Prabhu Kumar Rawat And Others v. National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd. And Others

 ! " 
#$%#&'(') '$*'' '
') "'$ 




 ) )+ +,- ./0/1$2

++

3 /

+4 54+2
6+7

$ 6

$', 8(7!$&#9
!' 709 !'$'7  , )924+:9';:2+ "/;$:';: 6++

 


 
+4:9';2+  9+ 4+"54:';: 6++

+


<

 '+5=+9+>
:';:

6++ +


-  / :94++"4 +2+ 7? 9+4:'; 9/;'>>24:'; +64+==:; ';5';:';:

 6 

 


        

  !  "

#$ % %$ &   



" " '(



$ "")   "* + "$  $  ", )-"" 

$.    "  

 "  " $ " * "   $ " " "

(

"   "&  $&"





/ 

 $  $ 0  " $"

"1( +- 2 "$ &     "$"$ " "  $"

 0 "&   & ""    $    

  "  &   ),&  3 

       '

  $      

.  $  $ / "+ 0 "&   -4 +-          "



  $     &  

"5 "$    "

  

            " $" "  " "   $

&" & "4 /"   ""

 $$ 

  6 % %  % % % '" " 

1(
 



  

    

 



     !



 

"



#
$%%$&$%%%  '      (  

  '  

      

 "

   

 

 



     !

 

"



#
$%%$&$%%%  )%%

"

  ' ** *  %
%
)%% + "

 ,  -   * * **  " )%%

"

 

  '  ) -  (

 "(

   %
%
)%% 

@

'  

 



"

 
..

"



   "

 

  '    '  (  

"

  

"

  %
%
)%% + "(  $

- /

 / 012)%
% 3%)

)%
%      '  

$ ,      '     * "     



"

 
..

"

    



 %
%

..  $

))%%2(   .



- /

 / 0)))%%2 3%.%#)%%2       '  

1  " *  ' 

     %
%

.!.

     4+

"

(  '

 -4+ "

,  "

  

   

  

   - /

 / 03)$.% 3
%%
..% /

 / 03
).$ 3
.%#
..$6 /"" " "$ "

"&

 &"

 

"$ 



" ""$ " "(  (7""

8  
 / " "   " &3  9

"5  " 



 " $ "8 "  ." +:8.,- " 5 "$



$ &3 9

"5 ")  "



+    ,),-  "        &     $"      % 

##; $ $  " )  

9 "  3 

 



   "

%  3 

 



 " %<%!

%     
   !  

"   #$%%&'()(* " 

1( 78  

 

      

  

    *    "

 

      

    

 9 :  +*  ;  "      *   ' 




.!2 * 

        

 "

'     "

*  < "

(
.!.(    :  *

)  0'(
.!! 8( *(  

*3



; 

"

    *      :  * '      " *  ' 

  *         

  

  4+ ; * ' ="



'    " * '"

  * '"



'   

  ' 

     * 



;  " 

     < "

(
.!.( * '   '"



"   *   "

'  '"



      ; 

   * -4+

 *     '     *       

 

  



;

"



   "  

*      '"

'    '     ( * >

  "

   *    



   

    " ;  " *( *(      ?"

   *    -4+



 

"

   "

'



;       :  * '    *



   

* ;   '"

 "

*      : 3

-

; '    *  


:

"  



.!2 

2

 +

 )

@   

2
.!$ 
2$

-  :

$

,    

$
.!# 
2$

-  :

1

+ 

  '



.!.@


.!2

 

2

 



4' $
(
.!!

   + * '

  

     

"

 

"

<

 





 

# 9 :  +* 

 

" 

9:+

   



*

   

A B / 0/
$ !$

  ' 



A 8


!$(


)
.!!;   9:+

'?    

  ' *

:
)#%(
%%%(2!%($1%

'"

A

   

  $
%

 4A'"(

  



 

+ A
  A)(   

   :  

   


#

 "

2





@

    '





)

 '"

   

 : 

 ,A



C ;  



!

/ +*   



; = 

'    '

= 

  

 '"

   

     

,   ' 

 


)
$



 "



 : 

---

 ---

 : 



;     

"( 4+    *  ( * ' ?'    

