High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4578/2017dismissed

K.K.Rao v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2023-12-19Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain19 pages

$%!&'(

*&'(

0 12 0+ $

! " #

$ ! "

!$ $ ! "

%&'()*+,-)

! "

%&+*.-+,-*

! ! "

! / ! " &+ 3

( + 0 "$$ 1

2""34

" + %&'()*+,-) 2

""# 2 $$ 2 5

6-7% % %%&+*.-+,-* 2$

""#2

6,7 6,.1%0

"$$

8 " 2"$$ 6 5 "$

91&+,. + :" 2 +,,, "

6,+ 6,) -'* -'7 -+,01% "

+(;+)!

$ !" " 1

' 2

"#2/ -'"" $ ( 91#

$ "

$ $ + :" 2 +,,,#" $ - :" 2 +,,, $8

<$$ 2 -(=+,"

# " ! # / # 2

5 "

1 #

$ > $ " ?

# 2 $ "$

-- :" 2 +,,, # 8 " -6 :" 2 +,,,

&+*.-+,-*# 1

&'()*+,-)# >

"3@4

$ ( "$

" $ ( & $2 +,,,

91&(,- ( & $2 +,,, 6,71% "

5" $ A% &7=%

&6--6% B5

% 2

$ "

--,,!

(--+,,, % 2 $

"$ &+"$ $

2!8

% 3>4%

$ $

! $ 2 2

$ "> " 5 " $ $ $ $ ?

# $

" 2

" 1" $

$ 2" " $

1 #1" $ #= 2 !

$ 1" $ 2 2$

# ## " $# $

D-+,,&

1 " 2 $ "

1 $$2 $ 5 #$ #

:E!% $

;= !8

1% 3%4 % '--+,,, 7+, 1"

" # C" " ;=!8

1%3>4 % '--+,,, 7+, $

$ ;=

3 :4 '--+,,, 7+, " "

51! # " 2

&6-#

"&'77 +,,, "

++7 6,' 1% 1 ""

&7 (--+,,,

2 % 2 8 & )7+ " D # "

'--+,,,

" $2 $

# " 1 ! 2 1 " "

8 ? 2

1 % !

$ "# $51!

2 1 " # % 2

% 28 8

&)7+ "

2 $

" 1

" 6,+ # 2

"$$ 2" $

2 !""

" 6,7 1% 2 "$$ !""

2 " 28

&)7+ " "91 &2

$ CCCCF . :

6- +,,-# "$

"91&+,.;+,,,2 - %

$ " # 91&(,- ( & $2 +,,, 6,71%2"

2 "

6,.1%

5$#$ /2

# " "

-*+1%

5 "$

" "

"" 8$

- >"$2 +,,72 - %

58$ 2 " 2 "$

C =+;+ ) 91&(,- ( & $2 +,,, 2

% " ;% # 2 " 5 "$

# " # 2

5"$

% $$ ""&+

""# 5

#"$$ % H

6, !

+,-'% # $

6, & $2 +,-. * ! $

% "$

?= -

! "$

# "

=C$

6-7% %#$ /

"" 5 " #

+7 & $2 +,-) 5$2 $

&'()*+,-) 7

$ $$

+7 +,-' % = &-7.)*+,-'# $# $ # # # 2

" $:

2 % 6,

+,-'2 " !

C =.

%=+*.- +,-*5

2 % # $## # ! % # $ 6, & $2 +,-.

" $0 $$ 0

$ -, H

2$ "#

$ "

2 "# 1 2 " 2 $

"$ 6- +,,- + $ +) $

&+ "$$ 1 2 "

"25# $ #

2 "!

# # "

-*+ 1%

;

% 2$

" / " $ # $

$ D$

" D# " = G

6-7% % % $$

2$ "$ # "

6-7 % %1 2 " " 5

" $

2 " 2

6-7 % 2 " 4 % $56"

+ $!4!

)74'( 8,9 $ 57 4 $56"

+ $!4!

474!"4( .89 85&54:9 ., 24'")!5 &4!75

"4;

+ $!4!

)744!( 89 85&54:9 $"5

4;4"

05"4

+ $!4!

!!4 4 "( 8 9 .

$ / $44'75!

