← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11236/2015dismissed

Amit Kumar Sidhu v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2015-11-05Mr. Justice Darshan Singh20 pages

  

  !

 

   

"#$  $%&'&()         

      )*+ ,

-   





     !

 



"



#   $ % &' ( )

"

 "&' 

-    . $ %       !   !  *     ! 

+,(-$.

" 

 +   !

/!

+ !! % "  + !    +   !0# 12

 !

(--34!!

!  !



! (.(--35

 

 !    *   !0#

**   !2

 $667 

   !! 4 !

   %4

 ! !

 "

"8

!

!% 9$!

*   " !!

!

"

  :" !

;





  ( %  " +   !

/! 





<

 0 < 2  !  +  

  %+4   

 " + (--3(-$-%+ 4:"

7,+  %+  4   !     !         "   !

" 4:! !  !

 + (----=1% "  

! ! ;

1$+4 +  %!   " 4  + !

 + ! 4   ! "

>  !!



4 !

"

4 ! +

4 !%+

   "    !   #

    ?

  #5

!! " ! ! !4   "  ! !4: ! !4    !+  + "!

!+ ! ! %! !

"! "  "% "4 

    !*) $396,(--3 @# "



    A *) $,36((--3 @



   A 9 %   ! *  ""  +

 ! !  !!  +   !

/! +"   <

 ?

 +)   + %+ + 4" "  !  "   +

 

 !

 ! 

!!

!

+" "4" ";!  4  " 5

+!

 "

;



 +  "

%!

 + 2 +!



!4 

!"      "

>  ! 

"

 +   !

/!5   + 0!2 +

"   +!

 +   !

/!!"

!

! ?

B!

!*  4 /#"0,&(12/,#"#$ 3(4"5 #2$0'  (-$(  0$2  C  39(D(-$$  072   E  .((. 4  ! !

 +4    "  

   +!

 +4  +

4 ! 7 ? " ""  + !!    # = *+  ! * 

+(F(-$.  !"   "  :4 +"

! 

: +      !      %  !     "  + 

4   

+,(-$.B+    G   3 $-  $6 (9   (3  4 

4    !  !! ! !4 54  !  

 !



: 

!  

 4  *)

$($F$(-$.!

"  % 4   

+(3(-$.%   !  !* 

 +  !   

6  4;

 

 F (-$.%

4;

    !    (6(-$.%

   :

! 

(--!

4!     4% 44 !



/!$((-$./!$F(-$.%4   !

  "         8

    4 ;

  4 !

   +

 % :

   :% "% ;

   ++4 +  

 + ! +   !  !*  

/!,(-$. . B+  !  "

  4      



  /!  ,  (-$.     

"  4       4!    "

 ! 

+ 

    "



4"  

*  F < " !

*  ,$%0$#"07,#"#$ 8"0("#"9"/':";$/&0'(--F072 **$     !   

< +   !

/! +        ""

>  !        # !!



!$3(-$$4!

!!

+4

* B!

*   

0  2"

> +  +  4:"    ! !            % !!

         +        #   

    09  B !2    *  !        %   !+ !!

  

*  #   "



!6(-$$5!

! !+ !!



!$.(--F 

 ! 4      

  $-(--F !  !!



  !+!  +4 4:" ! !  "

  4 4 

+

"!     :" 4 ! 8

!

  " +! 4

4 !!



"

>  $(-$$ !9+  !! ! 4! 

 4 +!

4

;      

!  !!

 ! !

"  +    #       <

  ?

 +)  * "

4!

E

+$((-$9   





<

 

 

 * 

"         "  !

  "

"  +   < +         !   !!   %   "   

  " !    <

0 < 2  % !+   .9  ;  +4:" ! !

+4 "

 !  

   4:1! "   +    B   * * !!

 +    #         %  !!

   

   $,  (-$$ 0;

1.2

, 5

 !

 +   ! "

 +  +4:   



 

 <

        4!     *

# "  "     +  #   

  %       8

 "  4     !   !   !

+ ""

 ! + 



+  

 7,+  4: ! !  !+ "

   3 5   

                     !4!

4

   +

" 4" ";!  +4  " 5 +4" " ;!     +        4    "    #   

"  



;

 "4 !    "  4    "        +     !

 + #  ! 4 %

     "    *   ! "        ! 4" ";!  ! 

   "  +!

!

!8

"4

  44" "+4

    ! !

"  "

   +     /  /4  +  4

 



 "  :" +     6

           

4"       

<

!    4

*  !   !    4

 : 

"

+ "

! !B  4 "

 +     :         ! 

9.6.=9F$($666 *!

% ;  0*%24 

+

4



4 !4  "

 "! !  

"  4" " ""

" 4:    "!

  % !  

+ !

