← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11213/2015allowed

Babita Khair v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-08-13Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj31 pages



   

  

  



  

         "  

 

  ( )

      

 



       #$#%&

()*+, *-./.+0"

1  &' 2 

  

  ( )

      

    



    

 !!!!   # # 

 #*   

   "

+, "* " 



-.     !   " # /0123( '"     

  " # $%&'" 

-2-      " # >!82&>2 # ;<!82;;

=<;& ;=;/2=<;0 AAAA   

3 %

' #1" #.0 #$#

*. '4" 4 5" 64* '  # $%& &' "  ."  "'    MAIN CASE ES   " 7    * '  *   '" '."4  3 ".""  5"   !82;;=;/  =<;0   ?'       -.  !

!'  ;/ ;< =< <;$ *" # /2-. !

! 

.    3 +     9-

3( :, *'.    ;& <0 =<;; <1 <> =<;; *%%&<"  "".  ( "=<<1+;<.

. ,'""  * " .*"

4 "     ?

?.  @  "    "    - 3( ( # /*"#  "." "3  

*- -. ;<.  " * *

-3-    *'. **              ;/ . *    " " **"7 '

'.*C*>< . "" "" " *3!B '   '.- 3(  .'

 * C' "

-.  ?

?*' 5"

      =& ;$ .      "  

'2      # # ;<=1;% <> =<;< *  *  "  "  *   " "   7     # # /23(       ;0<<<C2  "  .  6 6   ''*"

*;& <> =<;< 6 6   "

 "   * .  ".   24   *  '7  6 ""*" * *'"  "'*  " 2B"     B *      "  "  " "" *  "  '.   3!B  !8!     B  ! %<&  ;>&;  " " **'*

B  "D   !+ 9 D!:, ,"#'6   E  3!BE !    "  - 3(

 '"  .""  -"* *

-4-    "*  " "* '  * *". '  <> ;;

=<;<+ 5 2%,* * ' '.

.  D! * . " ".         * '  " "   *  6 *      *" D!* ' '  '.  F"  " D!'  '.

.  *  ;& <0 =<;;  ' *""'.- 3(

B*" "  '""  / %>C27    *

    " "   %%&< "  ""

". *    ( "  6   * "  5"

      '.       '  .     * *'" " F "          # /2 3(   '.   '.  =0 <1 =<;; * *" *  .     " " *     <& <> =<;;

 6  *    * * *  5"

  *   # /23(   ;& <% =<;;

 -"  "'" ""5" 67  "    .  !* " '.  " *'"  " ( " 

-5- =<<1 6 "   . =& <= =< <;= 6   3!B*(5"

 (- 3( "  6 " . *"  '. D!<& </ =<;= '  !""  " * " '.  D!         .      *   '   *   C "   #   "".2 " *    '. 

D! "  "  23!

!B  *  - 3(   "

""   F "  '  '. D!   " "    '       .       "

'G!D D)!"G   *     .        " "

" "    *  !" * '     " '.  D!  <& </ =<;= *  

  " ""   6          "  # /23( "" " "* C !   6" *"   ;< <0 =<;='.

. D!'

" . " "     *  *      6    "  " "'

'.  5 C   "  6 6  7         

-6- "      =1 <0 =<;= *"  *    ;1 <& =< <;=

 "

""'"' ""* *   "   '7  "  *" " "  7 '.  ;% <1 =<;=     " * 7   ;> <> =< <;= *  ! " ""  6 D!   ." " "<$ ;= =<;=  " . '*"" 

  

      

    

  

   

                      

                        

                    

   

   

  

        

    0" B"'       *'

'.   " "' .

.*' .'  * 6 6*" ' .*    *   "   6' " "C' " " <$ ;= =<;=* ""

" . '.      7   "      " "   

-7- "    *      "  '      6  " * "" . " " '.  D!  <= <= =<;/ B *'   $      

  

  

  

   

        $                              

   

         

   

                             

    

            



       

 +

 

      !

! "  $-

)  # #  

  $     

  

  

 

  

    6 '  ! "

"". '     * "'  5" * 

B* F"

"3!B.  "       6  F" " 

 "  "    '    D  ! +     9 D!:,   =$ $ <$ =<;/ B"" ' "* * " '   D!      ;< <% =<;/   # 0 ** "  %  &

   '()*&                    

         ( (      



  

    +   "   #

 ,

  &.)/+0% %&

-8- '

'()*& .% )#$  %& '+1#0   

   

 

      

    

    +2#   

 6 '  "    D! * " "   *  ''.  '  "'* * "  *" " '. D!"  "  " *". ' *  '

   " '4" *  '. 

