High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4211/2017dismissed

Harpreet Singh Alias Happy And ANR v. State Of Haryana

2018-07-02Mr. Justice Arun Palli15 pages

!"!# $ %&% !'( )!

" &&* (% !%"

,%"-"

"&+

%" #.

1+2

1 % !%" /% -%+% !'(11 %* /%

& !'(1+2

1 %%"&+ !! "#$% * (!"& !1 4& !%""5"

!' "!+ (%+% ( ) %+ ) -% 6++!

) ""!" -+'1 7 % )81 +

9 12!+4(! ( !%"( 2:"-00+ ";

++!

)

-"+;-&

!!)+:* ( 0&) 6! 81-+%

!<9 (%1"5!'

(*:""-00+ %!% (%+%4!0&-'+:% (!"-% 1 "!0!) %+%+

+=4 "& ""+:* () %+ 1

0 :

))'+:% (!"-% :*4 *%!0! ) 2!"!$9=1 4(! (4 ))4+:* (!"-% 6 .%+!

(812!+!

"%+%+

-'-"

91 1 (%:*"

!' "!+

%+% +

=1-% (%+!% !'

-% ( % !" %"( ++ !+

!6-+%

!<9%81'!2!'&%&%% "!' (-"1!

!" (% %

(!0&-'+%+%( ":& ""+1

! "-00!' ( & !%" ) ! %!0! ) &% +!'"

!'%0 (%'!"

! 9>$1+

+>1

! !2!) ?!1 7 % )1 ))'!' (%! ( 00!""! "

&-!"( :)-+%

!"$191< +>= "&% 1%'!"

(!"

!!)+-+%

!<9%81 (2!'

<>1"() (%(-" )'4!

((%(-":

@ *1 )!+% "/ )5( !'( +/ @"%0 !'(1! %:

%!'

%'!"

! ...=$ "&% ( 0&) 1"(( ++%&&+(%(-":

+ )!+%

'*0 "!-0"!

+! (/+)4/ %5

7 % )1 4(! ("(4 (0 %5 4!

(/ @ :- =#>&014("( +/ @4%% -%!' +( (+ % ('*0 "!-01(%(-":

+ )!+%4%" 0!'

+4"

!%"4!

(,! 5*" "( ?

@"("() !'(1:

%0+4!

("4%+" (% )!+% + @!+%1

@:!%1/ -A"(51

)" (&%" 4& !%"1! %&% !'(A &&* "( 1 4% )""

:&%" )'4!

(% (%*-':*"1 )) %0+ 4!

(!%%+" (* % ))"

( 2"-%%-++ ( 0&) ";(-":

@ *814!

(,! 5*B(% !' (0 ))4

@ * "

& +

(:5!))+

-% (% "&% 1

@"( +,! 5*'

2"4%+:)4"

(( +

@ *14!

(%0 !!' -"+ -"!'0-) !&)!@-%!"

& (!04!

(!%!%%+"

& ( 0&) 1 )!+% +/ @( 2!' %!+%()&1

+-& (0&% +!' %" -

@ *1 -"+ )!+% (&%"

4& !%" % ))'+ ( 2;&% ) !0+;

! (* %!+ ! %%1

(*C4-)+ )":!!"(+D ))'+)*1 (%-54:*4 )"!)!

+!@-%!":*

-"+& *4(!)) 2!' ("&

@ *( 2!':

5 (2%0 "&!

)17 % )1( "0+! .)'

))*B 0!+1 %4(! ((4

5 (,!%5"&!

)

7 % )1%04(%(4 ""(! % !""&!

)

/( )!14(% ("- -0:+ (!"!@-%!" < %!2"

!1 (&)! "-:0!

"%&% -+%

<%1+ ) %!' (&%" & !%" :! 42%1 % 0!' ( ( %'1 ( 0&) 1

1 ( 2!' : B 0!+

)'4!

(/ @6 "E" +%"& !2)*81

!-+%

<9%4 "!)+1"5!' "-00 (&%" 4& !%" ;

++!

