High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15021/2020dismissed

M/S Dara Engineering And Infrastructure Pvt Ltd v. State Of Punjab And Others

2020-12-23Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma31 pages

! !"#$#%& '()!"!*+!(,

-.$(%/#%!!(#%/%)% ($ (0" 0(! (#1 !2#*# !)

! 0%3+4 5!($

-& 62- - 62- 77 - -

!" #$

%& !# #

' ((((( - , ) * +,, - .# / 0 # 01

, 2 , 34356363/7 8%61 " $## $ +, * # 9

$# $ +,/1 !" , -# :6 " ) *

$ $# .# /

01 0

0" ,

, 633<6363/7 8<1 ,

' ; #

"# 2 , %%356363 /7 8%&1

"$## $ +, $# $ +,/1* # 9

!";

6 "

' ,*-=/7 8%1 " ", #, ,"

, ,"

, ,

, > ?

# #

, = = * ==

" ,

;# 6 # - 9@ "

/ 09@01

*,9 ,#/ 0 *901 "A#

,# ! " 2

" $ # B38B3=,

,# " !"

#/#1

" * , ?

/*?=1" & A

, > C#

= = * = = *?=" - "

, +, 9

$ # ;

& 9898*- 358:'<&8- /7 8%1 ="

0 0 0 0* # # ," " "

"# #

" , " " ,"

"=, " " ,"

, =

*-= /7 8%1 -

# #

", # = "

#2 #

- ", # =7 2 "

## # #" ,

?D )E ) .

# , #

## #&3.* " % 63%&&% 6363 #

"8F

# ! ##"#,#

"8" % 63%&&% 6363 ,

# 2

<%46 ? #

#! ##"#,#

"8" % 63%&&% 6363 ,

# 2

B%3< ? #

#! ##"#,#

"8" % 63%&&% 6363 ,

# 2

'3<: = #

# , 9=# ) # , ) #

)* "

" % 63%& "

## # 7

, # G ##" 2 7

, %B.* #

, ,! *-)$-) <3##" ## # , 63> , = 7 2 ,

# #

?D )E ) .

# , #

## # B .*

" % 63%&&% 6363 ?3&346363, #) #/7 8B1

& 7

, %B#

/.*1 #

, # %6.* ' A

, ;#

' ; #

*-= > ;#

7 353%6363/7 8:1

"#"

;# ",

#",

" # 3<3%6363/7 841

"#"

, ,

B6%<4B> />.D1A <&B.*- D 9 7

"#7

' 8# ,

<&B.*%6B6B.* !7 353%6363/7 8:1 B = " *-= > &%346363#, $## $ +, $#

6 , $ , " "

, ;# "0

0$ , 633<6363 7 8<= #

' ; # ", 08

6'3<6363/7 851 : - , "&%3<6363 7

## # " $## $ +, #, 36356363 , "

0" , #" #/7 8%1 -

--- *-=

", # = ## ## 34356363/7 8%61, #

"$## "

' ; # 0

0 , ",

7 353%6363/7 8:1

; #

, " # 3<3%6363/7 8417 #

<&B .* #, " #

## # 2 ,

%6.* 2 =$## # >

# , #

# " .*"

" 7

%6.* , , "

'",

7 ""$## $

+, ",)

,"08

0 =7

, ""

; # , # ,

*-= > /7 8%1 4 = "

## %%356363 /7 8%&1

' ; # " " 0

0 =

*-= > /7 8%1

," , # #

2 *-= > --- "" ,

, # #

" # , #) #

" #

)

) )# ", #

/7 8'1# ,",=$## $ +,

8 )# ,

0 #

,34356363/7 8%61

< -

# #"

# # 7 , #2 , #

" !