"  

   6 /     "      "  "         " 6  "$ % %

# "  "

6   " $" " ""  "" "" & "$'

 &  $"

$ = 

 /   

$ % %

"$ "      "         

 "  "     "  



" &

  ""& " $  '" "

1(

1 &+  
 )

&++>  
 ) +>+ "&  > ?"" &"" 2'

  %<%

# = "7""

+- . = "

 "

% 

# = "7""

+/;- .5 >

" " &"" 2'

  %!

# = "7""

+- )"" "

&"" 2'

  %

# = "7""

+- 3"> &"" 2'

 

%

# = "7""

+- ?"

 "

> "= "

&"" 2'

  @

# = "7""

+- ?""= "

&"" 2'

 

!%

# = "7""

+- 3"

  > A"

" &"" 2'

 

%%<

# = "7""

+- 3""8"&" &"" 2'

 

<%<

# = "7""

+- ."7" &"" 2'

 

%

# = "7""

+- )"3  &"" 2'

 

!%

# = "7""

+- 3"

> &"" 2'

  !%

# = "7""

+-

"53" " &"" 2'

  %@%#

# = "7""

+- "". "

&"" 2'

 

%

# = "7""

+- B" > 3"

&"" 2'

  %%<

# = " 7""

+2 "- B 58  &"" 2'

  %!

# = "7""

+- )"
" " &"" 2'

 

<%@

# = "7""

+- ?""C"" &"" 2'

 

%!

# = "7""

+- B" > 3" &"" 2'

 

%

# = "7""

+- 7" > 3  &"" 2'

  %<%<

# = "7""

+- ?" > " &"" %<%

# = "7""

+-

"

" 2'

  3"

7" &"" 2'

 

<%<

# = "7""

+- 3" > " " &"" 2'

  %!%!

# = "7""

+- " 3"5 3" &"" 2'

 

!%!

# = "7""

+- *"  > ;" &"" 2'

  %#%<

# = "7""

+- 7  ="  =5 &"" 2'

 

%

# = " 7""

+2 "- ?"

.

"" &"" 2'

  %!

# = "7""

+- 3""B "  "

% %

#  = "7""

 ?"

C" &"" 2'

 

#% 

# = "7""

+- 3"


""

&"" 2'

  !%<

# = "7""

+- ) 3""""""

&"" 2'

  #% 

# = "7""

+- ."7"  &"" 2'

  %! %

# = "7""

+- .>= &"" 2'

  %@ %

# = "7""

+- .>""5 &"" 2'

  !

# = "7""

+- .5> &"" 2'

  %@ %

# = "7""

+- .D=

" &"" 2'

  %@ %

# = " 7""

+2 "-

3 &  &"" 2'

  % %

# = "7""

+- 8>C" &"" 2'

  %! %

# = "7""

+- ) " 3 5" &"" 2'

  %@ %

# 2'

  8  7>= " &"" 2'

  %!

# = "7""

+- >C" &"" 2'

  %! %

# = "7""

+- ?"


"&"

&"" 2'

  %! %

# = "7""

+-

-

?"

C " &"" 2'

  % %

# = "7""

+- ?>.

"" &"" 2'

  #

# = "7""

+- ?3" " &"" 2'

  !

# = "7""

+- """ &"" 2'

  %! %

# = "7""

+- 37 5 

&"" 2'

 

# = "7""

+- B= "

&"" 2'

  %@ %

# = "7""

+- B 5?"" 3"""

&"" 2'

  %! %

# = "7""

+- .> "8" &"" 2'

  % %<

# = "7""

+- ;   " " 

("

"( /  $    E$$  E

   %6 "  %%!

 



 "  "  



"    3" $"    & 

% %

# <%%@

%  & " )3" " " "" " & $;      

 "= 

"" "  " "$ % %

# ; "$ 

" $$ 

 "

%!

<"

 ""$ 7$  

("



"

" $"6"" "   0  / " " ." +$,/8.,-"  $$ $ % %

#

  



"   "$ % %

#  7$   "   & 



#

# "&""2'

   " &

   "

"  $ "

   "

" 

1( 7



;

"

        9 * "

  '   '"



- 

 



"( *   -   

  ( " * '

  

"

       '

"



  

  

" ?  ( *   6

/"   " )  "



+)- &   % 

##  " " 

""5  ""$  "= 

&

)$"



"   "$ % %

#  / "  8 "   ."  +/8.-  "    7"  $          

$ % %  $    

$

<+ )E$$ ."" "(  (78 )- 8 )  E #%!

