High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4177/2017dismissed

Jaswant Singh v. Anil Aggarwal

2023-08-21Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill8 pages

!"#$!%!$&!

'"()*)+ $'"'

",!

'"()*)+ -%.-"#/0"1 ))) !#0#0'"!$ 2!$% % $)"03-$.-3 4) !%5'"

!"#

$!%!"#( $)6-503-$.-37 &',-#!78'$#1!5!#0#0'"!$) $) "0%16-503-7 &',-#!7-"

$)20%1-3-$-$.-"-7 &',-#!7 8'$#1!$!%5'"

!"#)

1-33!"!0"#1!5$!%!"#5!#0#0'" 0%#'#1!'$ 9):) 5-%%!

;< 3!-$"!

0,0-3 -0%#$-#! %# 3-%%7 -- 1-$07&0 !.10,1,' 53-0"# !$/!,#0'"+ 7803!

;<#1!5!#0#0'"!$7.-% -##1!%#-!'8% '"0"#1! !"#) " ;$0!87 #1! 8-,#% '8 #1! ,-%! -$! #1-# #1! 5!#0#0'"!$ ,' 53-0"-"#803!

-,' 53-0"# !$/!,#0'"+ --0"%# #1! $!%5'"

!"#7 .0#1 #1! -33!-#0'"% #1-# 10% 8-#1!$7 .1' 1- ;!!"% 88!$0"8$' !$"0-7.-%- 0##!

0"#1!1'%50#-3'8#1! !"# '" )) 8'$ #$!-# !"#= #1-# 5$0'$ #' #1! - 0%%0'" 0" #1! 1'%50#-37 8-#1!$ '8 #1! $!%5'" !"# #''> %' ! 0,0"!%8$' -"< $&!

0,',#'$-"

#1!%-0 8-,#1- ;!!"

0%,3'%!

#' #1! $!%5'"

!"#= #1-# 8-#1!$ '8 #1! 5!#0#0'"!$ .-%

'5!$-#!

5'"'"+));<#1!$!%5'"

!"#=#1-#1'.!&!$7 '5!$-#0'" .-% '"! .0#1'

# -"< 5$!'5!$-#0&! 0"&!%#0-#0'"7 -% $!?

0$!

0"#1!,-%!'8!&!$<5-#0!"#-;'&!#1!-!'89<!-$% #1-##1!$!%5'"

!"#.-%$-%17"!30!"#-"

,-$!3!%%.103! 0&0"#$!-# !"##'#1!8-#1!$'8#1!5!#0#0'"!$) # 0% 8 $#1!$ -33!!

#1-# -8#!$ 1-&0" ;!!" '5!$-#!

5'"7%#' -,1'8#1!8-#1!$'8#1!5!#0#0'"!$'#%.'33!"-" 10% 0#0'" 1- ;!,' ! "%#-;3!= #1-# #1! $!%5'"

!"# "'# #->! ,'$$!,#0&! %#!5% -"

$-#1!$ 1- >!5# '" -%% $0" #1! ,' 53-0"-"# #1-# 10% 8-#1!$ .'

$!,'&!$ 8$' #1! 5-0"= #1-# -8#!$ 1-&0" - ! #1! 5-< !"# '8 %)79@ #' #1! !"#7 8-#1!$ '8 #1! 5!#0#0'"!$ .-% 0%,1-$!

'" *))=#1-#1'.!&!$78-#1!$'8#1!5!#0#0'"!$.-%% 88!$0" 8$' %#' -,1 %.!330" -"

,'"%#05-#0'" -"

#1! %- ! 15!$%0%#!

7 -"

#1-# 8-#1!$ '8 #1! 5!#0#0'"!$ .-% --0" '5!$-#!

5'" '" A)+)7 -% - &0%!

7 ;

# #1! %-0 '5!$-#0'" 1- ;!!" ,'"

$-%13<7 "!30!"#3< -"

.0#1'

# 5$!'5!$-#0&! 0"&!%#0-#0'") # 0% 8 $#1!$ -33!!

#1-# 0"#!%#0"!% '8 10% 8-#1!$ .!$! #->!" '

#%0 ! #1! %#' -,1 -"

1- ;!!" >!5# 0"

"1<0!"0,%0 53!5'3<#1!"!70"%#!- '8 !

0,-#!

