High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22091/2010dismissed

Satyapal Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-07-31Mr. Justice Amit Rawal,Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal6 pages

"!#$%&'( )

* +"'","+-./.$

$ 0$&$ .+"!"'""/.$

$,1$

!"#$ " $ %

!"#$$#

&&&

$% 2 03"'+ 4"3")1#"! 2 4&5"+-.)1#" !.,$

2"."3")1#"")"'""5. 2 +"6".+"-")11 1#"")"'""

77777 $# ' .$.,1.,$5,$5.. .6$#6,8#$.,5$#!1&1$&9: $#;

<!+#(!."'""2&#,","#) = ;!$.) = #<1#"- .2&#,"&#)4"""$ " 2&#,",")4""9'"11-&""" .-"#!.,$)$.)$.""$,. ,$$!+# :!."'""2&#,"#) >("1$&9: $#;

<!+#(! =#)9!,6&-"!#-. 2&#,"&#9'"11-!5"-$"$2&#,",")

,,&'!."-5"$-"'93#$5$&-. $&,, !."!61$&96$$)"#."$9"1.,$$ !#$ =(:"1 =(:

!.$&!1"$&96." 2,"""6"$"""."-",,&"!"#$6 #6,$1 6 1$#$ "1 #$$- ! 5 6 2&#,"$ "#."'"$.#-&&$""$$,#!19'. 9',&9#!#"9"2,""" 2

2"."3")"11#"")"'"""$$$1 9' 2 +"6". +"-") "1 11" 1#" ") "'"" $&961.".#$'.$-"1."$""1'9$"$9' .$#.!.$&"

( )*)+,) - +.

+/+")

)0) )) - +'

123 3'1#11

?) 5. #$1- . 3&1-6 11 9' @9 . +&,6& )- " 4,) - +.

+/+") ()5,) )- +,) - +'$16"7'5.."$9.1"#! .6!'-#$&!.2&#,"'81- $6$"-$"!&#)5.#.1$A&"',,&'! ."-

."."1."11#"")"'"""1 ",,"$1.,",9B

+&9:$#;

<!+#(! =#"1$"$&1%:

C.66"')!666)9'!#". !!#" "D) 1#" "' 6&#,"' #&1- "" #6,$- &" "" " ," .!) ! "') 9 " ,"B5"$C.2&#,","!;"6! ,"<E

6 . ," "1 $6, "1- ! . "!61

7 ,$) $ #" ." . 6 $ $1 5. ,5 ,6&-".6&#,"'"1.$,$!"!!1-"' ,,&'

+6",,$#"6919"1&,.3&1-6 #1$&,")5.)5.#-."1#11#&1&. 3&1-611.) ) 8)( ) 5,)0)')

)9)) -

+/+") / 9):) - +'

1' 1#11

)."$9.1.",,&'!

."-!.,&,$!81-$6#$&!2&#,"' $A&19-.#"""$9-"-$"!&# -$""#$.#""1,6&-"!"-"&!#1&# 5.&!#,"#&"#"$$)5."$""16$""#$. 6"B-"1$$&!"$,#!#1#.",,#"!"-"& " ,"#&" #"$ "##1"# 5. . A&6$ ! ,#'

$& ! 2&#,"' "1 #$ ! 2&#," &# 9' "11-!5"-$2&#,","$.16"!. -$"&"1).&$)#"9A&$1 .$"B!9')" ,!.3&1-6"1$.&$%:

C!"#)"$#.!.$& >

*1"6 "#."'")2"2"3""1.$ +" ! &3"9"1.$)1#11

)."$"$.1." $"9$.6 ! " 2&#," 66 $ " -$" !&# ."8"#!6.$"13&1-6"1$"$ &1%:

C+6"$.5!...3&1-6$1 &,9'"1#&$!.,$ 2"1"F" +"! &3"9);

< ;<?(G"11" +&#$ F61 +#"') ,"6 ! F#" 1$);

