Radhey Sham v. F.C. & Principal Sect. To Hry Govt. & ORS
!"# "
$!%&'($)"*+"#
$,-).-$/
0&1&
$%$//&&$, %2$.%$)/!$)$$ 3-&
&2,&
!"#$ %&'()$ )(
#*%&+,$
&'
(
1$+.,%$4- ( 0$5-$$+,%$3 (& (%$-$61+,%$+ !-2
(
$75.8-++$)$$+ !-.$
( .
.
$$+,%$+ !&2,
:::::
)(
#*% -&-2,-2&42&4-- -.%)+5)$ !-2%,8&1,.% #"!- $)$$ ;2$ .%& %+ <= >! &- ?$)$$ %@A+ %,-$/1!/-2+4-4$&468$&$$&- 8$,8$8,/&$222$$,/5BB/!- $/1!
&
+# +###C;
-4,&+4--&1%-,&2141,!$4-- /&%-!!.%& #" #9!-$)$$% (
1$+$,.1&$&&&,5)0$5-$ $+2&8-2&15/,-$-24$&$22,
$&$6$,&15&D1) #
< 2/,$&$&-$,4- 468$&$$&-4--$6+-4$&&5)-$%-($$8 58$%$&-$/1! &
##$%&!/- $$6!//%
&$&1-!+-2-$,8-$!/,$6 $84-&%1)81$,$,%$/5$%64--%$&-$/1+4-%- 4$&,1)$%%1,! -%$&-$&$%&%1,,18-$5&% !-2 -%-%68-%$&--$, "
=$
(+ $&1/! &
+# +###C;4$&!1,&& -&$%%1+!48- $%&4$,$8$&-2'; $A
*,$, "
=4$&8&,E 5A 2$/$D1)4$&$,E$, %A 5$2%,8&4$,
!1- &15/, -$ - 2 D1&, %1 4- - $!/, ,2$/$ D1) $, $5$ 2%,8&$,71,%$!-%/$%$&+51-&$/4$& $%%2,5)-$6+4-%-%&$,-/!$.15$8 ="! =&68&$ 4+-/2$)71%4$& ,%,+51-$22$2!,$8$&-$!/,,4$& $%%2, -,!-22$14$&%-$8,5)-.%) -&15)!8 & =<! $,-&1+, ,,$,"9 *
+,&/&&,-&$/4-$,%-$1 F2,-,&2&$!-&1+51$&&15/,$5+-$6-$, $$,)$,2%,8&1,.%& #"$, #9!-$)$$ %!&68%)!-$/1! &
+# +###C;$84-&
2!/+-24$&2%,,F;2$+51-$! - F;2$ 2%,8& 4 &;$&, 4+ - /$4-+
-
%/$ 2%,8& $, $8$& - 2 21&1$ - 8&$ ! - &1, $%D1$ 5) - -! 1,%$ ($8&$ , 71,8/ ,$,
>F1 ;*A - $!/,71,8/4$&$&&$,5)-.$!$)$$5)!8 /$22$ <;!
,$&?.$!$)$$0&1&
$,-).-)$/@$,5)-&2,;$65)!8/$ & "9!
,$&?--4$2$$6G/,+-4$ 0&1& $,-) .-)$/ $, $-@ $, -& 1+ , , ,$, "
< "## >F1 ;
A+%%,-2!%-$8&1,.% =#< $,&%,-/1,881&/2&/!- )$&$,2$)$!! & #+###C;
-2-$,$22$%-,- H5.12/15)!8.G > A 9<# !"# #+4-%-4$& 8&,$&/$22$
!"# #$,-H5.12/ 1+,71,8/,$,"*
"# #+/$,,-/$5$%6-& 1$,/$,+,,,$, # "
"# *+2$&&,,18- %1&!--$8+-&1$%D1,-2 )88-$!/,!$%+-$&,-D1&! /$$$5) ! - $5$ 2%,8& $, 5) !8 - 2&&!.% #"+/1%-&&&15;&%>"A-!%,-$ F2&&?%&1+/$$8/-51&&&!$%;2$ &%)@41,%1,$,&21!%)!-$/15)$%; 2$5$6$8$&&/2)$&-%$/-$&F2&&)5,!, 1,%$1&>$A!&15;&%>"A!.% #"!-$)$$%5 ,1!/$//5+/+-&8$2&$&!$,%$&, //5+4--&1%-,5,/$,5$,/,$%$/5)$ &1) $8$& - 2%2$ ,5 $,+ -!+ $5$
.
