← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1440/2013allowed

Ram Chander Jain v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-08-17Mrs. Justice Raj Rahul Garg13 pages

  

  !

 "  #####



   

    



 !      



   

    



 !      

  $ %&$' '  

 # $%&'( "  #   &')'*& !  #'

+

,)+&'(     -   (  .!  +!    

   % / &  +  +   "

0

/1 233- 1 24- ))0   1 233-&" 

$

/+    6 

/78'

:;

  "

0!   -:# /

/  & ! 1

/  " &  $ )&  +0! " )!   <  

/

"

"  (!    "  6 

/78'

:

;  +0!    "")      "   +  

  0!   =9 (         "          

/  

  )  555'

"! )+ 

 ))!) 0)  +  +

 +77 ") ! / )

 !

( +7 1 24-&"  "! 

"

" -430

!" 

( +3

 

  

) 7-8'

:3 :3 ))!;  7-8'

:4; > $ 

&  0

/9  1 233- ,  "   %

      :"   

' 

 )$         +  

    *+

?"  + " # /*:555



!7 + " ?

%"





? )  + "   &



@ 077 

 ))  

/  

 " &    ")

  +   )  0!     / 

/& +$  @   ")

&  +  

 "

/

'

)!

&> & '

)!

 &

 

"   '5   &  , 

)  '

 &  1&  $&

" >      ""

0 0!  

 # /-8'

:;&+ $



/

  $ +   )

 

/

/ >5 +

0 ) ! " )  9 

( 

 /0/ +  )!

/ 

" +! &  / ) +  

) / : " 0!>5,++ +  /

  +    A'B  /!    "

&    0(    "&   / 8'

:;+

"  34 + /(

  

 

 " 377-- ,"  )

")! /  8'

:-; , 

!

   +  ""

     

))!    74  =

!  @ 

0 

!"8'

:3; 5 

!" 748'

:3;&

/  ))  / )())/

#

&# / "( '/"! & + 

  0



7 8'

:4; ""

/   " )!    

/

"

C4<" ! ,"   -(  8'

:;, "  /( ) ")!   -7 8'

:;  78'

:;0!

+ " )!< 

/

"

"  (!

  " &

&# /8;

  D9 2

,'8; ,"") /

   

 78'

:;0!=9   ! 1

/"  

)"  / 

!" 8'

  :3;    74  +   /      "  0

/ + 

  78'

:

4; 

/

 ))+

 

         /  +  

"")!

/

!"& "   !

+ )

/ + 

  8'

:4;)!

"



 "

  

"

,

)")

!

!8'

:; ) 0  

 + )"

/  8'

 :E :;>

))!

    )

0!  !& ! &

+    

!

"  )0+   ")! 

")

!  ! /+ 

!" !" &    

/    )  )   0  

     ")!) /+ "+!

0 

")!  &  

," (

/ 

&   "        

  +  

        " ! 

!"5"



) 0)0 

 0  -' 0/  " +  0 /   "9" )!

+ 

 @  &    +       0   )  0!    ,  $ 0!      E -

+   



"



 /  8'

  :; 

  /

    "    

)

/  % " )! " !  ( )( 8

  '"");

 ) &7  

(

  

 

   

        /         ))/

 )

 &/ )

!+ / ,

! ( 

"74 "!

+ 

9 '

:3)))))/

 3+"(/

" , "   !

# /

/  " "



!

" + "

" )! 

/

"

 9 4<" 

9! 0   "  0

/"

 & + 

  + / "  ') /+  + 

  & "

! +  

)

 ' 

/ " )

/ -7 /

/ / ")!8'

:; 78'

:

; "



"")+  )/

  # /

/    # /

/  + )  0 =9 ( &

 ) " 

=9 ( + 

+

$ " 1 )

/"")&=9 (  )    (

   /

!  0/   

+ 

   

)

"""   $ 0!  ,+  $ >E

"") "   ! '/5

 " +

  " (  +))  

)

/ 

  / &  /     )

//

)

/ ) 0!"

 0

/0    :" ," 

0

 0

"

-  /

348'

:;+

 ,  $



/" )" 

 

0/

 

"

 #(+ / < "(

)"

! )," )!

 <  

  /

 "

   "    4 !

 9 

( 

 ) / -'   /)! )

 (   )    4  8'

  :F; 

 ( +     " )" 

/

 ,"  ")- !  (  3 

  / -' +

9

  + 

+  /  + +   70!+!

/" )!  + "  ))! ) ) 0)/ - ' )+ ,+ "

/0

 /

)!  78'

:; ""))  ! 78'

:;

  )) /

!-/" !  ") &"   /) /  $  >  '50  )0!'" )3,/

"

 ()/ ! ")

" !