) -"+; " )% +* ! +(%! :21 ( %)!%2!+ "%+%+

+= ))4+

! %%%%!' @-+'0 ( -&%0 -% ! '" $ (!" "!! ) *!( '(* '

)*+!"# !" >68 6 8 + ,',$ "$"

,$ "-$"(" .

!$*()! !* '/ ( ! .!$*(+ 68&B-% -+'0 8=$1()+!'

: &&)!+%"-00!' *&%"-&

!0 +-+%

!<9%14-)+:

"!"0 +- 1 "B!"

!0% 0!' %'

(-"1 "&%

-% 1!

4 "@-"

!!+!"-00!' (&%"

4& !%" ++!

) -"+ > E(

%+% 0 : ( ))'+:*4 *

$9 =1 (!"-% 6 .%+!

(8 ))4+

& !1:* ! !' !% !"+:% :* (-:)! %" - %1 "% %++ !& '% &(=

-% ";%+%6+

+=8#.

! " # !$%& ! ' ' ' ( ! '(& ' ' ! ' ! ! ' !

$)*+

(& !

, (% %1 (%2!"!& !4 "+!"&"+:* (!"-% ()+!' "))4"#.

%+ !% -") % ( & !%" ++

)5!' :2& (%+%14-)+ 0"68 !0&%""! 4(

!"& ""!'! (0!+ () %+@-+'1 0)*1&%@-+! 2!'%'

%+ :2:"%2

!" +

4(! (1 "!":!'( %+1 (!51

"(-)+ ( 2 -"+ ( 4%+"1 2!F C" ))+ )&(!

!)"D1)

! -)+ ( 2: "!)*0 '+ :* (0D1 00 " :- 4!

"" / @ 7-0 % % &)!

5!'

"!'

-%":) 5& &%" &&%&%!

"14(% (%!"

2!+ % %+! )

! )@-+'1

%-+%'!' %"".B 0!

!1 (@-+'4-)+ :@-"

!!+!0 5!'"- (:"%2

!"1:- (

"(-)+:

% -))+%""+ )+ (!5!

4 "@-"

:)% ) %+ )-+' 0 5 :2:"%2

!"14(! (+!!

'!2%!" (!0&%""!! (0!+ &%" :- 4(

!"& ""!'! (0!+ (@-+'4%!

!' (%+% % ))1 !%&) *!" (( ))0 %5 (@-+! !

)&% +!'"14(! ("(-)+

)": && %%0 (%+%"% (@-+'0 (!51!

2!4 (0

%1!

4-)+: &&%&%!

"5 () %+ ) -+' ( % ( ) %+ -") % ( %!2 ) & !" +

(% %10 5 %"(%+%( +

5 (!"

-% ;":"%2

! :2 " %!

! !"0:- +2!

2!4 (0

%1!0&-'+%+%+

=1! ""!" "9=1!"G- "(+ +"

"!+4!

+!% ! ( %%!2 )& !" + + !+

!-+%

!<9+%!0! ) % +-%19 < %"(4!

(&%&%% ""(

!! G-"

!"( )):

5-&%( %!'4!

(!>+ *"%0 + *

+"( )):+ !+1 (% %1! (B >+ *"-% (%

!04!)):'% + !"

+"+!"&"+1 %+!')*D = (% % (!0&-'+%+% 0 :& ""+1%!

!' "-00"!""-+ !%"% && %!' ";

++!

) -"+;:%

-% 14!

()+!' "))4"#.

C9 !"&% ! 0 !(%

@-"

% (!"! !+ !@-%+ 4 "

5 % ) "&!

)1 4(% %0 ( 4 %%%+ % !""&!

)

/( )!1:- +"&!

% +:* 0&) )!

@ * -)+ :"

2+4 G-"

!!"4( (%"

0 "% %++:*&)! -+%

=%+-%!' -%"!2"

!5&"0%4!'(

% "

0 " % %++ :* &)! +-%!' !G-"

&% +!'"

-+%

! >%%

!)*&% +!'" 0&)!"(+ -+%

! %5&""!'

