# !

' * , 2+

' 1

" "!+%57 & ' %6 5 , 2 +

-$.- 3767, 8'(1

' 4 631(## 8% "% (#) !

" 5(##", 2 ' 9(#5" : ;(4* #5 "

: &*'8(#5" G+" # "5 '(% " 6 #5 % "

5 A+""11(#) 8( ' '(% 8(!

")"5(#) ' "1(" 5(%3+ <"

' 4"7 +"(#) ' 1 "4 ( #, "

( :

&*'8(#5" G+" 11)51 3(4*5 +3 31% (4 4 # (#" 4 # (#(#) *" %# !" 6 ' " 6 #5 3 +"5 ( ' 4 631(## >% 8(!, 8'(1 9(#5" : ;(4* ()#( 5 6 4'% (4* #5 % '" 21H7 ' 4 631(##

(665( 4 <"5 '(% 8(! 8( ' 21#* #5 A+(1 #5 C (#)+(%'5 !16% 2 3 +"(#) 8 "7 '"!

", 2 ' 44+%5 !15 !" 6 ' %3

()'2 +"%, #61 "(%', , #5 +"5< (#)', ""(<5 #5 %%(% '(6 (# 411(#) # 62+1#47 '# %'(!

5 '(% 8(!

(<(1 %3( 1, 6+# )", 8'" %' 8% )(<# !("% (5 #5 "!""5

'#5()"' ! " !+"

" 6# 7 ' 4 631(## ) '(% 8(! 56(

, '#5()"'I ' 8<", 5+"(#) " 6# , 2 , 8(! !

' 4 631(## %+44+625 '" 2+"# (#9+"(%7 .7 &"#5 4 +#%1 ! "

( #" '% (

( #"

(% (# 4+% %(#4

77- 7 &"#5 4 +#%1 '% !+"

'" (

( #" '% 2# !1%1 (631(4 5 (#

' (# A+% ( #7 &"#5 4 +#%1 '% (

( #" 8% #

"(2+ 5 # %34(!(4 " 1 (#

' (# A+% ( #7 &"#5 4 +#%1 '% !+"

'" ( %%+6(#) ")+#5 , ' 3" %4+ ( # <"%( # (% *# 2 4 ""4 ' 3 ( #" (% %4"(25 ' " 1 ! 4 4'(#) ' 15 !

' 54%5 #1 #5

44 +# ! 5(%41 %+"% 6# 65 2 4 44+%57 &"#5 4 +#%1 '% +")5

( #" (% 15 )5

"%7 '+%, ")+1" 2(1 (% 3" ! "7

&"#5

4 +#%1 '% 33 %5 ' 3"%# ( # 2

")+(#)

' 11) ( #% "(%5 )(#%

( #" " %"( +% (# # +"

#5 '+%, ( #" 5 % # 5%"< ' 4 #4%%( # !

' ")+1" 2(17 &"#5

4 +#%1 '% ")+5

' 3 ( #" (% #65 (# % 6# , "4 "55 +#5"

' "7 77, !

' 54%5, #5

'+%, '" (% %+!!(4(# 6 "(1 <(121 )(#%

' 3 ( #"7 &"#5

4 +#%1 %*% 314 # "4 "5 ' 4+% 4"

(!(4 5 .7 -7-= (# ' +"

5 , 8'(4' (% *# # "4 "57 =7

'< '"5 4 +#%1 ! "

' "(<1 3"

(% #5 '< ) # '" +)'

' <(121 "4 "5% !

' 4%7 7 ' 3 ( #" 8% ""% 5 #

77- 8'"(#!

(#<% () ( # A+ '" 8% 4""(5 + #5 4'11# 8% 3"%# 5 # - 77-

(% # 5(%3+ 5 2! "

'(% +"

1 .- 3" %4+

8( #%%% '< 2# 4( 5, + ! 8'(4' #1 - '< 2# C6(#5 (11 5

'(% 9+#4 +", ( 8 +15 2 33 %(

"!" '"(# 9+5)6# ' #>21 +3"6 +"

(# <5 +16 2( '(*' <%7 <5 +16 2( '(*' <%7 <5 +16 2( '(*' <%7 <5 +16 2( '(*' <%7

! '"%'

