← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1397/2018dismissed

Mohit Kharb v. The State Of Haryana And Another

2020-02-04Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh30 pages

     

!"#"$% &

'(")( * +  ""$ * , *#-# .

 */ $ $0 $( *  #1$0 $# '% 23'.'3.  

              

                 45

$."$6(7   

           

   

     

       

     !"  

"

   "

#

  $%& ' 

(" "

    #   

"  " )   



 "

*  +   +#

 "  *,  (  

        ++  +  )  !     "

      ##

     

             

"" !   "      "

##    $%&           "

, ! "

-  %+

   "

.  #"  %  $%&(     ,) "

#

   

 

  "     #    # !

 

(& # 

/ )!      0 # ! !

      



 & % #

"(&%)     .   

&   "

   #

! !  

!    "0

!   

  

(1 ) #!  !

 0#!   2 "  # !



 #

  #   

  &        #!    #

   "  

  

(

      )    

   #   

 "

#

!



          ""        !

 #  

    

    "     "

"   



   " %



 #"

    !

# 

 "

#  "



 . ,

        &  

"" !  

  0  "

#

       !



 "

#

         5     !       

"

#      "     "   

  # #      2 #

   #  "

      # "

  " (   #  # "

    )  !

"

2  6

  #  "

#

  

  ##

     "     4  !

  "

 '      ##

     #    "

      2#   # + 

.-4 $,.

 #( $ $0 $( *   %+7&(+).  

 -   # !     

     +  "

1 !

  "

        

           

"    

   "      #      #   #  

  

! "

   0

!    "

 

    #       "

,  ++   

 

&  

""    

    # #   



 

   

!

     "   "

! 

   #   # ##

  

  

 "

#

  #

5 !       

""

#      

 $%& 4       #        ##

     !

 



    "    2#    # +   ""

 

 "

   *"8 $0* ."$6( $0( *#    .

#( $ ,( )&+&(+#

) ,- . 1 !

        



 "

*

 ++( !" "

  "

   "

#

  

  ! 

)!"    "   !89   

 



     



     

   

 

    

  

     





 

 



      

 

 

  

   

  



         

&



        

      

  !

 



  

        

     

 

    



 





"    

  #

  # 

   

 



          



      

#$  %





                       

         &



'

 

 



    

 (

4  6# 

'       "

*

 "

"   1   

 # "  ()  "

  +  !"   !89  

  )     

*  

 +# ** ** ** ,

 ( 

   

    

   -  



( , 4 "

  !  " 

 # 

 #      # 9 "

()  "

, 

9 +    

"

     "  

"

 # 9 "

()  "

*  +     "



 ##

#!  "  #

  #    "

    

     "

() !

#    "

"" (&  )

"" !

     



  

 1 : !

   %     "

 6        

 !              +



;

"  *0 1."$6(,.

-$8 + $0( *#  - ()&+&(+#

)   !   "89 ,

.       



    

        

    



      *  



 .    

     





     

  

    

    





                 

        

         

 .    



 %

                 *       

  

              

  

/

0

!



       

*    /

 0

  

    



  



 

 

* 

 

 *



 (

: (7 !$  < "%=.--.) * $ #  

 2#   ( )         

   .(7 !$  < "%=., .)!    7       

"

 

  !      " 

      "  "

 (  

)  + !

     "  "

 

"

 #

 



"           ""      + !"!



"  ,.0# #  "   "" "     %!

      7   "

         +     "

 #  

! !

 "

     #    ++   

"     "   "

#

>  "

##

    "

*"



       +  # 

 "

   "  0  





         

"

   "

*!

 #  

2  "

!

   #      

   ##





#    

  "

#

 

  #  4 "

    !

            

"

   "

* #  

2  "

!"#  !

  #      

  ##

!  # +        2#  #   

  "

#

  #

!   !       #  # 0  "

#

  # #   #   "

   ++

  "  

##

 

"

"

#     

   "   

 1 !