-%H (-0:!0&%""!

(&%""14(@!+ ("&% +!'"1:- "

*1! &!! (!"-% !"0%

0 % %++-+%

! = %1 :

-" "

0 -+%

! = %!"! '% )& (!2"

!-%!'!2"

&% +!'"1"

0 "% %++:*2"

!' ! % %&-

-& :% / '!"

% &%-"

) + "

0 !" : "!'+ /%2%(4&)! &% +!'" :%)!+-& +"0 :%%0+-:

4(!

% %+++!% "

%!" *-+%

! % +-+%

!=%! @-B

&" ( (%

0 "4!

"""% %++-+%

! = % )" &%

!" > + !G-"

&% +!'" -+%

! % )" &%

!" > 0+ *1: (&%""0 !+!

!( 2:"(4 :! &%""14(!) 0+ *1&)! ) !0+ (0 : (&%""4( 00!

:* % %+!' "

0 " -+%

! = % %

!)*1 !

4 " ( +!" % ! &)! '!2 ) !!

("&%"":*0)+!' "! 2-%&%""

0 !+!

!E(!) 0+ *1 "!

%*"

) ) %

-"+ )*& ! !&

+! (! !+

4(%!+ "+"-%+!+!" %!0!

!@-%!"1:- (* )"

(+'(-"1! (&!! (!"-% 1"

% %++:*&)! +-%!' -%"!2"

!-+%

=%0 5" "&%" - ! %*"

) ) %1) +!'

( )-"!

-"+4%!2)2+! 4 "2(0 )* %'-+:*+ -")

+ %&% )!

" &&*4%

G-!

+!"

%0 (&)

4(% -%% 5&) 0!"%) !'%0 (!%

)&(H0:!) )

! (!" "

1 (!"

" %

!+ -%

)* :

-" (!" !0&%

4-)+ :

" %

!+ %2!+ 4-)+::%-'( :%-% '% 4!

( !) %+-:)! %" - % (!""-

!) " -)+( 2 2*+ (!%0:!)-+% "&!% * %"(4!' (!%&%"

"0 (%&) + " * "-:"

! %'-0 ") %++ -")

(

(!%: * "&!% * )) -"+! (!"%'

%+1 ( (% .

-"+ 0!'( )" ( 2 "(! + (!% 0:!)" +!% )

!" :

-" +

!) + )

! (% .

-"+( 2 ::%-'( :% (-% %"(4!' (!% )

!-% %'

(!"!0&%

! + *;"" !

* '% ))*&&)5&"0% 0:!)1"!

%-)+-

&%""0 !+!

!"(-)+( :-"!' (%0:!)-0:%"-%!' -%"!2"

!1 &)! +!+ 5 !+ 2!

%0 -"+!G-"

(* 4%-"!')*0:!)

(@- -%4( 4 00!

+D 2!':"%2+ :21 4 !

%0 %!-"@-+'0 " (!"-% -&%0-% 2 ))*()+ ))4"#.

C (&%" " (%( ":

!2& ! !&

! : -"+ "&% " 0&) "

&&+!

(4!

"":B "E +(% !0*!"! " 4!

( " 0&) B/%2%1(% !0* &&!'! (4!

"":B!""

04(

4 ":%&)! 42%1 " &%" - ! !" :*+ (!" " (% * 4!

"" (! !+ 0)*/ @"

&&+! (4!

:B "E + %%:%

!0*E(-"1! &!! -% 1 " &%" - ! 5&" "-:"

&%" - ! ( " "- ++ ! "

:)!"(!' !

" "

2!+ H0

) :%-'( :% ( -% :* &%" -

' *!"(!'(% (2!+ 4(! (!"%G-!%+%% 0!'

( %' '

-"+ (&!! (!"-% "& !!

!2& ! !&

!: "( + %&%

!'( )!

" &&*! ( H! !+ !G-"

!14(! (!"

% !!+ :* !0* E + -% (% %%:%

+ :*

!0*E!""-! ! %% (!'

)-"!

