Rabinderjit Singh v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd & ORS




   
 "#$ $%&'&() 

"*&(+$,-&#.&(/0 $#&#&($, 2$,'3'

3(-"*.#"#$ 4$,,5,"#&(6#+ "(+#0$,'

$'5(+$(#'

 


     

,$'$(#)1 ,.0&(+'"7+8%"#$ ,#0$5$#&#&($, ,6.0399",7+8%"#$ , , "(:"-0",+4"-7+8%"#$ ,#0$,$'5(+$(#' ;;;

         559&%"#&(&'"994$+"'5,"<$+ , 0$"%%=5"(<&(/"55$"93(+"#$+!5,$ $,,$+*<#0$5$#&#&($, "/"&('##0$,+$, 5$("9#<+"#$+ > 7&'#":$((,$%,+"#(($?3,$

"&("'$ 2&+$,+$,+"#$+  >  (($?3,$ 1!75"''$+*<#0$ 0&$ (/&($$,7&,%9$63+0&"("7#0$5$#&#&($,7404"''$,8&(/(#0$ 5'# 3(&,(/&($$,3(+$,#0$,$'5(+$(#1,5,"#&(4"'&=5'$+#0$ 5$("9#<   , $&#3,$    #4  "((3"9  &(%,$=$(#'  4&#03#  3#3,$  $

$%#

$#&#&($,0"8&(/"8"&9$+ #0$'#"#3#,<,$=$+<7#0$'"=$'#"(+'+$%9&($+ &(#$,=' ,+$,+"#$+  (($?3,$ 1!
('#"(#5$#&#&(&'+&,$%#$+"/"&('##0$"

,$'"&+#4,+$,'"# (($?3,$' 1"(+ 1

"8&(/0$",+%3('$9 ,#0$5",#&$'"#9$(/#07#0&'3,#&'

#0$%('&+$,$+8&$4#0"##0$8"9&+&#< #0$,+$, 53(&'0=$(#+"#$+  > (($?3,$ 1!75"''$+*<#0$53(&'0&(/"3#0,&#<($$+(#*$ $?"=&($+(=$,&#'7"##0&''#"/$.3%08&$4&'*$&(/#":$( ,#0$,$"'( #0"##0$ "%#' #0$5,$'$(#%"'$=":$3#"%"'$ ,,$="(+##0$55$99"#$ 3#0,&#< ,,$%('&+$,"#&( 0$  3(%(#,8$,#$+  "%#3"9  5'&#&(  #0"#  +$5",#=$(#"9 5,%$$+&(/'4$,$&(&#&"#$+"/"&('##0$5$#&#&($,&(#0$9&/0# "%0",/$ '0$$#+"#$+  "(+#0$ 994&(/,#&%9$ 0",/$4"' ,=39"#$+ "/"&('##0$5$#&#&($,)1


 

 

 !"!  !   #!

$ # %



  "$

&"

' ! 

     !"!  $'     !!

  " !

   (()*"!

&"  

 "!

+, !-

!

! % !

 " . )/0112 304 5!

0 

 

 !

! ! %$'  !

!  "!! % '#

 6



  !$' 1(* $7  

 "!

    "

 !8 "  "

! #!

7    , !- ( +  

 !  %$   "

(

 

! !

'$  

 !"!

3 

$' !!

" !

  9 :(, !- (+     



 !  !

   !

   ;"

 '

!  $"  < !  

(  !"      ;"

' 

  $ "

4     ! !!"  

4       "! !

    , 04/

 &" ;"

'  "!

#" %"$

.  3/  0=281> ) ?$   *

 @

(

("$& %

"!

  

  

$ # !  !

  ;"

'  ! !! % % !   /!

 

!  "!  !

$ #  6 

 

, !-  :($ 

  A       

   , !- (+

$  "

'       "

 !

   !"'(   $'   "    

    "- $       *! 9      

 

!     $   !"!  $'

  *"!

(   "

% "!  "- $     *! 

, !-  (+ "

'  B 0$,$59<'3*=&##$+##0$%0",/$'0$$#0"8&(/(#*$$( 3(+ '"#&'

"%#,<7  "( 
(@3&,< 

&%$,  4"'  "55&(#$+   9"%$+  (  ,$%,+  "# (($?3,$ &'#0$
(@3&,< $5,#+"#$+  "(+&(' ","'#0$ 5,$'$(#5$#&#&($,&'%(%$,($+7 &(+&(/'4$,$,$#3,($+&(0&' "83,"(+ #0$,$*<$?($,"#&(/0&= #0$%0",/$ 0$53(&'0&(/"3#0,&#<704$8$,7%"99$+ ,%==$(#' ,= #0$0&$ (/&($$, ,+3%#&(&,%9$!"(+"

