Amrik Singh v. Financial Commissioner And Others
!
"#$ '$()*)%+
, -,
./)0 1)+23
,,,,,, $#)#)%+$/ 4$/*5* 3$
)+"+()"6 %..)**)%+$/
77$"6*8 5+9":
%#3$/* ,,,,,, $*7%+'$+#* ; < ,
1 1 /$*$+# /, 1,1, 1)'358
'=%("#$
7$#)#)%+$/, /, )/."69)# 1)+23 )>"+"8 1$+)%/
5+9":,
/, %3)# 1"7$3)?"8
'=%("#$
/, ") 1)+23 3"53"+8
'=%("#$
,
, , 1 8
,
, $#)#)%+$/
./)0 1)+23 3"* &)6$'
)+*#"+# ()=)6 >/)# 5+'$/
/#)(6$* - %+*#)#5#)%+ +')"8 *$$0)+2 *$##)+2 "*)'$ %/'$/ '"#$'
@, @,
++$A5/$ 8 7"**$'
)*#/)(# %66$(#%/8
./)#*"/
8 >3$/$:?
$*3".
1)+23 >"* "77%)+#$'
=)66"2$ 3"+'$8 $3*)6 )*#/)(#
./)#*"/,
,
&5/#3$/ 7/"?$/ 3"* :$$+ ."'$ *$##)+2 "*)'$ %/'$/ '"#$'
, ,
++$A5/$ 8 7"**$'
%..)**)%+$/8
"6"+'3"/ )=)*)%+8
"6"+'3"/ %/'$/ '"#$'
, ,
++$A5/$ 8 7"**$'
)+"+()"6 %..)**)%+$/
+)."6 5*:"+'/?8 5+9":8 >3$/$:?
"77$"6 >$66 /$=)*)%+ &)6$'
"2")+*# %66$(#%/;* %/'$/ '"#$'
@, @,
++$A5/$ 8 >$/$ ')*.)**$'8 /$*7$(#)=$6?,
, /)$&6?8 57%+ '$.)*$ 7/$=)%5* =)66"2$ 3"+'$8 +".$6?8 "/+".
1)+23B 7/%($$')+2* >$/$ )+)#)"#$'
&)66)+2 ="("+# 7%*# <".:"/'"/,
+ 75/*5"+($ 7/%(6"."#)%+ )**5$'
&)66)+2 *")'
="("+# 7%*#8 >$66 "+%#3$/ ("+')'"#$ "776)$'
*")'
7%*# <".:"/'"/,
3$ 15:
)=)*)%+"6 "2)*#/"#$8
./)#*"/8 /$(%..$+'$'
("+')'"#5/$
$*3".
1)+23 "77%)+#.$+# "&%/$*")'
7%*# &%/>"/'$'
("*$ &)6$ )*#/)(# %66$(#%/8
./)#*"/, , # #/"+*7)/$* )*#/)(# %66$(#%/8
./)#*"/8 =)'$ )#* %/'$/ '"#$'
, ,
8 "77%)+#$'
<".:"/'"/8 3%>$=$/8 *")'
"77%)+#.$+# >"* (3"66$+2$'
:$&%/$ %..)**)%+$/8
"6"+'3"/ )=)*)%+8
"6"+'3"/8 >3% =)'$ )#* %/'$/ '"#$'
-, , 8 /$."+'$'
("*$ %66$(#%/8
./)#*"/8 "&/$*3 '$()*)%+,
, 7%+ /$."+'8 %66$(#%/8
./)#*"/8 =)'$ )#* %/'$/ '"#$'
@, @,
++$A5/$ 8 "77%)+#$'
=)66"2$ 3"+'$8 $3*)6 )*#/)(#
./)#*"/8 %:*$/=)+2 5+'$/
!
" #
$
%
& #
$
'
'
(
!
'
$
&
)
#
*
!
&
" #
& !
)
#
+ #
*
* , -
! &
* .
#
#
#
* & # - '
/ !
