Babita Khair v. State Of Haryana And ORS
"
( )
#$#%&
()*+, *-./.+0"
1 &' 2
( )
!!!! # #
#*
"
+, "* "
-. ! " # /0123( '"
" # $%&'"
-2- " # >!82&>2 # ;<!82;;
=<;& ;=;/2=<;0 AAAA
3 %
' #1" #.0 #$#
*. '4" 4 5" 64* ' # $%& &' " ." "' MAIN CASE ES " 7 * ' * '" '."4 3 "."" 5" !82;;=;/ =<;0 ?' -. !
!' ;/ ;< =< <;$ *" # /2-. !
!
. 3 + 9-
3( :, *'. ;& <0 =<;; <1 <> =<;; *%%&<" "". ( "=<<1+;<.
. ,'"" * " .*"
4 " ?
?. @ " " - 3( ( # /*"# "." "3
*- -. ;<. " * *
-3- *'. ** ;/ . * " " **"7 '
'.*C*>< . "" "" " *3!B ' '.- 3( .'
* C' "
-. ?
?*' 5"
=& ;$ . "
'2 # # ;<=1;% <> =<;< * * " " * " " 7 # # /23( ;0<<<C2 " . 6 6 ''*"
*;& <> =<;< 6 6 "
" * . ". 24 * '7 6 ""*" * *'" "'* " 2B" B * " " " "" * " '. 3!B !8! B ! %<& ;>&; " " **'*
B "D !+ 9 D!:, ,"#'6 E 3!BE ! " - 3(
'" ."" -"* *
-4- "* " "* ' * *". ' <> ;;
=<;<+ 5 2%,* * ' '.
. D! * . " ". * ' " " * 6 * *" D!* ' ' '. F" " D!' '.
. * ;& <0 =<;; ' *""'.- 3(
B*" " '"" / %>C27 *
" " %%&< " ""
". * ( " 6 * " 5"
'. ' . * *'" " F " # /2 3( '. '. =0 <1 =<;; * *" * . " " * <& <> =<;;
6 * * * * 5"
* # /23( ;& <% =<;;
-" "'" ""5" 67 " . !* " '. " *'" " ( "
-5- =<<1 6 " . =& <= =< <;= 6 3!B*(5"
(- 3( " 6 " . *" '. D!<& </ =<;= ' !"" " * " '. D! . * ' * C " # "".2 " * '.
D! " " 23!
!B * - 3( "
"" F " ' '. D! " " ' . "
'G!D D)!"G * . " "
" " * !" * ' " '. D! <& </ =<;= *
" "" 6 " # /23( "" " "* C ! 6" *" ;< <0 =<;='.
. D!'
" . " " * * 6 " " "'
'. 5 C " 6 6 7
-6- " =1 <0 =<;= *" * ;1 <& =< <;=
"
""'"' ""* * " '7 " *" " " 7 '. ;% <1 =<;= " * 7 ;> <> =< <;= * ! " "" 6 D! ." " "<$ ;= =<;= " . '*""
0" B"' *'
'. " "' .
.*' .' * 6 6*" ' .* * " 6' " "C' " " <$ ;= =<;=* ""
" . '. 7 " " "
-7- " * " ' 6 " * "" . " " '. D! <= <= =<;/ B *' $
$
+
!
! " $-
) # #
$
6 ' ! "
"". ' * "' 5" *
B* F"
"3!B. " 6 F" "
" " ' D ! + 9 D!:, =$ $ <$ =<;/ B"" ' "* * " ' D! ;< <% =<;/ # 0 ** " % &
'()*&
( (
+ " #
,
&.)/+0% %&
-8- '
'()*& .% )#$ %& '+1#0
+2#
6 ' " D! * " " * ''. ' "'* * " *" " '. D!" " " *". ' * '
" '4" * '.
D!
( 4' "'.* "". " "*' - 7 **=; * =& ;$ $ " '
' . * * " " * " 5" 7 "'. - ' " ' .'
' @'. /""
D! * /< ;< =<;/ ! (5"
" 3 !
! B 6 ' '." D! " 3 $
# #
% ,# 0 ! *
* * '()*& '
& &
% '()*& -
-9-
2
+ - 4&-# 2
, ,)4(/50 6 )
% , ,# 0)#$7 *
* * '()*&-
& &
% '()*&-
3899:89
,)4#0 #0 ;
; $
#
( % ) )#$ 7 % ,# 0 )#$ 7 7 <*= '()*& -
&
% '()*& & -
99 99:8>
$
$
$
+
! "
" -
) #
$
,) )4&0
-"
/< ;< =<;/ ' *"' ."
