High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12356/2014dismissed

Kulbir Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2015-06-30Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh7 pages

! "#$#%& '()*#+,#%-.

// ##% + 0$ , (%1 * %!. +$ / $2%! %$ 3& 453 ,'

3 35 453 , , '35

!"#$

"% " "

& '(!"$)&

'( #" **!&

% +,

% ---- 1 6'(7 +3# )8 ."%&/!" 0 0

*"% &&%&"0"!" !* & & / 1"* "

2% (,% ' *" &0 &&0 "* ""!*&!& , " !

! & " " , & "%0,( ."3 "

4&%0 ",53 6 & "0 &&0 7 "& &%&8(9 4*

2 ."& (0 %%& ! 7 %"< 0) " %& 1 , ! &(& " *& *, % " 0 "< 0) " "%%& !0 ""0( %&"!*& ,&! ( !"2 = "0( %&&(& "

*,+" !% ""%%& "!*&"&& (*&&0&, 0%&*"% &&0 &*(& %%& " %& " "0&,." !*&!& , !."% (*&*(&%%& " "0 &&0 %&0*

1, "*& *,."%(0

"%%& "*"8.<(/&*!"0,0*

>-." ! &! : 7!"(,0 "% * "!*&? ',$0%

* " & ! && & :

"<< 4*@

"3 % "" %!&& & ;

0*1, 8( 9 "<< 4*@

" 0&&, "! ! &7;

"<< 8(9 4*@

"# ! "%&"0 "! "%& - &.!<< "# &

#%%& ! A (,"% "&&, "!&& %&: 7."%0 0%& "% *"&&00 ',$0% ?% 0 "% "% 1,

"! ',$0% 00

&&*%"0%%% 2%&"% ( && & :

"<< 8(9 4*@

3 "." "! ! "&&* (, ',$0 %( " & : " &

"% (% *%"0 "&&0&."! !% :

2 (, (- 0-

& "

3 " * " % & " %&

*&, ; 2 " 9 ?

3 " && " &&0 ', $0% = "&& ."%%& (, ',$0%*" && !

0 2 ."%! & 7 2 ""

0 84

"&""(*"!*&(&& "%&B & 2

"9?

0 " %"%%& , !*&!& ,&, " 0," & ,( "0."%0

%"% "+&&,

5 2 6 "

& "

" & &&0 %&"%# " !%

<"!0 ("& %

"(& ""!*&!& &, ,% "< 0) "? " %

," 2% 7 : "0,!&

:: "% & &,, &0" %& &&0<! " "" &&

2" &,,"0 "&&* ( "

& 4 C * 3 " % * "< ( & ;;

D";;

%!0"&( (,% , "0/ <"(& ""&&0 "%&1&&&,*"0 % "0"( && && (*% * ( "

&4 C * "% * ";;

"" & & "%

3 & "%(0 ""

% !""%%& 0! &5 " 0 &&0 % " , %%& !"

> 0 "&&( & &&0 " " ( &*(& " , " %%& 0 " !3 & "(0 " " ! & "

&% !1 A"

0 ",!' "0(* "0< !* " " 0 % (, " % ! !"

! <!(,!, &!" "!&&*&&, ")/ ." ! &!"& : 7!"" && "%& !0 7: ."% ," ( / 0"

&& "%& 7 ? " " "

& & " % (0 ""0&* && %&% &&(' (& 0" %

(,"

&4 C * " 2@> :

0 &, " ! & ! "& : 7 ." %!"!*&&5 6 5 6 5 6 " 0 &&0%0 *"< 0 ) "% - 5 6""%%& 0""0( %&" !*& ,!&&( !"2 = "0( %&&(& " *,."%& 0 &(& " "0!&&(

"%%& "!*& "0."%%& " !*&"&&(0 &&0&, 0%&*" % &&0 &*(& %%& #! " %%& /%!*&!&&(*&&0" %& " "0&,50%"%%& 6 6."!*&!&&(& ,

! 6 ,%%& !"

> 0 "&&( &&&0 ">""(

&*(& " , "%%& 0 "

%& "( &"!""%%& "!*& !& &&0 %&" %& " "0&,."!*&!& , "

!+" "%%& !"

> 0! ( !( &&&0 "" (

&*(& , "%%& 0 " !

; 920*" &02"% ',$0 %!&& %& :

"<< 4*@

!"& : 7."%" &0 ""(&& " %&(*&"!*&."%" 0 0%&* ',$0%""!&&& & ;

4*3 "& !" ""! ! "0." "! ! "&&* (, ',$0 %( " & : " &

"% (% *%"0 "&&0&."! !% : (," ( 0

0 " <!

" "

& * (, ', $0 % * *&&0 %&! & "% ! &>0"%& * ',$0%." &&00 ',$0%! &&

; 2(,"9?

."%%& (,

',$0%!& 0 2 ', $0% "&&* "! 7: (, &*(' % ;;

( "

&4 C *

3 "."

&4 C * " ' *0

5 2@>6" "! 7: !"

&(,""

0 "% **" (' 5% "6 **"0 1 " % * "%(0 "0,"*"8.< )/ "A ")/; 7 &0 0,(* & !

" !0 "(/

& :: 7."!*&(*& ,2% 7 : +" % & 5 6 " 0 &&0 " &&0"%%& "!*&!(*" %&&,%&! *"% , " ! & (% (,"&

& " % " 0%*

2 !" "0, && (," &

> 7 " < +" 7 5

&* & " & , ( 0 (, " 1&, *0"% "0"(, 0