High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/430/2006disposed of

Commr. Of Income Tax Ludhiana-Ii v. M/S Avery Cycles Ind.Ltd.

2015-01-07Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu9 pages

! "# $

% && !! "

"& ()*+,- . && !! "

"& ()*+,- . //

'!+!

23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , !/", !/", !/", !/",

! "# $

% && !! "

"& ()*+,- . && !! "

"& ()*+,- . //

'!+!

23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , !/", !/", !/", !/", 6%

6 6%

! "# $

% && !! "

"& ()*+,- . && !! "

"& ()*+,- . //

'!+!

23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , !/", !/", !/", !/",

! "# $

% && !! "

"& ()*+,- . && !! "

"& ()*+,- . //

'!+!

23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , 23!4 '550 ",!* , !/", !/", !/", !/", 6$

6 6$

! "# $

&& !! "

"& ()*+,- . && !! "

"& ()*+,- . //

'!+!

23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , !/", !/", !/", !/", 67

6 67

! "# $

% && !! "

"& ()*+,- . && !! "

"& ()*+,- . //

'!+!

23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , !/", !/", !/", !/",

! "# $

% && !! "

"& ()*+,- . && !! "

"& ()*+,- . //

'!+!

23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , 23!4"50 !* , !/", !/", !/", !/", %6

6 %6

! "# $

% && !! "

"& ()*+,- . && !! "

"& ()*+,- . //

'!+!

23! '50 ",!* , 23! '50 ",!* , 23! '50 ",!* , 23! '50 ",!* , !/", !/", !/", !/", 2# 2# 2# 2# 8*291** 8*291** 8*291** 8*291** 8*299:* 8*299:* 8*299:* 8*299:* '

# 2!9

),4

2';!- 5- ")9 " ',4

- 2'0;2

0),4

=== > 4 - )?'

0@ > 4 - )?'

0@ 5< 5 - !', ')< !- 00, !

)

$) 6%

!&& !! "

(.)*+,- 1!23!4 '550 !",!* ,)! 6$

6 ",

6)&& !! "

"& (.)*+,-

1! 23!4"50 !* , ",%6

6)&& !! "

"& (.)*+,- 1!23! '50 !* , !A

+!- "B "B', '!/

"& (//

' A+"

0?- . ".

!8 ' A+"

08@

0!A5'

! "B +'!+A!

0C+ "! <)<- -

&&" 00

0!#.

, !

00< " +"

"&"

5A''< '/+'- ", "!

/0 ",& - "

" ,, " " +"

( !

,+ 5 "

0! "B!

; !+0 //0

" "

,4 ! , '

'! ", '/

! "

" /' ' "!

C+ ' !

! "

$A+ "!< "!

)

,& !! "

7)A5'

05 "B+/" >+,B&

9+/'

" /+ 5&& !! "

"& ()-& /+ 5&& !! "

"& ()-& 1! '

- * , '

- * , ?

7@ 9 % ?

7@ 9 % - '!

C+ ")

), C+ '

"5 +'

'"! ,

" ",C+ ' !

! "!

)

$) 6%

6) 6$

6) 67

6 ",

'5 ,>+,

- !C+ A "B

<-&

!50 /

+'", ' "B A+! "

!!0!! D) ) )7 3.-

+'"< /' , +", ' 9

" ?@ "& ( ) 6

!8 8@!

+ '5"

+", '9

@ !!

'4 ,+/"

) 00< ,

C+ ""

' "! , ' "B

0 "

',) !!

!! "B

,+/"9

"%?@ "0+, ( !

,+ 5 <- 0 &/+ "B / " "B ", 0! "B !

;)

8! "& BB'

- !', ')

&& !! "

' "& (.) *+,- - ?//

0!@ ?-

!8 ?@8@'

,+/" '+0 ' $$ ,

, 667 ", B+ , 0 "

! !!+ , A5 "!

,+"

,, D ) )% 3.& A5

!! "B

' - '

0 A

' A+"

0)<- -< !, !& !!

,A5', ',

%A5'

05 "B +/" >+,B& "8A0 9+/'

" 1! 23!", 23!", 23!", 23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

//"- 0",+!

!* &

//"- 0",+!

!* &

//"- 0",+!