: ( (" -"+ 4% !2)2+ ! ( ! !+ 1 4(%! "+

@ * )"

(!" )! (!" 2!+ !" :2

2!+ 1 4(! ( !" %G-!%+ % % 0!' ( %' 1

!!)+:*&%" - !%"-00!' "( ?

)

+ %&% !'( )!

" &&* " ++!

) -"+ % 00!""! " &-!"( :) -+%

!" <H91 $H9 +>=1& 6!!8H9+!

)+!"(%:*

))4+(

+"+!"&"+ %+!')*D

% (!"-% 1/%

1) %+ -")% & !%"1 !

@-+'0 -&%0-% !("/*.( "#$ .

!$*(+)! !* / +!$ 1 6<8 6%)8< 14(%!14(!) %%%!' (&%! !&)") !++4:* ("

! (! (.**3 "#$)! !* 4'/ , 16<8 9 1!

4 "()+6! (

"81

( ) -% "!0&)* ( :

"!" ( +&"!

! 0&) +"0 (%&%""! (!%B 0!

!.!. (!14!

( (%0

) "-&&% (".

))+2%:

)H -) %2%"!1"-&&% +"!0&)* :*

0 "% %++-+%

!=%14 "+- *:-+

)

)5! 0:%%0!' &%!0 !&!! "C4( (% 0- ("

%'%2!+ (0%&""!:!)!

* ( 0&)! !

-"+6 "4 ""-00+-+%

!<9%8( + 0% %+D /%-

)"1

-% ))*1%)!+-& (&%! !&)") !++4! # '- " "-:0!

1 (%%1 ( ) -% 4())* %%+ ! "-00!' !%"14!

))*

5!'! - 4(

(!"

-% ( )% +*()+4(!) ))4!' (&%2!-"%2!"!& !!)+:*

!%"6

$9=8I + "G- )*1 (!0&-'+%+% +"%2" :G- "(+ )" &! + - %0 (!0&-'+%+%1 %'-0

!"+:% (

"&%

0 "% %++:*

( &)! -+%

! > %1 !

( + : 0 2!+

&%" - !4!

""" 0 54 (+

(

@ *)* (B + *1

(%%1 (-'( "

0 0 +-+%

! >% %%!" 0%4!'( "

0 % %++-+%

!=%1 ) -% 4())*%%+! &&% !

! /%

& !'(1 ) %+ -") % 0&) 1 )"/% -%+% !'(1) %+""!"

% )1 %* 1 '

!%%%+ # '- "!

")1 "-:0!

) -% 4-)+ : 4!

(! !

" @-%!"+!

! "-00 -"+

!02+-+%

!<9%1 (:

"!"0

) 0!'

-% ! ( -%";G-!%!";1 ""- (G-!%!" )" 0 4!

(! 0:!

(4%+2!+ 1! %0" !+&%2!"!6

<98 (* )"&! %'-0 % !"+:% :*

(-:)! %" - %1 (

)&()

! (&%"

& !%"4 " "-! ! %!

%!% " %

!!' (!%

))

!1 :

-""- ()

! "%'

%+"& !%6 %&% !'(A &&*8 ""(4 : % (

))) 14!

()

!& !% (%! :!' %

%.1 7 % )1 +

%+! %!)* )&(!

)

!" 2 2%-& :- >50" (-:)! %" - %!"-% (%" ( 2 %'-+:%

! (%4 ""-:"

! ( !"% !"+:( )

!%"1 (*4-)+ ( 2&%+- + :% 1,

' (

))) 6( %'-0 " %%%+ :* : ( "!+" %

!+ ! & '% &(" +=%"& !2)* (!0&-'+%+%8

(1) %+ -")%

( 0&) 1 (%% "-:0!

!%"( 2!':"& !!

))* 0+!

")1

%!:- !' %) (0!)!

!'!@-%!"-& (+ "+4!

!%%+"1

' ):!')*

"-00!' -"+1 +'%2!+ :"

'!")*@-"

4(! (!" :"

!0% 0!' ( %' 9 2!' "!+%+ %'-0 ": ("!+"1!

