M/S Narula Foods P Ltd. v. Pb. St. Coop Supply And Mkt. Fed. Ltd. And ANR.










 

 

 



 !"

"#$%$&'
 &( )*

+

!,

-
.

/% )(0
1%
)$2 !"
3$4$!"1
()(, )% , $-
$%!)$#!
")5"6() 66"00 &!

7")%(% ,"
(&8 9
:! !"
6") !$2"
:(660*
&1
);"!$&<
"1") !$&
3$4$!"1

);"1-
")5"6()
&1
&!,")  "%6&1"&!%  



 !

!

"#

$%

 =,"!,")
"6)!")%

0# 0
6 6")%
4 *
9"
00>"1
!
%""
!,"
8(1<4"&!?  
9"
)""))"1
!
!,"
"6)!")%
)
&!?

@ =,"!,")
!,"
8(1<4"&!
%,(01
9"
)"6)!"1
$&
!,"
$<"%!?

)"%"&!'

)A &> 08$!
:$&<,-
:"&$)
12# !"
>$!,

):A3$9"), &
12# !"

)$< &;
:, )4 -
12# !"- )
!,"
66"00 &!

) (! 4
(!!-
12# !"- )
)"%6&1"&!
 BBBBB







































!

"#

 &'( $2$0
$%#@@C



)
!,"
)" %&%
4"&!$&"1
$&
!,"
660$# !$&-
>,$#,
$% %(66)!"1
9*
&
$1 2$!-
1"0 *


1 *%
$&
$0$&<
!,"
66" 0
$% #&1&"1
%! &1%
1$%6%"1


 

 ,"
66"00 &!C $00")
$%
<<)$"2"1

!,"
)1")
1 !"1
D.- >,")"9*
!,"
98"#!$&%
$0"1
(&1")
:"#!$&
@

!,"
)9$!) !$&
&1 &#$0$ !$&
#!-
++.
)
%,)!
E++.
#!F
%"";$&<
%"!!$&<C %$1"

!,"

> )1
1 !"1

D@-
, 2"
9""&
1$%4$%%"1

)A &> 08$!
:$&<,-
0" )&"1
:"&$)
(&%"0
%%$%!"1
9*

)$< &;
:, )4 -
12# !"-
66" )$&<
&
9", 0

!,"
66"00 &!C $00") %(94$!%
!, !
!,"
#0 $4

!,"
);"1
> %
 00$&<
(&1")
!,"
"G#"6!"1
#0 (%"

&1
&
98"#!$&
$&
!,$%
)"< )1
> %
0%
! ;"&
9")"
!,"
)9$!) !)-
9(!
!," )9$!) !)
 $0"1
!
! ;"
$&!
#&%$1") !$&
!,"
% 4"
,"
> )1

$&!")"%! H
I
6")
&&(4-
>,$#,
%
6")
!,"
!")4%
&1
#&1$!$&%

!,"
<)""4"&!-  00%
>$!,$&
!,"
"G#"6!"1
#0 (%"-
!,")")"-
!,"
)9$!) !)
1$1
&!
, 2"
!," 8()$%1$#!$&
: 4"
2")*
98"#!$&
> %
) $%"1
9")"
!,"
98"#!$&<
()!-
9(! &
)" %&
, %
9""&
%%$<&"1
"$!,")
##"6!$&<
)
1"#0$&$&<-
!,")")"-
!," 66"00 &!
, %
9""&
6)"2"&!"1
)4
18(1$# !$&

!,"
98"#!$&%

6) <4 !$# 00*

) (! 4
(!!-
0" )&"1
#(&%"0
66" )$&<
&
9", 0

!,"

);"1
%(94$!%
!, !
!,"
#0 $4

!,"
$00")
> %
&!
 00$&<
>$!,$&
!,"

"G#"6!"1
#0 (%"-
9(!
!,")
#0 (%"%
)"< )1$&<
!,"
%,)!
 00

!,"
)$#"
&1 )$<,!0*
!,"
98"#!$&%
, 2"
9""&
1$%4$%%"1
&1
!,"
> )1
$%
0$ 90"
!
9"
(6 ,"01 
, 2"
," )1
!,"
0" )&"1
#(&%"0
)
!,"
6 )!$"%
&1
66) $%"1 !,"
6 6")
9; &
<$&<
!,)(<,
!,"
$46(<&"1
)1")

!,"
98"#!$&<
()!-
 4

!,"
2$">
!, !
$!
, 1
&!$#"1
!,"
#&!"&!$&%

!,"
66"00 &!
2$%C C2$% 8()$%1$#!$&

!,"
)9$!) !)-
9(!
&
)" %&%
, 2"
9""&
%%$<&"1
9*
8(%! ,01$&<
!, !
!,"
>"00
)" %&"1
> )1
, %
9""&
6 %%"1
,"
6") !$2"
6 )!
 !,"
)1")
)" 1%
!,(%'C E

 

       

 

  

         

 





 

)       

   

         

       ! "#  

    

#

!   $           % &

%'  

  

          (  



           %'  !   !

        

        )  %( )

  *  %  %'   

   

!    

     !            (  



           %'+ %!

          

    ,!     

   

 !         )
-  

       

 

  ,!     

   '     ! 

   .*    '         

  !    

    

   

     

!  

      



           

  !  

        /

 

      !   0,1,.

  !  

   !



   



 %     .   2 
4

!,"
2$">
!, !
!,"
66"00 &!
, %
9""&
1"6)$2"1

,$% )$<,!

18(1$# !$&

!,"
98"#!$&%
$&
!")4%

!,"
6)2$%$&%

:"#!$& @

++.
#!
##)1$&<0*-
!,"
$46(<&"1
)1")
$%
%"!C %$1"
&1
!,"
4 !!") $%
)"4$!!"1
9 #;
!
!,"
98"#!$&<
()!
!
1"#$1"
!,"
% 4"
%
"G6"1$!$(%0* %
6%%$90"-
6)"") 90*
>$!,$&

6")$1

!,)""
4&!,%
)4
!,"
1 !"
 )"#"$6!

#")!$$"1
#6*

!,$%
)1") 
4
0%

!,"
2$">
!, !
!,"
98"#!$&<
()!
# &&!
6)"#0(1" !,"
66"00 &!
)4
! ;$&<
(6

!,"
98"#!$&%
&
!,"
<)(&1
!, !
!,"
% $1 98"#!$&%
, 2"
9""&
! ;"&
9")"
!,"
)9$!) !) ,"
6 )!$"%-
!,)(<,
!,"$)
#(&%"0-
)"
1$)"#!"1
!
66" )
9")" !,"
98"#!$&<
()!
&
D. 66" 0
%! &1%
00>"1

'*+'&, -./#

0

 !

"  &'123/

$%