G<= ;<?G .3&1-6$!1

2 9'."1#&$!.,,#1 . "$$&6, ." " !#" #$&- " 2&#,"' 81- $ 6&#," 6$ $ "16$""& +&#."$$&6,5"$,9"9'

!."$.".,$$!.##6," " ,,&' ! ."- ! . 3&1-6$ !19'."1#&$!.,). 1$# 95 . "16$" "1 -$" !&#$5"$9&-..#!.&)5.#. ."$9$&93#6"!#$1"9!."- #.$!.H9+&,6& $,#!. 2&#,"$"$"$.""-&$,$$) . &#.3&1-6$!.$&.""B. $6"5 .!)"#!."1#&$ !.,.$#.3&1-6$! .$ & . 3&1-6 !. +&,6 & "1+-."1$$ +"!6"#." "1$."1 $) *>+ ()$!.,, . 3&1-6 "1 +-.H$ #"$ ;$&,"< ."$ 9 #$11.#"$$"1."$91$-&$.1

.!)5!1.""#!.+"6 !'-#$&!.2&#,"'81- $6$"-$"!&#"1.$"6)1$ A&",,&'!."- &$#.$"& #6,"$",,&'!."-).-&! -"!,,&'!."-$.$"6"$$ A&1!""16$"A&"$3&1#"!&# $&#.,,&'#"16#&1,,&'! ,$"."- .&$)5!1.""!#"#$&-2&#,"'" !#""9$.-2&#,"'$""#!-$""1 .&$#" 96,&-1.-&1$5.#.""""9 ! "16$" A&"$:3&1#" 1$ #- . 1!!#95.-$""1"16$"!&#) $ #. "6 "#."'") 2" 2"3"H$ #"$

3 ;$&,"<)9$1"$&1%:

C5!."9)#"9.1.""-$""# $.#""1,6&-"!"-"&! #1&#5.&!#,"#&"#"$$)5."$" "16$""#$.6"B-"1$$&!"$,#!# 1# . ",,#" ! " -" & " ,"#&"#"$"##1"#5..A&6$! ,#'

F-$"$.,#$$&$&"',"- !&&) "16$" $ . ,#$$ ! ,!6- ,"#&""#$)!$$&-,"#&"1$!6"B- 1#$$5.#.",,'-"&$,"#&"#"$$

"13&1#")..."1)",,$$,#!# 11&"$$&"$ &).$"'"9"1 1$#$ . 93# ! . &) . "#. ! $ ",,#").-.$"19-"$"$-&!)$ 11!!#,"$),$"1!&&$)$ !6).6"!$,6&-""$6!"#$ 5.#.6"'.,1"5-.95-$" "1 :-$" "#$ . $"1 !"#$ ." 9 ",,1!.1-.".!8"!,#&1. ,$$!.$$"661$#"!! &1.##'#)

()"-$""&

+&#.,#,$."9",,1$,#!. #$&!.2&#,"'8$!$6$) .!#$&#.3&1-6$$6"1."! ,"!6."!$"13&1-6)"$#. "6 "#."'""$$+B." +"! &3"9"1.$) ;

< ;< )."$"$"B.$"65.""# !#$&!"2&#,"'$-$""#

"$!1."","!6.!"#."3&1-6. #"$!0 4",;$&,"<."$9!&191&1"9' . +&,6 & 9& . 1$# 95 " "16$" !&# . -$" !&# 5"$ 9&-..#!.&.3&1-6$!F"- #.$!.H9+&,6&"$#$11"6

;

"#."'")2"2"3"H$#"$;$&,"<5!1!. ,&$"!.& .!).$"13&1-61$"'

15"91-,#1!.$&

$A&')51!1"'6.,$ 5,

$6$$1 #"6"&61!&!.!"#.".5,$ ,1-"13&1#"$#

5.&"'6$"').!)#"&$ !"#"-1'"##&1-$&$

$"&,$.!&"$-).5,$1$6$$1

< " $ % = <$# = !%8 !%8 /07'1 )( +, , +> )* 4? )+

- @ +?

, > ): @ +?