'* *"' " ' 6- 3(
" "
-10- '
'" * 6* * ". ;$ </ =<;$'
*<= <& =<;$ 6 6 5 " 8 ;;?:%
+ 5 14
= &
,- 0
4
- 9 5
, 0
;;?:
:% )#$= 9?: (
> ( ( 83 %
6 7
5
+
5 5 5
-*.= > > 5 3:>@49A?
?;: -*.;;?:% %#
+ 5 4
5 5 1 5
3 $ "
#
) )#$
4
(
$ "
# #
,
-11- B ' ! * * ' "
"" '. B F ! D + 9BF!D:, * * " 4 * * "* * 7 *.". '. D!* <1 <1 =<;$ D! * ""
'.5" * " "". . ' "" * " *
6 " '.
D! "' * B<<< <<< <<< ( ( $ + # =;:?
86:
$
+2#
B
B ! # %<&" " * 7 ' " ;0< " " " * .2 "
' 6 " '"'
D! """ *
-12-
'
. ' # / 0 1 ' * ' " " 6# /2 3( " '
'. D! "
B ! # %<& ;>&; " " * B * " ;
;0< "* ' " "" "' B !# %<& ;>&;
. * '.
. -. # # ;=** ." *#
/23( .*" " 6" ;< <& =<;1*" # # /23( * " " * * ." "'. " ' #
+8- -, - 3( "
* * . "'
D!'
' .
. . .'" " ' B * ' *. * *
-13- " " '
'. " ' '. 3 ! B.
.' '.3!B 4 4 3 ! B # " "" ' * B !# %<&;>&;
B* * . " * <$ ;= =<;='.
. D!""" 5" * ." "
D ! * * 2 +, 6 "" . * * * * #B6 '
'"". 6 6 "
.""*" " "* "" '
' . '
'. 6 "
* 7 '
+, B ' ' """ "" ' " "*" "'.
D!*"".
-14- " # /2-
3( 3!B '
# #' 6 " 6 6
* *. ' "
""" ' '.BF!D +, 6* *5" "'. <$ ;= =<;= 6 C
' " " * " * * " '. " " * *''.
D!BF!D "" * '.BF!D * " ".' + , 6
. " "
"" * '* .
/" ( " -" '
. " '. ' '. " " *
"" " '
5 2=% ** " *' '.BF!D*"
-15- 5" * ". ' " ' * * . *. * 5" + , - ' ' * 6*"
. . * *'
. . " * - " ' ** . . .* * -' " '.* . " 2
'. " ' " "
" '. * C'*. '
' "" "
+, D" 3!B- 3(
' "
2B #B6 *" "' "" " " "
" .*'. * """
" '.3 3!B !8! B
!%<& @ " " * ' * 6 .
-16- '*' ";0< " *'. ' 7 '" " * +, B ''." "" '. *7 *
. '
' " -" " " '
"" +, D ! 23!B " !
! 0;+/, 63 * "". *' '*- 3( B23!B * ". ""' '.. ' '. + , D " 23!B ' "
3!B* ' * 3( "
* "
* '." ! 3!B "" " > > + "7 ) )D, ";>%=" *""
*". ' .
-17- "."' *"* ." . .* # # ' .4 '" '. B " " "
" ' " * ' "
6 " " " *" 4 " '. ! . * "" B !%<& ;>&;
'. *' * """""
" ." " " " " '." 6 . 7 *" ' ! *" *" .. ". " '
* ' "
" 2B " #B6 6 "
"" . " " "
* .
" 2B " " " . * '.
. * * * ' "7
' )'
'.
-18- "7 *" "'. D!
! <> ;;
=<;< *" #'
' 6 * * " 6.' '. 6" 23!B 3 !
*- 3( * "" 6 *". * '. . " B !%<& ;>&;
6* " " " " * (
" '
' '. ! "" "'.
. " HB '
;
#.
?'*6 = #! / !". %%&< 6 $
D / $%"
" *. % 8 &
'. "
B - 6 8 > ("
'" +? ." . ". "7 ;< "
"D ! * '. ' ' * = # I # # I 6 ' " "*
-19- ;;
. 222 AAAAA ;
*!! ;=0 00J=;
1< = F ;=% <;J== =% / C 8 ;
1/ * * < > * ' . +@ = $$J< > +, 3HH< 1< +, 322< >; (" ! !C!
$;
10 "".
;%&< 6 ;=# $ - 0<<< * " / ! % # "
" ! &
@ "
! . % ;<J> ;0+=<GJ/<G,
* " > 6 / >0' ;<
# 2M0 %<K 2M% /0 M/ /0 ;= # @ ;
1/ J = $$" 0$# '* J ;;
6 @ ;
0<J< %< ;=
1< />J< (5
, ;/
!
! ' $ /%"C" 8K ;$
' *
'
1<+?
*< %J< %+? , $ %0 "
"
* K K
!!C!
