High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3845/2017disposed of

Naseem v. Mohd. Ashraf And ORS

2020-01-09Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj4 pages

! " "

##$%&'(%)*+),&)*-)*'(%)*)+-.$'/)+00-'/1%1'$$)2.-

#$%#&'

.(%(%)*.,&)3#$'%*'*( '1..3 2%+. )+ )4- 56', 4'1 #,.+.,,.-(4.#,.1.*(,.7%1%)*#.(%(%)*'8'%*1((4.9:-83.*(-'(.- ; #'11.-6/(4.--$ .11%)*1:-8.'*8,:,24.,.6/(4.9:-8.3.*()+ &)*7%&(%)*-'(.-! 0#'11.-6/(,%'$ ):,(%*'&)3#$'%*(&'1.:*-., .&(%)*1<0!!!0<0=!< 2'1'++%,3.-6:((4.),-.,)+1.*(.*&.

-'(.-! 02'13)-%+%.-'*-(4.#,%7'(.,.1#)*-.*(12.,.),-.,.-() 6.,.$.'1.-)*#,)6'(%)*

,%'$ ):,(&)*7%&(.-'*-1.*(.*&.-(4.,.1#)*-.*(1'1:*-.,

%($)*$%

%+', ')*$%

'%*'%)'

<0>!<

):*-.,8),%8),):1%3#,%1)*3.*(+),/.','$)*82%(4 +%*.)+>'*-%*-.+':$(():*-.,8)+:,(4.,,%8),):1 %3#,%1)*3.*(+),3)*(4.'&4 !!>!<

):*-.,8)

+),/.',.'&4 )2.7.,6)(4(4.1.*(.*&.12.,.),-.,.-(),:*&)*&:,,.*($/

( %1 &'1. )+ (4. &)3#$'%*'*( (4'( ,.1#)*-.*( ) '*- ! *'3.$/)4- 14,'+'*-)4- ?6'$2.,.,)(4.,1%*$'2@.(4A)+(4.

&)3#$'%*'*('*-,.1#)*-.*() *'3.$/ 4'(%9'2%+.)+)4- 14,'+ 2'14.,%1(.,%*$'2@.(4'*%A (2'1'$$.8.-(4'('&%7%$$%(%8'(%)*2'1 8)%*8)*'3)*81((4.3'1(4.,.1#)*-.*(12.,.6.*(:#)*(),.&)*1(,:&( (4.4):1.9)%*($/)2*.-6/(4.3'+(.,-.3)$%14%*8(4.1'3. &&),-%*8() 4.,-:,%*8(4.#.*-.*&/)+(4.1:%((4.,.1#)*-.*(1&',,%.-)*&)*1(,:&(%)* 2),5'*-+:,(4.,)*!

B'('6):( # 24.*(4.&)3#$'%*'*(2'1 #,.#',%*8$:*&4(4.*(4.,.1#)*-.*(1.*(.,.-4.,4):1.'()4'$$' '&4' )('$.,5)($'%$$.8'$$/'*-+),&%6$/ &&:1.-)4- 14,'+'*-)4-

?6'$,'%1.-$'$5','()(.'&4$.11)*()4.,+),+%$%*8&'1.16/4.,4:16'*- '8'%*1((4.3 .,1%1(.,%*$'2 4'(%9'&':84(4)$-)+4.,'*-(4,.2)*(4. 8,):*- )4- 14,'+8'7.1(%&56$)2)*4.,$.+(',3 (2'1'$$.8.-(4'( (4.,.1#)*-.*(1 '$)*82%(4 )(4.,#.,1)*1%*1:$(.- 4.,'*- 4'-(),* 4., &$)(4.1 *,'%1%*84:.'*-&,/6/(4.&)3#$'%*'*(4.,4:16'*-)4-

56','*-1)*)4- '$%3&'3.(4.,.'*-,.1&:.-4., 4.,.1#)*-.*(1 '$)*82%(4)(4.,#.,1)*1+$.-'2'/+,)3(4.#$'&.)+)&&:,,.*&.6/%11:%*8 (4,.'(1()(4.&)3#$'%*'*('*-4.,4:16'*- 4.#)$%&.2'1%*+),3.-6:( *)'&(%)*2'1('5.*(4.,.+),.(4.&)3#$'%*'*(+%$.-#,%7'(.&)3#$'%*(

! +(.,.C'3%*%*8(4.#,.1:33)*%*8.7%-.*&.(4.(,%'$ ):,( 1:33)*.-(4.'&&:1.-'*-'+(.,(4.%,'##.','*&.(4.#,.&4',8..7%-.*&. 2'1,.&),-.- 4.(,%'$ ):,(7%-.),-.,-'(.-< +,'3.-(4.