;-=#1-##1! !"# 1- -%>!

#1! ,' 53-0"-"# #' --0" !5'%0#

%)97@=#1-#8-#1!$'8#1!5!#0#0'"!$1- ;!!"- 0"0%#!$!

,'%!8'$-$'

$ -<%=#1-#1'.!&!$7#1!,'"

0#0'"'8#1! 5!#0#0'"!$B% 8-#1!$ 1- !#!$0'$-#!

= #1-# #1! $!%5'"

!"#

! -"

'$! '"!<#'#1!# "!'8 %)93->17;

#1!1- "'# 0&!" -"< 5$'5!$ #$!-# !"# #' #1! 8-#1!$ '8 #1! 5!#0#0'"!$7 -" #1-##1!$!%5'"

!"#1- --0" ! -"

%)3->18'$8 $#1!$ #$!-# !"#) # 0% 8 $#1!$ -33!!

#1-# -##0#

! '8 #1! $!%5'"

!"#

$%0"%#-88.-%0"%!"%0#0&!.1'1- !&!""'#,1-"!

'$ ,3!-"!

#1!5'3<#1!"!;-%%#'$0"#1!0"#!%#0"!%'88-#1!$'8#1! 5!#0#0'"!$ -"

#1-#

! #' #1! -;'&! "!30!",!7 8-#1!$ '8 #1! 5!#0#0'"!$ 0!

'"#1!"01#'8@*)+)-#-;'

#)-) ) # 0% 8 $#1!$ -33!!

#1-# #1! $!5'$# '8 '-$ '8 ',#'$%7 0&03 '%50#-37 - "- --$7 ,3!-$3< %1'.% #1! $-%1 -"

"!30!"#

,# '" #1! 5-$# '8 #1! $!%5'"

!"# 0" #1! #$!-# !"# '8 #1! 5!#0#0'"!$B%8-#1!$) C!-$"!

0,0-3 -0%#$-#! -8#!$ -55$!,0-#0" #1! 5$!30 0"-$< !&0 !",!7 1- #1! ,' 53-0"# -# #1! '"0"%#-!7&0 !0 5 "!

'$ 9):)) C!-$"!

"%!3 8'$ #1! 5!#0#0'"!$ ,'"#!"

% #1-# #1! #$0-3'

$# "'#-55$!,0-#!#1!!&0 !",!0"-$01#5!$%5!,#0&!7 .103! 5-%%0" #1! 0 5 "!

'$ !$7 -"

#1-# #1!$! .!$! #.' $!5'$#%?

-#1!,- %!'8 !-#1'88-#1!$'8#1!5!#0#0'"!$0)!)'"! 5$!5-$!

;<#1!'-$ '88'

$',#'$%7.1'.!$! !5 #!

;<#1! 0&03 / $!'"7 - "- --$7 '" ))7 -"

#1! %!,'"

$!5'$# 0% )*)7 5$!5-$!

;< - '-$ '8 ',#'$%7 0",3

0" D+ $) !&!"

!$ ) ) )) -- 1-$0 7 .1' 1-

5'%# '$#! '8 #1! ) # .-% 8 $#1!$ #1-# -% 5!$ #1! 80$%# $!5'$#7 5!$8'$-#0'" ,' 1-&! ;!!"

! #' 0"E!,#0'"% #->!" 8$' - ?

-,> '$

$0" !$"0- $!$<7 ;

# !F-,# ,- %! .-% "'# !"#0'"!

'$ ,' !"#!

5'"7.1!$!-%#1!%!,'"

$!5'$#.-%5$!5-$!

-8#!$%!!0"#1!

10%#'5-#1'3'< !F- 0"-#0'" $!5'$#% '8 &0%,!$- '8 #1!

-% 5!$ #1! %- !7 ,- %! '8 !-#1 -55!-$!

#' ;! ,1$'"0, %,1! 0, 1!-$# 0%!-%! .0#1 /!5#0,! 0-7 .10,1 .-% 880,0!"##',- %! !-#10""-# $-3,'

$%!'8#0 !)#0%8 $#1!$

,'"#!"

#1-# #1!%! #.' $!5'$#% .'

%1'. #1-# #1! !"# "'# ,'"

,# -"< #!%#@0"&!%#0-#0'"7 -% $!?

0$!