BC L"
"
B "* "" " ""
" .* "" "'." *.
-20- " " " HB 8 " *" " *. E '. "
E *"
'
" . ' " B ! %<& & ;>&;" "* 6" "*"'
' "
#B6 -"'* "5 6"" . * " "'.
." D! " " 7 * " * '. " " " " "" " ' G ""
C ' G 7 '* " ;1 <& =<;= '
'
* "
"" ' ' 5" '.! ( '7 " " ! " * " " . 6 . * " * " " ". " + "* , " B" <$ ;= = <;=*"'. "' .* * ** 6 6 *C * " ' . * '. 2
-21- " * -" "5" * " '
'. " B '7 " " *! " *5" *" '
'
* F"
" 6 D! ' ' " ' '4 4" ' BF!D ;$ </ =< <;$ 3!B7
" "%%&< 6 "". **= &<" '.* * " 6 " " * *2' . "
.'
''. ' .*'"
* ' .' ( '. '" * '7 3!B 6 6 " ' *&%<7 6" "" BF!D'
' '' . " " " * * 6 "
'4" '.. 6 6 " * '.
. D! <1 <& =<;$ "" * "* D! "# # "." ' D!* * "
-226 '7 '
'.' " ' ' D! * ' " ' .'
D!
F""7 . " # /23( '" . "* *" * "* * " ;$ <& =<=< <& ;= =<=< "" '' 6 ' # /23( . "".
8.
D!"'. '"
"'. "
""" * * "" ". ."" 7 B !%<& ;>&;' . .
. . " " 6 # /2 3( " " 7 . "" " ' ! 6 6 * ' ' " "" " * 7 * "" " 2B * * 7 ' " '' D! ( * * "
' '. D! *
" 2B #B6 * "" "'
' "" " " ""
-23- ? " 3!BC!8 8! "'. * # " ' """ 6' " " '"+, '" . '
' "' '. 3!B !8!
6 " ' " "" '
6 6 5N "" O "
2B " ' ' '."" C
6 "" "' ' " . * 7 " 6 '
"' " 2B ""
"". " B
! %<&;>&; '. "
2B * ' " " *" "C 6" .*7 '" '. D!;; 6* * "" " '. "" "' " 2;
6 "" ' * ' " " * * * * B*"" ""
" " ' " " '* * . ' "
" 6
-24- '.'. "'5 ' . 7 '. " " * * ( " 6 6 ' " " ' . "" " 6 . "*'
' . " * ''. '"" '. B " "C' D!'
'.' . .
" " " *'
'.'. . * . "". ' * ""*"
"C' D!* ' * * ' .* '.7 . '" ".
" '. D! " "" '.B F!D ' " " * 6" ! ' " "* . " . ' . "" * 5"
-256' " B"
%2'"
""3''. -:'
! ' *" .4 .'.
6 5"
2 9>$
#
+ +
+
C
(
83
#
$ PPP PO
. ""'. # % # ;% # =1 # => # => # /< # /;+,# /;* '"". .*" 5'. BF!D* '"
. '*' '. ' D! " " " '. * . ' "" " ." '.. " F""
'. *"" 5" '" " ' *" ".'. ' ' . "**. " * 2
-266 " " * 5" " "' """ * "" " * ' * * ' 6 " "" ' .
.'* "' '4 * " " " " B " I "
# $% !
&'(') *
+ +,," '" -:'
! * '" * 7 "@ '. "@ 6 5" 2 2 8@
$ D
E
,+ % 0 F8G??H'#(9; <<< < <<< <<<
-2793 5 8GG: $
(
83 #
$ ) # #
$ 7 #
)$
,8GG> >08 + +##?8 #
D
# #
J ?FKH
+
!
!
C
E
#
-2896 $ L $ '
& #
, ,8GG>0>+##3GG #
J , , 0
M , ,
0
M , ,
0
M , , 0
M , ,0
C
E
M , , 0 #
<<< < <<< <<< > >@
#
-29-
1 1
3:
D .
$= C,
0 2 2N
C
C
1
C
D -"B * "" ' ' ' " ' * ""'
'. 6 57 " . *" " '.
' F " * ' " " 5" ?'. !
-30- ' * ' .'"
" "
"
" ' ! ' " ) ) ""
" 5
" "" " 6*"
"".* *"
" " # /23( " ! " +, , ". - 3( +', " + .''. "+",(5"
( -
3(
6 ' ! " " " * "
'
'. * "5 '4" ! 6 6" "" "5"
" . .
.' " *" *''
'
'.# /23(
'4"' ! " "7 .
. * ' ** @ @'..
B .' * *' . . "" "C ' " C" '.' !
-31D 5" ' " " '. # /2 3( * 5 """. F"".
%
'
"
- "32 1
4 J 4= 1
J 4=