!* &

$% +"!

0 !+A&

>+,B& " 23!

23!

", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,?!+/'

@ ", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,?!+/'

@ ", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,?!+/'

@ ", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,?!+/'

@)'

"0+! "

&,4

",)

), //05 /'

)<- - /

"! "0+! " ( !

,+ 5<- 0 0+0

"B/ " "B ",0! "B ; +"!

!+A&

!",

>+,B& "23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,8!

23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,8!

23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,8!

23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,8!

?!+/'

@ /

"! &,4

! ! &

"5 ", /' " /0 !

+ " 23! ", //" - 23! ", //" - 23! ", //" - 23! ", //" - ",+!

!* &

,8! ?!+/'

@ ",+!

!* &

,8! ?!+/'

@ ",+!

!* &

,8! ?!+/'

@ ",+!

!* &

,8! ?!+/'

/ '+!

! '

!! "B

"0+, ( !

,+ 5<- 0 &/+ "B/ " "B ",0! "B!

; -

?@)A5'

05 "B+/" '+0 '$$ ),

667 ", B+ , 0 "

! !!+ -

,+"

! , "0+! "

% ( !

,+ 5<- 0 &/+ "B/ " "B ",0! "B!

;A5-0, "B

00<!#. E- "! , - !&

+005 ", ", "

"! *

,+"!

0! 00< "B

!"!# ? @

"%'

'! 4 0+

/+'- ", B,! ", "4 '5 -

; 0! "B!

;"05 ", !"

, !) "4 ! <+0, "0+,

/ " "B!

;)/+'- !) !< 00 0! "B!

; ? @ & '

& ", , '+0 ' $$ ,

67 <- - 0

, A ; B'+", '

"% !0

"%- ,A

" "!

,< 666 < - 4 < /+ ", / "

4 0+ 0! "B!

; "/+ !) <'; "/'B'

!!) ", " !- ,B,!&+!

' 05 "0+, ' <- - &,4

"% < ! "!

, " ', ' "!+'

4 0+

/ " "B ",0! "B!

4 0+ ? @ *

,+"!

0- 0! 00+, B+ , 0 "

!!+ , A5 "!

, -

, +"

!) <- - ! 8!/ (,5

'- 4 "B"! ,

' 4 0!+A& !! "!) ", " "

,+"!

- !"

"& "!

<', "4 '5F '+0 0!!/

4 0+ / " "B ",0! "B!

;) ", " &

'! +"

"5) B+ , 0 "

, +"

! / ( ,5) A

-,"4 <

A4 ) & "0 "

- '& !

,+"!

0 ', "B05) 00< - !B'+",

0 "

4+' ", , '

!! "B

' ,

- ! ,, "

) )% 3.& " - ! +"

' '

"! , &

", - 0,

00<!#.

E "

B'+",/

"! ,

"B ,, "

D ) )% 3.& !+0 //0

% - ! !!+ - !A

", 0 A

,+/"A5

' A+"

0 " 23! '9/ "" "B2 00!* &

4 , ', ' ,

, 7

% , !+!! " !

"/ 6 ",

/ 7 ,', '"

!) ! " "

*, +"!

0 '

- ! !!+ - ! 0! A

"8A0 / (+'

" 1! 23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

$% <- !- 0,

&,4

+' "BB,!< -,+ 5/ ,'

0 !" "

"& A

,:- 0 & "B - !"0+! ")

"8A0 / (+'

'& , ! " "8A0

B- +'

<- < ! - 0,

& 05 A

&,4

< ! '

'! A0 '

') / " /+'- ,+ 5 / , '

< &

<+0," &+"

"& <- -< !0 A

+",

G / '+!

"%?@ ", 0

-, +"

"B)"

, " '+0 ' !!+ ,A5

,+"

), +! -0,

/ " " '

', , A5 ' A+"

0 ! " "5 & ""

' / '4 '!

'A '5 -

>+,B& " 23!", //"- 23!", //"- 23!", //"- 23!", //"- ",+!

!* &

,8! ?9+/'

@ ",+!

!* &

,8! ?9+/'

@ ",+!

!* &

,8! ?9+/'

@ ",+!