$7(* 5   ! %! 7F  

4!

  1 H7F5!



" !!!

;  <"*   !  "

" 

+4 " 4 "8



+

4 !  "  "

 +!

"   !4!

4!+ 4  !  +  % !  :  ! +

 "

")  <"* 

!

+ "4" !"  +  

+8



+

4 !

" "

 +

"  !4!

4!+4!  +"

" 

 54 <"*   !  "

 4 +8 <"* !

4 4 +4  8

 +8

4:!

4 

+%+

"

" 

=  ! )   4   B! <"* 

  !  4 "8

 

+  " "

 +  

+4 " +4! 



"<!  

! B!  

!  

+4 "  4 " 8



+  4"

 + !

*!

% ;    "    !     

     

" B!<"* 

!+  +

+4 " 4

8 

4 !"  5 4 !!

 *   ;!   ! :" !   !4    

!      <"  *   !"   #     !     !

   "

> )

! <"*   

  ! 44 "

> 4 " " !+ 4 "  !  +    <"  *   5   ! 



    !       "

 4

 

 

 + 4



4  ;5 !  

0+   2 4

 :  

"+ "

! !B 4"

! 

 : * 9.6.19F$(

       *!

 % ;    

+  

  4

  

4    !  "    "  !       !    " "   4" "     ""

" 4: 

>

 "!

       %   4

    ;;!4+*   !

  $7(      *        !   I $-

  ! 

+

*  ,"#7""09"'2/,#"#$ &2"00'(-$-0(2 *%(794

  *               4    4:"  4

 

!=! !  !       !  !!    " 

;

 4" " ""

" 4: 

  !    $$ <4 !

 1* 

 

 +  "

;

 4" "       "        +  4    4:"  +   !

/!4 # 

 + + ! ! %*   



   

!

% "!

$3+ 9,+  E

+$(-$.5   $$ G 3$-$6(9 (3 !  " 4 4  "4!+

 4;

 5!

!

 4  " "  !4

  !

+     

    $-  4     8

    4 ;

   





 !! J     4

!

  !!



 "!

4;  

 G  !    "      + !

       +   !

/! +  +" 

4

4      

 +4! " 4  "  !!     + 

!

 + " 4*

= # ?         !



!      "" "    ";  + " %+

 4 11 !+#  !  !8 + " !!! $( / 

"

 



 !

#

   "     *    +  #    

  %+  "

" + "4:! ! ;

+  4   



 

 <

    4!     *

#     !   "     +      # " !  

"   # 

+  

< 4    *       " 

   !     ! !

4 + *! !  





<

 %! !

 +  + ! +4  "   !

  $7    $F      *     5  

 ! !

 +! 

!

 ! ! ;

   

 %

"!



 ! ! !

 !%8

+ "   "  !  "

  " !8

 +

4! %   !

        ;      +  !:   

"4+  !*

7 

               "   ;!   4  % "  !

 "C" ! 

+    "

  !   4

 !  

+  +  "     %+!

 :!

"

>  !!  !+!!

 ! !

 +   + # %+  !

%

  !

!

4"

 +

 !  ! !  <  $9 / 4" ";!"   4

 !

4     +   !

/! 

 "  4

" 

 4 !4" "4!4

+

"

!

     * !"

 4

 

 !5 + "

  !  ""

  

+  "

 " !4

"

+  !

 !

   +*  # " 4" "4 ;!5 ! ! 

 4

 

8

+!

!

$7* 5   8

 +

4!

$F

4!4

   8

8

"4!*   $7 %  "

4  "

!

 *   !

4" "!! ""

 !

4" ""  ! 4* 

      4:  4

   + 

    

!

  

 ! ! 1"!

!:

* : ! +



  "

 = !4! 

  !! %4



  !  4

 "

 ! ""

!  +  "   !  

4!4 "

!   %!

  !!

((F * 5   !   4

  +

!   ! 

"

4

  #  " 

 4" + +! 54

4 4!

"   :" !! +   !

/! "B   4  

 

 :4 ;

  + !

 4   4 4" ";!  ! " 

   4  $. 5     

    0  2    "

 ! !

 



 * 4

+4 "* : 4!

 "

>   "B K * ! 0

2!(--,%+

          $-  +    

+           B 5 K * !  !   <"*  "

>  !%  "

E

"!   8 "

>  ! * !   

 !

 

;" "   !4 "  * ! "

>  !% B!



  +!

+4: 

+4 " + 4* !  4

! +""

>    ! 4   ! 

% C 

4    ""  +    ! 

* +!



 54  "



  " .9    !

 !

!+   $-+  "



+   !     %+     8

    %  * !

!     !

   "     +  4          !  +!





!  !

4!

"4    +

  +4   "

+ ! 

 +* ! $66.