< )3" "  $

    $$   & 

  8.  "  /8. ; "$  # %

<  " "

   )  """" 8." ""& " & $

%!

<E%#%

 )   "

"   )       "  ""    8.  "      "$       )   )   " 

"$ " '  "

 $"" "& "& &   &  $"

$  3  )"$$  $$ 3"     $ " )   )   $) """



  #%!$

<+/


" 9$/ ""  -" .""&"

)  . = "

9$/ ""  



E%

# ) " "



 "

$ "   " $ /8.  / " " ." " .      " " " "

"&    

$   $ &

/ "&   " 

$ /8." " "& ;    $ /8."   $$ $ % %

/   /8." """  

 "$     " "

F $$  $ % %

 ; "$  %  %%%  "" 

$$ $ % %

  

 ; "

"

 "& " ;  $ & $ 8 )  "

  &    $  (      % %%#   .

        "$ "$  & $ 8  )  3 "  $ "  )         E  @

 %%#    "       $$   $

% %  %%" 

 /$"" ""  "$   8 )    

  $

)3 .

     $"" 

"; $ ""&

  &   ""& " $   '" " 

1( + $,%%-.&.& 1 &++ 
 ) 

=++>  6 +>

"""3 8"$ "="

// % 

#< 7""

+28- =""

8"$ "="

// %%

#< 7""

+28- >""3 8"$ "="

// !%<

#< 7""

+28-



3"

C= "

8"$ "="

// %

#< 7""

+28-
" "

""

8" 8"$ "="

// %%

# 7""

+287"5"3 8"$ "="

//

%

#< 7""

+283
"" 8"$ "="

//

@

#< 7""

+28- ?"5   > = "

8"$ "="

//

%

#< 7""

+28- ." > 3" "

8"$ "="

// !%

# 7""

+28- >7""" 8"$ "="

//

%

#    7""

+288"&3 8"$ "="

// <%

#    7""

+283>3 "

8"$ "="

//

%

#%    7""

+28-?



*"3 8"$ "="

//

%<

#<    7""

+28-?



+ $,,.,.&.& 1 ) 

&++>  +  
&++ 6 

$+1 /   ) +>+ 3""3

#% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +7 ""- < %% % < = " 7""

+7 ""- B > 7" %% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <  %

2'

  8  )"> " % %

#!

&"" 2'

  +- < %  % 2'

  8  3"

 *" >"

%

# =  < %  % < 2'

  8  ?"">

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- < %# % G $ = " 7""

)"

3  

!%!

#@  . "6 &"" 2'

  +- < %  %  $= " 7""

"5" "

#% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +7 ""- <%%@ % = " 7""

+7 ""- ;""3"

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%% % < = " 7""

+- C" 3" % %

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%%@ % < = " 7""

+- B

3" "

# 2

+- < % %

= " 7""

+- . >  5 

<%!

#!

&"" 2'

  +- < %! % < = " 7""

+- .  > C" % 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%%@ % = " 7""

+- ""

3"'

" % 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- < % % < = " 7""

+- ?"

 3"

"

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- #%  % < = " 7""

+- >""3""

#

&"" 2'

  +- < % %  = " 7""

+-
7" !

#

&"" 2'

  +- <%%@ %  = " 7""

+- ?"

3" %#%<

% &"" 2'

  +7 ""- <%% % @ = " 7""

+7 ""- + $,,./.&.& 012  # 34 012'

1 ) 

=++>  
&+  
 ) 

$+1 ) +>+ 

$+1 ?" > C""

<

# &"" 2'

  +- <%%  % % 2'

  8 

@

. > % %!

#

&"" 2'

  +- < %< %

2'

  8  .

 > .

""

%

# &"" 2'

  +- <%%@ %

2'

  8  3  > "8 & 

%

# &"" 2'

  +- < %! %

2'

  8  ? "5C"

< %

# &"" 2'

  +2 - <%

 %

2'

  8  .  > 3"

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- < %! %

 $= " 7""

?"7"

#% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +7 - < %# %

 $= " 7""

.

"& 3""

# 2

+7 ""- < %# % % = " 7""

+7 - """

>
" %@%!

#  "

< %  % % = " 7""

+/;- ?"5 = "

#  "

< % % # = " 7""

+/;- ?"

