High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11367/2015allowed

Balwinder Singh v. Punjab State Power Corporation Limited And Others

2016-07-19Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

! " !

!#$% &%'()(*+,

#-.(*&%/0(*12 %$($(*%/) 3%/)4) 4*5#60$#$%.%//7/#$(*8(9($%&#*&$2%/) %)7*&%*$) + : 8 0;8!0 /%)%*$+ /3#/(*&%/0(*12 #*#<&='#$%< /$2%7%$($(*%/ ) ;4/*#<&='#$%< //%)7*&%*$) 2%$2%/$2% %7/$%/) -'#-*%.)7#7%/9#>6%#--.%&$)%%$2% 54&19%*$?

6%/% %//%&$$2% %7/$%//*$ 2%$2%/$2%54&19%*$)24-&6%/%7/$%&(*$2%&(1%)$? ;8!0 2%7%$($(*%/)%%@)./($(*$2%*#$4/% 9#*&#94)<&(/%'$(*1 /%)7*&%*$)$/%14-#/(A%2())%/=('%# $%/$#@(*1(*$'*)(&%/#$(*$2% %*$(/%)%/=('%/%*&%/%&6>2(9*&#(->.#1%6#)()/*./@'2#/1%6#)() #*&# $%//%14-#/(A(*12())%/=('%<$2%7%*)(*#*&7%*)(*#/>6%*% ($)6% 1(=%*$2(9 2%6/(% #'$) $2%'#)%#/%$2#$$2%7%$($(*%/.#)#77(*$%& #)#./@'2#/1%#$%<=(&%%*&/)%9%*$

<&#$%& , , , 2%7#> $2%7%$($(*%/.#) (B%&6>$2%''4*$#*$

('%/<0 < 84&2(#*#<#$ ) C .($2%

%'$ /9 , ,2%7%$($(*%//%$(/%&

/9)%/=('%* C * D,D,<$2%!%7#/$9%*$ (*#*'%< =%/*9%*$ 4*5#6< ())4%& *)$/4'$(*) **%B4/% /%1#/&(*1 /#$(*#-(A#$(* 7%*)(* #9(->7%*)(*$.#)(*)$/4'$%&$2#$$2%%*$(/% )%/=('%/%*&%/%&6>#*%97->%%#)./@'2#/1%<#)#-)$2%)%/=('%7#(&

/9'*$(*1%*'(%))2#--6%/%'@*%&$.#/&)/%$(/#-6%*% ($) 2%)#(& *)$/4'$(*)&#$%& D,D,**%B4/% .%/%#&7$%&6>0 <=(&%

%9 &#$%& ,D, **%B4/%C 2% !%7#/$9%*$ (*#*'%< =%/*9%*$ 4*5#6<())4%&#*$2%/*)$/4'$(*)* ,,**%B4/% /%1#/&(*11(=(*1 7%*)(*#/>6%*% ($) ./@'2#/1%)%/=('%

=%/*9%*$%97->%%)<.22#=%&*%./@6% /%,D 3(&%

('% /&%/<&#$%&,,, **%B4/%,<$2%)%/=('%) $2%7%$($(*%/ .%/%#1#(*'*=%/$%& /9&#(->.#1%/$./@'2#/1%3(&%

('%/&%/

< &#$%& D **%B4/%< ())4%& 6> $2% B%'4$(=% *1(*%%//#*)9())(*< 046 /6#* !(=()(*< 4*5#6 0$#$% .%/ /7/#$(*8(9($%&8#-$*;#-#*<84&2(#*#<$2%&#$% #77(*$9%*$ $2% 7%$($(*%/.#))2.*#) ,,,<.2%/%#)#)7%/$2%)%/=('%6@<$2% &#$% #77(*$9%*$ $2%7%$($(*%/.#) , , ,#)./@'2#/1%#$% 2% 7%$($(*%/ () )2.* $ 2#=% /%$(/%& * #$$#(*(*1 $2% #1%

)47%/#**4#$(*2%7%$($(*%/#-)'-#(9)$2#$2%2#&#-) (-%&#'(=(-)4($ (=(-04($ ,,D<&%'(&%&* ,$($-%&#)

< 7/#>(*1 / /%14-#/(A#$(* 2() )%/=('% #) 2% 2#) '97-%$%& C &#>) .($2 #-- '*)%E4%*$(#-6%*% ($)())4($.#)&()9())%&#*&$2%#77%#-7/% %//%&6> 2(9.#)#-)&()9())%&2%7%$($(*%/2#&#-)#77/#'2%&$2()4/$6> .#> (-(*1,C,C /1/#*$ 7%*)(*#/>6%*% ($)# $%/ '*)(&%/(*1$2%%*$(/%)%/=('%/%*&%/%&6>2(9*./@'2#/1%6#)()<64$$2% 7/#>%/ /%14-#/(A#$(*.#)*$(*'/7/#$%&(*$2%)#9%2()4/$<=(&% /&%/&#$%& <&(/%'$%&$2%/%)7*&%*$)$ (-%#*#

(&#=($/%1#/&(*1 $2%&%$#(-) 7%/(&$2#$$2%7%$($(*%/2#&./@%&.($2$2%9* %($2%/ &#(-> .#1% / ./@'2#/1% / (* #*> $2%/ '#7#'($> 2% /%)7*&%*$)#''/&(*1-> (-%&#*#

