Prem Kumar & Co. v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!" #$
% " &'() $'
*# '' # ++## $,++-'."/ 0 '' , ' # 0
'' '."/ '"+, # '/0 %12(/+3413 '# (/+&+- 34415 +3) $ 6666 *"+ *"+ " ,+' '-'
&'# '"/'- 7"'
# ,$ ' # 9 : #"$ ;< &< 3 ;<3 ! + - " / ' #++-'# #'+ /' # = , /+$ 7"+ + '1 + , "/' &' # 1 ' < / ' ! + ' , < #+$ ' $ (.$=, + 5 "#9 3> ?43" $+7" + - # / 1 # 8 + &' (.$"+#$/'++ 91 , 3
&' #3' 32# ++/5 "#9 -''', ++' &' #1 ' ,$"/
@ $ ' #",+ @ -++ ,
13'-1 3 '<#+$#" "-''' ++ '1" 2
&' +1# 1'<#+$ ++-
!
"
# $ # &' "
# &'( !) %*' $# &'+,-./ "!0 ##"! +,/1!%"##
"##
2" 2 0$ "! 24-!
3 #56-7 7-!
"*%5 6-8 !'
* 2##0 * !, % # * !
!%"##
"
!'** !!2'#
"! !2% % !
* ( 2
"6-7,-. % "## 0 ##
2 $ " 6-.,-8 "#!0 % * %"
# * !
2 6-.,-80 ##
8:4 # * !
2 "6-7,-. ;
,0 !
&' " 2 # &' + % *' $ "! ##"! /!%"## 4" !"4 2 "*% 2 "! 76
, <; %!
'3!<( ! 2 0% *%5 "
"= ! " *'#
"##
2 !
" 2 "* "# $ "5 !%"## " "
"( !
" "2
(
! " 2##0 !"4 3* ' 5 !%"##
"##
"
"# !
% 3* !! 2 (
! !%"##
"3
" * '
$ !'** !! ( #$ '* !
( 3 * !#"
28:2 "# !
( 3 * ## !"##
'3 -8 %"$ > 0= "$50% *% ( ! "# *"!
"$ '3<( !
## 4" !'"##
'3 -8 %"$ > 0= "$5 '3<( !%"##
!3!
22 $ >* !
" ">"
44 !! "= "333 "
4 "!' ! "!% 4"$
42
!
2 ( '
*!'# "
0 % >* !
## * "
+>* !
/**
7-
,
<;
*"!
2 ,"## 5 3* !! !%"##
0 % (
! !
( 3 * *43'
24 "# # * !
2
"#"* # * !
2 '3<;
$ '* !'** !! ( !#"
!2-6:2 "## * !
"#"* # * !
2'3<;
## !"##
4" 3 !*
22 !%"## *' *$ 2 "% ,"## !%"##
"
!="*!
2 "#"##
*"!
2 " % % "# 5
!
( "#"##
, *"!
2 ,"## '3<;
5 0 ##
'* "#&' " "#"* &' "5"! *"!
4"$
52 %"
'3<;
?
&'#",+
' ++ ' 1'- + ++'(.$ +1 " @ "# '
# * ! 24 %"
' >* !
# *$2 "6-7,-.+7( !2 '3 /5 ( +'3 / 2 *' $ # &' !
* A""# !
"##
"
B6: # !! !
( 3 * "# "33# *"
!" (
-8676-. 24-6 . 22 * 2
3'
$ >* !
" ">"
44 !! +>* !
/5
!
#5 '" A"*% % 5 A""# % !" "33# *"
0'#
3 3 !
* 2 "33# *" ! $ 44
" $
3'
$ 44 !! 5 A""#
24"
0 % " " !
4 $5 *'4 !5 #*"
2 ( 5 # * * 2
+ !
( "4' /5&' "" * ! 2 "## *"
"= 24 #*"# >* !
22 * "24 0
!