* ) 



/,  $ +) "!77:

77 777:,/$")   

)

/  -  '

""

 # /& 1&$8'

:;&//

 $  + ) ) / / , " %

 ( "  37 ")-3! / )

 ! (  @

 

  / 

" 

! & 

0" (-'   

)"  "   

!+ +  " -#, + '5 "!77:77&44#+>  "!77:77&77-#+ '5 "!777:    1 ) 

/  "

   (        78'

:;&  0 ( 

//

+  $ 

" 9" 0!>5

<'  

"  0!  "

/      '

)!

&    '

)!

    >     "")

" &

 ,'& 1&$'  ) 0

"0!>""   0 $ 0! # / ,'" 1 &  ,"  + +   ) (

/

 

+ ") +  1" ")

 "-8'

:;

+ 0!

 # /& ! 1

/" &

 $

 > "")! ))&

 /"

&- 3 "" 

  

 

     

 





   



    

  

   





     





 

 

 



  



   

  

    

  ! "   !#$% 

   %%&&# 

  



  

  





       





'

    

( 

  



  

   

      

  

 ) * "  

   



 +,- 

  

  



  

   

'          



   

  



+ ,   

   +     (  

"

"-8'

:;/ 0! 

   # /  '  "

)          7 8'

:;  + 9"  /

+

 $ 

" + <0!>50 + ())

/) 3<+  $  '5 "

!777:,

" )! 0  ) /

0 (

 '5+ "!777: )

/

>+ "!77:777  

 + )0+ " "4& ) (

/

 

 +  $  +   

 ! /) / +   )0  " '

"" 

 & 0!( # )&, 

)&   

"  +0/ )!

/ " ")

1

?,

"  +      

 ")

0!/

/&+$ & 1))/

/ ")!  1(0 / /6 ) !+ 0/ )!

/

" ")

 )   ("



 6 ) !+

") + 

))!/, +  

/@ &2 0,

)&?"



/* ))&# '>=&# &# /& '>=&)% 

/

&

" &> "")!&  % 

/&5

" & ! '/& /

/& @& )   5  "  ")

&/

/&

  +$ &++ 

0 "$,+ 0/  +       

   "     1    $

/  +       &7&  -   

))0/ ++ 

"$ + 

+ "!77:770)

/>E

"")!"   ! '/& &+ 

 "  $  1 "

) 

    

       

    

   !"# !# ,  $+ )!

/ 

" - 

+ 0(

(

/+ 0 80/ ; 

/

) /" 5+ )+ )0 

+) ,    )

+  )

  ))+   ) ) ,

" / 0!

 )?

&

'

)!

& > &  '//+)& '

)!

&>& & %

/&5

" & '5& & 1

&,'& 1&$& )% 

/

&5

" &>&  '"

) )" 

" - 8'

:; +     /

"   +

        ")

   0! / 

/&  +$  

&FF&7 - 

   )

+ +  $ +)!

/

"  ) -  '

"

"     4 0!  '//+)& '

)!

&>*

D0

&"  &1 &, '

@ #1$"  ??

)&'

)!

&>*

D0& "-8'

:; ))  ()!&/  "+   

)!

/

" " - 

    "



/    !  + )   "

/    "   4    )

"  +/

)!

 $

/""   $5+ "  ))!  0!>

"&

""   0 $ 0! # / ,'" 1 &  5

)+ ))0  +) #(+ )

/"")"  78'

:;&=9 (  0 (     +   $    >  E  '5  +    " (  +)) 

)

/

/ & / )

//

)

/ )  0! "

    0

/ 0    "  +(& )  ) 0!"

 

0  /  0!   

   +      ,   

!

)

+ )0 )

  

"

 

+)!

/

" 0! " -   #(&    "

)              "

    " +

1 1: +    

9 

 +  0 /

  ") / / #(&9

D 9 2!

,'  -74

 )  )(  +     

 $ + 0 

" +"")! (   + ) +0/

" " )0/ =(

 

9

2  +     $ +  

" 0



"")! ('



//

/ / 



 # / 

# /

  " 

&# / D 9 2



"         $+   

  '"0/ +   



 ++ 

0A'B /! "" -8'

:; ,&

0  !

) 0!"

 + //+& "

   " 

/<  

"

6

 0 

   B0) " 

(

% /  )

/  "

+ )(0 

(! 



0!"



/  !'

  +   0 /) /

"   >5  2  4    4  /

  

   

3F4F:.  5     )     H  &  

   

  , ))/

 /

     +      

  ?

 

( + 

 

"")!/+

 -"

0! 0 (

)

)#/

& 2+ &!+ 6

)) / /



  (

/0   0 ( +)) 

0(&+ "

))+'

/  1 2 4-& 

( +  6

)" 

>5244

( +         3    

 

      

) 7-8'

:3 :3 ))!;

 7-8'

:4;&

"

" -430  !" '

/ 1 233-&   

     ) )) 

6 )0 

" + 

"     "    "!

 2      , - 

  "