5$0'$#''$-8#!$% ,1>0"

'8% $!$0!%-"

#1-#"'",'"

,#0" '8 -"< 5$!'5!$-#0&! '$ 5'%#'5!$-#0&! ! 0,-3 #!%#%7 .'

,'"%#0# #!- !

0,-3"!30!",!'"#1!5-$#'8#1!$!%5'"

!"#)# 0%8 $#1!$% #1-##1!%!#.'$!5'$#% "'#0"

0,-#!#1-# #1! .-%% 88!$0"8$' -"<1!-$#5$';3! 5'%##1!%-0 #.' '5!$-#0'"% '$ #1-# #1!$! .-% - 5'%%0;030#< '8 -"< 1!-$# 5$';3! 5'%# % ,1 '5!$-#0'"%7 .10,1 #1! $!%5'"

!"# .-% $!?

0$!

#' #->! ,-$! '8) # 0% 8 $#1!$ % #1-# #1! -8'$!%-0 #.' $!5'$#% 1- ;!!" 5$!5-$!

.0#1'

# #->0" 0"#' ,'"%0 !$-#0'" #1! !

0,-3 $!,'$ '8 #1! 7 -"

#1-# 0# .-% - ,3!-$ ,-%! '8 !

0,-3 "!30!",! '" #1! 5-$# '8 #1! !"#) # 0% <!# 8 $#1!$ % #1-# '" #1! ;-%0% '8 #1! 5$!30 0"-$< !&0 !",! 3!

;!8'$! #1! #$0-3 '

$#7 - 5$0 -8-,0! ,-%!.-% - !'

#;<#1!5!#0#0'"!$#',- %!#1!% '"0"'8 #1! $!%5'"

!"#) '.!&!$7 #1! 3!-$"!

#$0-3 '

$#7 1-% ;$ %1!

-%0 ! #1! %- ! -"

$-#1!$ #1! ,' 53-0"-"# ;< $!,'$ 0"#1!80"

0"%7-%080#.!$!'"#1! !$0#%'8-,-%!-8#!$- 3383!

#$0-3) !$ ,'"#$-7 3!-$"!

"%!3 8'$ #1! $!%5'"

!"# 1-% #1-##1!,' 53-0"#.-%803!

;!8'$!#1!#$0-3'

$#'" 9)+)A7 ;

# 5$0'$ #' 0#7 #1! 5!#0#0'"!$ 1- -3%' 803!

- ,' 53-0"# ,'"#-0"0" %0 03-$ %!# '8 -33!-#0'"%7 ;!8'$! #1! 0%#$0,#'"% !$0%5 #!% $!%%-37 '$ 7- "---$-# -- 1$07 '" ))A) # 0% 8 $#1!$ ,'"#!"

#1-# -33 "!,!%%-$< 5$0'$ 0"&!%#0-#0'"%7 0",3

0" $0"! -"

#!%#%7

1- ;!!" ,'"

;< #1! $!%5'"

!"# ;!8'$! '5!$-#0" 5'" #1! 1!$"0- '8 #1! '" ))) # 0% 8 $#1!$ #1-# -% 5!$ #1! $!5'$#7 #1! 5!$8'$-#0'" ,' 1-&! ;!!" '"!

! #' #1! 0"E!,#0'"% #->!" 8$' #1! ?

-,>

$0" 1!$"0- % $!$< -"

#1-# 0# .-% #1! - 0##!

,-%! '8 #1! 5!#0#0'"!$#1-##1! 1- #->!"#$!-# !"#8$' -?

-,> ;< .-< '8 0"%!$#0'" '8 #.' 0"E!,#0'"% -# #1! %0#! '8 1!$"0-) 1! 0%#$0,# '"% '$ 7 .103! 0% 0%%0" #1! ,' 53-0"# 803!

;< #1! 5!#0#0'"!$7 &0 ! '$ +))*7 "'#0,!

#1-# 0"8!,#0'"% %!5#0,! 0- ',, $$!

%'3!3< ;!,- %! '8 1-&0" #.' 0"E!,#0'"%-##1!%0#!'81!$"0-;<-?

-,>7-"

#1-##1!$!.-%"'

!&0-#0'" 8$' #1! .!33 !%#-;30%1!

5$!%,$0;!

0,-3 5$-,#0,! -"

5$',!

