High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1895/2005allowed

Baggar Singh v. St Of Hry

2020-03-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

""# "$ %%&& '#

)#* % +#

# $#$,(%-. #$%%&& )#%#/(#-,-)#* 1$ %%& #"

$2("3 .

4 5

## 5

6*&# &

7("-# .8$$( ""# "$8

. # ( # 9# #("

+ *$#%(6 - $# #### $

( #"#"#( 3%# 3 # . *# %*

: (&$#-(#$#( #"#"#(

3%# 3 #%# *# 1$( .; ""# "$-8$ %%&& 6# $ (#%#* $$%%&6%-$3%("

2("3 $ . 6 $6<($$#"

#3"

#&* -$ $ %#$%#

#*#$

-%&%#*#3+& "($- ## $6*=3 $/(3# $# #### = "#:= -)$ %& #.&& "

&.$&8 %#& #3 (* 8$ ($ .$&##* "$%&%#*#$6#" 3&# # .&&" (&%(# /$#- ( ""# "$ 8 % 3 "#3.&&">?#8& 6*&8$"(

*6"%& ###@ "$%&%#*-$ %%$6*& # %@$8 %%#$ $6 % @$ *8

.#@ $ = " # % 3 #6 $ "(

*6"%& $###6*&( - ($$ #.

( $(% $( %%# "$3$

#"$ #$6#"A##" #@$( $8.# #% $ $ = " #@ $## $ = " # % $ "(

* 6" ( $ 8

"%%%* #8@$?(8 3%&

"3 $ $##3 8"$$# (-8$$3(4 ?"

"3 @ $ 3%& # (8# .# %#& - &8$$ & = "#$. "

#% B/B@ ($#& 8#?

%&%

@$6*&( 3?& 8 & A@ $= "#$ .#$ &#( =7" $ $ #@$$%#%##(< $ 3%&

("($$#("$

6&7%- $6 8$$#3&C=

! 9

#$ ( $8

#" #6*)3 $/(3#@$= "#%#%# #("$ %& $%&#.#* ## 8

@$%#%##%#( 5$@ #(# $%& -$( %( $&?(%-8$# $ %#%#*8 #( )$ %& @#%#( # 5$8 +-)<(##-# 3%&%#& 8 ##-C>-$(6

##%#%##3C>-$(6 - 3%&

" $##3& -$&& "

%#%# & $(# =8

7("-# %# $&& $(#-% (3

#&(% $$&& 8# (%%&$( #

%#.(

5# + ># &

7("-# - "$%#3 $#"#$ ( $8 & "

$ ( - $#" $ $3 # "&*- 8$$- $ %& "(&* &3#& 1$ 8 D#. $%#

1 6# " $3 "(& $ ( - $ %#

D3 3 * .8

%#& 6&8

+E3 $/(3#-)-#3&8

. $ .FD + +E =+$&/(3#$ $ 3%&

4 " $ -$$%#%#$&&

& $(# +E!

6&$ >&-" #3&8

(63 $ .FD +

+E4=3 $/(3#-$= "#$ 8$#"#%%#$

$( - "#.#* #6 #3$3 (6 <( %# "

$#"# 8&&

$ " (6*$3 $ +E =7" $$ #-8

#.#*%

$#"# 1$%# # . C>#%# FD +7 E$$$%# . & 3 $( ##( !!

# + - 8$$&&$ #3 "#(3 %%# ""

$38#%($36($ $&&"

"$$8

$6 & &* .&. $ $

,(# "$->36##.&&">??#8&6( $$$8

8#? "8$ ,(# "$ 3 &&6(## $#8 3 %(68 $3#"# "%*3 &6(#$#" #$ # $$ 6 .&. $

( & *. #$# "#"(3 - &

7("-# . $( #$ ( $ 3 (%#-8$$&$3""#. $$ &$ %# %%&

= $. $# &# (

& # $ %%&& ( . &#

., #&#$)#* 6 " "$#("$$## 1$# &%# %& #3 &2(# %#( #$$ %# 3( %#. $#""

$( 6* $8 # 6&(6 ($ %#."(&$( $$&

#* $%# .# $ 1$( D%%#.$ 8$ 3D

#"#-8$8$$ $%# #<(#%#."(&$( 1$(

#<(## # &*# 6& %&( 6&D%& -8$$ 3* (6 $3 6($#($(&

$%#

#* C(#$#3#- %#(#2(# %#( -$( # "(&*%#

3*" #6(.