! 

  = * : "

 + 



6   (.($66.%

  

      4   +* ! !! "

+

  4  !    %     4    4    $666   !   !! !! "

+  

+$.$(---K    

> !  4 E : +B 1"

 !(--,?

   * !     4     +    B   5   * !

0

2!(--,<!4 8 "

>  +  +* !  % !4 5 * ! 4  B  ! K;

 B 4! 

4 4! 

%

* 

 4 "

>  !!

"  !+ 4   "

 + !  4"

" 

+4 "<4 !!

" $7

 !

 0  2   

  *   

   

4 !  +  " "  " 

;

4

!  " !  4 B   : "

 !!

  "

; %

4" 4

 $71 H$7

  +

"

 !  !  

    +    !:



4" 

  + $66.  4        !  !   "  

 :+* ! 4 ! 

4* ! ;! <4 B    : + "

 !!





  +  +

 + 

    !    " "  " 

;

5J

 G!

 " .. 

"* B! 

   ! !  ! !4  " "

;

 " " 4" " ""

" 4:     "!

 I $F 5 :" *    ..      $, * "4  "   "

! !

 !

   

"

*  "1$(;0"2"(;0"$#%/ ,#"#$ 2"092"(;0'. 4

*  !"

  



 

4 ! !

  "

"

 * E : 44!  "

 ! 4!4

  "  +;! "

4  4

 



FF9B  !

 4   !  4

    +   !

+% 4  

!  4!

 

! 

   

  !

$7$F*    

"

  <4 !!

" 6$-

 * 

 

(-$-

  

" 

41 H6 5 4"" !

4   

   

 

 !! 

 4

 

 !

$7 $F   *    "  

+  4

 

!

!

5!

 

!4

 4      

  4     +    !  

FF90 2B   !

 

 

 !

$7 $F     *    4!     



 

"

L  !  ! 

+4  8      " ! <"* +    "     4   8      



"  $- 5



  

 !! "

+     4  ! 

 !  !    + 4 +4    !

 +!      "  + + 

; 

 %

   !I $3 5     !

  0  2  "  

;

  4 4 4+

* 

"

F,(-$$    (&( (;&""(0/ 03(:?2&(&"0"'30' 0(-$$2, **96,D5(-$$ *(,9$%

*  ;

 + !     !

 4

;!4 !

$7(*  5 4! +<"* %

 %  "

    4   



 !  #

   5

<

"*

#   + "  <"*  

!  !"

;

 " +  " !!



" *   "

! %

*  " 

 $9 

41 H$9B "   ! 

4   + 4         !   

"

* 0  25

  

" !       8   4!  

  !   !  E

" * 4  4  

 !

4

"

"

 %*   ! 

4 + !! 

  

  

    !

  $7   $F     * 5 4

"

54  

 

4

 "  !!  J

 092   0  2  4!        +    

  +44  "

+   ! < "!!!

       !    "  

"

   !

+4    "  ! +!! <" * 4 

   

"  4+   

  "       

"   

"  *

0  2  !4   !* B!J

  092!

0  25 ! !

+ 

 !  ;!   +

! ="

   !

! +! !

!

+

= "

1! + +!

 !  +!  "+   5 



 !     +  4

         

    "

   !    

     +" !!

! "

4 

+

4"

! !   " + 

%               ;    "

! 

4  " "  !  ! 

    !4  

;



+ " +!!

" "   "

   !        /  +      "

      4   

  +  * ;!  ! !

$7( * 5 !

    "! 5 ! !

 ! !

I $6 5      

"   

  *   

           4             !

!

   ; "

! 

4  "

" !    !4  

;



+ " +!!

" "  "

 ! 

4  " ! !   ! ?  "

!   !   !



  !

   +*  ! 

;

 "! +

 !" " +   !

/!%!

  

>

4!4 +

"  "

 "

4 "*  " + :" +

!  "

;

! !  "  !4  "

" "!  !

 !!   !

!

 !!   "   !! 8 4" ";! 4

!       !      

     !      +    

   !   4 *    



!

 4

4 !!

4! !

  (-

+ +! 

!

! !

4

+8 + 4       +  *    !     !

        

 "

4  "!

!4  8  4 K 4

  !!

 !  8  ! !

 :    +

 +" 4" ";!" 

4+

" 

!

4

  

+ !: 5

 + 4

  !

  >! !  4""   >>+ "  +" ! " 4

  *  " +      " ! ! 4+!4 8

   +  +

"     +     *   

     8       #  <

0+ 2 ($ ? * 4

  4 ! !4  4! 4 :  "!

!!

4  !

 +  54!! "  !

  4

   !   +!

$7 $F * 5  (( *8  +" 

 4  "! 4  !  4   ! 

  

-          :(&9"