5 = 7 353%6363 /7 8:1

"# "

' ; # "

, " , , " # 3<3%6363 /7 841

"# "

7 ,

B6%<4B>.D/<&B.*19

" ,

" 7

#$##6'3<6363

' ; # 08

0 -,, # /7 841 "

"# "

' # $## 7

,, "

, "#

353%6363/7 8:1 !,

"" #%6.*

<&B.* %3 , " "

6;$###

, 34356363/7 8%61

*-=/7 8%1 = #

# *-=,, # # "

" # ," #

6;$##

2 # "

" # , # 7

" 9

# "

%% %5/%1/,1 $ -

, "

" "

= ,

" #

, #

H 2 "

# ? " "# , #

, )

6 ; $## 34356363/7 8%61)## %%356363 /7 8%&1 " "

" ", ;# 2

*-= >

;# ", %6

% &

" "

"" ;#

2 7 !

# = #,

" #;#

# " # , = #

, 34356363 /7 8%61"

"$## $ +,

" # -

$ +, $##

# * ,

A * #

,+,= "D, $##

" #,

- "7

, "

6;$##633<6363 "

! ,

7 $

%& 0@ $0

'6 *-= * , ,

<&B.*

$## $ +,

6'3<6363 "

# 08

"# 6B3<6363# $#

D , # "

"# #

)

8-" , #

" , 8--"/ "1-

2 7 ##

, #

#%6.* 2 - "

2 7

,2 =

, #

7 "

9 %3" #/7 841

"#"

';# #

0>.D0 0.*0

, #

7 "

' %6B6B.*

,2 ", # , #=$## $ +,

#7"" "

, "

9> #

"6' #","

# "#

9 # B6%<4B

>.D%6B4B.*

;# $## $ +,

" # # $#

D , , , "

)

8-"

= $## " )#

"#"" #, # $## $ +, ,

# " ,

= $## $ +, #

# ,

, " "$## $ +, ,

'8# #7

" #

7 "

# #

B6%<4B>.D%6B4B.* ## 2 %' 9, 7 353%6363/7 8:1 "#

, #

, " , %6B6B.*6' -

"# "

" ,# # 2

, "

"! " "

, $ +, $##34356363/7 8%61 "

0 , " ;#

"# #

' #"!

$ ,

, "

- # 8 " #

, ,

, "

"# ?# " "

- "#$

64 65 &% &6 &: *-= #

2 "

" ##

2 " " " "

8 # " "

# # "

# 8# 8 # " # # #2 # "

%: . #

$## $ +, "

# 7 " #

<&B .* ? )"

, #"" #" # #

" #=

2 "##

, , #

=$## $ +,

, "

*-= ,

, $## "

' !

$## , ! "

* !

,# $ $9:'4& 63%5 0!#/88 9(:;<;,/(!/(,20)5#%$ ! 0%3+4 5!($0663B63%5 ,

$ # ## # "

, #

""$## $ +,

, "

' ; # #

, $## $ +,

" .

"#$## $ +,

2 ", *-=

, , ,

", #

, " , #

, ,

" %4 ? !",

, 7

D , *-=D 7

" # # =

8-" " 2 " " #

8 # #

- "

"# #

)

= #

) "

" , 8--" / " 1 - #

) " " # " #

, " "

# #

) ""

" " D " ;#

" #

8 "

$## 8-" / "1D #

, 7

, = # # #

2 "# #

" "$## $ +,

# *-= #

, , "

' ; # 0

", ,"

,# D0"

#$ 0%= % !(% #% 2 ) $ %$ (0" #% 2 ) 4 5!($ I/%5551 %

#$ $ '56J !8808($ %#% %)#,I/%55'1:

#$ $ :B%J/)#$5-%)8$ ! ((#$$4 5!($I/63341%'

#$ $ B%4J

" #

" $

D0"

#$ !

,# " %< .

,, "

"# "

# , "

' ;

# "

6465&%&6&: *-=

" 7 " $## $ +,

*-=

#$ -.$ #!*!%$> #!%/!$!8#$"5 42 )$- 2 ) I63%B/41 $

/$ 1J'6B-% !"(82 )$ 2 )I63%:/%B1$$646J

,# A

,# $ 5#(%3# 284 5!($$ #%%"#8**#$$#%!((?%4 5!($I%54<.

B<6J

;# , %5 9

# "

, ,

, #

63 , "

, 9$ # "

,# " " , " # ", #" # #

#9$ - 0 /

1D0"

#$ ,

" $ #

K<@=

#" = # !

# =

# # '= 7 # - # #

@=#

" !