" #5 # '"%, - /.@ /"(6(#1@ J

! '"%'

" #5 # '"%, - /.@ /"(6(#1@ J

! '"%'

" #5 # '"%, - /.@ /"(6(#1@ J

! '"%'

" #5 # '"%, - /.@ /"(6(#1@ J , (# 8'(4', (

'% 2# '15 % +#5"$ 7 "(6(#1% " # 2 "# + 2+ 657 ' '+6# 3 (1 (# <"

# (% ) 5 #5 % , #<" 8"( !! # 4"(6(#1 % 2 #5 "563 ( #7 '(% '+6#(% !+#56# 1 (% !

# 6(%%5 8'# 51(#) 8( 51(#A+# %, 9+<#(1 #5 5+1 #55, <"

%(# '% 3% #5 <"

%(##" !+ +"7 K'# 4"(6 (% 4 66(

5, <"(

! !4 "% (% "%3 #%(21 ! " 6*(#) ' !!#5" 4 66(

' 4"(67 ' % !4 "% 6

2 % 4(1 #5 4 # 6(4, 6 2, ' "%+1 ! <1+ " %( # " 3"# 1 #)14 I 6 2, 24+% !

' % "%% ! 4("4+6% #4%, "

6#(!% ( # !

( #% (# 6(1(+ ! !!1+#4 4 # "% 5 8( (#5()#4 "

'" 3"(< ( #%7

" # 3" %4+ (#) )#4 (#41+5(#) ' 4 +"

4 #4"#5 '% # 8'"8( '1 3" <(5 " 3"

' !+#56# 1 "()'

! # 44+%5 '< %35

"(1 % #%'"(#5 +#5" "

(41 #% + '#

" #

'" 3" %4+ (#) )#4 %' +15 #

33 % ' 31 ! " 2(1 # ' )" +#5

' 4"(6 4 66(

5 (% %"( +%7 "

(41 ' #% + ( # 331(% (""%34 (< !

' # +" !

4"(67 -7 K 6 '% 55

( #" (% % (11 # 44+%5I # 4 #<(4 7 ' <""4'(#) 3 % +1 ! 4"(6(#1 9+"(%3"+5#4

# 44+%5 (% 3"%+65 2 (## 4# +# (1 3" <# )+(1

4## 2"+%'5 %(5 1()'

, ' 8% <" % "(#)#

' 3#1 18 6 27 K " 4 #<(#45

' 6##" (# 8'(4'

' 3" %4+ (#) )#4

% 811 % ' +"

'< 3" 455, ' "()'

' 44+%5 '< %35

"(1 4 +15 2 %(5 '< 2# (#!"(#)5 '"2 <( 1 (#) "

(41 ' #% + ( #7E

#5+2( 21, 4 #41+%( # !

"(1 8(11 * 1 #) (67 '

"(<1 4 # ( #% "(%5 " )(< "(% 52 21 (%%+%, 8'(4' %'11 2 ( 4(# 5 +3 # 5+"(#) ' 4 +"% !

"(17 '(% +"

5 % # 56 (

33" 3"(

51< 53 (#

'% "(<1 4 # ( #%,

'(% % ), 1%

6 3"9+5(4 "(17

'(#) #)(21 '% 2# 2" +)'

! "8"5

(#5(4

' 1(*1(' 5 !

' 3 ( #" 2%4 #5(#) !" 6 ' 3" 4%% !

9+% (4 " (# "!"(#) 8( ' 3" %4+ ( # <(5#47

= 7 ' 3 ( #" (% 15 )5 2 +

"%, '#4, 2(1 3 +)'

2 4 #%(5"5 (# <(8 ! 3" <(%

-/@

(% 3"

(##

6# ( # '"(#

' 3" <(%

, -., (% 3"( 6 "( 8( ' 3" <(%

. "777, J.7 '(% ")"5, (

8 +15 2 33 %(

"!" '"(# 9+5)6# 3%%5 2

'(% +"

7-.7- (#

=-.

=-.-

15 % 0<(#5" G+" ;%7

0<(#5" G+" ;%7

+#92 +#92 +#92 +#92> /51(#) 8( ' 3" <(%

. "777@, "1<#

'" ! "5% % +#5"$

8 +15 2 33 %(

"!" '"(#

' 5(4 ! 9+5)6# #L21 +3"6 +"

(# 4% ! 0 #5" G+6" # (1 ;%7 # "1 +"+ !

