Ishwar Singh Dhanda & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!"#$%"&'('#)* + +
(,- ./')0, , )% )%#!,".( +++"!'!'#)".
( 12(+ /! !"#$ .3 ) )%#!,".( +++"(4#)%")!
( * 5 6/+/
+
7
!
!
" # " " $% &$ $&'()* +,- .
/
$ 0 .1 2"3 .14 # "
5 0 6"
1 7 2" )8- .
" 9 "* + '
5 # # 623!2 "
" 5 " ""82""*/ '&
"" 2""
" .
: ;
2"8 +66<1 )6"
! -: '=%&)* +$- : > :
.
''
&?
$&&@ 4 $& &$ $&&= / $ "". &'
&'
$&&=)* +(- .
1 2"34 : =
2"8 +66: '==& 5
" 5 # "# . 5
'( '& $&'&)* +@-
. 14 # # 623!2 "
$% '$ $&'&)* +?-
5 8 .
"
!"# $$%& !$% 5 (& ''
$&'$ .
)* +>-
5 $& '$ $&'$ )* +%- $% &$ $&'()* +,- 0 5 ." ".
A " 0 "
8
'%$ !$%"#
!
! $% $&'& 6: 8 $'%' $$ &@ $&'& .
*
0" $% &$ $&'()* +,- 5 " 0 "
.
8 8 / (,(%'==& ' ()'* !$%"# $$%& " 0 "
.
8
', &'
$&'')* +'&- . .
" .
.1 2" "
7 2" ". " 62"
A " . . "
" # # 623!2 . . 0 "
.
1!+ ,,,$ $(%!
'-!%.
!$%"# & %/% %$ 0$
+ * $%! !$%)* +'- # "
" 2" "
'$BC# .
" 2"" . 8 "
23!
# " 51!
:" =)'-).-)- 0 . 2 !
2")8-: :" '=>??
. 2"" .
#
23!
".
.
"
" # #
3!
.
. " # #
A " A0 "
")* +'-.
A0 "
. "
" 2"
"
'$BC# "2"" .
23!
# $% &$ '=,= "2"" . 2" . # #
3!
? 5
. " # "# D
$& '& '==( .
"
". . ".
. # # ? * .
." # "# .
""
'$BC# 2" " : # "
3!
+! 7 2" .
2 +!
.
8
12213, $
! $% "# $$% & ! $% )* :+'-
: .*
6 : =
2" +! .<1 )6"
! -: '=%&) E : E- 7 2" 1 "2 . " 2") .1 4- + 89"7 44#')!:")!;34.#:#!'#)* '- *"
".
7
#<".):")!(, 994."4 ." 9'(!#$#$$'&".((8'! ;9" $#. 4.#:#!'#) !# !," (".<'&"+ ," ("9"&!'#) $#. ')&98('#)')(8&,9'(!(, 99;"; ("%#):".'! )% (8'! ;'9'!3') 99."(4"&!(-'!,%8"."0 .%!#(")'#.'!3+
,") :"(#$!,"#$$'&".(')&98%"%')!,'(9'(!(, 99;" .. )0"% ') #.%". #$ (")'#.'!3 ') .3 ) 8;9'& -#.=( "4 .!:")! ..'0 !'#) . )&, <".(" (
)0')"".')0/".<'&" )%":;".(#$!," . $!(:") )%. &".(/".<'&">4.#<'%"%!, ! )3?8)'#.#$$'&". -,# ') !," #4')'#) #$ !," #<".):")! '( #$ "@&"4!'#) 9:".'! )%(8'! ;'9'!3: 3;" (('0)"% 49 &"')!,"9'(!,'0,".!, )!, !#$#$$'&".((")'#.!# ,':'),'(#-)&9 ((+ ,"9'(!(#4."4 ."%(, 99;"."<'("%"<".33" .+
A ?- 6 " ".
>- 5 .+ )$- )@- )?- . 8
.
" + )- F )- .
F )- .
%- 5 8
.
" "
,- 68
" 8
" .
=- .
.
. .
8
'&- .
.
*+ "
/+5 " . 5 2" *EDE . : =)$- : . . "
."
/ '
B 7 2") - #
"8 / ' # " " " 2 + !<1)6"
! -: '=%&".. . 1 4 1" "
5 0 "
"
3!
" : =)$- : . " # "
3!
0 2. : =)@- : # #
3!
7 2" 5:
.8 8 0 "
$
56%7'08)* :+'- ": =)@- : " . ". "
* 2
0 . 5
. " " ''
@ 2 # *
0
. "0 " 7 2"" . D : =)@- " "
" " .
0 . . " #
3!
".
5 "
" . 0 "
$
56%7'08 .
E.* 8
.
(00%( 39 " +7 8 ,, ' ( )'* "# $$% & ": . 6
.
.
"
" : =)@-
6.
" + ,,,
" $% &$ '=,= 2" 5
.
$& '& '==()* +>-
"" + 5 ". . # # 623!2 ? 2""
. 5". . " . " 623!2*
. " * 5
)-
. 6 2"" . " # 623!2 ". . *?
5 "2"" . 2
. '
7
7 5
)-". )- " . . " 623!2*
? 2"" . 6 .
" . " 2"" . 5 . "
. ". '
7
". . . "
3!
*
? 6 .
" .
" 2"" .
! !
" ! # ! !
$ !
%&&' & & %&&' % !
$ ! % " (
'
(
%)*)'*+'*,&*,'*'%*'-*') '. ! /0120# !340150 ! (
& "
(
% ! /01203340150
! "
!
6
/ ! 7
!8
!
!
%&&' !
(
&
/7
%&-
'
&- %&- !
! %+ % %&&
9 &- %& - :
!
0 * ;
5 <! :
$ /
4
5
!* '+& ! '%
+ +
'<3 )(,'
,"!,".(4" =')02." (#)"% * "(2# ,"!,".."4#.! ;9"
* "(2#