High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14776/2013allowed

Harish Garg v. Chandigarh Administration And ORS.

2016-11-10Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari8 pages

!"## $% &

!"#$%&! '%())%

*)+!!!"#$%&!!#

,!+,"#$%&!'%(%#

"## $% &

' ()

())%&!--.# !#%)&!)#/0 (%#&%--.%$ #)&!-%--.!#%()!-" &% 12" !#).! '% 3 -!+ 4)& 4! ),# % 2 252"

252!#27 25189, :3" :6!# :7;

! %, ) &-!) # % '!& ! ())% !# <%)# :

)&%/)%-%.0;&%,!#-')/'%)&% (-)% !--.! !-%/!)#%%)&89, :=;),#/0)! %--&%!#"!#).!4/0&%$0)%,.%/ !# ,#(%$))%%'

! 8)% >&>;

!)#%)&"())%!/!+#%#(%) ! %,/0!(!)&,-!#!"'!)-).4)&&%$0/04!0%' 4!!%'!%!!& %'(%(04%,-#/%#% )%#)(,.!#).'!&!())%!#!+!# ))%

)!)#&%, )&!%'(%#!!( !# &%#))%%'(%(&,")'&!#)#!-!$!)#&%,/'% 9()0%'&%,"4)--/-)!/-%(!0%' 3-!+! &% (!)%" -%)&,#/0(%#)),#,% )# #(!,89, :;

)&!%'(%#! ())%!#<%)#%15 5?

25289, ;!#)'% !)% 4!.)$%5 25289, :;.!#).,#%' !)#&%,4)&-#%),!&%'%)& ! %,&-!) # )%/!)%'!'')#!$)#!#53 25289, :3;4)&4! ,/ )#/0())%!) %'!((-0).'%!# ))% %,-'%())%!!-%'#%&-!,2=%' (%(&, %'(%(&,(%$)##!!&%!& /%#:)# )0/%#!#%/9&,#/0&!#)#!4%<%)# !)#&%,"!#4%,-#/-)!/-%(!0!, %' 3-!+) &!-!$&%,/'%)&% (-)% ! !#! ,# # $ % &''

" "

( &'' )

+ ' " ,-+( " '

" .

/ '(

'' ) " ' & 0 ( ( & " "

'' + + & - '

" &'' "'1 " '

/ &''

" '

" / "

" )

" &'' ' " " 0" ( & 2- 2.

*( "

- '' ''

( " 3 ,, ,,, 4 5

' '(6 " ' (

2 7 )%#)(,#!)(,,!&%'!# ))%/'% )# )0/%#&%,-#/9&,#"())%!#!-!#0-' )),)&!#%-0,#)#'%5#!0 %) ,&&)&, !&%&%$0,#&/04!0%', !0 (%&#,"),!/- &)%?6%'&(%$)#(%&#, /04)&&%$0&!/''&#4)&!#!,# @?6 %&'%&%$0%'!! ,/<&% %(%$))%%')&"!!!%'-!#$, !0/&%$#/0!0%% %%''%--%4). (%&"! -0 8!;/0$)&%'4)%'# !#%#'!,-A 8/;/0!!##)%%')(%A 8&;/0#)!#!-%') %$!/-(%(0 !#,&,%,.!

#&%(A 8#;/0!'%'%-#).)(&%'4)& !!)#,A 8; /0 !!& %' ! % %-#). ) (&%'4)&!!)#,A 8';/0!,- %'! %'!! %%-#).A 8.;/0!-%'!!%%-#).A 8; /0 (%&#). !.!) % ) %$!/- (%(0%'#'!

!#). %' &)% 4%,-# .% % % %4 ! &%$0!#!!%'-!#$,&!/#%/0$!)%, %#

&)%1,/&-!,8?;!#86;%'&"(%$)##')))%%' -!#$,!#!!4)&!#!,#

#486 #'+

7 ' '+

( ('

" ' ( &( " ) "

: & ;

( 4!6 # " '+

7 '

& " &

%,-'%())%!'#%9,% ,/ )!4!-!&!#)#!!# )#"!#!-%%-! #!"4!%%&!#)#!!$!)-!/-"!' '%"% -%!/&!,#%(%#!!4!04!0.%). $!&!