#<% () ( # M #"7, -/ -@ = > , 8'(4' '15 % +#5"$ = " <(%

. !

' 5 6#5 % 8'# 44+%5 (% +#5"

' ) ! %(C "%, %(4* " (#!("6 " 2(#) 8 6#, (% % 6 '(#) 8'(4' (% "A+("5 *# # !7 2<( +%1 ' 4 +"

'% % (%!

%1!

' 44+%5 3"% # (% %(4* " (#!("67 # 4% 3"

(#(#) 8 6#, ' 4 +"

(% C34 %' 8 % 6 %#%( (<(

7 K '< 1"5

*# # ' !4

6# 8 6# 8' 4 66(

4 )#(H21 !!#%% " 3 " #5 (11( # 6# 4%%, +3 # 2(#)

+#) '< 4'(15"#

* 4" !, #5 '" " 6# (#% #4% 8'# ' 4'(15"# "

1(< (# 3"(% #%7 ' % (% (4% 8 +15 %' 8

6 "

'# --- 4'(15"# " 1(<(#) (# 3"(% #% 1 #) 8( '(" 6 '"%7 '(% (% # %34

' 4 +"

% " C34

* # ! % ( 8 +15 #

#1 (#< 1< ' (# "% ' 44+%5, 2+ 1% ' 4'(15"# 8' " #

C34 ) C3 %5

' 3"(% #%7 '" (% )"< 5#)" !

'("

2(#) (#'"( 5 # #1 8( ' 3 <"

2+ 8( ' 4"(6 % 8117 CCCC CCCC CCC =7

. !

' 5 63 8"% ' )(%

51 8( ' 11

' !!#%% 8'(1 4 #%(5"(#) # 331(4 ( # ! " 2(1 8( ' C43 ( # !

# !!#% 3+#(%'21 ( '" 8( ' 1(! (63"(% #6# " 5 "(21 C41+%(<1

' +"

%%( #%7 ' !("% 3" <(% !4(1( % 4 +"

4 #5( ( #11 "1% # 2(1 # 44+%5 (! ' (% +#5"

' ) !

"% " (% 8 6# " (% %(4* " (#!("6, % 5(%4+%%5 "1("7 '(% 2(#) 81!" 1)(%1 ( #, ' +)' (# " 5+45 2 8 ! 3" <(% , '% 331(5 8'(1 4 #%(5"(#) "1% # 2(1 ( '" 2

' +"

%%( #% "

' ()' +"

, % ' 4% 6 27 ' 3 8" +#5"

.J !

5 (% C"4(%5 )(#% # "5" "94 (#) # 331(4 ( # ! " 2(1 #5 )(#% # !!#4 C41+%(<1 54(55 2

' +"

%%( #%7 '"

4## 2 5(<(55 331(4 ( # ! 3" <(%

., 8'(1 C"4(%(#)

' 3 8" +#5"

.J7 K'(1 51(#) 8( ' 81!" 1)(%1 ( #, 3+"3 %(< (# "3"

( # )(<(#) ' 2#!(

' #5 3"% # 2(#) (# #56# (% ' " 1 "A+("5 2 31 5 2

' 4 +"

7 K 5 # 8(%'

'(% 3" <(% '% 2 4 #%(5"5 !< +"21 (# 11 4%% % 331(4 ( # 53#5% +3 # ' !4 % #5 4("4+6% #4% 4 # (#5 '"(#7 K' (% "A+("5 (% ' 4 #%(5" ( # 3" % 2

' 4 +"

'(% 3" <(% 6 #) '" !4 "%7E

77 % 3" 4+% 4"

(!(4 5 5 .7 -7-= !(15 2 1"#5

4 +#%1, ( #" '% 1"5 %+!!"5 (#4"4" ( # ! " 3"( 5 ! -

", -J 6 # '% #5 -J 5 %7 +"

'", % 3"

' %(5 4+%

(!(4

( #" (% % 2 (#< 1<5 (# '" /%@7 8<",

'(% !4 +6 4## 2 )" +#5 %+!!(4(# %1!, 541(# ' 4 #4%%( # ! ")+1" 2(1

( #" (# ' (# A+% ( # 8'# 4% (% 65 + ! " )"# ! ")+1" 2(1 A+ ' (# A+% ( # 2 ( 4(# (#) +3 # !4 %N4("4+6% #4% !

