Vikram v. State Of Haryana And Another




   
   




  

!!

"#

"

&'& (##"$) *%%$#+"

!!

"&,$%-"%#&   !"#$% &'()*%&%( # +&

"&"%#!

.

/(/(/ % ,'

0-1$2#")$ #+","# .

/3

,4( %5+0///0 *%/ .

/ /3/( % 0-1$2#")$ "&,$%-"%#%$// &%( # +& &
,-
%&#%#  ,"# $%  +&  7""%  ) 4"-  '%-"

 ("2# $%  8   , * %5)$ 9'&+ %5$) $/-#"-//:'%-"

$%&!0 ;
 &#"

"-# $4 2"(## $%0+%&0

2#3'

4$%5 #+  44  #+"  &'7&"9'"%#  , $2""- %5& 

%5  #+"

") $  $%  #+"  7& &  $) 2$ , &"-#"-://:=%%">'

" !;?/

%9'"&# $%<&5$# &#"

"-7*2$ ,4 %%#!

"&,$%-"%# $/  %-  #+"  %1"&# 5# $%  2$ "%2"-  #+"

"$%/  $<"1"

0  < #+  #+"

%#"

1"%# $%$) "&,"2#74"&0) %44*#+", "&

1"-#&"##4" "%#%-#+"*

"&$41"-#+"

%#"

&"- &,'#"0<+ 2+ &,, "%#) $ #+"2$ , &"/ % #+"7& &$)#+"& "0#+","# & %1$

%5#+" %+"

"%#,$<"

$)#+ $'

#7*, * %5#+#2$%# $%$)#+"&", $2""- %5&<$'4-7")'# 4"

">"

&"%-%7'&"$), $2"&&$)#+"$'

#%-#+'&0#+" %9'"&# $% %-44#+"&'7&"9'"%#, $2""- %5&

") $  *7"9'&+"- %#+"

%#"

"&#$)@'&# 2"/

+ #1 -"$ -"

&-#"-::/:/-

"2#"-#+", "&#$ ,,"

7")$ "#+"
449.5 #"A'#*.5 #")$ -

&##" "%#&0&2$%#"%-"-7")$ "#+"$'

#%-#+"
449.5 #"A'#* .5 #"<&4&$-

"2#"-#$&"%- #& #/(##"<&4&$-

"2#"-#$) 4"

&##'& %#+" ##"

%,'

&'%2"#$#+"& "04"

%"-("&& $%&'-5"03'

&"%#+"

#-#"-B/:/#$#+ #/C #+#+" #&+"+&4&$ %%">"-#+",+$#$2$, "&$)&##" "%#&$)2$ ,4 %%#A %@'

"- %-"

4( %5+022'&"-A,"# 

 4$%5< #+&##" "%#&$)(


4%-(
 "&+3'

-"-$%/:// %#+"7& &$)#+"

&##" "%#&04"

%"-("&& $%&'-5"03'

+&2$%24'-"- %#+" #+# #,,"

&#+##+", "&+1""%#"

"- %#$2$ , &"1$4'%#

4* %-  #+#  #+"

"  &  %$  $#+"

 22'&"-  %  #+"  , "&"%#  2&"  %-  #+# ,"# A22'&"-+&%$#7""%-"24 "-

$24 "- ))"%-"

%#+ &2&"/ +"  2$'

#  +&  ,, "2 #"-  #+"  44"5# $%&  4"1"44"-  7*  #+"

2$ ,4 %%#'%-"

$%!
0+$<"1"

0#+"&##'& #+&7""% ) 4"-7*#+" "&,$%-"%#!(##"7*<*$))) -1 #$)*7( %5+0( 3'

/ 
#+&7""%&'7 ##"-7")$ "#+ &2$'

##+##+" %@'

"-!

2$ ,4 %%#<&-'4* "- 244*"> %"-%-#+" %1"&# 5# %55"%2* ) 4"-%,,4 2# $%7")$ "#+"-$2#$ )$ 5 %5+ &$, % $% -

%@'

"&2'&"-/+"$, % $%5 1"%7*#+"-$2#$ +&7""%,42"-$% -0 <+"

% #+&7""%$, %"-#+# &%$#,$&& 74"#$#"44#, "&"%#<+"#+"

<&%*2 -/ +$'5+#+"44"5# $%&,"

% %5#$2'& %5 %@'

"& "#+"

"0 +$<"1"

0#+" "- 24 #,

)2 "-$"&%$#2$

$7$ #"#+"& "/

+1"+"

-4"

%"-2$'%&"4)$ #+", "&0,"