!"!%"

() %+ ( " ! +

0 "% %++:*

(&)! -+%

!" H > +=% %: ( 0+

! >1 4!

( ( "

0 " % %++ -+%

! = % "(4!' !%"(%! :: (!2)2+! ( 00!""! 1:- 4!

0 "% %++! ( -%"!G-"

&% +!'"1 "(4!'

(*4%!

-% (%124(!):"%2!'

!:* ( 0&)

+-%!' !0*14(

!"% %++! ( 0&) 1!" -'(% "-00!' -"+-+%

!<9%1 "

!))4

! ( +!

%*"

0 "% %++-+%

!"= + H >%1 (% %()+!'

!2!4 (

: (1 0&) (*4!

"" (! !+ 1/ @1( + %%:%

(% "%'

%+" (%) (&%" & !%"1 (%4 ""-! ! % "

"(4

(*( +& ! !&

+! ( -%% (%%4% %G-!%+ :"-00+ -"+ +" : ! +

(!""

( "1!

1B&%""+!

"&!!

(* %

))*!2)2+! ( 00!""!

( (-'(!0*&!!) %+ -")%

0&) 6:% (!"-% 8 % %% !"-:0!

" %%+!"-00!' !%"! %"

!+ !% -0"

"1 4(

(42%-% (%+" :"

(!""

'1!"4( (%4(

( ":

+:* (!"-% ! %)!%%2!"!& !!)+:* !%"1( : "!+%+:* % 14(!)& ""!' (!0&-'+%+%

(" + !0 %-+ E(

(!" -% ( + :"%2+ 6 " )% +* %&%+- + (%! :28!"

0" %""

() %+ )-+'4 "&%@-+! + 4(!)"-00!' !%"1 "!

"(-)+ ( 2-"+4%+")!5C"

))+ )&(! +

!)"D1 +C)

! -)+( 2: "!)*0 '+:*

(0D ( )"::"%2+

00 ""(-)+( 2:0 +:*

( ) -% " %'

%+" 4!

"" / @1 % :- ( &)!

5!'

"!'

-%":) 5& &%" ( + -% (%: :"%2+ :* (!" -%

! *"- ( 00 "4% :0 +!

4-)+:

'4%!

!' (@-+'0 )-"! )1:-

'"-00!' &%" ;

++!

) -"+;

! !)+ -+%

! <9 % "G- )* (&%2!-"%+%+

+=( +:"

"!+14!

+!% + !+

! %"( < "&!

!""

:*-"!'&(% """- ( "C! &!! (!"-% ("& !!

!2& ! !&

!: "( + %&% !'( )!

" &&*! ( H! !+ !G-"

!14(! (!"

% !!+:* !0*E +-% (% %%:%

+:* !0*E !" "-! ! % % (!'

)-"!

: ( (" -"+ 4% !2)2+! (! !+ 14(%!+ "+

@ *)"

(!")!D1

! 00!

0%%%

+!+4(!)& ""!' (%+%+

=1!!

(

))*B&%""+!

"&!!

: !%"

(%!4%C!2)2+! (! !+ D14(% "1

"(-)+( 2: % %++14(!) )-+!' %"

!+" 1

: -"+:!'

!2)2+! (! !+ -)+ :%-)+- (%% (*4% %G-!%+ :"-00+ : %!+ )'4!

( (%" )% +* %% !'+

-"+

(42%1+ " *%%%! (!0&-'+ %+%1!

))*"-00!' !%" ++!

) -"+1 )* :

-" ( 0&) + (% &%" 4( % "

+ : * 4!

""" ( -%% 1 ! E J E1 : ( %!

+ ! (!%

!0!"

( & !%" 4% )" (" 4( ( +

5+ "+1:- )":

-" (% %"

: +!

!"6 "&% %+% 8!

0 ""(4 :% %++-+%

H >%

!=% > !" )" ""

%*1:%+ !+!' "1 %% @-+'0 ("

! (! (.**3"#$)! !* 4'/ , .!$*(+ 68< 9 "))4"#.

