High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4589/2017dismissed

Rajinder Kumar Meghwal v. Santra Devi And ORS

2023-04-25Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil8 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()**+

) ,-. * / ./ ..

- ****

! "#

$

! %& ' / (0""1 #203&45 * ( ) " * # *'

+,+-.+(/

*'

0 ! 1 (.+..+(-

*' 0 !) "

*"2 . ) #" 3 # #

* "

""

4

#

"536(7 ##%! 3 (8+9.++:

! 53 "! """

"'" #" # # "!0 !

* ! .++: ;

* # )< " *

# # # "* ! .++, ) "" *== # .!+++74"" # # 8 > " #

* " # "

"*'; *

- 2 -

# "** " ""

#" ""

"

" * "#

" # .!+++74" # '< # ""

" #

*' ##3

*

#

"

# " 9+:9+-<;!

!* *' #

" 9 & " # " ? 1# "3

*' ; *! *

" ##" $ " *#" 9+- 9+:!9.+<; !# # * '" * "#

# "9+? <; # ""

# ##" * "9+:<; # * ""

#

" 9+? <;! ! * '

'! '

'!

"

'!

# '#' "# " * "

"

* " ! #'" "!3

!" " " #

"

! # '

## ' !

- 3 - "

" * "#

)

!# # ##" # " * " #

* 2 *

'

""

" '

" #

' - " 9+: <; * '

'! ' ' " "'#

*" '# *

*$ ! "!#" ! * $ ! ' !"

" * "#

"#

'! *

# #

# " # " '3' ! **#<

" ##" # #" * "#

"

*'

#1'' "# ! 7 "4""

"* *"

#

/

##" "9.+<; " *' ' " " ' ' ' ! $! ' ' # *

'! '" !" " *#* " * '! *

# " # " '3 ' ! * * # <

" # ##" * "9.+<;! * ""

" ) " * # " 9(? <;! "

- 4 - *' " ' ! # ' ' "

" ' '' ! " ' ' '! ' " " '" # "!""

"

$'"

*'! !

'! " < " ##"#"" *3 " < "

' # # $ ' "

" # " # $

* 2 ' " *

" "! *

* 2 " "# ""

#" # # " ##" "

, )3""#3

@

@

" 9+? 9+: # <; * *' " #

;

!" #$ % && ' %

( %&) "" " !A

A"

" # *' # ' $ * *' " ""' *

#*'

#" ) #

# ' " ' # ' #

- 5 - # '"

'# '*$

#*' # *# # ' ) 3

@5

@ "

" ' ' *# ' " * : )

# * ##"#" * "#

#"9+?

* "9+-! <; "#

' # *! BC

' ' ' 'D BC

"

'D

# ' # '

## ' "# " * "

"

* " ! #'" " " " #

"

)3

A

A"

" ' ' *# ' ! " * 5

"

' # < ' ##

" ## "3 < #""!

#

" '

' "# # '

' ) *#" '

" # " " * " #

* "

!

* ""

"" # '# *#< *

# '!* '

- 6 -

' "

# ; " *$+" , + $$ -.

/ 0 102 (+ < *

# ' ""

! 3 " # @

' <

*#

#

)

*

(( E! * **

2 #* #<; *' # * * " #

!""

*== # .!+++74# ' ' # # % (8+9.++:< " # # ' ** # # '! 0 !

* ! .++:! # .!+++74 < ! # * 2 ' 536875" "*' *4

##" F;G!)

';

!1 E8++/ (,+..+(8 6 " ""

536875! F;G!)

### # F# ""

G "#6 E/ # # ##%

! # ' " < # 536875 4 ' *# # " "" '

"" # < *

"#"'

- 7 -

$ "

"

' ) '! F;G! ) 536875 """

*

#

" ") '! 536875! F;G!) ! ##" # # *4 !) ! """

' $ (( 5!6( !) 2 ' (,+..+(8"" *""

" # F;G! ) "

#" 2 ' * *' *' "' " (/8 ; ; ) #" " ' " ""

*

""

# ' * " " # < ""

" " # * ' " ""

*'

# * *) !

! # " *' # * * 68 ##" *""

# "& ) *

# *4 ) #" *'68 #

< ##" #" (. )

! # # ##" # " * "#

" 9+-9+: 2 *

'

""

- 8 -

" '

" #

' < " ! *' #

# ""

(8 )

! # * "

! ; * ' " "2 ""

*' *## * *' # * #""

)" # * *' # "" " * " *' # )

! "

2 " ""

(9 <#* "

! ' # '

*'*" * "" '! " *'

.?+9.+.8

/ (0""1 #203&4

203"

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No