D!

 (        4' "'.* "".  "  "*' -  7    **=; *    =&  ;$ $  "     '

' . *   *   " "     *        "     5" 7 "'.  -   '  " '  .'

' @'.      /""   

   D! *     /< ;< =<;/  !  (5"

  " 3 !

! B  6   '  '."  D! "    3 $  

          

 

 

 # #

 

  %   ,# 0 !   *

 * *   '()*& '

   & &

 %  '()*& -



-9-

  2

 +   -   4&-# 2               

          

 , ,)4(/50 6 ) 

    

 

%  , ,# 0)#$7 *

* *  '()*&-

  & &

% '()*&-   

  

    3899:89 

   

                     

         

       

 

            ,)4#0 #0 ;

; $ 

#

 

( % ) )#$ 7  %  ,# 0 )#$ 7 7  <*= '()*& -

   &

 %  '()*& & -    

  

  

 99 99:8>    

      

  

   $                       

        

  



       

    

      

          $

$  

       

        

        



   

         



     

+



   !   "

"  -

 ) #   

  $     

 



   ,) )4&0 

      -"      

  /< ;< =<;/    '  *"'  ."  

  '* *"'   " '  6- 3(

"  "  

-10-  '

'"   * 6* * ". ;$ </ =<;$'

 *<= <& =<;$ 6 6  5 "  8      ;;?:%

   

 +  5  14    

 =  &

 ,-  0  

      4  

 

-            9  5     

 , 0  

                

   

    

          

 

;;?:

:%  )#$=  9?: (               

 > ( (    83 %   

     6 7                         



 5

+

        

            5      5     5

            

        

   -*.=   > > 5       3:>@49A?

?;: -*.;;?:% %#

+ 5  4      

      

       5    5 1  5

            3  $  "

 #  

                ) )#$          

4

(

   



$ "

# #  

          ,

   

-11-   B       '      ! * * '   "

""   '.  B F ! D  +      9BF!D:, *  * "        4 * * "* * 7   *.". '.    D!* <1 <1 =<;$ D! *   ""

 '.5"  * " "". .  ' "" *   "  *

6      "   '.

D! "' * B<<< <<<  <<< ( (    $  +    # =;:?     

                         

86:    

    

 



   

  

 



    

    $

                 

  

 +2#           

       

       B  

B ! # %<&" "  * 7  ' "  ;0<    "    "     "  *   .2 "

'   6 " '"'

D!  """ *    

-12-

   '

       .  '    # / 0  1  '   * ' " "   6# /2 3(     "   '

'.  D!    "    

   B   ! # %<&  ;>&;  " " * B  *  " ;

;0< "*  ' "  "" "' B   !# %<& ;>&;

  . *   '.

.     -.  # # ;=** ."   *#

/23( .*"  "  6"  ;< <& =<;1*"    # # /23(  * "     "   * * ." "'. " '     # 

   +8- -, - 3(  "

 *   * .  "' 

D!'

 ' .

.   . .'" " '   B *     '       *.       * *

-13- " " '

'.   "  '    '.  3 !   B.

.' '.3!B    4 4        3 !  B # " "" ' *     B  !# %<&;>&;

B* *       .      "  *  <$ ;= =<;='.

. D!""" 5"   * ." "

   D   !         * *  2 +, 6      ""  .    * *  * *   #B6  '

'"".  6 6 "

  .""*"  "  "* ""  '

' .    '

'.     6  "

 * 7   ' 

  +, B    '    '  """  "" '     "                 "*" "'.

D!*"".

-14- "   # /2-

3(   3!B '

   # #' 6    "        6 6

    *  *. '    "

  """  ' '.BF!D +, 6*  *5"    "'.    <$ ;= =<;=  6       C 

'  " "   *    "  * * "    '.      " "   * *''.

D!BF!D "" * '.BF!D   * "  ".'     + , 6    

.   "   "

""               *      '*       . 

 /"      ( " -"    '

   .  " '.  '    '.      " "  *

"" "         '

  5 2=% ** " *'  '.BF!D*"

-15- 5"    *  ". '   " '      * *  . *.  *  5" + , -    '         '    *              6*"

. . *   *'

. . "   *  -   "    '     **   .     . .* * -' " '.*      . "  2

'.         "   ' " "

" '.    *      C'*. '

'  "" "

     +, D"   3!B- 3(     

' "

2B   #B6 *" "' ""  " "   "

" .*'.  *   """

" '.3 3!B !8! B

!%<&   @  " "   *   ' *  6 .

