Agya Pal Singh Bath v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And ORS

 


   
   
   
   
  
  
  
         




!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'()#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, )#*+#, - .

- .

- .

- . /'0!+"!"#1#,
,2,!"%'3"4!'4"5#,& #"%"%'#,& 6& 7!89%"%':5!'4!'"5#, #&2'4#'"&     








 :;!!8%':5 !"5 #"%"%'#, 6& /'0!+"!"#1#,
,2,!"%'3"4!'4"5#,& #&2'4#'"&
7(
7(
7(
7(< 37 
==7  < 37 
==7  < 37 
==7  < 37 
==7  ,#&#'"( 7,!,*%'4#,%':5 -4)$!"#-

,"5#2#"%"%'#,&>%'


? 7,/'%!-,4)$!"#-1%"5 7&!,)##'=!/,-4)$!"#-

,"5#2#"%"%'#,>%'
 

? 7,= ,!,-4)$!"#- , 7, ,!,-4)$!"#-

,,#&2'4#'" >%'


? 7,/,'!-4)$!"#- , 7& =/,'!-4)$!"#- ,,#&2'4#'"& ">%'
 

? ==7 - >3?

==7 - >3?

==7 - >3?

==7 - >3?

"5 "5# 2#"%"%'& +#!,%':
     

     

     

     

 "%"8#4 !& @/'!0+ "!"# 1#,
,2,!"%' 3"4 6& 7!89%" %':5 !'4 !'"5#,A @/'!0+ "!"# 1#,
,2,!"%' 3"4 6& 7!89%" %':5 !'4 !'"5#,A @/'!0+ "!"# 1#,
,2,!"%' 3"4 6& 7!89%" %':5 !'4 !'"5#,A @/'!0+ "!"# 1#,
,2,!"%' 3"4 6& 7!89%" %':5 !'4 !'"5#,A B5#,#%'!

"#, ,# #,,#4 " !& "5# C &" 2#"%"%'<D !'4
      

      

      

      



"%"8#4!&@:;!!8%':5 !"5 @:;!!8%':5 !"5 @:;!!8%':5 !"5 @:;!!8%':5 !"56&/'0!+"!"#1#,
,2,!"%'3"4!'4 /'0!+"!"#1#,
,2,!"%'3"4!'4 /'0!+"!"#1#,
,2,!"%'3"4!'4 /'0!+"!"#1#,
,2,!"%'3"4!'4 "5#,&A "5#,&A "5#,&A "5#,&AB5#,#%'!

"#,,# #,,#4"!&C"5#'42#"%"%'<D!,#+#%':4%&2&#4 +; ! $**' ,4#, +#$!/&#   "5# ,4#, 4!"#4 E   2!&&#4 %' "5# '4 2#"%"%'"5!"%"1/84+#5#!,4!8':1%"5"5# &"2#"%"%' 5# &"2#"%"%'%& %8#4 ,F/!&5%':"5#!1!,44!"#4E  2!&&#4 +; "5# #,*!'#'" 39 4!8!" , /+8%$ "%8%"; #,)%$#&- !,%49" , &5," C"5# 3<D +; 15%$5 "5# !228%$!"%' %8#4 +; ,#&2'4#'"   /'4#,#$"%'>
? "5#8#:!8#,)%$#&/"5,%"%#&$"- EG.B ,&5," C"5#$"  EG.D$5!88#':%':"5#4#*!'4,!%&#4+;"5#2#"%"%'#,-%'"#,*&   #$"%' >?   "5# 8#$",%$%"; $"- 