&4',8.1'8'%*1((4.'&&:1.-+),(4.)++.*&.1#:*%14'6$.:*-.,.&(%)*<0 !!!0<0=,.'-2%(4.&(%)*!<

4.'&&:1.-#$.'-.-*)(8:%$(/'*- &$'%3.-(,%'$

+(., &)3#$.(%)* )+ #,)1.&:(%)* .7%-.*&. 1('(.3.*(1 )+ '&&:1.-2.,.,.&),-.-:*-.,.&(%)*!! ,

24.,.%*(4./-.*%.-(4.

&4',8.1'*-#$.'-.-%**)&.*&.

*(4.%,-.+.*&.(4.'&&:1.-.C'3%*.- 2%(*.11.1

4. (,%'$ ):,( '+(., .C'3%*%*8 (4. .7%-.*&. )* ,.&),- #,)&..-.-()&)*7%&((4.'&&:1.-'*-1.*(.*&.-(4.3'1*)(%&.-'6)7.

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

.',*.-&):*1.$+),(4.#.(%(%)*.,4'1&)*(.*-.-(4'((4.(,%'$

):,('12.$$'1(4.'##.$$'(. ):,(4'7.&'(.8),%&'$$/4.$-(4.)&:$', 7.,1%)*%1+:$$/&),,)6),'(.-6/(4.3.-%&'$.7%-.*&.(4.,.+),.(4.,.2'1 *),.'1)*()14)2$.*%.*&/()(4.'&&:1.-#',(%&:$',$/%*(4.$%84()+(4.

< (.1(%3)*%.1 )+ &)3#$'%*'*( " '1..3 " )4- '$%3 "< %5'*-', '*''*- ";)4- 56',24%&42.,.'$1)+):*-()6.,.$%'6$.

'*-(,:1(2),(4/ (4'16..*+:,(4.,&)*(.*-.-(4'(*)$)8%&'$,.'1)*4'1 6..* 8%7.* 6/ (4. '##.$$'(. ):,( 24%$. ,.$.'1%*8 (4. ,.1#)*-.*(1 )* #,)6'(%)*

*(4.)(4.,4'*-$.',*.-&):*1.$+),(4.#,%7'(.,.1#)*-.*(1 4'11:63%((.-(4'((4.)&&:,,.*&.#.,('%*1()(4./.',B'*-3),.(4'* /.',14'7..$'#1.- 4.&)*7%&(1,.1#)*-.*(14'7.()$))5'+(.,(4.%, +'3%$%.1'*-*):1.+:$#:,#)1.2):$-6.1.,7.-6/1.*-%*8(4.3'8'%* 6.4%*-(4.6',1 .4'1+:,(4.,1:63%((.-(4'((4.&)*7%&(1',..7.*,.'-/() #'/&)3#.*1'(%)*()(4.&)3#$'%*'*('13'/6.-%,.&(.-6/(4%1 ):,(

)*1%-.,%*8(4.+'&((4'(#',(%.1',.&$)1.,.$'(%7.1'*-(4. &)*7%&(14'7.&)3#$.(.-(4.#.,%)-)+#,)6'(%)*24%&42'1*.7.,3%1:1.- 6/(4.3(4%1 ):,(-).1*)(+%*-%('+%(&'1.().*4'*&.(4.1.*(.*&. 1

(4. ,.1#)*-.*(1 ',. ,.'-/ '*- 2%$$%*8 () &)3#.*1'(. (4. &)3#$'%*'*( (4.,.+),.%(%1),-.,.-(4'((4.&)*7%&(114'$$#'/'*'3):*()+> .'&4'1&)3#.*1'(%)*()(4.&)3#$'%*'*(2%(4%*'#.,%)-)+3)*(41+,)3 (4.-'(.)+,.&.%#()+&.,(%+%.-&)#/)+(4%19:-8.3.*(

.1:$('*($/(4.&)*7%&(%)*)+(4.,.1#)*-.*(1'1,.&),-.-6/ (4. ):,(16.$)2%1:#4.$-'*-(4.1.*(.*&.#',(%13)-%+%.-'1%*-%&'(.- '6)7.

4.,.7%1%)*#.(%(%)*%1-%1#)1.-)++

'*:',/ :$'(%

-. "4.(4., .#),('6$.

.1>) "4.(4.,#.'5%*8> .'1)*.- .1>)