     

 "

2#   # + 

          



 !"#



$%&%'( )%*+  %'%) )%*,#   #   -.

#"#    #  

 



   



 /0 )%*"'12  

  3( ,

.

      /

 0 

1    

      

 2 ) 



/      

 

        & 

   

   /

 0



1 .     

  

 

 

     

    

 4

 

5  /

     

      *   



     



     *

      

     

    

5 

 .

#"   6 7    (( 6 ,

.  

     

 





      





 

  

(   #   "   

2#  "



;

" + 

  



 )%* !%+0"0!"#

+'% 

  1 !

 6#  ! #   

    "

#

     + #    #

   !        + !

         #   #   

  "       #      

 ( 

  #   

!" # 

     )   ##

  

    "

 #    

 

    !

  

1;;   #+

 "        #"

  

   "

   !

     #         

# 

  $7      "  !

2 !  "

 

 !

!



    !



 4 " "

!

      2 "



      

    

""    "  &     1;   +       #

#    "

"

     

! #             2#       +



 ;

"  

*0 1."$6(#2"

 

#"  #        

  

 

  "   6

   

!

#    "

   

   "



"

  4      " "#         

  

  "   6

   

!    #   "

 

   "

   +  !  "  # +   

    # ( "

    "

 )    

   #     "           " 

"

    "

*

  - %  "

 6 # *0 1."$6(#2"

    

   (7 !$  < "%=.--.)!        !89 ?!     

   

   

      # 

  )   /

77 7 7

$  /

 08

     

  

    /

 0 

-   

   

     

  



       

  *   /

 0

   

   



 

  

)   



9 

9

/

 0

     



 





  ( 4"

    !



  #    " "

 

0     +     

  2#       " 

"

     "

*! 

    "

  6 #      

#   #  "



 

 

*  +  

 #     

 "       +      

"  "

#

   

 !        "

# !   

 ""

  

       "    #

 #

 #  !"  "

 !

  "" &  !   #

"   "

 

      #  ##

  

 

  

""  . 1; "

    #    2#   

  

"  # 

'

"      "

"   + 

 #   "

0         ""    2 " 

"

    "

*  4  6"

  

   "        +  "

   



 #   #      

  "  !

    # 

 "#    "   !

 6

   # 

 " 

  "!

     "

,  +   !

 "

     

2#   # +   8 $0* ."$6(  .

 $0 $( * (7 !

$  < "= 

.) #!"  ""

        !"   !89 ?7 5

        

   

 

 

 

  /

6 



 

 

 

   

& 

 

.5      

  

      / :

( , @  #  !    

 "

 ( ) 1; #    "

  "#    "          "   !   !    6

      #        "

 ,     ++  (      !  !      ##

"

    "

*  +  )! 

  

! !          "   

" !

    "

  "

  

 # "

"

##

 # "" # 

  

  "

#

 !

 '  #

 !       

"

#  4     #   !



 

"

 

  !  "      "

    #         

   

   "   6

   

(     "

 ) #  !

  #    

    

! !



"

 # 0   #  



" "  #  "

 (

   



 "

   ++ "

 )"

  " 

  # 

  #        2#   # +   

 "

   4  6#   

"

     "

    

 "    # +   "

 6   " "

 (  

#   2# !

    )!#     2#   # ;

"    " ;2   A"

 !    7      (          "

 )     2#   !

 

       . '( 0#1 ( $"  6 $0 * ( $0 ; $0( *# ,(-)&+& (+#

) .

(+) !"!

   !89          

   

       !          

           !



      



       "

  # 

 $           %$   $

         

   $    &      '()  '*+ ,  

             -,.

$    !

  !    !                 

    

! 

   

!      

 !             

    !   

      

!     /  

 !   

      

                     

       -,.

        

 0   

!   



 

$  

 '()     ! 

  

      

 

         '1+ ,      !        

   $     

 (2(      ,   $      ,      !