$(& 6%( $ %#$%# #*-$#.#*$6

)8.#- 8 %#( $ 8

#(&&*-$ 3 ($+E4=3 $/(3# &&8-$

#$%# ".$#.#*

3&#&*+E =7" $$ #-$$##.#*8

& ". $#.#*

! 7(

(#$$3"$ $.6 ". # (&*%"#%$&3 ?-$#

## .# (&#& 8#%#( -8$# $$ 6

! % 6$ $ 8

9 D%& #3 "8# "#.#* 3 "#$

$ 8

F. &# "- %%& 8

3. 6$& $ %# $ .# &*- $

#.#* $ 6 6

! 6* $ 8 %#

8$ 3#$#.#*$? %&

8 $ $( ( !!

# + $ #3 " #(3 %( $3- $ #.#*$ 6 3 6

! # 3%& *# 1$". 6"2&$%# #* %( <(

3#?.#$" (

$%# .# (# -$ ( "#&*%#2( $ # 3#$ "6 $ $6&8$ # 3 = "#-$# .#8# " $3 $

#" &&*8 3 5 5

8$ 6*8*.#8# " 8 $ "

1$ 8 36*+E4=3 $ /(3# &&8 $ #

D3 8$( ". " * D%& #$ 3 C(#$#3#- 3 6* +E4 = 3 $ /(3# &&8 $(# & D $ %#%#*FD +- 8 & 8#( 6 6#? 1$& # (6 $3 6(" (

$%# #* '8 $ D- 6 $6$$8

#.#*#& 8

1$("$%

#%#8$$ % 8

( &

33.#& 3%& $# # 3$#(6(&#(3 3(6$# $## = .8 $ .#8# " $ 6&8 "

(# $ = "#6&8 # 3 $#(<-8# " #.#* 6 " ". 6* $ = " # $ #.#*

5 8

$$ % ##6# 3

" $

(3 "

1$ %&#.#* $%% 66( * $#("$# %%&8#3 " " "(# "$#.#* %# "

$ " 6*+E4=3 $/(3# 6( % 8

8 2 1$##- 2 " % 8

% *.&6&* $#6&* $%# #* 1$D%& ". 6*+E4=3 $/(3# $$#2 % 8

6( 8 #* %%&# $3$$$ 8 3 * ($%#

$6 "

($%#

# #( "2 $%&%#* 1$ $## .#& #

68 &8

# "+E4=3 $/(3#-( $#8$6*& "$%&%#*@$%&%#*#(# 2(# * 4 % 3 $%#& $#.&&" (&%(# )8.#- 6*+E =7" $$ # "

$%&%#*-$( ##( 8*#$#8 "$6*&@ $%&%#*#(# 2(# *

% 3 $%&%#* %#& *$#%& $#%&# 6$&&# (

$ %# . FD + ) 3 $ /(3#- 3%& & 3%#

8# % 6*=3 $/(3#8$)$ %& & "8$ $ %#%#*# "$ 3 ##-C>-$(6 #3%# 8$ & %#%#* )8.#-# ".+E!

6&$ >&FD +

C>%# +7- 3%& &8 $ .#6*+E)3 $ /(3#+E!

6&$ >& 8 & #. C>-$(6 8$$ %#%#* &$("$$ 3%&

&3%#

8 % 6*+E4=3 $/(3#8$) 3 $/(3# 1$##-(& #$$##-C>- $(6 8$$ %#%#* C#3&&$ # -# 6&(6$ # 3 6($" (

$%# #* %#&86 (6 6". $( 1$#&(#$ 3 $ % 6( ?$3.# &*$%# E$# $ # $(&$.6

# %#%# %# %.- $ 8* $ %# #* (& $. 6

% 1$##-( ( 6 &6 (6 1$( -= $$2("3 . ##

6*$(#6&8# 6& 1$ 3# 6*8*% $ %%& 1$%%&& <( $$#"( $6*". "$36 (6 9

#* 3 6 $<(## # !

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#