High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4494/2017dismissed

Satwinder Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab

2018-07-06Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul5 pages

!" # $%&'($)*%&*(+ ,,,-&&(+ .(+ + $&%& - /%0 ,,,+1&

22222 -(+& ( .345"63%&

(&*1&&(+ ( %%7%(/%+1$)*"65"- /%0

(&*(+1& $&%& ( 7%(4%(%$)*"63%& ( 8 $ 8*%%"63%&

(&*91%%& -&&(+"%9 "$%&'($)*"*($)*"5 (1(& $)*%%1(&$)**%3 &*1(+&(3+1&&%)%+&&* / )9& %& 1%++ 0 %( 6&% $+++

)" )%'*(0 &*(%11%%)%+&&*/ )9& 3&%(( +& %&

! 1%++ 0 %(

% %)+&(%& +& %++" )%"'%++9++'&*9 +& 8( +&%&"%:; %&

($&+ "" #%

;-$&!;-%%&('%+()+&( %)%+&&*1&&(+ % +%&-$&%&*%&*%)%&+&*%&

%& %0 & - " '* 91%%& 6)(/ $)* '%+ +&%) (& *+* +"&*1&&(+ % +

(&*(% &*( 99 && % + +91 %+ ' %+ )(3 + / (+ & *9 '&* +*%(1)'%1+ <* +&%&9& / ( 91%%& '%+ (( 0 &* 3+&)%&)

( % &* :; = +& '%+ ()+&( %)%+& &* % + 6 &( 91& 3+&)%&" *%% '%+ 1(+& &* (& <* 1+ *%% %+ 3+%) ( $& ( - '( + 11 & &* % + ( +&+ ) % 1(9%

% %+" &* % +'(*%()+*& (&*99++

1 +*%0 ( $&+" %!(%'&*$& ;-&'**&* & 1%) & %%9&(% &((()&*3%*%()&*1%(&+"%(&(% (&3/ )9&%((%&

!3&&*1&&(+% +&&*9%+ (

$& !;- )( + 91(+9& ( &*( %(+ % & 1%

> %*% % & 1% 9&

(&*( () ()( + 91(+9& 9&*%* ;- )( +91(+9& ( %(%&1% +

> %*% % & 1% 9& &

(&*( () ()( + 91(+9& & % +%* ;- )( + 91(+9& ( +? 9&*+ % & 1%

> %*% % & 1% 9&

(&*( () ()( + 91(+9&

&% +%*

;& '%+

(&*( (( &*%& % &* +&+ +*% ( ((& :)%))(3"&*1&&(+1( ((%%11%%)%+&&* +%/ )9&%(( +&0 (&* (& $++ 7'3(" 3/ )9&%& 1%++0 %(6&%$+++

)" )%" &* %11% 0 &* 1&&(+ '%+ +9++" *'3(" '&* 9 +&&&*

&&*%&&*+&91+

1&*9 ($&!;-'%+( (9; %(+&%1( ; %(+ ;&+&*% (+%( 9+&%+"&*1&&(+*%3 &* 1(+&(3+1&& 90( " "'*&*1(+&(3+1&&%9

1 (*%()0 (&*+ (&"%( + (&*1&&(+& *%)&*(3+9(&+"*'3("1(% &*%&+9&3'9% 0 &%4 = % = %& 9 +& <*( (" & 9& = % = %& 9 +& '%+++ @%( + (&*1&&(+*%+&&*%&%+%)%+& &* %'%( +& &' %(+" &* 1&&(+ %( +& + &*%&'*&*91 )/ )9&'%+1%++0 %( %11%& (& 6++ *"&* *%3%(% ()%& %91(+9&

(%1( 9(&*%9&*+%% + 7 *%+

(&*( & &*%&&* 1&&(+ %(1(1(++"

(+&&9

(+%&*(+&*((9%%+1)%)%+&&*9 <*1&&(+*%30+

()&*%) (9%1()++

&*%&'*&*:;= +&'%+()+&(%)%+&&*9 <* +"**%+1(% &*%&&*+& &*1&&(+9% 0( &&* 1(%(% ()0 &*9 &* &*( *%" %( $&%& + *%+ & +1 & &* +& &*1&&(+"0 &*%+11+&*1% &%4)%0(%3'"%+ 1%0 %( + (&*1&&(+ 7'3("*+&%&+&*%&&*(+ &*(%+%)%+&&*1&&(+ ;*%3*%(%( + (&*1%(&+ 1( +% &*/ )9&+ 0&*&* (&+0'"&*+ (& + &* +( 3' &*%& &* &(% (& *%+ ()*& %11(%& &* 3 (( '* *) &* 1&&(+ ) & ( 99++

($&+!" %;- <*%11%& (&*%+%+ ()*& +9++ &*( %11% <*( + )%& ( 1(3(+& &*

)+)30 0&*&* (&+0''**9% '%((%&&( ( &*+ (& 0 34) (3+% / (+& A3 &*('+" %( + (&*1&&(+*%+&%++%&*/ )9&+ 3&% *%+"(%&*("(+&(&*+%() 9&+= %&*= %& 9 +& <* 3& 1&&(+" %9 " $%&'( $)*" *( $)*" (1(&$)*%%1(&$)*+"&*( ("%

(9 $ %( %+ &* ++ = %& 9 +& + (" %9&& " &* 1&&(+*%3 %(% ()%& % 91(+9& 9(&*%+39&*+%% +%&*(%++1)%)%+& &*9 <* *%3 0 %) &* %) (9% 1()+ +

&*%&'*&*:;= +&'%+()+&(%)%+&&*9

<*( ("&%4)&% &&*1(&(%&&(%"%&&+ &* 1&&(+" 1 '&* &* %& &*%& &* *%3 %(% +

( %((%& (%1( 9(&*%9&*+%% +"&*+ (& + &*%& &* + / +& ' 0 9&" &* +& %'%( & &* 1&&(+ + ( & &* 1( %(% () 0 &*9 + 0/& & 1% 9& + "

> %* ( $& ! ;- +&% + "

> %* %+ 91+ 0 %( &(% (& % %

(9 0 %( %11%& (& 1+& (%+ %9 & " &* 1&&(+ 0 (%+ (&*'&*" &(= (% &*(%+ B&*% (+%9 +&"&*1(+& (3+1&&++9++

! C%) && B*&*(+1%4)>(%+ C+ B*&*(1(&%0