        &   3  *  # 

   "

  !

 





"

 "   "     

       #  +  

        !"    "

    

##

!    

  #  "

    



 "

   +  "

 

0    + ! 0   "

"

    "

*     # +      ##



 "

 "



  ##

 # !



""

  "    "6 

 

!

   #

   # # 

(  

      # + )

    !

"

 !   #

            

    "

#   !         +      $7  (    "

 )           #     #  !

 #  >"

 !   "

  #  

"

 '  #  "

 !

 !   "

  #  "



   

 

    

!

  "     2 

  

    "

#

  !   "

        #  

    #

    +   !

"  

 2    



  &   @     # "

     # "

 9 #   

  

     #

  "  

     !    #"     

2#  < 

;

" +  .

++"*<#$  #*-= .

 */ $

 ( )&+&(+#

).*  " 1; #   #  

"

   " !  1            "

              

# #    

  "         

      !

     

  4 !

        #   

  !   "       #

 "

#

     +     "   

 # 

&  %         # 1 !

   +        

     !  

   4   A"

   !89 ,.        

               *      

   

    



  *

 

 

   

    

)



 



   

*

  /

 0

( 1   !

  6  #      !     #  +         

"

  "

       2#  "

 

    "  "

  4"

      !

  #            - "

   #  ! "

   

    !      #         

     

   "           "



     #  !

   



 #    "

 "

      #    2#  +



;

"

 

!

 !  "#   "

 "







   "

   ##

  

     !"   "

    !     "

    "

*"

 #



  "    #           "  0    !  # 1 !

  "

    

    " !  

  A# A  "    

  

  " 

" "

9   "   #

 "  . "

  ' 

  

!    

 

          #    "

 

0    +    "  

"

    "

*   !  !

 ' 

#    +



;

"     " 89 4+ 5      66   

 '()4(+      $    

$ 

78      8             

     877    

9 4+ 5      66   

 '() 4(+ 

                

         66 

         %  " ' 

()         #  2#  7    !89 1: ,  !     %$     $   



 !  

              $    $      

     

 $          

      $             !       !

 

$      

  $ 8  $       "

   

$                 

 

:  $   

                  $   

  $

    $ 

  

  "



$  

    

$    $   

    8         %$          

  

$     !  $! %$     '()  3     7        !

A ' A '  

      "

*  

'   #  ?



 "



   "++ "

   #

  !

   #   (.)   ! "

 

 " !

  ?

 " #

 "  "     B %!

   89 ?.   

     





              

   /

;< = 

!



   



  





   

. 

*      /

 0   

    > 

?          

 

    

  

  

 )  



    

 

    



  

 

 

  

/

 0

( /  # 

   ,(7 !$  < "%=.--.)

       !89 ;( ,  !  !        3   '()     $ 

      !    

 !       !       ,   $     

 &   $   <             '()    

 8        

     ;= "

 %$ $        

           !

 $       

    &     

    ,    $                 $      3 ( #    "



 ) , $  

 !   "

  

  ' 

    #          "



 " '  "

   

 " 

"

   "

*!

    !89 ;* / %$    $       $      

    "

               

$ "

  $  8

        $       ;1 "



  

  $        $   ! $  

    &  

        $ 

    $       ,   8   '()        $  

 !       

   



  !

     



$     %$  !    

   8       $  3 << )          

   

     

          



'

  &        

&

 

 

 

 

  

     

 '    & 

  

  

         

     

         



    

.



  



     

  *

 

        



       

         

  

      



;) "

                  

!   

  !       %$!

    '()   "

 !  !

             $    

    $  



 

  "

 $  

         &   

$     

    )       





 

             

     

 

  

         

   

'

  &     



  

   

 

   

     

&

    /

 0  

.@ 

?  

 

   

 

  ( ( #       2#

 )   

   !    "   #  "

*#

 "  "      6 #

9 9" 

   !" 9 6 #

!