$! '" #1! 5-$# '8 #1! $!%5'"

!"# .103!

,#0" 80$%# % $!$< "- !3< ;03-#!$-3 1!$"0- 53-%#< '" +)) %!,'"

$!$< "- !3< 33!'%#' < '" )+)) # .-% 8 $#1!$ ,'"#!"

#1-# -% 5!$ #1! 0"?

0$< $!5'$# )9)A7 #1! #$!-# !"# - '5#!

.-% -% 5!$ %#-"

5$'#','3 !"#0'"!

0"#1! !

0,-330#!$-# $!) #0%8 $#1!$,'"#!"

#1-#.1!"-?

-3080!

',#'$ #$!-#% - 5-#0!"# 0" 10% %>033 -"

5$'8!%%0'"-3 5$

!",!7 !$!3< ;!,- %!

$0"'$5'%#% ,1#$!-# !"#7#1!5-#0!"#5-%%!%-.-<7 0%"'$'

#'8-%#!"-,$0 0"-330-;030#<'"#1!5$!#!F#'8#1!$! ;!0"- !

0,-3"!30!",!'"#1!5-$#'8% ,1',#'$) !30-",! 0% 53-,!

5'" - ''$ 0"-#! !",1 E

!"# '8 #10% '

$# 0" D 9**: G $) )/) -""

#1!$% 2%) !0%#$-$7

"E-; -"

-$<-"- 01 '

$#7 1-"

0-$1 -"

-"'#1!$7

!,0 '" 9)9) -"

- /0"3! !",1 E

!"# '8 01 '

$#'8- 6-%1 0$-"

C- ->1-#- 70" D ')

'89G ''"- /1-$ --"

'#1!$%&)/#-#!'86-"

'#1!$%7 !,0 '"A))) 1-&!1!-$ #1!3!-$"!

"%!38'$#1!5-$#0!%-"

1-&!-3%''"!#1$'

1#1!,-%!803!) 1!$!0%"' !"<0"#1!8-,##1-##1!5!#0#0'"!$1803!

' 53-0"# -%! ') A: '8 A ;!8'$! #1! 0%#$0,# '"% !$ 0%5 #!% $!%%-3 '$ 7 - "- --$ -# -- 1$0)%"'#0,!

-;'&!7#1!%-0 ,' 53-0"#.-% ;< #1! 0%#$0,# '$ '" +))* 1'3 0" #1-# #1! !"#% 1- ,'"

5$'5!$ 0"&!%#0-#0'"%@#!%#%7 ;!8'$!

,#0" #1! % $!$< '8 1!$"0-) # .-% 8 $#1!$ 8'

#1-# -% "'#10"-;"'$ -3.-%8'

0"#1!$!5'$#'8#1! 7 "'#$!-# !"#8'$#1!1!-$#.-% '"!) #0%#1!&!1! !"#,-%!'8#1!5!#0#0'"!$,' 53-0"-"# #1-#"'#!%#%@0"&!%#0-#0'"%.!$! '"!;<#1!$!%5'"

!"#%;!8'$!

,#0"#1!% $!$<'"#1! 7.1!$!-%#1!-8'$!%-0 80"

0" '8 #1! 0%#$0,# '$ 7 ;!30!% #1! %- !) # ,'

"'# ;! %1'."#1-##1!%-0 80"

0"'8#1!0%#$0,# '$ 71-&!;!!"%!# -%0 !@ '

080!

'$-3#!$!

0"-55!-3'$$!&0%0'"7-%#1!,-%! -< ;!) %5!$#1!"?

0$< !5'$#""!F $! ) 7.10,11-% ;!!" %0"!

;< 8'

$ ',#'$% 0",3

0" / 7 C7 - "-"--$70#.-%8'

#1-##1!#$!-# !"#- '5#!

.-%-% 5!$#1!%#-"

5$'#','3 !"#0'"!

0"#1! !

0,-330#!$-# $!)# -3%'%#''

!%#-;30%1!

'"$!,'$ #1-##1!8-#1!$'8#1!5!#0#0'"!$ 1- #->!"#$!-# !"#70",3

0" 0"E!,#0'"%78$' -?

-,>;!8'$! #1!% $!$<.-% '"!;<#1!$!%5'"

!"#)'$!'&!$7#1!3!-$"!