$%.

! '

! ! '

'' !

/ ! ' 0$1 +

/ 0$1+

' ' ,

& ' , ,

! ! ' 0$1+

, 23 + 4 = E( + 2!)4(

( ":()+ :2K!%&)*

( G-"

! % 0+ :* (!% ?%+"(!&" ( +'% "

%G-!%+%!25!'@-%!"+!

!-+%

!<9%6G-"

!!28L1 4-)+::2!-"

4(!)!""-!' (!0&-'+%+%1 () %+ ) -% '

2'+% "!' ()+

(%4 "0% ;@-"

&%!0 .

!; " '

!%"(%!14!

-% '!':*+ 2% %+!'

+'%"

!1 +!"

(*4%

))*C!2)2+! (! !+ D E(%

1 )% +*:"%2+(%! :26!& <814 :2!-")* &%&%

'"-00!'1(42%1

-% )" ! +

(% 4% +!

!" ! ( "

0 " % %++ -+%

!" +=%:* (&)! 6: (% %++ 0+

-% (%1

-% )"&!+

"!0&)* (&%" 0:!)&("

& ! -) % 4%)

!1 -)+ : &

2 )- +-% (% 2!+ 4-)+:%G-!%+ :)+

G-"

!1"& !

))* 0:!)&("0 *( 2:"(! +!% )

!" (%%1 2 4(!) ()+!'

"!0&) %!

! !

!0!"E" +1 (

+! 1!" "-! !

2!+ &! ( -)& :!)!

* ( & !%"1 ! ( !% !% -0"

-% -% (% 4 % %+

( &"!

!2 %%:%

! !+ 44!

"""6"4!

( +!

!0!"-+%

!" +=%81+!+0 5- 0%

&%!0 . ! " '

!%" 1 (@-+'0 %)!+-&:*/%

1) %+ -")% !%"1! '- "6"-&% 81!0*&!!1 +" 0 (!"()&1:

-"!

4 "-+

2 ))*

4 "-00 (&%"" 0+!

!!)+ -+%

!<9%1)* (:

"!" (

( 0&)

+"0 (%&%""1! (!%B 0!

!".!. (!1( +%!

+4(

)% +*% %++!

0 "0 +-+%

!=%14!

(%0

) "-&&% (" !"14!

(&)! ( 2!'-+

("4(4%"-'( :"-00+14%

))* :- >50"

*%0 (&) -%% $ (&%" "1 (&"!

! (0:!)&( 4%"

% %++ (0:!)&(-0:%" !%"

!0 -%% 1:!'4!

(!50" (&) -%% 1 +!

( 2!'

:"(4:% 1!%"

)*14( (%!

()

! 0:!)&(" -)+( 2:&! 5+-&:* (% 4%"4!

(! 50 '1 +-% (%1

(%4% * (%0:!)&(" %%!+:* & !%"% 6 ":"%2+:* 81 +0%2%1 (%:!'

!" "%'

%+" !%";&%" 6% (%4!"82!

0 "% %++-+%

!" H >

!=%1" " "

"!+ ( "" ( !0&-'+ %+%1 :- 4!

( )) :"%2

!"0 +:* :!'%+%0 (!0&-'+%+%1 :*4(! (

-% ( "2!% ))* )% +*B&%""+ !

"&!!

& !%" %!2)2+! ( 00!""! ( 9 "G- )*14(!)+!"0!""!' (!"& !1 !"

+!% "-%

))"- (:"%2

!"0 +:*

-% 12!% ))* ()+!' !%"'-!) *

(!""

")1 % 0&) )*!'%+:*!

('-!) %! !%" )) (% .

-"+

% %!+:%!

1!""

:)!"(+4())* +)* (:

"!"2!+ )+ :%!

: ("!+" (! %!0%+%+

+ 0:%$1 1 "G- )*"

+14!

&% +4!

)B&+!

!-")* '6% 7 8 +!"( 9 E( (%% "+H"& 5!'# "H E( (%%&%

:)# "H