← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10591/2016dismissed

Nathi And ORS v. The Financial Commissioner Haryana And ORS

2017-11-13Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa6 pages



      

 !

"# %"&' ()* %. %)% /.' 

 '

'0'

. %% /.' 

'2 / '



   

    

' (3 4% 5%/26 7.,/&%,".2 

8 

 9 %:

.2 '&%) 7.)''*5 '".%

/'20% /&%) 7.2/&'''8 8 '"'2 / '

-,

%)1,

%  %)%'. .'%/% /,"/% &

2 %7% '

% %)0 /6& ;8". <%*6&01"

=% / 0'&, ! +'> 7& "

% %) .70 /.% ..%'"%/2%1' & %*, !!-5.0% 1'0""& %'

.% /'20'

>% % )%%&)2' 7 &% 7 + ,4.%'%  ##% &% 7 +$,4.%'% #?#,'0%/5. . 0 '%"%7.%>5%%,'&4% % .'''% &, ' %/,@&' 7.25'"&,4% %,/')''/.&

2 ///%/ #

# ./ 7%'"5'(8

 ".% 7.%70) '20".*1*.. &0 ''% /20'%"&/,'*0'.%%

B0' ')7%7/221% /%''.%)%/.

&0) '.29%)%*% /"1% !$;8$ ?

CC 8 C$:

.'2 / '%. '.07.)7%7'

%'2<%)%*% / !!$8!- . ' .'%) '

  %&  0 7.&/ 3,.' . 7

&/    '.5  .%  .  % /    B0'  .%'  *

/)/

/'0&. &&0)'% &', ''%*'./ .%.'2 / '% '*0".)7%7'  ".2% ""

6.% '.2"% //% /  ' 2/  5"./'&0'' %*,.2%  "/  *1 .  2% ""  '  .*1  /')''/  * 7   )% %*

D E#F .  2 '  0 '0&&''"01  &.% 7/  .  %*8'%/ /  "'1  *"  .  ))'' ,  .%>  ' ,  %)1,  . 22%0.1% /. *". %,  ,. ' %0.1 ..'0.'%'/')''/. %22%% /' 2

. ' %0.1.%'./%'"5'(8

.%.%/.%70) '".&0 '".*.

.2%'% /20'/.&/%%%* ."  .%%'20'/.<%)%*% / !$;8$ , !!$8!-% #8

'/ ").<%)%*% / !$;8$ .% .'%/% /5%'&//%''.%)%/.6) 6.* 5%''.5 %')7%7 .&0) '.2% 6.

%  %)  '  "  6.

'.%  %)  5%'  &//  %'

)7%7% /.% /5%'/'&*/%'% <%4%/)

'2<%)%*% / !!$8!-.'2 / '5'.5

%'. '.07.)7%7% /. ' '%) %&  0 3,.' . 7

&/    '.5  .%  .  % /    B0'  .%'  *

/)/%'2%5% /.&%)".2  .'

7%/'//"% 1/&0) %1/ &

/ '0&.&&0)'% &',''%*'./.%.'2 / '

% '".)7%7% ".2 

E+F

7%/''"./%1").%  1% " 7.5 2 ,5.%.%/% /&0 '".2 ' )'%% '/%* 7.% /7 .07..&/'

 E;F )7'0".& &0 " / 7'""%&.%.%

/'20.%'* &  00'1&//%'G

 5. .)% "6& #97:". <%*H%7)) =% /' 70% &,

!!

,%'%22&%*.6%"%1% %9"'.,G. !$ &G:



% /& &//1'' %) &.%1% 5"6& ;

#:". !$ &,.% @%&"5.&.%/'%'"5'(8 A;

 !

"

#  $%  "#& !  "

 ' (&   )  * +$+"

$!*  9 :  5.'% / 7  % 1. 7    . %1& / % 1.%5".)* 7

"& % 1%7) , '0) ,&0')0'%7 1/&/"% 1&0.%0.1,% 7.',% ''5.% .% /I8 9%: 5.&.' &0// .'.%)%/."% 1%7 /5.&..%' '/ % &.%1%0 /. '.%)%%5'.%,%.&)) &) ".'&, ' &.%1%& '0/"'0&.%7,% 5. '0&.  &.%1%.%'* & '0/" '0&.%7,' . &.%1% '0&./%%'%

&.%1%  .% 7  <0'/&    .%  %7  '

'0/I 9*: 5.&.''0%/5. 0'/.%*%//."% %7% /5.&.'0 /..0'5 /*1%

 822,  '.%,    .  &)) &)   "

'.%)%%5,*/)/.%* '/ '0&.

 822

9#: 1% /5.&.''/ % &.%1%0 /. '.%)%%5'.%*/)/.%* '/

&.%1%0 /.'&

E F .&%'".2 ', ...% /,'.%.%

/'20''0*<&%& % /%''0&.&%

*

% .",/' ' .%) &.%1% '&%)/.%.% /'205%'%/%. %) .1% !$;8$  .5/',

 .2 'G&%)'.%.% /'20'5 /*1.22'

*1.%) &.%1% E$F % 7.%/% /&0 '".2 ',5%". '//5.%  " & .)207 //'&%/"

.)/B0' 5.&.""& '/% ".0.'*5 5./&/ 7.<&) 2 0 /. <%*6&01"=%  0'&, ! +5%',5.. .@'/% '.2"% // / *5 .2 '%

% %)9' &/&%'/:, 5 2' /*17%.'J./&/ 7.%B0' ,.&%'

5%'.'020.'5*7%//) %'5..  .2 '%5 '".% /,)',5. .5%'

@2''1/'20/*1

% %) ' .%& @.%.0.'

5&)2/0 %" / 77%/ 7 '".%  0&/%'

 .%'* "0."0 /.%%'2. <%)%*% /".1% !$;8$ ,.% /5%'&//%'

% /.&0) '.2,6) 6.*5%'&//%')7%7% % %)' "'.% %)5%'&//%')7%7

% %)5%'

'.5 *% 0 /.)7%7 .2 '.0' 5. "70/.%'5 ')7%7')7%7

E-F ./'20*5 %%) &.%1%9 5.)

 ''0 /.'%0:%22&% *'/ 1*1. 0"&*15%1"%/&%%12 *"/0 /6&

+8". !$ & .<0'/& "0'@2''1*%/

.'7%/ .2 ',"'%/'/,)%1'%*'..&%)%7% ' .%) &.%1%*15%1"%222%2&/ 7',"')% %* ECF .*1%")  /,5/ " /% 170 /

  "5..)207 // E!F ')''/   , -  .

)* ,   .



        

 3 -#C;"# $

 

 !

"# 888 %.% /.''0'. % '

8888

' ( 3 4% 5%/26 7.,/&%, ".%22&% 82 '

KKKK

.%' ')  / .%22&% ,.'%)'

%5/'0*<&%<0'@&2 '% /-#+/%1'G/%1 " 7. 52 '%5/

3'% /'/'2'/"

  , -  .

)* ,   .