2
3" 000%"$""
">*4? " '/''# ' # / ''# +"# '1 '$ @3'$/ ''# ,""# '1 '$ &'$" ' / '','
,'<#+$ '$ &'#"# ' "#$,+,$'# '<# 3 +$3 ' $ +"4",1# 1''+ ' $ -"+,A ''+'$
&'# ''' A,+"+' ,',", ,$' ',',", ,$ '(.$ 4 - + 3 (.$ ' ", , +'# '", ,838B3C ? ' "+#
&' "+# -+$<$ &' # $3' 3- 3C88? &' # '3' 3," 383
8? 4 /+$3'"+ 3 3 3 ? 4 /' # 3'A' '$ ,+"+ ' " 3 3 3 ? ' (.$ = , + &' #'' '''' A,+"+','(.$=, + &' #9 ,$' #"/ "#'+' #= &' #9 '+''# =- #$ ",$+"+/'A' ',,3 "/''1 ' + -'+", /',''1/ +'","#$' "+"+' ,' /+, ',", ,$'(.$
& ' " , "3 $ ' # 1'<#+$'#",+ &'# '1/ ' ", /," /' +1 +$/ -''", ,'+
'# &'"',1" '# ,$ '."/ 1D''"
' A"3 " % ;! "
2 C"$"" " !
&' 1D'#++$ '# 1'<#+$ ",$" "' &'1D''+++- E% 3
0"! ,"##
( !2# * *
2 !85665666<,2"3 2DE"$!#$ 2DE"$!2 4" 2 2 "* "#$ " 6-7,-. "
!= " *!
"# "##
!3 #"'!
5 # &'( !0 "##
2"3 2 0$ "! 6-6.6-7
7-676-8 "##$# * * 0"!
"
2"3 2 " 2 "6-7,-.5 0% "2
0"!
2 " 6-.,-8 0 % 8: 4 # * * 2
%" 2 $ " 6-7,-. " 2" #'
# * * 5 # * *
0"! 22
% !!
*' $ 3!
" ( 0'#
,"##
"! 3 3 !*
3* ' "
% ! !="*!
% !
"!3 * !2 3# *$0 2'##$ =0# 2 "#"##
5% %5"!0 ##"!
5 A"3 " % %'!5 % "# "##
% %"!0 ##"!A"3 " %
"0" 2 3( ! !2#"'!
"!0 ##"! #"'!
7- 2 C"$"" >* !
# *$5 "
' $
4! " * ! * "
* 3
0"! "##
# * * 2 " 3 2 DE "$! #$ 24 76-6-. 7-676-.5 2 5 % 0'# !
3 !% ! 2 "# "##
% %"0'#
' !
= 0"# 2 # * * 2 "6-.,-8!'
* * %"
0"#0'#
"
8:4
# * *
2 "6-7,-.%
48: 4 # * *
2 "6-7,-.
*"!
2 3
%"!
""! # * *
3" $ 3
"*43'
!" "! ! 2 $ " 6-6.6-7 7-676-.F8:2 !" 3 * *43'
5 # * *
2 "6-7,-. 0=!'
!-5.65B656G7<," 3
%" 22 0 # * * 2 $ " 6-.,-8 "
!" "
! ( # "# * >' ,. "
G676-. C0 ( 5 !3 ! *%!
"** !"4 " ! !
%"
3
!
= 0"# 2 # * * 2 $ " 6-.,-8 $ "
# * *
2 "6-7,-."!3 "##
"# # * *
% % ! 5.B5BB5BBB<, 2"* "2 ,4
!
"2 !3 ! !( $!'3 ! ! *
4!2#"'!
7-5 ,"## 2 # &' ( !0"! 3
"2
*"* ##
"## "# "##
% %""!3 #"'!
7-5 ,"## !
"
!= " *!
"# "##
+ >' ,G/4 ! %"
, "## # &' ( "##
% % 0"! 3
4! 2 #"'!
7- % 2 5 *#" 45 2 "$5 &'" #!! *"'!
"**' 2
"# * *
2 4" 3" 2 "6-7,-."!0 ##"!2
"6-.,-85# !!
%"8:4 # * *
2 "6-7,-. "
"
"
0% *% # * * 0"!"##
2 "6-7, -." !'# #!!50'#
*( "
#
4!2#"'!
7-24 "#"##
5 "4 #$5% %% !3 ! #$ "** 22 2 3
2 0"# 2 # &'( "
!-5.65B656G7<,5 '
"#! 3*
" " !
% %
4! 2 #"'!
7- 2 *( $ 2 #!! *"'!
