High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12171/2014allowed

Anmol Sharma v. Guru Ravidas Ayurved University Punjab & ORS

2015-07-22Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath12 pages

! "

! "

# $%&

'

( ) ) ! "

# *

! "

#

!"# $ %&'% , -- - ! "

# & .

.

&/$+ 0 1! (

# ' ! - 2 " &/$*3$+ 0

! !

4 0 " $&

- ! "

' ! 0! ! 5 1! !!

1 # 1 !!

6" 7#89:

, ! "4 6" 7 49: 7 !

9 $$ $& &/$*

" - ! !

$&

- ! 0"

' !

0!! 5 4 1! !!

!" #8 ; $&

! " ( " ! <! 6" 7(<9: ( " 4 # $ ! " ) 0 < , = <,3&/$*> " ( ! " !

! - 6" 7( 9: ( ! "

!

! - 6" 7(

9:! ,

-0 !

" <, 1 "! $& ?

&/$$ 0 " ) 0 "

! <!

! 1! 344 " ! 0

# $

3

!

" # # $ %

&

'

&

'

( )*

+

!

&

'

"

", -

'

. /

'

"

&

!

0

/

'

!

#

"

#

$

! 1

3

'

/

. *

)$

(

(

'

" # $ "

6 6 3

-

)

-

'

" #

$#

'

-

&

'

+

-

)

'

# $

6 3

(

" #

$

6

'

*

'

7

! "

$+/+ '

. *

#

$+/+

'

" "

" 6 -#

$ $ # 8

&

'

" " 6 -#

$ 3

'

"#

&

/

'

. *

)$

# 9 # $

6 +7 !

1 - 7 !

9" $/@&

"

0 ! "

"

- <,3&/$* " (

! &/$*3$+

1 ! " ! -&?

$$ &/$* # ' !

! - 2 , ! 0 .

.

&/$+

# & ! !

" - A

-4 # !;

B $/@&"

!- 0

!- "!"( "! ! 4 4 0 "! $* * $CC? 0

"

!

= "<! > "4 !

! " ( " " <! D "! "

- ; "! 1!

!-E B ; 0 4 1 0

!-E " " !

"

!- " ! "

- ; "! 0

;

0 4 " 0 ( 0 A "

! &?

$ &/$*

! # <!

!%4 ! "

'-" 1 1 "

- F

!- 0 ! " 4 # 1

$/@& - ; "! " 4 ( -0 " - ! " 4 0 .

.

&/$+ - 0

! 1 " 7 !

9 0 4 $$ $& &/$*

# $ & ! 0 "-

"

- " 0' 04

!" " -! 1!

!

3

"

&

, -

&

!+ :

1+

+ "

9 .* "

#

"

" # .*

'

&

#

&

"

"

, -

&

!+ :

1+

*

.*

&

# #

&

. *

+ .*

&

"

#

+ :

"

.

&

.*+ .*

&

"

.

+ /

&

) )

" + /

&

$ :

.

!

&

'

# 9

"

' " 6 . *

$ :

.*

&

/ ;

'

"

.*

&

" + + $ < # 4= % =

#

0 / : # .

$

"

.

$

( <

# /"(

# >

.

$

#

!

<

/

/

'

< +

" !

&

.* ' ???

!

0 / :

"

/).

/

"

/ + ??? 0 / :

"

/ */

"

/

:

45 /' 5

*/,

@ / /

+ !+ " /

+ 1+ 2

/

+

A+ 2 "

/

+ B+ /

/

+ C+

/

+ .*

0 / :

<:)

& ): :

" 9

&

"

# /

"

+7 , - 0

! "

# $ & 7 !

9 ! 0

! " -

" ! " " - " !

-0

;

" 4 4 0 !

!;

$&

"

! !

"

!

!- # + "

1!

4 !! 7 ! " <! 9

- ! 1! 1 " ! " $&

" ! ! ! "1- ! "<!

;

0 !!

0 "<! - !

;

0 !!

0 " - !!

- ! #8 " F

- !!

- ! 4"

' !

0! ! 5 !!

1 #8

* !

! 5 !!

#8

"

7 !

9 0

04 , " "" $* $$ &/$+--- 0 1 !

$&

- ! "

! 0

- 0 "" " 0

# + --

?*? 4 1

0 " 4 !-

# $ 4

!

0 4 $CCG 1

3 .* EEF G

.*

&

3 '

"

/ #

3 + *

& # .* " #

'

'

# '

"

/ 3 + "

&

.*3 :

&

"

5 <

"+ ++

A+

+!E .* +7 ,

" !

$CCC 4 !

!-E " ! !

+ !

"1 0 4 " !! - ! " ! -! "1 3 .*

EEE G

)

'

3 +

+

!

. & 3 +

+

/ :

.

+

9)

$

3

+ &

#

!

/ )

! 0 )/ / /

#

.*

+7 4 "

! # => H =>

! 0 ! " ! "" "

-0 ! 0 =>

! 0 !!

B ""

" F !!

- ! !"! ! "" ! - ! , ! 1 !

!

'

"

-0 =

( "!" ! 4 ( !

> 1

F

!! 0 - 0

- "

0 ! " ! - ! , #8 0 " <! ""

!!

1

" 0

!

4 !

!

#8B !

!!

! F 0 0 !!

!1 1

4

1 $ &/$**$ * &/$+ 4 &/// !

! 1 0 -

"

"

- ! ! "" "

- 0 I " &/// !

$&* !

1

! 1 @& - ; "! 1 -4 !"1-"

- " ! " 0 $&& ! GG

!

1

! 1 0 ! -! "

! 4 "1- ! " ! <! # + ! ! - " ! <

# " !B0 !

4

! " 0

! , ! 1

# $ )" ! !

- " - !;

$/@& ; "! "

!- 0 4 ! -!

!

0 0 #8 1! 0

" ; $&

! !

" (<04 # $ & 0) ! " - 0

0 0 1 - " ! " "I - -

0 " 1

- "$&

1 " !

"4 - ! "

- "@& ; "! 1!$&

-! "

!!

! "

!- 04 $&

-! 1 0 !!

! !B4 ! ! "1 ! " <! 4 " - ! 1 0 ! ! " 1 0 !!

0 " <! I 0 F

- !!

- - ! 1!

"1 3

@ / /

+ !+ " /

+ 1+ 2

/

+ A+ 2 "

/

+ B+ /

/

+ C+

/

+ 4 1 4 !!

- ! =<>B ! ; "! - B !

4"

! !!

"

!

B !

" -! 1 0 ! !"

- ! 4 1 - !

-0

!- 04 1 0 #8 " !!

" " <! " , 1 " "

! 4 " !

- F

3? 0

# $ -

0;

!