' %(5 7 1(#4 (# '(% ")"5 4# 2 3145 +3 # ' 9+5)6# ' #>21 +3"6 +"

(# +1# '57 6("

+1# '57 6("

%'5( <7

! %'5( <7

! 77 #5 # '", - / @ /"(6(#1@ = 77 #5 # '", - / @ /"(6(#1@ = 77 #5 # '", - / @ /"(6(#1@ = 77 #5 # '", - / @ /"(6(#1@ =I (<(%( # #4' 9+5)6# ' #>21 14+

()' +"

(# 4% !

"(5'" % <7

JJ /@ /"(6(#1@

"(5'" % <7

JJ /@ /"(6(#1@

"(5'" % <7

JJ /@ /"(6(#1@

"(5'" % <7

JJ /@ /"(6(#1@ M 9+5)6# % !

'(% +"

(# 7.- 15 % *'(1%'

(#)' <7

*'(1%'

(#)' <7

*'(1%'

(#)' <7

*'(1%'

(#)' <7

# # # #, 54(55 # J7

7- , #5 1"9 <7

! "

#, JJ /.@ 1"9 <7

! "

#, JJ /.@ 1"9 <7

! "

#, JJ /.@ 1"9 <7

! "

#, JJ /.@ /"(6(#1@ J /"(6(#1@ J /"(6(#1@ J /"(6(#1@ J

+!!(4 % , !+"

'" 5 ( # !

' 3 ( #" % # +#5"

"(1 (% # 8""# 5 (# ' !4 % #5 4("4+6% #4% !

' 4%7 7

# <(8 ! 2 <, ' 3"%# ( # (% 11 857 ( #" (% "5"5 2 "1%5 # ")+1" 2(1 # '" !+"#(%'(#) 2(1N%+"

2 #5%

' % (%!4 ( # !

' &57 4 #4"#5 N+

)(% 7 8<", (# 55( 4 #5( ( #% 6 2 (63 %5 2

' 4 #4"#5 N+

)(% ( #" %'11 "6(# 2 +#5 2

' ! 11 8(#) 4 #5( ( #%$ /(@ ' 3 ( #" %'11 # 6(%+% ' 1(2"

)"# /((@ ' 3 ( #" %'11 #

63" 8( ' # <(5#4, "1 " 5 4+6# "

, 5+"(#) "(17 /(((@ ' 3 ( #" %'11 # 2%# '"%1! # # 5 2! "

"(17 /(<@ ' 3 ( #" %'11 # 4 66( # !!#4 8'(1 # 2(17

/<@ ' 3 ( #" %'11 53 %( '" 3%%3 "

, (! # , 8(

"(1 +"

/<(@ ' 3 ( #" %'11 )(< '" 4113' # #+62"

#<% () (#) !!(4"N ! 4 #4"#5 1(4

#5 %'11 # 4'#) '" 4113' # #+62" 8( ' + 3"( "

3"6(%%( # !

"(1 +"

N 11A )(% /<((@ ' 3 ( #" %'11 # (# # 6##"

"(17 7

# 4% ! 2"4' ! # ' ! "%(5 4 #5( ( #% #5 ' % 8'(4' 6 2 (63 %5 2 4 #4"#5 N+

)(% % 5("4 '"(#2 < +3 # %' 8(#) #

%+!!(4(#

4+%,

N4 631(## %'11 2 1(2"

6 < 4#411 ( # ! 2(1 !

( #"7 J7 "5"5 44 "5(#)1

-7

'(#) %(5 '"(#2 < %'11 2 4 #% "+5 % # C3"%%( # !

3(#( # # ' 6"( % !

' 4%7

(#4 ' 6(# 4% '% 2# 54(55, 3#5(#) 6(%411# +% 331(4 ( #, (! # , %'11 1% % #5% 5(%3 %5 !!7 / &

&@ 4 2" 4 2" 4 2" 4 2" , -= , -= , -= , -= 6'<("

'" %3*(#)N"% #5$ %N

'" "3 "

21$ %N