2%,8& $, - $22$ 2!, $8$& -! 4 4-1 71&,%
!1-&15/,-$/-.%)-$&5 $558$),%1/$),%%,!-$8,&-$8+ F%2+-$8,$,/&&,$, "
=>F1 ;
#A$&- 24$&%/2,$,%%,C!%5)/2,&1!!-&$/ 48--$!8&$!- +51)-
*! = 4$& 8&, - $8, $,/&& & $& 2 - 2&& ! .%&"
$,"9!-,$,%% &122!-&%+ ,12-$,%,,%1,1
/' 01 02 343 567 6
6"6 86 9 1 3*'4/ :
463 3 %,-$-,2$/$2%,8&+/2,1%! ,%1/$) ,% & 18- $& -) -$ 5 2, 5) F$/8-4&&&$,-$5$2%,8&+-&2,; $6-$&F$/,-($$8-!!%5!4-/-$8, $,/&&>F1 ;
#A4$&/$,+/1%-&&-&$/-$&52, $%%,$%4-$4 -&!$%&4$&,5!-5$+ /1%- && - $1-& 54+ + - $%$ //&& $, //&&+2$.%&+&182$&&8!-$4$, ,$,
"
"#
>F1 ;
A$,-,,$,"* = "# ">F1
;
"A!- $%$//&&,&/&&8-$22$2!,1, .%
=!-$)$$%
%$+( .
.
$$+$,%1&!&2, &15/,-$-D1&!/$$$5)!-$5$2%,8& -$&$$,)5,5$,125)-&%-!-&1
#6'16:62 343 (1 '6 6;6 66 9 1 3* <
#%<=*4-+4-28-2&&!.%& =$, ! - 17$5;2$.%&%+ * +4-%-$2$/$$- $)$$%+-$&5-,-$-5$41,-$-71&,% &2%!-,&21&8$,8-$5)!$2&/$$88- $!!$&!-2$.%) !1-&15/,-$4!-$,/&&+2%! ,%4$&D1,52, -2-$&,,- $!/,$,/&& -2,%)!-%/$2%,8& ,,,5$-$6$2%,8&$&,2$/$D1)&! ,&/&&$!-/2)+$5$2%,8&$!%)$, %/$2%,8&$!21&-8-8!!%$ -D1&!;/$$$5)!
-2-$&$& 5,$5)-$1-&$,7%,$,+-!+-2 %$ 5 2/, $& - $!/, 2$ - F2&& ?/$$8/!-&%)@41,$&%1,!$1,1 ! /)-22)!-.
5) - H5 .12/ 1
68 6 '6:46 2 343 >
/ 6 68 '
? ;#9*
686/66 96
1 * = )
'=-1&+-%!( $&5$&,12-48!$%&$, $557%,
-$-$,-$,%1&!-2$&+$22$&,- 2$256$,!-4-$-&!%$,/-&15/&&& !( $
, $22%$ - %&)+ 41, 5 $2 2,1%.% #"!-$)$$%+4-%-$,&-1&';
!
=
!""#$%
&
"""#
&
&
% ' !
!
(
!
!
!
!
) !
(
!
!
!
!
&
!
(
!
)
)
)
(
*
& +
""""
,&
!
-
!
&
!
!
!
&
!
(
&
!
(
./ )
*
!
&
!
*
)
0
*
1 - !& 51&-+ - $81/ ! ( $ D1$ ;
/$$$5)!-$5$%$&5!- 8&$$22$,5 $$%+2$%1$)5)!8-2&&!.% #"!- $)$$%8$,8;/$$$5)+51-F2&&?/$$88 !-$!!$&@-$&$$,)5,5$,5)-H5.12/1
68 6'6:44!3?63 34/6+-$2$,&$&1,'; ?/
2 3 4 5 6
&
*
4
& 5
!/7*89:2 .:; & 5
08
5
9/
5
089!