#$0-3 '

$# 1-% "'#0,!

0" 0#% '$ 9):) #1-# #1!

5!#0#0'"!$ "'# !F- 0"! -"< !

0,-3 5$-,#0#0'"!$ 0" '$ !$ #' ;%#-"#0-#! #1! -33!-#0'"% #1-# #1! $!%5'" !"# .-% !

0,-33< "!30!"#-"

$-%1.103!5!$8'$ 0"% $!$0!% 5'"#1!8-#1!$'8 #1!5!#0#0'"!$)1!3!-$"!

#$0-3'

$#.-%$01#0"1'3 0"#1-# "'"! '8 #1! #.' $!5'$#% % ;< #1! '-$ '8 ',#'$%7 5'0"#!

# #1-# #1! 1- % 88!$!

-"< 1!-$# 5$';3! 5'%##1!#.'% $!$0!%,'"

;<#1!$!%5'"

!"#) "$)$%) 1-"

- -"0>1'

$0 #1!$%2%)$) )) !#1 %!#1 5-#10 #1!$%7 0&03 *97 #1! '"B;3!/ 5$! !'

$#7.103!$!8!$$0"#'0#%!-$30!$E

!"#% 0"-,';-#1!.&)/#-#!'8

"E-;-"

"'#1!$79 A/ 6 /1-$ --"

#1!$%&)-#$-'%50#-3-"

0,-3

!%!-$,1 !"#$! -"

#1!$%7 + / *7 1-% 1!3 -%

!$( H)# ,3!-$3< ! !$!% 8$' #1! !F5'%0#0'" '8 3-.#1-#- !

0,-35$-,#0#0'"!$0%"'##';!1!3 30-;3! %0 53< ;!,- %! #10"% .!"# .$'" 8$' 0%,1-",!'$ 0%- &!"# $!'$#1$'

1-"!$$'$ '8E

!"#0",1''%0"'"!$!-%'"-;3!,'

$%! '8 #$!-# !"# 0" 5$!8!$!",! #' -"'#1!$) " #1! 5$-,#0,! '8 !

0,0"!7 #1!$! ,'

;! &-$<0" -55$'-,1!% '8 #$!-# !"#) 1!$! ,'

;! - !"

0"! 088!$!",! '8 '50"0'") '.!&!$7 .103! - '5#0" - ,'

$%! '8 #$!-# !"#7 #1!

#< ,-%#

5'" #1! !

0,-3 5$-,#0#0'"!$ 0% #1-# 1! %# !"% $!#1-##1! !

0,-35$'#','3;!0"8'33'.!

;< 10 0% #' #1! ;!%# '8 10% %>033 -" .0#1 ,' 5!#!",!-#10%,' -"

)##1!0&!"#0 !7 0,-35$-,#0#0'"!$.'

;!30-;3!'"3<.1!$! 10%,'"

,#8!33;!3'.#1-#'8#1!%#-"

%'8- $!-%'"-;3<,' 5!#!"#5$-,#0#0'"!$0"10%80!3 )I

% .'

! !$! 8$' #1! $!5'$# '8 #1! '-$ '8 ',#'$% ""!F $! ) 7 #1! %#-"

0,-3 5$'#','3 .-% 8'33'.!

;< #1! $!%5'"

!"# ')7 .103! ,'"

,#0" % $!$0!% '8 #1!8-#1!$'8#1!5!#0#0'"!$)%"'#0,!

-;'&!7#1!5!#0#0'"!$ "'# !F- 0"! -"< !F5!$# .0#"!%% '$ 53-,! '" $!,'$ -"< -#!$0-37.10,1,'

;! -#!$0-33< 088!$!"#8$' #1!-8'$!%-0 #.' $!5'$#%7 %' -% #' 5$0 -8-,0!7 !%#-;30%1 #1-# #1!$! .-% -"< 0,-3"!30!",!'"#1!5-$#'8#1!$!%5'"

!"#) ''#1!$5'0"#1-%;!!" $!

) "&0!.'8#1!-;'&!780"

0""' !$0#0"#1!5$!%!"# 5!#0#0'"7#1!%- !0%1!$!;< ) )*)+

5-$&!!"> -$ D1!#1!$$!-%'"!

@%5!->0"J!%@' D1!#1!$$!5'$#-;3!J!%@'