$56"

+ $!4!

)74'( 89 85&54:9 // 4 $56"

+ $!4!

)74'( 89 24< 4:

. 24=&5

+ $!4!

4>44

!"( /89 85&54:9 /.

6 4 4

+ $!4!

5"4( 8-9

$ ,, 0? %5

!+ 2!

+ $%*54:

) 5*54:

0465!4!( 8 /9- $ ., 475!

"4;)

+ 5

8 /.9 , $ -- %

2$ 2 # 5

% $ " "#

# "

"D I -+ "

! / ! " "

2$ 5

$ "

6-7% % 2$ "$

# % $9 $

# #

4 % $56"

+ $!4!

)74'( 8,9 $ D "D$ D " "$2 5

% D $8$

D"3 4 2$ % 0 " #

A--,?""

$ " " #

@-? # "# 6-7% % " 2C I !&> @111 ? # J "J

6-73-4 % %2

" """

# J "J

I !1 > $D" % 0 " "$$ "

" "" 2 /

$ ""2

#$ $

2 $ 2 "

"" 2 /

-76% % # K "D "

6-7 % % 2"$ 2

""I "

6-7 % %

" #C 2 /

3-41 G

3+45

"$$ " $

" 2 2 =

1 G

+,, +,- +,+% %L "

67* % % "

" $ 2"

6-7% %

2 %

" " G

" 2

2 "

"$$ " C # "

6-7 % % ""# $2 #

%$ + " = 1 # 2

# K "D

6-7% % 22 "2

@11 ? # J "J

6-73-4 % %" $ " 2"

=C$

" " C #

2 $ $

=" #

I !%

" 6-7% %

#$$

" $$ "

" 6-73'4% % "

" "$$ " $ /

" % #

"" 2$$ 2 2 =C$

@1 ? "

/ # "

6-7 % %

""I ? # "

6-7 3-4 % % " 2 C " "" $$ #

/ 2"

" I ! 5 "

6-73'4324 % % "" 2G $ 2 2

""# %

" "

# 2 G

6-7% %#2 $

" 5 "

"" 2G ""

"" "

$ "$$ "

" "

# $$ ""9 $$

""#

= "

""3

2G 4 2 @ > # "

6-7 % % C $

91 $

912 " = # 2 " I !! $

91 $

912 2 " # 2 " " 2$$ 6-7% % $ " " " 2

# "" "

""#2 " "

$ "

6,, 67*% % 2"$ 2 " 2$$ -6 1

" " -' "

2 %

# 2 " "

" 2 @

+ :" 2 +,,, 91&+,.# "

6,+1%

-- :" 2 +,,, 5"$

8 " -6 :" 2 +,,, ' & $2 +,,, $

2 "$

" $

" # 2 - % %

' & $2 +,,, !

( & $2 +,,, 91# 6,71% 6- +,,- ! $ "$

""2

- %

91&+,.;+,,,$

" "

91&(,- ( & $2 +,,, 6,71% "

6,.1%

1 " %1! >

" 3@4 "

" $

$ $

$ $ 2

1 " >3@4$ +,," $ "

$ $ $$2

"5$ #

" ' !

+,,- :

" 2"$

91&(,- $ 6,71% "

6,.1% "

-*+ 1%%$

"G " -*+ - >"$2 +,,7 ' 92 +,,'

"" "G

91&+,.

+ :" 2 +,,, -6 +,,.

="$=%$

91 &(,- ( & $2 +,,, +7 +,-'

" $$ $ !

#"$$ % " # $ "$

" "

6-7% % -( 5 "

6-7% %"$ "

% 0 "

D" 3 4 2

# 2

" $$

6-7 % % "

2 "

2 % 0 " 2

A(- 5 # " $

6-7% % "

+,, +,- +,+ "% % "2

"%$

%!2 "

"$ ""2 " %$

" " "

# $ "

" "

6 M !" -*)+ 3

NM "!" O4"$ 2 " 5 $ 2

6-7 % % " " ""$

2 "

2 " 2 $ "2 0 ""2 % " "" 2 "

2 "

6-7% %

(+?