$ % 4 "#"##
2 "!!
!
=0
4
" "(" #"
# $ 2 "#
"
( $ 2 "33 "#!'22 * * %"
!"4 0"! 3 !!
( 0 !
" *"!
# = % ! (#(
3
"
2 3( ! ! 2 >* !
# *$ 0 2" 24 # "
"(" # $2"33 "#! * '# 2 "#
"
( $ ! 4 #$ " '# *"'
** #$5 &'
!
!3!
"
( %"(
"!0 "!"
( 5 0 3
!"##0 + >' ,G/ !&'"!%
! # %"
"# %' % 3
0"! ' !
= 0"#2 # * * 2 "6-.,-8 # * * 2
8: 4 # * * 2
6-7,-.$
3
H!22
4! 2 "!4" ( # "# * + >' ,./"
G676-. %"(
"**
5
!
"
!#( 2% ! !3!
# $
# * !
% 3
! !3!
# 2 #!!"
'
"
# "# "##
* *'4!
"* !5 !3 ! " '
$ ' 2' !
*' $"4' 2 ! 8585666<, "! "#! " "# "4' 2 ! -5665666<, 3
% !"4 0'#
%'
3 9' * 3
H! % !
= *43 !
"**"* 0 % #"0" " !
!3 ! 2 #"$ 2' 2 "2 ,4 "4' C0 ( 5
!3 !0'#
"
#
$ "= "* "**"* 0 % #"0 *( #!! "**' 2
""4' 0"#2
# &'( !2 "6-.,-8# !!
# * *
F8:2 "6-7,-.24% % "#"##
I 3
!"##0 "! *!
? ,",$'."/ '1D' @ # '"" 3' + &'1D''+' A' ,+"+','+#,$' # @,'+' #''."/ -"+ ##+$'# ''# ' "##+$ ' -+ '",7"$ 1-' #=' 'A' -,+"+' ",,$' /+ + @'''# , "' 3' ."/ -"+'1,##+,+ ",+/ &' '."
/ #"#'2'## '# ,$'# &' # '#+$#"#' ;1 ' 3 -"+ '1 , # ' # " # ' + -'" # ."
$1 #"+/ -''."/ ' 1 D'
+" 4 ' #+$ ' ' ' ,$ A " , +"+ ' , ' + ##+,+' /+++ F# ++ ', ,1"+$
2 ' /+ , = , &' , ' ++ -' ' , -' ' , ' # 1" , ),-"+, +1' "/'" &' '/' ' , ' ++ -"+ , ," ,$ ' , ' /+ + $ + ',$"' # &' # +"#'."/ '1D' ' "
A""4 " " " ;! % "
C"$"" " ! &' + +$ /"',+ ', " &' ", '1D'' -'+"D' #+$ '$ -++/+ '<''+',/1#" +$1 -''++''/'-$"' #+/ "# #++/'+ " -' ' 1 &' # ' ' + '++/ #",+ -' ,$ ' 1"+1 ''/'-$ ' , #" ",$' # @'3'# - +++ +"+" $+7" / "# &'-#' ' 9+ )/'-$ 4"' $ @ 4 @> - + '++//'#+$'(,'".,('"+* ++ 4 * F /"+ 1+# 43 B8 # ,/
,/ $' ",$' 9)4@' $*& # )/'-$ &'() $ " #+$ +/' '9+)/'-$ '()/'-$-''-'",. '@> &'( ) $= #+$ + + ' '/ ' 1 ' " ' +" D ' #+$ ,$ $/ ," ' / "#-++'+"+ ++$-'"2/'+= &' 7" - -'' ' ( 51 - + "+ ++$ &'1D''+'-'1 #+7" +
" +/ +7" 1 9+ ( )/'-$ +/-' +7" 1 " + 3 ' ( -"+ , + ' +" / ' + -'" ' &' 1 D'" ' '+'"'+-"+,,+/"-' '1' " + /' <# 1 # &'" , "-,$'1D' @ ' " 3 ' #"/
4<" 7"' &' + #$,+ ,$ ' # '$ '++, ',', ", ,$'# ',',", ,$' /++3 +$3'(.$ &' '++3'-1 3, !"# "$% &'() Whether to be referred to the reporter Yes √ No