 B , &5," C"5# $"<D , /'!/"5,%H#4 /&#   #8#$",%$%"; 5!& +##' 4#$%4#4 +; ,#&2'4#'"  !'4 ,#&2'4#'" 5!&+##'!&9#4"2!;'8;
. -

I!:!%'&""5#4#*!'4
-

-EI 3#!,'#4 $/'&#8 , ,#&2'4#'"   5!& &/+*%""#4 "5!" 2/,&/!'" " "5# ,4#, 2!&&#4 +; "5# 3
. -

I 5!& !8,#!4; +##' 4#2&%"#4  1#)#,- 8#!,'#4 $/'&#8 , "5# 2#"%"%'#, &/+*%"& "5!" "5# !1!,42!&&#4+;"5#3%&2!"#'"8;%88#:!8!'41%"5/"0/,%&4%$"%'!&"5# %*2/:'#4 ,4#, 2!&&#4 /'4#, #$"%' >?   "5# $" $/84 '8; +# $5!88#':#4+;1!; !'!22#!8/'4#,#$"%' . "5#$"!'4"5#3 5!4'0/,%&4%$"%'!"!88"4#$%4#"5#&!*# !*%'!:,##*#'"1%"5"5#2#"%"%'#,&+#$!/&##$"%' . "5# $" 2,)%4#& !' !22#!8 " $5!88#':# "5# ,4#, 2!&&#4 /'4#, #$"%' >? "5#$"1%"5,#:!,4""5#/'!/"5,%H#4/&# #8#$",%$%";BD
'&#F/#'"8;-"5#2,#&#'"2#"%"%'%&5#,#+;!881#4!'4"5#!1!,42!&&#4 +;"5#34!"#4E %&5#,#+;&#"!&%4#'"5%&:,/'4!8'#



'& !, !& "5# '4 2#"%"%' %& $'$#,'#4- "5# 2#"%"%'#, %& "5# $'&/*#,- 15 5!& $5!88#':#4 "5# ,4#, 2!&&#4 +; "5# #,*!'#'" 39 4!8!">/+8%$"%8%";#,)%$#&?-!"#5:!,5!5%+4!"#4. 

+;15%$5 5%&!228%$!"%' %8#4/'4#,>
? "5#8#:!8#,)%$#&/"5,%"%#&$"- EG. 5!&+##'4%&*%&&#4 "%&'##48#&&"*#'"%'"5!""5#2#"%"%'#,%'"5#'42#"%"%' 5!& !8& $5!88#':#4 "5# 4#*!'4 ,!%&#4 /'4#, #$"%' >?   "5# $" +# ,# "5# #,*!'#'" 39 4!8!" "5/:5 5# 5!4 "5# ,#*#4;   !22#!8 %' "#,*& #$"%' . "5#$" 3#!,'#4 $/'&#8 , "5# 2#"%"%'#, 5!& &/+*%""#4 "5!" 5# 5!4 4#2&%"#4  J   "5# !*/'"   "5# 4#*!'4 !" "5# "%*# 15#' &"!; 1!& :,!'"#4 +; "5%&
/,"  " %& &/+*%""#4 "5!" 5# 1/84 !)%8 "5# ,#*#4;  !22#!8+/""%88"5#'5%&#8#$",%$%";$''#$"%'*!;'"+#4%&$''#$"#4!&5# 5!&!8,#!4;2!%4"5#&/+&"!'"%!8!*/'" ')%#1 "5#!+)#-"5#'42#"%"%'%&5#,#+;4%&2&#4  "%&'##48#&&"*#'"%'"5!"

,#&2'4#'" %'"5# &"2#"%"%' !'42#"%"%'#,%'"5#'42#"%"%'*!;-% &!4)%&#4-!)%8"5#%,,#*#4; !22#!8%'15%$5"5#;*!;!8& %8#!'!228%$!"%'/'4#,#$"%' "5# '4%!'3%*%"!"%'$"- E ,$'4'!"%' 4#8!;'"5#:,/'4"5!""5#; 1#,# 2/,&/%': "5#%, ,#*#4; +# ,# "5#
/,"   8!1 "5/:5 5!)%': ' 0/,%&4%$"%' %'$#,#&2'4#'" %'"5# &"2#"%"%'!'4"5#2#"%"%'#,%' "5#'42#"%"%'5!)#!8,#!4;2!%4*,#"5!'

J "5#4#*!'4,!%&#4+; "5#
,2,!"%'-"5#,# ,#-"%88"5# %8%': "5#%,!22#!8!'4$'&%4#,!"%'

 

"5#%, !228%$!"%' , &"!;- "5#%, #8#$",%$%"; $''#$"%' &5!88 '" +# 4%&$''#$"#4  25"$2;  "5%& ,4#, +#28!$#4'"5# %8#  $''#$"#4 $!&# >==7 ?

>==7 ?

>==7 ?

>==7 ? 67  67  67  67  - . - . - . - .             
 5#"5#,&2#!9%':I,#!&'#4 #&I 5#"5#,,#2,"!+8# #&I