%,-'%(%#"%%!#",/ ) !(%(&,:!#/%%+"!'%&%'-!4"'%"!,&") /)#).,(%())% %4$"4!%)!(%))%%%4 !%4!0&%$0&%,-#/''&#/0%).%, !0 %#,# & ) !/& %' ! %, !$). / # )#" ! ( -!4" !# 4 # !# % /!) %' !'')#!$)"&%,-#/!/- ),%'%).%, !0(%&#,")&%$# !.!)(%#+().)$)4()&)(--!)##%4)/ 1 5

. ($ . "25 8; 15= !)#&!"#)(,(!)).%-)&&' 4)&4!&%$!/-'% %&)04%4!,&&',- /)## %--&%!##)&#%&%$! %,"!#),# %)& 4)& !# / ) (,.# ) &)$)- ,) )#). 4!

+ &%##!#'#!4!%)-#%&%$! %,4)%, .). ) !#<,#)&!# '% %, % !,%)0 %' &% ( <,)#)&)% !)# $)4 4! ,(-# /0 ) %, /0 '! ). ,/!)!-D,)%%'-!4!4%--&%&!),! &%$0 %)& 4)%, !#<,#)&!)% %' ! %, !# !''%#). %((%,)0%'!).%(-!))''

-$!%/$!)%!# !,# #< 0 " ( ''

(

&'' ''

& '& " ""

( " '( ( ''

" ''

" ""

( ) = &

" "" ( " '"" > 5 ' "

;;,>? ; & . % '

" " " '"" ( (

5 4 6 @' & " " @' " ( ? + ;

'""

"' ( "

' ,;? ;,,<? ; 0 "

" " " & "

@' &' + /

"" '

" " '

' '

' " ' &

"' "" ( "

" (

(

A( " (

( " "

' . " ) & " " '' ** ** ** ** ?

( " '

/ " "

8! "

& ' " "' '

" '

( B .

3 "

' ''

( '

& "

(

" (

( " '

(

" '

;, /

" .

& '

' (

" & (

(

" ( " '& $* ' " "

' "

( ( ( '

0 "'( '

" " '&

( * / ( ( .

8! "

''(

& &

* & & ''

' 0

(

' '

& '& C ( " & '' " C '

' & ''D

'( ''

' E '" ''

' ' 0 & & "

' * & '

' '

& '& / " ' " "

' " '" ''

' .

' " '" ''

' "

' / "

) &

' & ""

7 E().)$)4!/%$%/$!)%")&!/!'-0 -# ! ! %, &! / &%$# /0 ')-). !((%()! (%&#).!$!)%, #)!!$!)-!/-%(%# ) #-%!0!())%!-%.!!((%()!&!&% &%! % )

'&&!!-%/ !#%%/$!)% %') %,)F 2161)-#!@

= * /

. / >"#&)##%27 5 25?

4)!-%%(%!)%!#%,.%&%$! %,4)& (!)#%'%& %',0/%# %(%!)%!#,"

/-.!#% #0%'&)$)-&%,+().)$)4%' (%$))%%'&)%6%'%!&&"762 %/$!)% !#!,# #/ & & (

( & &'

" /

& '& & ( "' ' ( &

= &

5 &''

(

& '& 0

'&(

- *+

" ( = '

& ( &

= 0 '

& '

"" ( &''

' 0 .

!> " 0 !;

& ( ( )"

'( " "

& '

7 ) )-!&)&, !&")%,)F 3?3251 )-#!F / ( . #&)##%15 25?"!-#!%-#)./!&+%' %).)!-#%&, ")%!/-%!&&%,%' !+).) ).%'%&,0/%# -$!(%)%%'<,#. !#!,# #

'( "

& &' '( "

''( & " = &

(

'( & " & ' ( '

( "

( ( "'

0 &

" "' "

&' &' ( ' " .''( ( ' " " &

&' & '

&' '

( '7 F)%,&% ).% )%'&!(!)).% ).%'&%$0")'!0"%'(%#")%,)%' %())%!%!,&%, !0(%&#,/0%). %(%$))%%'&)%!/- &&%#).-0")%,)%'%())%!%4&!, %)& ,# (%&#). /'% &%&# &%--&% ! % !)!)!/-"!D,!# %4$")) !#&-!!))%('% (%#%!.)!)&-!) /'%&%,%'&% ( <,)#)&)% $)4 %' !/%$" (%# 4)-- , %).)!-&)')&!")'!0"%())%4))!()%#%'4% 4+'% #!%'&)(%'&)')#&%(0%'%# 5 25?

G"##-.

--/0-H # "2 E = - G -C E '

-C