(&#=($.2%/%(*$(--$2%&#$% 2() /%$(/%9%*$(% C <$2%7%$($(*%/.#))2.*$2#=%'97-%$%&

>%#/)<9*$2)#*&,&#>) 2())%/=('%!4/(*1$2%7%*&%*'> $2% )#(&7%$($(*<$2%/%)7*&%*$)7#))%&$2%/&%/(*'97-(#*'%.($2$2%/&%/ 7#))%&6>$2()4/$* </%5%'$(*1$2%'-#(9 $2%7%$($(*%/$2#$ 2%/%$(/%&* C #)./@'2#/1%%97->%%#*&$2#$2())%/=('%)'4-& *$6%/%14-#/(A%&2%

('%/&%/<&#$%& **%B4/% <.#)())4%& ''/&(*1-><*

C <$2%7%$($(*%/.($2&/%.$2% )#(&7%$($(*.($2-(6%/$>$ (-%# /%)2*$2%)#9%'#4)% #'$(*<'-#(9(*1 $2%/%14-#/(A#$(* 2())%/=('%)#-) *$2% ./($$%*)$#$%9%*$<.2(-%/% %//(*1$$2%&()9())#-

%#/-(%/'(=(-)4($(=(-04($ ,,D<$($-%&#)

&%'(&%&* ,<

(-%&6>$2%7%$($(*%/ //%14-#/(A#$(* 2())%/=('%)<#'2#/$.#)1(=%*< 1(=(*19*$2.()%6/%#@47 )%/=('% $2%7%$($(*%/$())$#$%&$2#$2% ./@%& /# %.9*$2)(*$2%>%#/), ,#*&,D2%/%# $%/<2%.#) /%$/%*'2%& /9)%/=('%(*#><,D 2%/% /%<2())%/=('%.#)*$ '*$(*44)*%<.2('2()9#*&#$/>/%E4(/%9%*$<#)7%/$2%=%/*9%*$ 7-('>&#$%& D,D, !4/(*1$2%'4/)% #/149%*$)<$2%-%#/*%&'4*)%- /$2% 7%$($(*%/2#)/%)$/('$%& 2() 7/#>%/*-> /7%*)(*#/>6%*% ($)&4%$ '*$(*44) )%/=('% .($2 %

%'$ /9 !%'%96%/< ,, .2%* 2% 2#& '*$(*44)->./@%& / C&#>)(*%#'2>%#/ 2#=%2%#/&$2%-%#/*%&'4*)%- /$2%7%$($(*%/<$2%-%#/*%& '4*)%- //%)7*&%*$)#*&2#=%#-)'#/% 4-->1*%$2/412$2% (-% 2%7%$($(*%/2#)6%%*/%$(/%&<$/%#$(*12()&#$% #77(*$9%*$ #) ,,,2%7%/4)#- #

(&#=($ #-5(*&%/0(*120(&24<&&($(*#- 008<8#-$*;#-#*<84&2(#*#<)2.)$2#$$2%&%$#(-) ./@'2#/1%

C )%/=('%=%/( ('#$(*'2#/$ $2%7%$($(*%/ #-.(*&%/0(*122#)6%%*1(=%* 2%7%/4)#- $2%'2#/$)2.)$2#$$2%!%7#/$9%*$'-#(9)$2#$$2%7%$($(*%/ /%$(/%&* C # $%/'97-%$(*1 >%#/) #1%#*&2()$$#-)%/=('% 7%/(&() >%#/)<9*$2)#*&,&#>).%=%/<$2%)#(&'2#/$#-) )2.)$2#$ /9 , <$2%7%$($(*%/'97-%$%& C&#>)(*%#'2>%#/

/9$2%7%/(& , $ ,D<$2%$$#-./@(*1&#>)#/%

/9$2% 7%/(&,,$ ,,<$2%$$#-./@(*1&#>)#/% #*&)()$2%7)($(*

$2%)46)%E4%*$>%#/) 2%7%$($(*%/&%)*$)%%@$2%/%14-#/(A#$(*

)%/=('%<64$7/#>)$2#$2()'*$(*44))%/=('%#)./@'2#/1%6%$#@%*(*$ #''4*$ /7#>9%*$$.#/&)7%*)(*#/>6%*% ($)2()4/$(*

DD, <&%'(&%&* #--.%&)4'2 /%-(% /%->(*147*$2% 4-- %*'2#4$2/($> $2()4/$(*

,D,

, <.2%/%(*($.#) 2%-& $2#$ $2% ./@'2#/1% )%/=('% --.%& 6> /%14-#/(A#$(* () $ 6% '4*$%&$.#/&)E4#-( >(*1)%/=('% /$2%74/7)% 7%*)(*#*&#*&$2%/ /%$(/#- 6%*% ($) * $2% 7/%)%*$ '#)%< )(*'% $2% 7%$($(*%/ '*$(*44)-> ./@%&#)./@'2#/1%%97->%%.($2%

%'$ /9 , <$2%/% /%<2() )%/=('%) /9 , *.#/&)#/%$6%$/%#$%&#)E4#-( >(*1)%/=('% /$2% 74/7)% 1/#*$ 7%*)(*#/>6%*% ($)2%7/%)%*$7%$($(*()#--.%&$ $2% #6=%*$%& %B$%*$ 2% /%)7*&%*$) #/% &(/%'$%& $ /%-%#)% $2% 7%*)(*#/>6%*% ($)(*$2%#6=%*$%&$%/9).($2(*$2/%%9*$2) /9$2% &#$% /%'%(7$ '7> $2()/&%/2%#//%#/))2#--6%7#(&#$$2%/#$%

,F7%/#**49(*$%/%)$ /9$2%&#$%&4%$(--7#>9%*$ ;8!0 ! ,

)5@)