-16- '*' ";0<    "    *'. ' 7    '" "   * +, B ''."    "" '.  *7 *

.   '

'  "  -"   " " ' 

  "" +, D !     23!B   "    !

!  0;+/,   63    * "".     *' '*- 3(             B23!B  *     ".  ""'   '..  ' '. + , D "     23!B    '   "

3!B*  ' * 3( "

* "

*    '."    ! 3!B "" "  > >   + "7   ) )D, ";>%=" *""

    *". ' .

-17- "."' *"* ."  .  .*  # # ' .4 '"  '.  B "  "         "

  "   '  "  *   ' " 

 6 "  "     "      *"   4 " '.  !   .   * ""    B   !%<&  ;>&;   

'. *'  *   """""

" ." "  " "       " '."  6 . 7  *"   '  !     *" *"  .. ".    "    '  

  *  ' "  

" 2B  "   #B6  6 "

"" .  " "            "

 *  .   

" 2B   " "  "  . * '.    

.     *     *  * ' "7

' )'

'.

-18-  "7  *" "'.    D!

!  <> ;;

=<;<  *" #'

' 6    * * "  6.'   '. 6"   23!B 3 ! 

*- 3( * "" 6 *".  *     '.       . "      B !%<& ;>&;

6* "  "      " "   *    (

"  '

' '.   !    ""  "'.

. " HB '

   ;

#.

 ?'*6 = #!  / !". %%&< 6 $

D / $%"

" *.  % 8  &

'.          "

B  - 6 8   > ("

'" +? ." . ". "7  ;< "  

"D ! *    '.         '   '   * =  # I # # I 6    '  " "* 

-19-  ;;

 . 222 AAAAA ;

*!! ;=0 00J=;

1< = F  ;=% <;J== =% / C 8 ;

1/  *     *    < > *  '        . +@ = $$J< > +, 3HH< 1< +, 322< >; (" ! !C!

 $;

10  "".

;%&< 6 ;=#      $ - 0<<<  * " / ! % #   "

  " ! &

@ "

 ! . % ;<J> ;0+=<GJ/<G,

*  " > 6  / >0'  ;<

#   2M0 %<K 2M% /0 M/ /0   ;= #   @ ;

1/ J = $$" 0$# '* J ;;

6  @ ;

0<J< %< ;=

1< />J< (5

, ;/

 !

 !   '   $ /%"C" 8K ;$

' *

  '

1<+?

*< %J< %+? ,    $ %0 "

"

   * K K

!!C!

BC L"

"

   B   "* "" " ""

" .* ""  "'." *. 

-20-   "     "    " HB  8 " *"   " *.  E '.    "

E *"

'

   "     .  '       "   B  ! %<& &  ;>&;"  "* 6"  "*"'

'  "

 #B6 -"'*  "5 6""  . *  " "'.

."   D!       " "  7  *  "        *  '.    "      " "  "  "" "   '  G  ""

C ' G 7 '* "  ;1 <& =<;= '

'

  *    "

""  '  '  5"   '.! (  '7   "     "    !      " *   "  " .  6 .   *     "  *  " "  ". "  + "* , " B"  <$ ;= = <;=*"'. "' .* *  **    6 6 *C  *    "   ' . * '. 2  

-21-       "      *      -" "5" *    " '

'.  "      B   '7  "    " *!  " *5" *"  '

 '

* F"

" 6 D!    '  '    " '  '4 4" '    BF!D ;$ </ =< <;$  3!B7

" "%%&< 6 "". **= &<" '.* *  "  6 " "       * *2' .   "

       .'

''. ' .*'"

*  ' .'  ( '.  '" * '7  3!B 6 6 " '  *&%<7   6" ""  BF!D'

' ''  . "   " "    *     *     6   "

  '4" '.. 6 6    " *    '.

.  D!      <1 <& =<;$ "" * "* D!  "# # "." ' D!* *  " 

-226 '7  '

'.' "  '  ' D! * ' "  '  .'

D!

F""7 .  "  # /23(  '" . "* *" * "* *     "      ;$ <& =<=<   <& ;= =<=< "" ''  6 '       # /23(     . "".

8.

D!"'.   '"

"'. "

""" * * "" ".   .""  7  B !%<& ;>&;' . .

. . "     "     6  # /2 3(   "   "          7 .   ""  " '  !   6 6   *    '   '  "  ""  "     *  7     *  ""      " 2B   *     * 7   ' " ''  D! ( * *   "       

' '.  D!  *    

" 2B   #B6 *    "" "'

'   "" " " ""   

-23- ? " 3!BC!8 8!   "'. * # "     '   """    6' " "  '"+,   '"    .    '

' "' '.  3!B  !8!