      

 " "

#    6 #

9 9" ?

"     



  + 936 #

B"

 

0     '  #" 

   " 

#      "

#"    

  ##

 * @     !"  !    "

*++"

  6 "    "!

 ' 

 #    7   +



;

"

  #  "    !

##      !(   "   -*7 !$  < %=.--.)89 ?,     $       

         %$  

$  !      '()    8 3       !                  (     - )   "

## "  

 "

 #  "  (

 #   0 "

C

"     " )

 "

     "

    ! 

   +



;

" #  

 

"

""     

 ! 1 !

      

!     #     

0     "

      #    # 

     ( 

  "

   

6 9.!   

)  



9%  "  " !"  !89 ?

!

, 

 $ %       >  / , ?

 

! /

 !  =@(:=:(;!

            $ ?

 /

 ! .  !

  <  .! ?





A ?



  B 

! C   ? .! <    ?

 

!

 D!    B          

        

            ,       

! .  ! ?

 

?

 C! <    

    "

  

   & 

#?

  / ,!   <  ! ?E =2:'=:(@3

  1 !

!     "       ?



"

"    B      

  

 

 "     

 

 "

 '  "

  ##

"

    "

* #  



# "

  ""    !   "   2#  +



;

"  + "

 6 " 2"

 ##



 

 #  "

*

       "

## " 

     "

   !

      #

    59      "  !

 # 

 "

""  &   5      +



;

"

 "      "



"         # " 9 6 #

"

    

      "

* #   6 #

9 9" 

 " 1 !

A #     "     # 

     #  !

   

  #   



9%  "   

0 

#  "

  

 #      #   #    

!

     

!



  "

##

 "#    "

    + "

  ""   "

 " #        

  "   # !        # +  4   A"

 "

  " 

0     "

"#          #   "         "



  #      

'      "



"

#  "



#             "

   !       "   

 #   A2# !

     !89 ?;( ,  !  !        3   '()     $ 

      !    

 !       !       ,   $       &

  $   <             '()     8        

     ;= "

 %$ $        

           !



$       

   

&     

    ,   $                 $      3       ,      !! ' 

    7 89 ?;' "

           

             

$      

 %$          ,    $  

    !

      8  $    

  %$ $             '()  93  !   ' 

!

   !89 ;* / %$    $       $      

    "

               

$ "

  $  8

        $       ;1 "



  

  $         $   ! $ 

    &  

        $ 

    $       ,   8   '() 

       $  

 !       

   

  !

     



$     %$  !    

   8       $  3 (3#       2#

 )

" 

'       1          "

   ""    " 

      "

,   ! #        

  

"            !  ""    2 " 

"

   "

* !



  !

 "



#

  #         # 

  #  

 

(

 

  #     

  " )!

     

'       "

  #    

      9 "

()   9 "

()  "

,  +  

-                  ""

 

"     '       9 "

()  "

, !

       + 

 "  "

"" &    

( "



!" 

6  

6 9-!  

)%  "    

         

!+&19 19.

-  

!

  

!+&&D --  

 '   !  

(+&&D --  )  

  "

"" &         +  2 "   #    #   

!

#  + 

 * *

& (  +&1919.

-   !

 



    &     



 "

- *  +    0  "

" 

 )

. + #  "0   #    (

6 9-)      !  

! "

  "

# #    "

#

   # &    

  !               !    

 "

   !

#        #                9 "

 ()     "

 ,  !

      

  . ,

  &  

""      '  !

   &  !

  



 !   ?

    B           

" 

  "

 '      #      9 "

()!

  #  "  #  



  

      !

 "       E 

 !   !

"    !

 "         

     "

 # #    "

#

   #     "    



    ! A2 "A       #     

 "

"" &                           

 

   %  "  "   

 

#        !



   

"

   #      



'      "

  "  "

 

0   

9  +       ""    2 "   "

    "

*  #    2#  +



;

" 4   

, +

 '     

      "  #       #    

          "

       

   "   

      #  A

   "

, 

 !