#$,%('&+$,&(/#0$="##$,7 &=5'$+#0$5$("9#<35(#0$5$#&#&($,"'(#&%$+0$,$&("*8$

$#&#&($,5,$ $,,$+"'#"#3#,<"55$"9+"#$+(&9!40&%00"' *$$(59"%$+(,$%,+"'(($?3,$

$,3'"9 #0$"55$"9439+,$8$"9#0"#"5",# ,=0"8&(/,"&'$+ "(3=*$, %(#$(#&('A'3*=&''&('7"'5$%& &%/,3(+0"'*$$(,"&'$+#0"# #0$53(&'0&(/"3#0,&#<0"'+&

$,$+4&#0#0$ &(+&(/' #0$
(@3&,<

&%$, 4&#03#$8$(,$%,+&(/"+&''$(#&(/(#$ 0$&=53/($+,+$,5"''$+*<#0$55$99"#$3#0,&#<,$8$"9' #0"##0$%(#$(#&('"(+'3*=&''&(',"&'$+&(#0$"55$"90"8$(#$8$(*$$(

11 (#&%$+=3%09$''+$"9#4&#00$$(#&,$,$"'(&(/"+5#$+*<#0$55$99"#$ 3#0,&#<&'##0$ 994&(/$

$%#)1


    , !-    (  +  

 

 /    

 &  $" =

>(*"!



   ! !% !

 /!

5  $  !  

 &"

 (    !$'

 ' !$ !

 

 

  

"

!

"

 %   ' @ %    !  

!

 %$'

  

   (     

       '    $'

-! 9

( 



!$'  '

     !   !  $'  

     =&  $" > 

*"!

% !  /!

5  $'

-!B 0$@3$'#&("',$/",+',$"'('#*$"''&/($+*<#0$55$99"#$ 3#0,&#<$8$(40&9$"

&,=&(/#0$,+$,5"''$+*<#0$53(&'0&(/"3#0,&#< %"=$35 ,%('&+$,"#&(*$ ,$#0$(B*9$.35,$=$3,#&(


  

  ! "##$%&' &(""(+&#4"'*'$,8$+ "'3(+$,)1
5  9        (        

" 'C !!   

'  ( !  

' 

 

! 4   "     !

 "      (    !  $' 

  " <  

 "  1"

-% ?  9!

 ! = 44>/4( 

  "

%  ! -"!

 ;"

-"!

" 

  ?         !

 !(         

  " '



! 

!  D  ( %    

E

  $  :(

.  3/  0=281> / 

;"

  "

 



   (

 $ ( "$!

 ! -"!

 ;"

-"!

!(%   !  

  ! "$( ) *+,  =" >(

$ $%!=% ! )0>

F G6 

 %

" '(   "  !(!  %     

  %

" '      

! !"!

G

 $ % $% (  "  (

' 

 !  

!  



$    

 

!  !   

" '($"    $"! ! 

%$   ! $ %

 !  

6 

  '%   "



 "   '!

 

$' 

 !     

   '        %        

" 'B

$,3'"9 #0$&=53/($+,+$,+"#$+  (($?3,$ !75"''$+*<#0$55$99"#$3#0,&#<439+,$8$"9#0"##0$'"=$&'##"99< ((1'5$":&(/  "(+  "  %,<5#&%  ,+$,   0$  55$99"#$  3#0,&#<  40&9$ $?"=&(&(/  "  '#"#3#,<  "55$"9  5,$ $,,$+  *<  #0$  $

$%#$+  $=59<$$  4"'

*9&/"#$+#%('&+$,#0$8",&3'/,3(+'A'3*=&''&(',"&'$+&(#0$"55$"9 "(+#+$"94&#0'3%0'3*=&''&('<"559<&(/#0$+&%#3=9"&++4(&(
  

  , %"'$  '35,"!  #0$  &=53/($+  ,+$, 5"''$+*<#0$55$99"#$3#0,&#<7%"((#'3'#"&(

,#0$,$"'(',$%,+$+"*8$7#0$5,$'$(#4,&#5$#&#&(&' 5",#9<"994$+"(+#0$,+$,+"#$+  (($?3,$ 1!75"''$+*< #0$55$99"#$3#0,&#<7&''$#"'&+$0$="##$,&',$="(+$+*"%:##0$ 55$99"#$3#0,&#<#5"''"(,+$,"

,$'0"

#$,#":&(/&(#%('&+$,"#&( "99#0$'3*=&''&('"(+%(#$(#&(',"&'$+*<#0$5$#&#&($,&(#0$"55$"9 +"#$+(&9!59"%$+(,$%,+"#(($?3,$

6$#" &("9,+$,*$5"''$+4&#0&("5$,&+ #0,$$=(#0' ,= #0$+"#$ ,$%$&5# "%$,#& &$+%5< #0&',+$,

$#&#&(&'+&'5'$+ &(#0$"

,$'"&+#$,='       

93%:< 0$#0$,'5$":&(/A,$"'($+) $'A 0$#0$, $5,#"*9$) $'A