?""

<

# 2

+- <%% % % = " 7""

+- A

>"

%

# 2

+- <%%@ % % = " 7""

+- ""> % 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%%@ % % = " 7""

+- B" > "

" % 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- < % % % = " 7""

+- 3 = "

%!%!

# 2

+- <%%@ % #  $ 2

+- ?

 "

"  = " 7""

+-

 "  " 7" "

< %

# &"" 2'

  +- < % % % = " 7""

+- 3>"



# 2

+- < % %

= " 7""

+- .   > "

"

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <  %

= " 7""

+- 3""

""

% %@

## =   <%

 %

= " 7""

+=  - ?"5  " "

3" "

% %

# =   < % %

= " 7""

+=  - C"" " "

"

# &"" 2'

  +2 - < %< % % 8  +;

"- 8 " ""

% %!

#

&"" 2'

  +- < % % # 2'

  8  ?"5 

< %

# &"" 2'

  +2 - < %! % % 2'

  8 

"

>

< %

# &"" 2'

  +- <%%  %

2'

  8  B"  > ?""

%

# &"" 2'

  +- < % % # 2'

  8  "

 > "C"

@ %

# &"" 2'

  +7 - <  % # 2'

  8  7"> " @

# 2

+- <%

 %

 $= " 7""

8  " "

;" % %

#!

=   #%  %

 $= " 7""

3  "

> .

"" <%

# 2

+- <  %

= " 7""

+- 7  "" %# %

# =  <%%  % #  $ += -

 "

"  = "

<

7""

+= - 3""

" 3 >  "

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%%@ % % = " 7""

+-
"& *" = "

@%

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%%@ %

= " 7""

+- .  > ""

#!

2

+28- < %< % % = " 7""

+/;-
  7" = "

%@%@

#@  . " <%%@ %

= " 7""

+H/ - 0125 +"$6

" 3 &"

"" ""

""

#% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +2 "- < %! %

2'

  8  3    " "

"

%

# &"" 2'

  +- < % %

2'

  8  &" ""

"

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +2 "- < %  %

2'

  8  " " 
" 3

%

# &"" 2'

  +7 ""- < %  %

2'

  8  .5>

#% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +7 ""- < % % %  $= " 7""

?" %% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%% %

= " 7""

+- >" 9

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%

 % % = " 7""

+- &" ""

" @%<

#!

&"" 2'

  +2 "- < %  %

= " 7""

+2 "- 7"" .""

"

""&"" @%<

#!

&"" 2'

  +2 "- < %! %

= " 7""

+2 "-

A

?"

 ?"

A"

" %%

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%%@ %

= " 7""

+- 3""&3

% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- < % %

= " 7""

+- ?"5 = % %

#!

&"" 2'

  +- < %# %

= " 7""

+- 3""

>" " %% 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- #%  %

= " 7""

+- C

"> 3 % 

#!

&"" 2'

  +- <%

 % % = " 7""

+- B"> #

# &"" 2'

  +H" - <  % % 2'

  8 +/.- /"& $  "$$ " 

 "   " " $

        " & 

  ""

 $?

 @ < 6( " $"  " ""

   "& $   " $ ' "

 $  

" &   

? @ %%%%%6( $?<@<%%%%%6(" "

  " "



    "  $ " " "$  " % #( %

/"$  &

  "

   $"  

"5   "

< "  &  " $"

& $ " )   E  %#%

    )      $  8      

 $ 

<  $"&  " ' "

 "  " $ 



"& "& &  $   $"   /"$  &

  " " ' "



 &  $ #%





?!!#  ; #%



" &

 

"

 "

 !" " @ @ ("



 /"$  &

  "        

 $ % % "      "



" ""& 

<!"!"  /"" &

&   $  "  $ &



"

$$

/8." "

  & )  $) """



 "

@%<

 #%!$

< ; )  $ 3" $ C"

I>" "    

 

; "&

  "   "     $"

;
"  "   $ " " "  "& ""    " &5 ;  "         "  &  "   " &

  ""   "

  "&  $" $ "  

 

"

"  ""& ; $    "

 "5 & 

"5 ""& " "

& " &" & ""  "& $$  ""

 ;  $     &   "  

    % % %  "  &  "

       

" & ),& 3 

  78! 9:"#.&$/')(()  

"  "& "

$



 ;  "         

-

  !$ % %  

 "& "

"" "

$     " " "

  "  

$ 

)    &  "    & "

  $ 

"  9:"#') $     " 

 

"

 0 "& " "    "  &  "    "    "

         '   "

 " "    " "$"     "   "             

( "

" "

 &  "  

" &  

%!