  #   " (

  #      



'

    + )  + !

  

0      #    "    !   "       

  #

    " !

  "

#

59

 "  " 

    

!      #      

 $%&

  ! "

"



   "#      "

## 

  # # ! "

#

  "  !

2    #

 #

"  (     

#  

  17& "



   

  "

    

)

"

 '   "

#

#       

   

'   "  #   "" (     

 $%&)    "



"

"



 " #



   

!  "   " 2 E(    !

   

 !

     "       "

   

 

"

    

   "

## 

"  " )

* %    

"   

  

#  

   (    "



 ;

"  # !

"  #

!

   

 - )    "   !

:       $%&     ! #   !   (      

   " )      "

      !    #  #

2     #   2 !  "

   

!  "

   " 

     "



   #   !

   #    " 

  6 (   !"  # !

#     " #"

  

)      "

  !

 

 

    # 0 

" ##

    "

!

    "            "



 #   "

     ##

   "  (  ! ) !

! "

  

"   

"       #       "

,

("

 

6 9-) " 

 "

   

   

  

" #

   " 

 , "

#

2   #    

""

  "  

  2 

%

+

   

    

 #



"

 0   " A  " !       2  !

  # 0    #

  !

       

"      "             

    #  

 '     ( #  

    #    )            

   "  "     

  6  

  , "

#

A   #   !

   "

   #"

     

           &  

# 

    

   !   "0  # 0    !    "   



#  

  + 

     #   - + #    2#    "

   

  

   "

    

      7   "    "

  "

  " 

 #





0    "#  #                ##

""  !  #  

   "        "   "" "    

# E !!      +



;

"   # +   

 "

     "

 #      

' "

"    "

(     "

)   !

  "  "   "

   "

 

0           " 

"

    "

*++   "

   

"



  "

          

  #   

!" #  !

  

! "      

#        (              -  #  )

 "

     

     #   #

 "

#

   

! !

"  

 2 (  

   "

A"

 ) " %!

  !1;   "

 

    "

#

  2#   

 "

( )           """"#

"   "

  ! +



;

"  

 "

    

   

" ##      

!

     !  "   2#     . 

 "

 ( )!

 

   #  !   "

    "

   +    

#   " 

"



  "

 

"  "

(  "

 )   

!  

#   " 

           "

 #   <  ,  A"

 ( ) !

  #     " "

 "   

  "   

 ' "

    "



      "

   "

   

0 2"

   "

*  +   - + #   2#      1 !

("

    

) -

1&: 9

 A% ! % .&9  !. + .



   #      1%*   # 

   # 

 .    

  .                  #     #

 .    

 

.

 8 

.

0           1%*

    6    #  2  "# 

  #

  

 #        %'1!9+      "     . .#

   .





. .

 

  -

# . (#     .

##.    #    .

 . .

 

 5/

9  .  

   # 

 ## ##  1%*   #  

  ..#.

 



 .

7 #7.



 :#

4 .# ;)1 )%9  /     

<.

.-

 .( !9+%'1  . .

   

. #

 

   

 

  1%*  

.# #   

      ##   .   

 

 .

#

    . .

 0 .  .



 .



 

 .  ./    

 .      / .   .



-     .  .  

  - +

 '                  "

    

   #   !     !

  #       "     

 

#     

       

 !



#

  "  

"



  " #   "

    



  

#       !    "

 6 !  

  

 

 " ##



"

    "

*++

   !

     "

 

    

(  ! )!"!

 

     "

 '    !  

     "      -- %     !

       ""

         !    

       

1;;   +

  + !

    ##

  # !      #    "

  !

     6   ""

 "

 

    

  

 "

  

 6" 

  "     "

 ! "  "  "   

    !

   "



  #  !   

  ##

 # !   0    "    +*- */&7

<'3.=  > 

  5   0 >

F G  5      F G