 6 " '       " ""  '

  6 6 5N "" O   "

2B " ' ' '.""          C   

 6   ""  "'      '   " . * 7  "    6       '

 "'   " 2B ""

"". "   B 

! %<&;>&; '.  "

2B * ' " "  *" "C  6" .*7   '" '. D!;;  6* * "" "  '. ""   "'  "  2;

6   "" ' * '  "     "   *     *    * *    B*""  ""

" "    ' "        "  '* * .   '     "

"  6  

-24- '.'.    "'5     '    .     7  '.    " "   * *   ( "  6 6   ' " "   '    .  "" " 6 . "*'

' .           "    *  ''. '""    '.   B    "   "C' D!'

'.' .       . 

"  " "       *'

'.'. .  *  . "". ' * ""*"

"C' D!*  ' * *  ' .*  '.7     . '"   ".

    "    '.  D!       " "" '.B F!D '     " " *  6" !   ' " "*  .    " .   '    . ""  *     5" 

-256' "  B"              



        %2'"

""3''. -:'

 !     '  *" .4 .'.

6    5"

2 9>$       

  #



 + +    

    +   

 



   

    

C

    



 (

83

#

$ PPP PO 

.   ""'.    # %  # ;%   # =1   # =>   # =>   # /<   # /;+,# /;* '"".   .*" 5'. BF!D*    '"

. '*'  '.  '   D!       " " " '.   *    .   '  ""       " ."    '..  " F""

'.  *"" 5" '" " '    *" ".'.  ' '   . "**. " * 2

-266           " "   *       5"  " "'   """  *    ""  " * '    *     *  '  6  "   ""     ' .

.'* "'  '4  * "  " " " B  "  I " 

#     $%    !

    &'(') *

+ +,," '" -:'

 !  *  '"    *   7 "@            '. "@     6    5" 2 2  8@   

 

  

         

  

   



         

  $  D        



E             

  

    

  

  

    

        



        

    

      



      

 

 

   

       

      

,+ %  0 F8G??H'#(9; <<<  < <<<  <<<

-2793 5 8GG:  $  

    

   

   

         

 

       



    (

  83   #

 $ )  # #  

$ 7  #

)$

 ,8GG> >08 + +##?8 #

  

 



 

 





     

           

      

  

  

 

D  

 

  

  

 

 

 

   

    

 

  # #

  

      

 



  

  

  

    

     

          J ?FKH 



   



 

 +  

   

                

  

       

       

    





                   

 

 

   

    

           



 !

!

             

 

    

 



    

   C  

  

     

    

   

               E   

                          

    

   #

     

   

    

   

      

-2896 $ L   $   '

 

 &  #  

 , ,8GG>0>+##3GG #

 

   

 

  

  

      J , , 0 

   

 

         

       



M , ,

0 

    

   

  

   

  

    

  

  

  M , ,

0 

  

           M , , 0  

       

   



    

              

  M , ,0

    



 

 C

        E  

   

    

  

     

 M , , 0 #

  

  







         

       <<<  < <<<  <<< > >@  

  



  

             



           



   

  

               

      



         

              

    

      

  

      

   

      

  



    

    

   

                         

 

   

 

 

  

#

  

-29-                 

   

    

      1 1       

     



 

 

 

  

  

  

 3:  

   

  



         



     

   

  



               

D  .    





     



                 

      

    

         $= C,

0 2 2N    



  C

C





    

    

     

    

 1                 



    

      

   

  

 C

  

   



  



 

          

   

 

      



  

 

   

 

  

       

   



 

D  -"B * "" '   '    '    " '    *   ""'

'. 6 57     "  .     *"  " '.

  '  F   "  *  ' "       " 5" ?'.  !  

-30-  ' *  ' .'"

"       "

   "

"  '   !     ' "    ) )  ""

"  5 

  " "" " 6*"

"".*  *"

"  " # /23(   "   ! "  +, , ". - 3(  +',  " + .''.   "+",(5"

   ( -

3(

 6 '  !     "  " "   *  "

 '

'.   *   "5  '4"    ! 6 6" ""  "5"

    " .      .

.'     "  *"  *''

'

'.# /23(

   '4"' ! " "7 .

. * ' ** @ @'.. 

 B   .' * *' .   . ""     "C     '  "  C" '.' !  

-31D   5" ' " " '.  # /2 3( * 5 """.   F"".

%  

'

"

-   "32        1   

4    J  4= 1  

 J  4=