!* &

,8! ?9+/'

&,4

<+0,&

" ,

! ! &

-, +"

"5 ", /' " /0

'& , "23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,8! ?9+/'

@ 23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,8! ?9+/'

@ 23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,8! ?9+/'

@ 23!", //"- 0",+!

!* &

,8! ?9+/'

C+ 05) ",C+ " ! "!< "!

- ', C+ ") '

! "

" "

,4 ! , '

'! ", ' /

! +"!

0 ' '

$ !+A&

! & 0 '&

'!- A

' A+"

0 "4 < >+,B& "8A0 9+/'

" 9+ 0, '!* , 9+ 0, '!* , 9+ 0, '!* , 9+ 0, '!* , 1! 1! 1! 1! && !! "

"& (?//

0!@ ", " && !! "

"& (?//

0!@ ", " && !! "

"& (?//

0!@ ", " && !! "

"& (?//

0!@ ", " ')?

$@ 77 )?

$@ 77 +"!

'05"

- !C+ "- 0'

"!< "!

",/'

+'!

, "

! && !! "

"& && !! "

"& ( 1! 23!

23!

9+ '"

!4 * , 9+ '"

!4 * ,& 5 0!A ,/

, " /'

"4 <

!& A5 +"!

0 /

- ',C+ "<- - ' !

! "! 6$ ",

6 !

"!< , "

4+' ", "!

A5!

"B.

! , ', ' / , A5 "& ( //

' A+"

0 ", ' "B

' A+"

0 ,>+,

; "B "

"! ,

/ " "'

', "8A0 9+/'

"23!9+ 0, '!* ,8! ?!+/'

@ 23!9+ 0, '!* ,8! ?!+/'

@ +'

-C+ ' !

! "! ",%6

6 +"!

0 !+A&

! " " ,

!!& )

C+ '

/ 5 "

" !!'

+", ,&

,05'

!! "B

' ' B05 0 , "

A+ ?@ ",

"& (//

' A+"

0- A - ''

, ",

"B "

+"!

" '- ",)!+A&

, //05 ", !- 0,

! //0 )

- ! A

0+0

'& ,

"'/'

"," '&

+ A5 !!

!! "B

,! 00<!#.

? @

? @ 9+A>

'/'4 ! "! - ! )<-

"5 '

+", ! B'

+", ' !+A.

"?@

" ) ",.

@ "'

+", !,+ "'

B+0 !!& F' ?A@

&+"

+", , +", ' !+A.!

"?@

,! &+"

+", "'

B+0

!!& )

!- 00A / 5! &/0 "

.- @/ " <-0 ' !! &+"

+", ,) '5&"

-'/ &"

-&/' !

, "

/ ' , '& ,

+", ,

!+-'

B+0 !!& ?

@ :- ) !+0 "', '+", '!

"%'

"%%'!

% '!

%'!

' "',

&& !! " +", ' !+A.!

" ?@ !

%) &+"

+",B'

,+", '!+A.!

"?@

" !- 0, A ''

05 00< ,)

' "<-0

' " / ) ! & 5 A ) ") "

) "5)+", '!+A.!

"?@!- 00A ,+

', "B05 (/0

"?@.

:- ) "'

!!& 5

!!& !& '!

+", '!

"$ '!

"% ) !!& !& !- 00A ',

B+0 !!& /+'/!

! - !!

" (/0

' '

&4 0 ,+A !) ! - A5

/'4 ! "! - !!

"!- 00 0! //05

!!& 5

'&& " "BA

, 5

)

, "B! "'

!+- !!&

' !&/0

G A / '+!

0 9

" ) 0

! "

&A B+ 5

!0 / 5 "

" !!'

+", / " "'

', ' A+"

, " //05

! "''

, " , "5 '

/ !! '

+", ",)

) ! A0 B , +",

/ 5 "

< ') ! 9

", ,&

,05 , ! " /

'!/

05)

<+0,A C+ '

/ 5 "

"'/'

C+ 05) C+ < ! "!< , "

4+'

A5-0, "B

!0 / 5 "

!!'

+", '&

C+ "! <- 4 "BA

"!< ,)

, !/!

, ', "B05 ?1**@ 1**@ 1**@ 1**@ ?9:*@ ?9:*@ ?9:*@ ?9:*@ '5 $)

% '5 $)

% "-