<"   "$ "  

 " "

  

    $  " &       

 "



/"$  &

  " " $     "& "  "

 &   "$   

" $ "&

"" &     " &

   ) $   &  "

"$ "

"    "  &

  "

      &(    #%! % %  "   

        ;      "  $"    $"  " 

) $  

"  "&

"     " " &

  " $ " &   .$ "   "   $ "  , ""J "

/ 

 $  "

$ "

  $ " "& 

 $ "1( +- ;     $  "

  $$  $

" "

" F +- ;  $ "" & $$ 

  " " $ " +- / $ ""  

" &  ),& 3 

  9:"#' "

 "&  "$  ""

$"

.

 $" "&  "        " "   """  8. 

  



" &  /$"  "

<"  

$   3 

   "



 " 6   "$   % %

#

 $ /8." ;  "$   "

"

&$ "    "  

  ; 8 )   %#%

   )  " "

 $8."    ""      "

 "& "& &  / " $ "$ " & ""  & "

;   

" $   "3$   "

   &  " """ 

"  %%"" " & " "; "

"&

$"J 

%< %

;  "$  ""  ( " "  $"/   "  "  $"$"

 ""  7" %

3$     "$ "   "



    $  "&      "

" "  " " "

     $

 " H   "& "

 $ "" "

  "5   &   )  

 "

     &  "    



 " "

  &   "

 ; "

"  & "   "   H   "" "

  $      5      &3 9

"5   ;  

 " ""5

 )  

""  " "

" &3 9

"5 3$  

 "





"  ; " " &       $       

   7        ""   "  "$

 "$   " )       $



("   "

 $ '  " )  
$ 

" 

"" 

 

"

.       

 "     "

"5  $ "  " $"   / "&   "

 ""  " & $""5 

%< %

 ; "$  & 

 "

% % %         ($'"  $    "     $  &

  " " " """$'

3$     "

<      & $ 8.

"  $  " " 

   

$  "   ""8." 3  

 " &

    $  & "

 / & 

   "  " $ "$"/8.

"  7   ($'"$ "" "

  &  #%! % %  

$



; "$  ""  "  !%@ % % ;     &  "

 $  ""    "

  . % % ;    " " " " &

  "  "  3$     " $"     "   /&   "   $" "   " "$ '&  " $  F $$  "  &"   / "&  $  " "

""    $ "" 

;  $" "  "&   ""   $   "$""  " $ " ?"  0  & " "

 $""

 "/   "  $" "  "     " "&  "" "5 $ " 3$     " &

  " &  * "          " &

 " )  
$ 

 " $""  " $  " & "" $  $ / $"$   "    "   "  

"    $  "     $  #   " " ""$  3 

 "



"   "& " " "  

/ "8 " ." " )  
  '     "&   "    "

  $  "   

        ;   '   0   "   "

$ "        " $ 

 " & 3 

  9:"#'  "&

"

$



" ""$ " ""

$

" "$ 

$   " " "

  / "&   " 

" & 3 

  9:"#'" '

 $  

.  $      $  / "         0 "&     ; $  

 "   "& "  

'"

 $". "

  " $  9:"#' " $  "*"


$ 3 

    " " " & $ *"


" " 

" 

'

 $  

.    $  $/ ""

 $ " &  

?

" 

"& "

 

$ *"


  78 "!

9:" "#.&$)'---( 3$   

 "   9:"#'  " $"$   " F" "  "

  &  "    

" &  ;   "$ "   "

 

    $  "    "  "



 " %#%

3$  "

  " "

 "

      " "

  &  7    " "   $" & $ $ 

"  9:"#'

@

" "       ""

"    "  #  $    

    ),& 3 

 " "    "

"



" &     "  "  3$  "  "&    "  "



 ?

   " "&

" " &"""

 " $ $ "";

" & "

   "

;   " $"  0  $"   
 '  "&" 

$  "          "  "   '/>/ :  ' 709 !'$'7   &#)"!

 6?+>B  ,*!9B 6.4 ,*!9B