# #

, "

#2 "7 = ##

# -

# # "

, #

2 8#

D #

" "

9 "

, "1"

"" " # A@ , ## # "

,7 L 6% # 66 !

,# 0 /

1D0"

G # "

" # -

K L9 !

# ,

""# ##

, ,

2 !

- , "

7 !

# !

# =

" #"

= ,

# "

#, , "

# # #

# ) # !

"7 ,

" # #

# ! # = " , # 7 !

,2 #9

# # ?

# " 0

, "

0 ##9

" 66: $ ,"

, # 2 ) "

# ) ,

, # 2 ,,

L 9

",, ,

66 = # , " ! "

,,34356363/7 8%61 , "

' ; #

, 8 "

, $#

D , *-=

8 - 22

2 B $ $0+*#$$#% #)$ !(C!%#%/ ( +#)$ - /= @ 1

" +#

", # =

" #

8 # / ))

!",1 #

- "

"# #

)

B , #

)

" , --"

B ,

)

-" C# , --"

180 #% 5! ( +#)$%)$!8!" #%

$0""!$$ 08+#))!( ,--" /A 1 +#

" ", # =

, #

8 #

/ ))

!",1 9&

, #8 # /1# "

"#"F /1" " ,F /1 #

/1# " " ! !F /1# ,"

## - " , "

2 # M

N,# #O = +#

# ,7

" - "2 " , #,

" ,#,L 6&

" #

8-" / 2 "1

# "#

8 # # !" #

"# #

)

, #

) #

# 2 "

, 8--" / 2 "1=

# #

8-""#

","

" #

) ,

) "

8- " #

) # " # #"

" , 8--"/ 2 "1 -

) "#

" 2

8-"

" # " # , 8--" = # ,

;# , ,"

6 ; $## 633<6363 "

# 6'3<6363 6B3<6363 # $#

D , #

';# -

# 2 7 # " *-= =

' ; # "

6;$## ,7

H, #

# %3 , " #

6;$##

9 "

"# #

7 "

';#

# B6%<4B>.D"

#%6B4B.* ,## #2 %6.* - " 7

, ,

" , ##

#," #

= ",,

# "

;# , #, )

, "

# 9 "

6;$##

# *-= 6' D " ,

, $#

D ,

" #

" ;# , ",

6;$##

, "

# " ; # #

, $#

D ,

8 ;# 2 "

" , = ;

" , # A

$ /

'8 #

" $

" ," #$

, # ,,# 6B . ;#

---+

@ $ *-=

7 8'

", #=

- ,A# L $ " #

" #

" 2 "

= " #

#2 #

,- " # "

? "

","

6;$##,,

, 8# $## $ +,

' ; # , "

# #

*-= ", #

, "# "#

;# ""

6;#

*-=9

6;$##,

# "#

" # ,

#> . D

B6%<4B>.D

. *# %6B4B.* ,"#$

6465&% &6 &: *-= #

2 " #,#

,# " #

" "

# # , 8# 8 # " , # # #2 # - "

#" "

# 7

#/ 1 ,

" 6: - # "

6 ; $## $ +, "

# , * ,

A * #

,+, = $## " D, $##

" , "

"D, $## # , 7 $ ,7 # $

# 2 "

;# "

$## ;# 64 , 2 " ;#

, 7 353%6363/7 8:1

"#"

H8 8H, " #3<3%6363/7 841

, " #$

#%3

7 ,

# # B6%<4B>.D/<&B.*1

7 353%6363 /7 8:1 ,#

B6%<4B>.D"

# %6B6B.*#,"

, , >.D.* = #

# # #$#

#= 7 353%6363/7 8:1 " "

=# ""

# <&B.* ", #

' ;

# , #

, #

9 $# #

7 ##

,7 " # "

;# " -

, "

;# #

B6%<4B >.D

%6B6B.* 0 # 0 "0 # 0 6< - " 7

, ;#

"D0"

#$ /

1 /

1 " " "

#,) #, " $ = #

- 77 - -

'()!"!*+!(,

5! 5!($C!>#%/.(!$%!)& !$. 5! 5!( !C( +8!& !$.