$ "

? "$

"$"

2 "

2 $ "

"$ $ # "

6-7% %" $#

" ;

" 5 "

6-7 % % "$ 8 " # 2

2 "

# "

6-7% %

"# " "$

# #

(6 5 " "

6-7

% %

5 # "

6-7 % % " 2 C 2 ""2 "

"" # $ 2 $

%$ + "

#$ 2 ""$ " CCCC .7:

" $

" "!2 "

++)% %## $ A "F A"$ 2$ # F 1

" C # N "O

6-7% % 2 5$

" 2 2 -() M "!" "

2 "

" $ #

2 " 5 C # 6-7% % # D "O$ $

"$2 "

2 1 $

""2 "$$ " $$$

" 6-7% % CCCC )'!

" 2" " 2 $ "

2 " 5 #

# " 2 ""

5 "$ "C 2

$ $

" )(5 " "

2 $ "

$ 2 " $$

" " " 2 $

1 " C "

6-7% %

$ "$ "$

" 2 "

" 2

$ "" 2 "

$ "

).5 =

# 8 " " "

# " = 2 2 2 " $" 2

"# $

" ! " $ " / " " 2

" "

6 M "!" 5"

"22

"" 2 " 2 ? 2 $

2 2$ 2 "

# " = 1 " " $

2 "2 "

2 $

" ))1 $

" 2

" / 2" 2 # $/

" " /

$$ 2 "" 2 % #$2 2 "$

2 ""$ "

"$$ " 5

" " 2 # $

# " C" " 2 " 2 $

"" 2 " " 2 "

2 $$

"" )* 5 # $

" $

# # N "O$

""$ " # "$

"$ 2

" " " )75# A "F 2

6-7% % 5" 2 # "

$ 2 " $

2 2 5 2 " 2"$$

/" # " "$

80. In view of the discussion made and the conclusion drawn hereinabove, the answer to the aforesaid question posed is that apart from evidence recorded during trial, any material that has been received by the court after cognizance is taken and before the trial commences, can be utilised only for corroboration and to support the evidence recorded by the court to invoke the power under Section 319 Cr.P.C. The 'evidence' is thus, limited to the evidence recorded during trial."

3$ 4 -. 5

# =

# %

% $

8" -) %$

G # "

# 2 >

>" 2 "$

2 - % % ' & $2 +,,, A $2 2

" # " " "$ $ $

$? "

$ " 2

" 1 " $ / $2" " $

=== # 1 / +=6 2 !$

$ !$

$ 2

# # #

-+&

$ >

1 " 2 $ % 1 / # $ 5 &

$ 2 F -* 5 "$

" 2 /

91 $

2 6,7 1% "

6,.1% A' $

$ "

# "

" %

# "

# " 2 -'-,+,,, +*-,+,,,

2 $ "

$ $ $$2

$ " $

5 #" $$

" # H/$

# #$$

%1!

+)-,+,,, # 2 $ "

" 2 > 1 "

$ #" $ " $ $ $$2

$ "F -7 5$2 2 $#

?=-

% # $# " $

"2 5

% 2 5

% +, 1 "

"$ " 5

A-. &# G

" " "$

# $ "

""$

""&-# # ""&+I5

" MC=-

2" #

# "#

$ 5 " "

" $

$ ""&+ "" &-1 $ #

% 2 "$ " "

""&-9 $ 2 " " #"$

""&-# # ""&+ "$$ " "

6,. "

6'1% # ""&+ " "$"$

/C $ 5

" $ $ $ # "# $2 2 "" $ $ $# " $#

# $ 2 ""

" $/ $ ₹ 2 " $ + / ,(--+,,, >" ₹ $ -/3 "

$ $ ?=-42 $ "" / " "

2" 2 $ "

" $

" $/$ 2 ₹ $ +/

""#

" $ $ "" / C $ 2 " $

2 $

$ -) 5

"" " # "$ "2"$

# "

% 2

"" &- "" &+ G 2

"$ " "

"$ " G 2 "

2 ""

"2 "# " $"

# G

"" "$$ " "

6,.

# "

6'1 %F +- %$

2 ""

# >

>" 2 " $

# " #

2 $ "$

""# "

" 2

2 $ ++ !" 2/ "

" " *&' (

8 3

Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No Whether reportable :

Yes/No