High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/10684/2016dismissed

Shri Charan Dass And ANR v. Union Of India And ORS

2016-05-26Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik,Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta5 pages

!"#"$% & '()"( ) $ ## $ $ ()

"$)# *#

$"$$ "

$ ()# #+$ $ # ,% -., '/ , ,.

-., ' ' . !"# $ "# ' % !" &"'&!# "()*" +&",* - )*.&-/,* -, &&" 0 1/23 ),"

45 $ &&" 0 &"! & !"

1 23 2,*""4 "&" 2 , *""4 & &&" & "

0 &&&" 5 " 0 &"! & !" "& &&" 6%666 "

%%666 "

,*""4 ,2"

1&--&"! "

&" 78 &!5&"&""

$"" &"9"

*0 &&&", &&&""

" *, %7&" , : % *;8$&&"- &"!&" "

! * -" &&" "-&"-- " &"&&" "& $&&" "

-&"! !"

"* - " "

&! "

" $ - " &-&"! & &&" &" & & "& &-" -""

&".&!<", "

&! & 0 & &! & &&""' "!""=& .&!$ &, '&&>& ?"6 %,&" ?"

&"*&5"

"&"&" &"!9&"?"

&$&&" " "

&! &

661 "

& &"

&"!

&"," &"0 &"$" &" &&" " *&5@ -&"!, &&" &- -&

61661,*""4 "

" "

! " %66 ,*""4 " &" &&"! ,"/&",""

" &"!&"

&- "&-&"!!&"+" 66 .& "& &&"

& &"17&8 0 &&&"&"!"

*0 &&&" ?- *,62,A-""0 & &".&!<", "

&!,>

%&" &"!"

9&9 " B&" " $ ,"

&!* &"&&"&

""& &&" 6%666,*""4 &" 9"

*0 &&&"*, 7&",: *;8&"-/&"! !"-&&"

% "

&"1 */&"!0 & %% &".&! <"&" &"!"

" & &&" "

&"!,

& C 0 ","& &&" "

&" * & * &"!&&"," "

&!-""4&"!& && C&"2* *& "& &&"$&&" & "&"

,*""4 && &"0 &" &"! " & 4 0 &&&"$9"

*0 &&&"

& & &"!""& "

&"6 * &&" ,*""4 1&" 0 &

&" &"!"

&&"$ " " "&" 3 &&" -&"! " &" &&" " &D $ ! 1"&" "

" * &"!&&",-" "& ""&"& *!!&- ,&&" & 2% &"&

"2 E-"-& &&" $ ,&&" & & & $&&" *4 $&&" *4 &"

-& &&" & &" &&&" & * &"!&&",

"" %*,&! -"

"& "&""

& " &-&

&"! 4& " & && %**!!&- &" "

", &&" & & & % 66 2&"& &"!

& & !" "& &&""

--"

&" "

$& &&&" & -&

1% 2,*""4 6 & &&""

&&"""&" &&" 2 ,*""4 &"

" & &"! /&"! "

&"! "

"& &"!&&" &&"& "? & & && & "" &&, 0 &"&" &.& 1 2,*""4 , "

"&"

&&"0 &&&" "&&"

" &-&&" *$ &&&""

&&" & & "

" &"

"" ? & &&" / " "&" &&" &&"! &

& &'&& >"&"" &&&" %- " " &&"

* 1 23 2*""4 ' &&","

&! "

1% 2 & , "& &"! !" &&"* 4&"&"!"

&"!&&",& "

!& &" & !" 0 &&&" " &&" " & "

0 & !" & C&"17 8 *$"&"

*0 &&&"@

&,"

&! "" "" )& "

"- &- "&"$ &&" ""&""

& 2% &"

& -"-& &&" $ ,&" "

"/""2

&!* &"&&""

-5 &&$

-" ' &&" (= :*"

0 & !" 17 8 9"

*0 &&&"*, ,"&"

" 9"

*0 &&&"@

&F$,"

&! "" "" $"&" & "

" -" .&! <", F$ "

&! )& "

" - /" "&" & 0 & "

$ 0 &&&" " &&" " &-&&" 9"

*0 &&&"*,

> -,C&"'" C&C "

C '-&3C&"' " "&""

0 &&&" &"

>"G >&! &&"!2% "

-& &&"% 7@H)8 "

6 "

2 &-* && -&

&&" "

-& &&", &" &&"G "

"/""2 * &"&&""

-5 &&;

29" " &&"" " " & & !" ' &&"& " $ ,-"& &&" "

&" 78 % * "" & "

" &- "&"E-"&" "

-5 && "0 ", &"

&"!"&&" &&&",& 60 1/23 ),"

2 8 , 1 5 6

(24 )87 98#- 2 8