← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16367/2019disposed of

Satish Kumar Kakkar v. The State Of Haryana And ORS

2020-08-07Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal16 pages



   !

 " #$%$& $!'$$ $  $&$!

  (

 )*+,-./,00/ (((((((**/  )1 /2+/ ((((((!3 (  

 !+-4)+/.+/ (((((((**/  )1 /2+/ ((((((!3 (5 6

 !+ (((((((**/  )1 /2+/ ((((((!3 &1**7 ( 5(

 !$7

8%9 !(# )  $9,)

$!$9 

  



    

 ! "#$#% &'"(

  )*+ 

*   

! ("&& &'"(

+  

 ! ",#'- &'"(

  

. /0  

  

 *  !  2

"#$#% ("&& ",#'-

&'"( 

 3   

4

       0 

**

 *

 60 0 7

   60  &''$

* 8  60 0  :

 0 6 0;

 &'"'

9    < &'"'

=;8  * 



* &- '( &'"'

  530 "$ - &'">

 



<



5=   @  .*   6  0 6  9    66;

   *

 





    $'

-$

&'"'



  





6 ? /0  5  



@



/0  5



 50 



* 

* +

 

 

  

                



                   ! 

       " 

    " 

  #$%&'



  ( )*+ 

     ,  #   + 

        *   

 



 -  .+ 

   /'       '0                

 

1+ A 

 &'( 3    *  @  

A "

$ &'", &'"'

 

  >9;

  60 0 

&# # &'", *





@



  5

*** 3 

669;  

5

 .*

 3  B  @

66  

5

***  50 3* 7 

       

        !

  ) 

* *

   *  *                       ,                    

     3  

            * *4   $5   ,                    

     3       3      

      + 



       

*( 4  "#     + )    

 

  "+  

 

       3     *    6    *   #  7 #  /5$5    

:

         7       "+   7 

  *  (   * (   

  "   **+ # "       3  ,    

  *  (  * ( +   ) 

* *



         "+   "+ 8   

  !       3 **+  



   

                      ,9(     

          

  * (  *  (             1+   5  

@ 

6 ? 0 &'"#







 5

0       

#> 0  

 50  5 

 *

  

 



3 

"

!     @    @

  *       



 530 5 @ 0

 .

0 

 @     @

 530 5 *0 

       @

C &

! 53 

*7**

#& 0 B *0  50 

    

 3   50  *7**

  #> 0C !  B  @     @

 

#> 0  5

* 

53 5  *0

   50

#& 0C    *  53 **

&'"'

     5

 D0 



/0 '% '% &'"(  

 3  *

  

/0    &, , &'"(  0

     *0

    B      5   

  3  7   > 9 ;

 60 0  :

 0 6 0;

*  &'", 9    < &'", =;

@

5  **



   

     5 

     *

4 

 

 !  2

"#$#%

&'"( 5* ** 5  0 &'", *

&'"'

    5   0

/

 5*   

 + 0 53 **  

  

  &'"'

5

/

 5*

5

0 5

  5   



*  

  )*+   

 !  2

("&&

&'"( 5*   .*  B@  

#> 0 *

  B 

 ** &'"'

@  0 + 3  *  



 0

5



**   5



8

*0 8 5 5 

*0* 

/

 5* 0 &'"# @  * 5    0    50    

&'",  .

A  

     . /0   



/0

    .   60 0

  0   



 5   0  

 +  + 5    0

* 5  *

1  7*

 *



      

 

6 6 

0  *

 .* 3 0 0 *  *

 

  0  



0  *    *



B *

   

*  .*  0  3*

+ * 66  5 

  *BB @      *

*   0

 * 

  *

   50





   5  5   5

*    .

  5 5

* * 

* 



A   



 0 &'",     B 0 5   5 

      9;



5 





 * * 0 

 

  0 



 

6 6       +     +  7*      66 +

*

5  * 



  



5

5 



 

      5 D0 '% '% &'"( 

    

 *  

+  0

 

?

    + *

  0

* 5     **

 5 * 





6 ? 

 

 

6 ?   





*



5 

5  

/ 

    0  0 

        50

*   

  

5*     

  

  0  

0 5  *  

#>   0    



 0   0 5 *  

  3*

+ *

7  *





 *+ 

0  5   

     0 0

 



 9;

 7 5

    

5

7  *



  0

5    5

   7* 5 5  

 

! "#$#% &'"(    

 *  #()(';<()1 //++/ 9&'"";

#  >%'



 5*

/85 *     7*

*

 **5

/* :  **

 

 **5

** &( # &''#



> 0   $'

# &'""

 **  * 

 

&$ ""

&''#

/85 *   7*

*

 <=  &'

&&  7     

 5 + 0

( <$:

 EF   .3;

-4

9# 6 ;



">#$ EG

7G G G 5G *

/



  

5 G  G 5      :  EF     0*   5* 0

*     G * 70

 5    

0

  

     

<

;

  4

9? 6 ;



"$(% EF   EH4I   5    0G *G 5  *  G   = 9 .     

    .  H9"((#;

(  >"#

?:

"((#  "($#I  

>&%  "% ;

(  <= *0    **

7   

  0* 

0 

! 

   <=  3 *

< 5  5  =

?  < *= < 7= 5    0 0 

 < 7=   *5

 *     

1   < 7=   <  =    5       **



9   6

+ 

"  7  +  -+ H9&''-;

"

 ##$I ;

(  <  =   

0  0

    

*   



     + 0 0 

  0 0 * 

   =   J8  9;    **5

**

    5    



  

 *    50

4      *   K 1 ! 2 ","-$

&'",

D*0    *  5  .

 3*

 6 50  * 

 *  



 *

K 1

4

   L  1  * ,+;94#+94;(+94%+=>$! 5  )    

 #*.4    .32  ;( ..**/ 9&'"#;

">  "&>

1 

 *  0

   5

 *

 5  

 

? *0   /85 *  )1 //+;(!.++/)+/.+/ 9"((>;

#  >&%  7

 

 * ,-./* )+/*40+<*2/+*(<()1 +/ 9"((";

"

 &"&   

    .

*   *  *  .



    * 

 * 

6 



   1 8)1 ((<(

*//4+/8 &'"";

>  $'>       *

  *    

*7**

   

* #& 0 #'

0   .

0

2   7*  *

)*+

   

  *  * 5

 *  B+ 

#> 0 7   &'"#     0

*  5  +

   .

 5    

  0 +

* 5  *

   +

* 0



7  *

 

3

  

 *0  

  5

0 &'"#  *   5



A  5* 6 6  0  0   0

 *

* 3*

+

  

*0   +



 

  *0   



     0

:

   

5 0

**

/   

 5



1  +



*0   *0

0  5 



   0        * 

  * 

  

*  . 5 2

  *

    0 5 5   5

  

    50 5 

  

*    

669;    0 &'"#  0 &'",    +  

#> 0

/  /0   5  

0 

0  

#& 0

  7*

  0 7

?



#&    B * 

  5

* 0

  

   

 *





 0

/

0  * 

 5

 

* 

 **  

#& 50  

*     * 0



0 5



#& 0   * 

  

 5 *

* 



?

 

6 6  

  5

 + 0 +    0   5 0   70   

0 3*

+ * *

)

    

 

***

#& 0

0    50   5     *+

 

  

( 5(

$9,)

$!$9 +B+

# &

! + B J 2 ! :5 J 2