' &
0 , 3$ "&%/$*")'
%/'$/ '"#$'
@, @,
++$A5/$ >"* (3"66$+2$'
:$&%/$ %..)**)%+$/8
"6"+'3"/ )=)*)%+8
"6"+'3"/8 3%>$=$/8 *".$ >"* ')*.)**$'8 =)'$ %/'$/ '"#$'
, ,
++$A5/$ , , 1#)66 "22/)$=$'8 7/$&$//$'
/$=)*)%+
:$&%/$
)+"+()"6 %..)**)%+$/
+)."6 5*:"+'/? 5+9":8 >3)(3 >"* "6*% ')*.)**$'8 =)'$ %/'$/
'"#$'
, ,
++$A5/$ %:*$/=)+2 5+'$/ %
' '
'
& - 2
)
#
3 '
-
.
" #
4
" #
5 & 2
2 1
$ "
, # .
8 $3)
9 6 9
2!
' !
'
:
!
2
!
' ;
!
2 <
2
0 . '
!
'
0 , + "&%/$.$+#)%+$'
()/(5.*#"+($*8 3"* &)6$'
)+*#"+# ()=)6 >/)# :$&%/$ #3)* %5/#8 /$6)$& *8 +%#)($'
":%=$,
, <$"/+$'
(%5+*$6 *5:.)#* (%+($/+$'
%66$(#%/ >$66 "77$66"#$ /$=)*)%+"6 "5#3%/)#)$* 3"=$ $//$'
"77%)+#)+2 )2+%/)+2 .$/)#* 7$#)#)%+$/,
# *5:.)##$'
*%+ '$($"*$'
"+'8 #3$/$&%/$8 3$ 3"'
3$/$')#"/?
(6").,
# &5/#3$/ *5:.)##$'
*5&&)()$+#6?
$'5("#$'
57#% #3 *#"+'"/'
3$ %>+* "/%5+'
0"+"6 6"+'
:$)+2 *%+
'$($"*$'
<".:"/'"/8 3$ 3"'
2")+$'
0+%>6$'2$ $A7$/)$+($ >%/0 <".:"/'"/,
# +$A# *5:.)##$'
/$=$+5$ "5#3%/)#)$* :$6%> 3"=$ >/%+26?
+%+*5)#$'
%+ 2/%5+'
3$ 3"'
$+(/%"(3$'
57%+ 2/".
7"+(3"?"# 6"+'8 >3$/$"* 3$ 3"'
+$=$/ /$.")+$'
7%**$**)%+ "+?
2/".
7"+(3"?"#
7/%7$/#?,
((%/')+26?8 )# *5:.)##$'
.%/$ .$/)#%/)%5* #3"+ /$C5)/$'
:$ "77%)+#$'
<".:"/'"/,
, )#3 "&%/$*")'
*5:.)**)%+*8 (%5+*$6 7/"?$'
).752+$'
%/'$/* :$ *$# "*)'$ :$ "77%)+#$'
=)66"2$ 3"+'$8 $3*)6 )*#/)(#
./)#*"/,
, $/ (%+#/"8 (%5+*$6 "77$"/)+2
3"* %77%*$'
*5:.)**)%+* ."'$ %+ :$3"6& *5:.)##)+2 /$=$+5$ "5#3%/)#)$* :$6%> 3"=$ (%+*)'$/$'
/$6$="+# .$/)#* '$.$/)#* ("+')'"#$* 3"* /)23#6?
"77%)+#$'
<".:"/'"/,
# *5:.)##$'
(3%)($ (%+($/+$'
%66$(#%/ ."##$/ :$ #"0$+ &)+"6 5+6$** #3$/$ 7"#$+# )66$2"6)#?
%/ 7$/=$/*)#?,
# (%+#$+'$'
.%/$ .$/)#%/)%5* #3"+ #3$/$ +% *(%7$ "+?
)+#$/&$/$+($ ).752+$'
%/'$/*,
((%/')+26?8 7/"?$/ ')*.)**"6 )+*#"+# ()=)6 >/)# 3"* :$$+ ."'$,
, 3"=$ 3$"/'
(%5+*$6 7"/#)$* 3"=$ "6*% 7$/5*$'
7"7$/ :%%0 >)#3 #3$)/ ":6$ "**)*#"+($,
-, 3$ .$/)#* '$.$/)#* ("+')'"#$* ("+ :$ *5.."/)D$'
&%66%>)+2 #":56"/ (3"/#
1/, "/#)(56"/* $#)#)%+$/
$*7%+'$+#
./)0 1)+23
$*3".