&
< 5
9 =
+
4& 4 !
!
08
! 5
9 =
<
- ! 5
9
& &
=
&
&
5
08
=
!
5
9> &
5
& 5
08
? !
5
@
5
1 ! !
& 5
08 )
*
+
)
*
5
9 <
;
! & !
)
5
08?
& +
!
08
;
&
&
.: ) 5
.A
5
.8!
5
2* *
5
08
! &
) 5
.A
)
/
)
5
5
.A!
/ &
! !
) ; &
)
*
4
2* *
) 4
/ ! !
) 5
.A
!
*
*
9;
! !
08 <
; 5
08
! +
& ! *
5
9
+
; !
! +
1 -&$/-$&5-,5!4,$/21,5)$68 %&,$-!$1,1!/)+-!+-D1&4- 8$,/$$$5)!-2+-$&4&!$1!- &2,;$6$,$8$&-2+&&%-%! ( $4-8$,-/$$$5)&-5)7%,
4$&/&+4---&2,;$6-$&,&%-$8, -$5)4-%- -$&$$228 !$%,&215)F$/8 - ,%-$8,$,/&&!-2+&&%--$& 5%/2$%!-2&&!.%" !-,$,%%+ -$&4&IH 41,5$22,1%-2&&!.%"
!-,$,%%+4-%-$,&$&1,'; ,
B !
<
& &
B !
&
(
&
B
&
!
=
< &
B !
!
B
!
&
. < &
B !
=
!
&
!
=
!
.< &
B !
& 1
/-21&$!-$4$,!- 8&$$,-,!
- $%$//&&+4--$&%/%,-$-$6 -$&+$$)2!/+F$/,-/$$85!4-/-$,/&& -$&5/$,5)-2+/1%-&&-2-$&5 %!,,%-$/1 -$8,$,/&&%1, -$5$,$8$&-2 -1&+-$64$&D1,2 %,-/$$+ +-%$&-56!$8,&-!$ ,15+-2-$&5$%D1,!-%/$ %-$8&$,-!,8&!-%/$%141,-$5,8!!% -%,&21+-!+41,5!$8/)&!5)$68-$, !!,8&!$%D1$,,5)-&1+51-!$%/$&-$- $6-$&$%1$),&%-$8,-1& !%!$%,5)-
8&$-$8-!5$&$&+/)4+1&$, !$$%1& $& ,%1/& - -$ - $8, $,/&& -$& 5 518-%, -&!$%&4D1,52,,12$, %,5)-$1-&+4-&2%!%$)18,$,$&, $8!$, $, &1%- 2&+$/!-4-$ -!,8& $ &1&$$5-)&!$4
-$!/,4!/&$&$,!/-
71,8/%,$&
/' 01 0+4--H5.12/1+ 4- ,$8 4- - 2%,1 ! ,2$/$ 2%,8&+ -$, $ %%$&-,-$-2,1%!-,%1/&&&1!!% %/2$% ! ,&%-$8 -& -$ 5 2, 5) F$/8 - 4&&& $$8$2-& =$," !-&$,71,8/$2,1%,$& 1,';
!
"#
# $
#
% #
&%#
'( )
#
#
*
#
#
*
!
+
#
! !*
#
#
# #
#
# 4$&$)&/2%$&!-$6,&%-$8-1&5) $,8-,%$&,%$,$5$,-$8!$,,&+$/! -4-$-$5)! &
+# +###C;$84-&J #K%1, -$5!$&,12-2
&1$)+,,$,
"
"#
>F1 ;
A,,5) -5$$,-,,$,"* = "# ">F1 ;
"A2$&&,5)-
$%$//&&$&1&$$558%&$%4- -2&&!.%"
!-,$,%% &$4,
6;=* )(
# 6:
%&+,$ 1 1 3/ 68 0@
3@
1 1
/ 67
3@