High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13069/2023disposed of

Sooba Singh v. Union Of India And Others

2026-05-11Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda3 pages

"# $%% &'

&()*+ %%%%% , -,#.# /)()0() ( ) 1+2 & %%%%%%%% #3 !"

# $ $ $$ "

# $ % ,# $ , & 4&563,# % #%&67

,8 9 " 8 & ,7 .#7 ! , 6337"

,#3 #% :::: $ $$& '() **+ * , 163,# ,9;337" 6#4!7! ,,9;5 ,, %%3##

% <35 9; 6 !"

6 = 3 6# 4 #3 # !8 6,! ,8 ,,#,>., 43## ,9; 337" % "" ,57?8 ,9;337" ##=##% (-.(/0 % ( 6 3,# 3 8 6 "6775 ;# ,# 4? ,>.6# ,#!,89 ,, %%8!, = 6 !!" ! *2 , 0 ,"

*2 ( , 0 ,"

8 +56 *, .% 16 ,57 337" !7 4? , ;# #=## 4? ,7

=# , 91,4.7! ,#6 , 8 61,4.7 9 ,, %%

@., 85# ;6"68 3 ;#!7% %

, '"6 ! 6# ., 3## 7 ,, %% ,"

5 , #6 .7 4 3 # *2 8

65,68 ;6"6 ,, 6# 4 " =37 ; 68 , # 3,# 7?3 # 6,% % 16 3 ,8 ;6 33,# 3,# 8 #.4= 6 6# 33, @= 7??,# !#,9"7!

. 76#, ,= !, =#,9"

6,! ,8 "66#7,?477 ; A 65,686#6 .7 4, 65,6 7?% % B," .#733,5 467! ! 6,#3 # /( # ,."

#!, =,% %<% ?8 ,1,#3 , !!",8#.4= ,;# ,#!,,!, =*2 ,0 ,"

*2( , 0 ,"

8+56*, . 6?,8!

,;6"66 A 3,! ,= 6#.

?! ,3, !33, @= 7??,#4.

8" "# 6!"

3.,#." 6 ,, %%3##4? 6"

, '"6 !

6# ., 8 63 ,;#,"

477 ; ; ,C 65,68 ;6"6 ,,6#4" =37; 6%B," .#7! , 6,#3 !., 6,#.4= ,#!,,5=37 ?#; 6 6A.,#"

! =37 ?, #3"77? ;6 6 3 # ! ,#!, ;# = , 6 C= ;?!, = 6,7,3 # 8; 6 65,686"? ,!," 6,>.# 63 ,! , ,#!,#6 .7 4 , % %

696, 63 ,#;77#7," .#7! , ,#3 #695 6, .56 6," ,; 6 6,47### "% % 16 .568 .7## . 7 ,#!, # =7 !8 ,; 6 .

?A.,#"

8 ,!,"#6 .74"77! ,# 6=37 ?#, ,>., ; ,C;6,9,8 6=37 ?,6# 6A.,#"

3 # 6= 9; ! 6=# , 9@5"#%

% 16 "

, '"6 ! 6# ., 8 9 ,, %%8 6# 77 ; , ,A 6# #,9" ! , 67# 33, @= 7??,86#; ,C5 65,6%+6#

; = ,?,#7!

, ,8 77D.7?8%<359; 6!"

,# 6!5 !6#",,8.7##. 7 6" ."

,! ,"# 6,#3 ,#!,6=8 63 ,477 ; " . 776#, ,= %16# ,,# 7?453## C359; 6@"3 7!"

#",".=# "# ! "#8 " .37; 6 6!"

,= ,,3##4? 6"

, '"6 ! 6# ., 86#7,?4" =37; 64? 6,#3 ## # 77 ; 63 , 3,! ,=6#.

# 65,6% % 163,# 3 ##3 # ! 64 9 ,=#% %

97=#"77 .#337" 358!?8#7# #3 # !% $ $$

6,&3C5 # $ E#

6, 3 , 47$ )