M/S Karnail Singh & Co. v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
"# $%&'
() *+,-. / '
0'1 )'/ +'
.
!"# "$ "
! !"# #!$#
'
$' (&+'.(2) '34+ $' /1+**'4(23'+. '
$' 0+('*2( 2'/ $' 5+''23''. 6 "$ "% & '
+ +(( * + .' 4' . ''
"#4+'8/+ '18-8/+. '4'5'+ ' + 8/+-1 '
/3'1.18( "!
"
"#9
:1' ;"<2( ''' *' %='(8/''- ' +'4+ )'/ 4' 3'-+4(( * '' + '4' 3 4 .';+ (8 .'8 + '4+++ (88-. / 4 .((/ - (1 + + ( 82 4+ + '>1 -1 '
- / 4(( 8 '5
(3 (1'1 '
?" + ''+((*3+ '.'-1- +8' + ''- ('- -/88 '-+ )%((* + ''4((*3+'' 4 3(. + ' 3(. * + ( .' ( >1( 4+ 1- '/ 3 3'1 1- 2 - 8(424((818- 1..' (1 :.' 4'= ( *4+ $ 3(. +1( 8 1.'
'8%-'=@ + 3(. * +1('4+>1.' *' '.'
+1(81.''8%-'=
+( 3(. *A+ ( 'A+1(8.1 +'( 3(. 4+++1(81.''8%-'=? '''*1('
' BBBBBB$ C +1(8'+ ) :::::::::
;
'41(8. ''>1(/++ ( 8 ++ (-18-. / #D +( ' '31/'2- '4++ ' 818-2 ++.- ''4 31'+ ) &1'1=+' + ( 4++'>1-1 '
/4((8'5 +-1 '
/ + 11( '' 4(( 8 '1 4+ # 4'= * /
(E + ':.@ @! +'
/@ @!4((8'1 4+ "#/ C -(/2+ (8+. '4 8/ +'
/ .'+. '2+-48/-=.(
3(. *.'8 @'
1 ('+. ''(1. + 51*- A8(+)1.'-1''.' (()!
* )
+,+$)
+-
.
. /+) ( - + 9"FF"<!) G!2 )+-0 )/+ 0 ( ) ( )
- +,+ 1 /)) * ) 2 *0
,- 3) ( - +9 "!<"
)F# +-8/*+1''.'
.)4) )(
+ ( +,+ # () * )
() (
- +
!9"<$+'+'@41'
(7"
+1+-=+1( +38 ((48'' .18( ' H+3+'('
1 ('+.' -'
+.' 4' . + ( 8 +. '4 '>1' 8 / +-4-(/ + 3(. - '++ (8 .'+ ' 2.'848. (/ ''>1(++ (8 '-+ ' 2+.'8 1( 8. 1++. '+1'
++'
/ 3(.++ (824++-. /+-1 '
/ +12+ (8+. '+8 '*+(/'5 + 8 -1 '
91.'<2+- '.'
+ ' 48'4 ) = 814'4
= +
= +3'+1+ /+ '1- 4 +'1- 4+(++./-
= -18'1 '+.1'.+3 *+85 '
91.'< + + '418- +( -:'1'
( *4++8 + 1'1 ++ -:'1'
41(+31-++''
('- +>1( 4+'+*' -'+ - 4++:4'24++41 8 -1 42
1+1 24+(+4 51>1( ++ 51*- ' ..(8( +.' +8 +51*-
8: ++.' 4+'++ (84 8/+'
91.'<2 + ( '.' 9 < 1 '(1-'.' @ 9 @< +'
'(1- '.' @ 9 @< 3 ' ' 4' .' ''* 4'' 81(=@ 8/' ='1= ..'+3'- 4.18(+ 3( '1 '48 /- ' (8 '8 +. '18- ' ++' @81+- '- ' @4
: 4++ '18- @ 33' +'1- 2+ 1'1 +4 (/+ (''*1('/ ++ 1(83(+ ( + ' +.' 2+ (84 4++ -1 '
- / 2 +''2 + .'8 1( +38
' +8 + ( +.'
>1 (/24 /-' +.' 4'.
+--+' '-/'''*1('/ +''
"# & "$ "'
2$
)5-% & #!$#
'
' 2$