'&"-#+" - %-#+" #&"%#7*4"

%"-("&& $%&'-5"03'

7 ","

'&4$)&##'#$ *, $1 $%$)#+"8 //<$'4- &+$<#+##+" 5+$'

# * "&'2+$ -"

&0& *7"%"2"&& *#$ 1""))"2##$%*$ -"

'%-"

#+ &$-"$ #$, "1"%#7'&"$)#+", $2"&& $)%*$'

#$ $#+"

&"#$&"2'

"#+""%-&$)@'&# 2"/("2# $%

&"9'44* "4"1%#)$ 2$%& -"

$%0<+ 2+, "&2

7"&#+", $2"-'

")$

2$ ,$'%- %5$)#+"$))"%2"&'%-"

#+"
%- % "%4$-"/ 3"", %5 %1 "<#+"%#'

"$)$))"%2"&44"5"-4*2$ ##"- %-#+")2##+#7$#+#+", "&+1" 274*&"##4"-#+"

- &,'#"0#+"

2$%# $%$)2

%4, $&"2'# $%<$'4-7")'# 4"">"

&"/+"$%D74"

(', " "$'

%%' 7"

$)2&"& %24'- %5
 



   



  B.S.Joshi and others 1&State of Haryana ./,
 (01,20,

 )$44$<"-7*#+ % '44"%2+2&"$)30-4.,(5/.

/,6 (7089./,:
 +1"-"4# #+#+", $,$& $% %1$41"- %#+", "&"%#2&"%-&"##4"-#+"4</ +"

")#"

0$%D74"(', " "$'

%Gian Singh ;State of Punjab and another
(01,20, )' #+"

-"4# #+#+" &&'"%-#+""

4<&"##4"-7*#+"(', " "$'

#)$ 9'&+ %5 $)#+" %State of Haryana ;Bhajan Lal:

(011
(

:$)#+"@'-5 "%# "-&&'%-"

!





 

 









 




 
 !


"


#





   

 



 

 ! !"#$! !!



$


%&'




  








 (





 "



 




 


 

  )*
+ ,


 
#

-

+

,


 


 


(




 
  
 !
(

"

 








 


 
   




 

 

 



  (


  
 -
 
"



-








 
 

(

 
 



  


 

(



.
-
 -


(-
 


 

 (










/


(









 
$




  
 




  

(
$

 (- (
  


 
















.
0







1 
 


(








 .

 

(-
 *


 
 
( 

 


  

 


 
2 


   (
 3

 (
 

  




 



 





-


  (



  
  -
  -


-
 

-
  



.
 





 
  ( 

 (-
 




(





 





(
  



 




 


 





 


  (

 -


(

 

 -



  


 





-




(

 





 .







 
  
 
 

 


# 

"


#


  

 

 
(




 










  












  -

 ! !"#$! !#!

 






 

  

 
 (



#















 
 

  
 
 





  


 






  
  


 
#

-

   







 
 



+ ,


 

-







#



 4 ,,4* %5#+"4<&"##4"-7*$%D74"(', " "$'

%,4"#+$

$)@'-5 "%#&%-#+ & 5+$'

#0 &,, "%##+#<+"%#+", "&+1"

"%#"

"- %#$2$ , &"0#+"%2$%# $%$)#+", $2""- %5&<$'4-7"

"4*%7'&"$), $2"&&$)#+"$'

#%-7*44$< %5%-22",# , *"

$)#+","# &7*9'&+ %5#+" <$'4-7"&"2'

%5#+""%-&$) @'&# 2"0 <+ 2+ &,

4*#+"$7@"2#$)#+"4"5 &4#'

""%2# %5'%-"

("2# $%8 & "&'4#0#+ #) %-&#+##+"2&" %+%-&9'

"4*)44& #+ %#+" 7 #%-,  "#"

&&"##4"-7*@'- 4, "2"-"%#&%-+"%2"0

$/-#"-//:'%-"

$%&!0;
 &#"

"-#

$4 2"  (## $%0  +%&0  

2#  3'

  %-  44  #+"  &'7&"9'"%# , $2""- %5&

") $  "9'&+"-9'#+","# $%#+"7& &$) #+"2$ , &"/

""-4"&&#$&*#+##+", "&&+44 %7$'%-7*#+"

#"

& %-2$%- $%&$)#+"2$ , &" %-#+"

&##" "%#& -"- 7")$ "#+"2$'

#7"4$</

"# $%&#%-&44$<"-/ 
&%( # +&    &'<%

  4'2 * C+"#+"

&,"

%5A "&$%"- "&A$ C+"#+"

#74" "&A$