1)+23 ,
2$ @
?$"/*
?$"/* , '5("#)%+"6 E5"6)&)("#)%+ #3
#3
, <"+'
%6')+2 0"+"6 0"+"6 , $(%..$+'$'
1, ,,
./)#*"/
-,
:"/$ 7$/5*"6 ":%=$ (%.7"/"#)=$ (3"/# ("+')'"#$* >%56'
*3%> ?%5+2$/ "2$8 3$ 3%6'* .%/$ 6"+'8 3$ .%/$ $'5("#$'
#3"+ $=$+ 6%>$/ /$=$+5$ %&&)($/
1 8
./)#*"/ 3"'
/$(%..$+'$'
3)* +".$ "77%)+#.$+# <".:"/'"/,
=)'$+#6?8 3"* "+ $'2$ %=$/ 7$#)#)%+$/,
-,
* /$2"/'* (%+#$+#)%+ (%5+*$6 *3%56'
:$ "77%)+#$'
:$)+2 *%+ '$($"*$'
<".:"/'"/8 )# %:*$/=$'
("*$8 *5(3 76$"
:$ "(($7#$'
#3$+ *".$ *3"66 ".%5+# 2)=)+2 $&&$(# 3$/$')#"/?
(6").8 >3)(3 3"* "6/$"'?
:$$+ 3$6'
:$ 56#/"
=)/$* %+*#)#5#)%+ )=)*)%+ $+(3 #3)* %5/# ("*$
8 - <
-8 >3$/$)+ )# >"* 3$6'
5+'$/ = 1 '
) % 6
'
.
3 2 68
68
=%
%=!
' &
' $ ;
61
8 =
>!
%= &
&
'
) %
"
6 8 ) 5
'
.
! '
!
' 1
'
'
!
6
8
-
) 5
) %
&
' 1 ?
1
* =
'
( * =@ 5
'
'
( *
!
) 56
'"
3 &
' '
1
A
'
;
'
' A &
' '
# * #
! - # .
!
A "
$
! ) 56
8
) 56
8 "
&
! !
@
'
'
=! %
2 1
)
# 2
B -
)
) ' # $
! 1) # 2 %=!
& #
'
" 2
- ! 1) 5 # 2 @@= # * #
- '
+
/ .
2
)
" '
*
' # #
'
)
! 1) % / 5@!
&
'
.
'
A
% < '
'! 6
3
)' ) 5 '
&
* =
'
( * =@ 5! * 7
'
( *
* =
'
( *
A
# ' "
0 -, # "6*% %:*$/=$'
"# 7/$*$+#6?8 .%/$ #3"+ @
?$"/* "2$, %+;:6$ 157/$.$ %5/# ("*$
)=)6 - -8 3$6'
."##$/ "77%)+#.$+# <".:"/'"/8 "2$ /$6$="+# &"(#%/, %/$%=$/8 )# >$66 $*#":6)*3$'
(3%)($ %66$(#%/ +%# :$ 6)23#6?
)+#$/&$/$'
>)#3 $=$+ )& #>% =)$>* "/$ 7%**):6$,
+ #3)* /$2"/'8
/$&$/$+($ ("+ :$ ."'$ 95'2.$+# /$+'$/$'
)=)*)%+ $+(3 #3)* %5/# ("*$
!
"## $%&
)=)6 -,
, F$$7)+2 =)$> #%#"6)#?
&"(#* ()/(5.*#"+($*8 '% +%# &)+'
"+?
)66$2"6)#?
%/ 7$/=$/*)#?
).752+$'
%/'$/*,
$*56#"+#6?8 )+*#"+# ()=)6 >/)# &")6* *".$ "((%/')+26?
')*.)**$',
, $+')+2 "776)("#)%+
*8 )& "+?8 *3"66 "6*% *#"+'
(6%*$',
1
, -,
*90* 3$#3$/ *7$"0)+2/$"*%+$'
!$*
% 3$#3$/ /$7%/#":6$ !$*
%